Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tween and WhatsApp do you allow it?

39 replies

justeatavocado · 23/07/2021 20:37

To let me 11.5 year old daughter to have WhatsApp?

I have said no, she messages her friends but they are all on WhatsApp and she keeps asking for it.

I'm in two frames of mind. I hate the idea of the groups and it's age is 16!!! However it appears all her peers have it, then I worry she will be feeling left out/cut off from friends.

It's so hard being a parent of a tween now. ☹️ knowing the right thing to do,

Does your 11 year old have it? Do you have any ground rules if they do?

Thanks in advance

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Travielkapelka · 24/07/2021 09:49

Mine has it but no insta or snap chat, I prefer it as at least you’ve got a chance of seeing the train of messages rather than snap chat where it all disappears

LabStan · 24/07/2021 09:41

We allowed it as soon as they have a phone. We just check it constantly. They don't have access to any other social media though.

OakleyStreetisnotinChelsea · 24/07/2021 08:48

Mine have it and got it from when they got their phones. Dc2 got a phone a little early due to lockdowns precisely so that they could keep in touch with friends when we were not allowed to meet anyone. It was great for the transition to secondary school too as of course there were no transition days to meet your tutor group etc but someone started a WhatsApp for the kids and through parents they all got added and were able to chat.

My kids phones have good parental controls, time limits so no all night messaging and I check them.

VerySmallPears · 24/07/2021 08:48

@icedcoffees I just went and checked it out, on younger DC’s phone. We have the group messaging function in settings switched off, and settings password protected so she can’t access them.

LFQuery · 24/07/2021 08:42

I have teenagers and they all had WhatsApp during year 6 age 11. A few years on and we’ve had no issues. They tend to use Snapchat more than WhatsApp.

icedcoffees · 24/07/2021 08:27

I don't use the iMessage function either as it doesn't work if your data is off, but you can still have group texts the "normal" way with other smart-phone users. They don't need to have iPhones.

WhoDidAndWhy · 24/07/2021 08:21

Yes, it’s the same as texting really. I monitor it (ie read her messages) and she doesn’t have the phone much in the day. To be honest, her friends talk rubbish so she basically is on there so they don’t hassle her but she limits her replies.

VerySmallPears · 24/07/2021 08:19

You can have group iMessages, true. But not everyone has an iPhone (and for a while, we had the iMessage function switched off so DC could only text, for exactly that reason).

icedcoffees · 24/07/2021 08:12

@VerySmallPears but you can have group texts and photo messaging via regular texting as well.

I maybe get your point around photo messages but I have an old iPhone and I can participate in group text messages on there no problem.

VerySmallPears · 24/07/2021 07:42

The differences between WhatsApp and texting are group chats rather than just one to one (so people you may not know well or at all, and can get caught in the crossfire of other peoples arguments), statuses (seen them used to bully, seek validation, flirt etc all of which you can’t do to your whole friendship group at the same time via text), can send photos (which I had disabled on text for primary age DC), can be added to groups with lots of people you don’t know who may be much older (depending on your WhatsApp settings), people in groups who you don’t know can contact you direct as they have your number. It’s a step on from text messages, in terms of risk of seeing dodgy stuff and being contacted by dodgy people. Especially as you can set the phone to only send and receive texts with people in your address book.

FrankButchersDickieBow · 24/07/2021 07:27

Dd 12 has it. I take her phone randomly to check messages.

Luckily she has a very nice group of friends and I've never seen anything untoward and she is on a whole year group chat which she has muted as some of the stuff on there she didn't like.

When have a family group, which we share funny stuff on. She chats separately to grandparents/aunties on it.

She is sensible and I have absolutely no qualms about her having it.

icedcoffees · 24/07/2021 07:23

Why is everyone so against WhatsApp?

Isn't it just online texting? What's the difference between WhatsApp and just regular texts in terms of safety?

CeeceeBloomingdale · 24/07/2021 07:20

My DDs 14 and 10 both have it (I monitor). They really just use it as a cheaper way of texting. I discourage but don't ban group chats. They are both sensible and I have often found they've have removed themselves from groups with drama and don't get drawn in in the past. Now it is literally just texts when I check.

IamnotSethRogan · 24/07/2021 07:16

If she has a phone I don't understand what the problem with WhatsApp is. It's just a messaging service. My 10 year old doesn't have a phone but he has a messaging app on his iPad that I check.

VerySmallPears · 24/07/2021 07:04

We waited until end of Y8 to allow WhatsApp. That got us past the worse of the Y7 learning how to use it nastiness with school having to get involved, and the Y8 friendship drama (there’s a ‘thing’ about being unkind by reading but not responding to messages, it’s odd but very important if you’re 13, it turns out).

We also have Qustudio (net nanny), have set WhatsApp so that she can’t be added to groups by people not in her contacts, and have parental controls limiting time on her phone. She has no other social media, and can’t download apps without a parent approving them.

Of course, we talk a lot about internet safety, too. I hope this will be enough…

girlmom21 · 24/07/2021 06:55

If she's already messaging her friends WhatsApp is no different.

Set some ground rules.

KingdomScrolls · 24/07/2021 06:53

I work with sexual offending and I don't know how I'm ever going to let DS have his own smart phone with some of the things I've seen. I realise my job means I see the worst of it and I'm quite tech savvy so would use parental control apps etc. A case I was involved in recently two twelve year old girls reported a male to CEOPS and whilst that's admirable, it just made me so sad that children that young even know what CEOPS is. Both of those girls were from good homes had lots of parental support and monitoring etc, it didn't stop it happening to them and whilst they weren't contact offences actually what he did/said/sent violated then and will have a long term impact

GlacindaTheTroll · 24/07/2021 06:30

WhatsApp is no different to texting

And much better for group chats

SE13's list seems a good one.

The important thing is to talk about cyber security and netiquette before they hit secondary school (ideally well beforehand) and before they start wanting Snapchat or others which can be way more problematic than the texting apps

SE13Mummy · 24/07/2021 02:00

My Y7 has had it since this time last year so she could stay in touch with a group from her hobby plus a couple of friends who moved away at the end of Y6 - they don't all have iPhones so weren't able to access some of the similar apps.

Ground rules specific to WhatsApp are:

  • no forwarding of chain messages
  • be kind and be friendly or don't bother
  • send people invitations to join groups, don't just add them
  • challenge unkindness or report to an adult
  • no blocking of people without checking with me first
  • daily limit is 30 minutes

General phone rules:

  • enforced down time is set for 8pm to 7am
  • phones are not in bedrooms overnight
  • if it's used for being unkind, it will be taken away
  • it's OK to not give someone your number/to block theirs but be consistent i.e. don't block and unblock repeatedly
  • use your brain; if someone doesn't reply immediately it doesn't necessarily mean they hate you!
  • if I ask to see your messages etc., I expect them to be suitable for me to see (silliness is fine, bullying or body parts pics are not)
nocutsnobuttsnococonuts · 24/07/2021 01:22

My dd is 12, she has WhatsApp and has done since she got her phone over a year ago.

Rules here are - i can check messages whenever and without warning. I periodically check. If she feels uncomfortable or unsure about anything someone has said she must tell me. She knows how to mute and leave groups (as she did when girls became bitchy to each other. She said "thats unkind" and left the group!) And finally the most important rule - if I find she has bullied/been nasty or shared anything inappropriate she will immediately lose her phone and be given the most basic one to make calls on (not a smart phone). Doubly hard as she has no other access to technology/gaming/tv that is her own!

So far so good, she is very open with me. She leaves her phone downstairs at night without argument. I know the log in for her phone (only me, not her dad. He agrees with this. Only because she talks about girl stuff with friends and would be embarrassed if he saw. I would tell him if there was anything concerning)

WhatsApp has also been helpful for sharing photos or asking for help on homework on class groups. Eg the other week she had forgotten her homework she had been working on, she messaged me from the bus and I could WhatsApp her a photo of it to show the teacher.

Miranda15110 · 24/07/2021 00:26

No, my son 11 is actually pleased I said no when he asked. It's the source of much bad behaviour and inappropriate comms in his class. One kid who uses her mums phone (along with older sibling) to access the App shared a dick pic with half the kids in the class. The fallout from that was spectacular.

funtimefrank · 23/07/2021 23:54

Like others mine have it - just finished yr 6.

I can check any time and do. Mostly it's just small groups of 2 or 3 but we have had the whole class group fiasco and Dd2 recently got caught out bringing in an argument from the playground into the group chat. That got picked up by us and school and as a consequence she has had a phone ban and left the group. On the other hand it's helped with friendships especially with her club mates who go to different schools.

Also no phones allowed in bedrooms.

So my advice is if you allow it, monitor it well.

Snoopsnoggysnog · 23/07/2021 23:52

My DD same age and I’ve just got her a phone and allowed her to have WhatsApp.

All her friends are on it and I know most of the parents and kids.

Rule is I can check it regularly and she only has the phone a couple of hours a day at the moment. I’m going to look into the parental control apps.

I’m a bit worried, as a PP said they’re not really mature enough to deal with the etiquette of it. Although I think they pick it up pretty fast. Also my DD at the moment is quite keen to check with me before she posts certain things !

Hankunamatata · 23/07/2021 23:52

I let my dc have it summer he started high school. I check it most nights and he brings it to me if anything is said.

buckeejit · 23/07/2021 23:48

My 8 & 11 yo have it. I check it & keep discussions open. People friending them on online games is more of a concern I think