Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

10 year olds learning about the holocaust etc

258 replies

restbetweentheelements · 23/07/2021 19:48

Dc's yeargroup are 9/10
His teacher this year has told them in graphic detail about:

  • gas chambers in german concentration camps
  • terror in french revolution by showing painting of chopped off head with blood held up next to guillotine and details of what happened
  • all about the charlie hebdo teacher terrorist attack in france
  • murders in news how many women were killed by partners - they chatted about the news on fridays and dc said it was never about life affirming things (he said nice or interesting things)
DC has been affected by it, and he drew a picture of his teacher with a guillotine and children and he wrote "our teacher is killing us with terror" (he draws a lot, is quite expressive generally...) - i found the drawing screwed up in the bottom of his bag

YANBU - the teaching is not appropriate, the subject matter of treatment of Jews etc is ok in age appropriare way is okay but focusing on terror aspects is not
YABU - no problem with this

If YANBU, then WWYD
I remember learning about medieval torture methods when 10, at school. Is there some sort of theory about terror being useful for 10 year olds???

OP posts:
Mayim · 23/07/2021 21:15

I don't think that the subject matter in itself is inappropriate but from the way in which you described it, the teacher seems to be focussing on violent imagery. I'd really need to know more about the context and what else was covered in the lesson. If this has been going on for the school year, have you raised it in order to find out more!

I'm quite old and found out about forced labour in WW2 when I was about 6, because the parent of a friend had been a victim. Her health was ruined by this experience and it limited her ability to parent. This was discussed very openly and it was reality to all who knew her. There would have been no point in censoring this information.

My dd has known about the Holocaust from about the same age. All of her grandfather's immediate family were killed and again, it was reality.

Similarly the thing about discussing DV is that there could be children in the class for whom this is reality - and they may not realise that it is wrong, unless it is discussed.

Sh05 · 23/07/2021 21:12

My reception aged DD was taught about the crucification in great detail at Easter. She had nightmares for the whole week leading up to the next Tuesday because Tuesdays are RE days so much so that for the next Tuesday I took her into school in the afternoon so she was reassured that RE had already taken place on the morning and she was guaranteed to miss it.
When I mentioned it to the class teacher I was told that they'd only touched on the subject which cannot have been truthful because DD was able to tell me in great detail, through her tears, what they'd covered.

NomadMum · 23/07/2021 21:09

YABU, he needs to learn it. But I’d make sure he knew that he was able to discuss his worries with you.

restbetweentheelements · 23/07/2021 21:07

@Alpenguin

My child learned about the Holocaust recently at 10/11 and I think it’s the best age to teach these things in full Graphic horror. Get kids young and teach them what is unacceptable, develop empathy and respect for diversity young. Ensure they know why war is bad and why we cannot allow it to happen again. As a child I was taken to auschwitz and i was shown the living accommodation, and the personal effects, I stood in the gas chamber and it did scar me for life but in a way that meant I knew we could not allow this to happen again. It was as positive an experience as it was a difficult one. I wasn’t desensitised to violence on tv, in films or in games by then and I was seeing real life. It was impossible to disassociate it from reality. I’m not sure I’d have felt the same at 20 having seen horror films and violence on the news.

I plan to take my daughter when we’re allowed to travel.

When I see 40something fat males wandering around London waving a single arm in the air in a nazi style Salute at any non white skinned person they see, I wish they’d been shown the horrors of the Holocaust young and maybe they’d have developed some empathy and understanding instead of the bigotry and racism we’re seeing rising in the UK now.

I know what you mean, but I just dont think that terrorising children is the way to teach empathy and right from wrong and and diversity.

The men you refer to are dysfunctional because they have been terrorised themselves, they were not brought up with empathy or positive awareness of the world around them, nor taught about why war happens, and why some men and women hurt each other. It is largely ignorance. Hitler's ideas as set out in mein kampf were fundamentally ignorant, incorrect, not coherent.

Showing graphic details to this age is going to be counterproductive. The guidance about teaching these subjects says that at 9 and 10 it shoudl be about talking about empathy and equality and morals and diversity with examples in outline not graphic detail.

Judging by the other thread, it looks like not all teachers are aware of the guidance. I hadn't seen other thread until it was linked here.

OP posts:
JesusIsAnyNameFree · 23/07/2021 21:01

We definitely learnt about the Holocaust at age 9/10 when I was in school, early 2000's. YABU I think.

KingdomScrolls · 23/07/2021 21:00

I read Anne Frank's diary at that age. I'd exhausted the reading scheme several years before and my mum re-read it at the same time so we could discuss it. Children can learn an awful lot from WW2 and the Holocaust at that age. I do remember putting something on the TV admit the concentration camps when I was about the same age, my dad was working away my brother was at camp so I was watching a film in my parents from with my mum, it finished and she went to lock up and get the cat in and I was giving through the channels. I can still see those images of piles of emaciated bodies now and I've studied the period numerous times since, but the visual imagery at that age really stuck with me.

Candodad · 23/07/2021 21:00

You totally are being unreasonable and half added your own views on everything you commented on. You clearly want there to be an issue.

Alpenguin · 23/07/2021 20:58

My child learned about the Holocaust recently at 10/11 and I think it’s the best age to teach these things in full Graphic horror. Get kids young and teach them what is unacceptable, develop empathy and respect for diversity young. Ensure they know why war is bad and why we cannot allow it to happen again. As a child I was taken to auschwitz and i was shown the living accommodation, and the personal effects, I stood in the gas chamber and it did scar me for life but in a way that meant I knew we could not allow this to happen again. It was as positive an experience as it was a difficult one. I wasn’t desensitised to violence on tv, in films or in games by then and I was seeing real life. It was impossible to disassociate it from reality. I’m not sure I’d have felt the same at 20 having seen horror films and violence on the news.

I plan to take my daughter when we’re allowed to travel.

When I see 40something fat males wandering around London waving a single arm in the air in a nazi style Salute at any non white skinned person they see, I wish they’d been shown the horrors of the Holocaust young and maybe they’d have developed some empathy and understanding instead of the bigotry and racism we’re seeing rising in the UK now.

Flossing · 23/07/2021 20:56

Having thought about this more I think it's really hard for us to comment or judge if YABU or not. We don't have a clear enough understanding of the lesson content being delivered.

If you are concerned contact the teacher and ask directly about how age appropriate the lessons were.

SetPhasersTaeMalkie · 23/07/2021 20:55

I am quoting from the Primary School guide from the Holocaust Education Trust -

'The Trust very strongly believes that it is not appropriate for them (primary children) to directly study the murder of European Jews during the Second World War. In particular, the horrifying history of the Nazi extermination camps and other mass killing operations should be avoided.'

I've linked to the guide upthread if anyone wants to read it.

LolaSmiles · 23/07/2021 20:53

WW2 and thw Holocaust was taught in primary school when I was a student. It's fine for issues and topics to be discussed, but they ought to be handled with care.

KittenKong · 23/07/2021 20:52

And i had a Meccano guillotine when I was little.

Ozanj · 23/07/2021 20:52

8-10 is about the age when, if they don’t learn the facts about the holocaust, they will definitely learn the mistruths about it. As for female murders / domestic violence - the horrific truth is that for many girls the sexual objectification starts between 8-10; and for future abusers the patterns of behaviour that will lead them to murdering / abusing a woman starts getting laid between 8-10 (if not earlier). So they should definitely be learning about how it is wrong.

KittenKong · 23/07/2021 20:50

I remember watching the World At War when I was little in my grandmas old house. I was about 4 at the time.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 23/07/2021 20:50

I’m old. We learned about Anne frank and the Holocaust at primary . Yoy can’t hide the horrid of history if you want to raise kids to learn but to repeat thrm

My dad is 20 and he learned about Anne Frank at primary too, 7/8 iirc.

sadperson16 · 23/07/2021 20:50

So let me get this straight......some sicko comes on here from time to time and makes something up about young children being taught in graphic detail about the holocaust?

Bbq1 · 23/07/2021 20:49

I agree because there are children aged 10 and far, far younger currently living in war torn countries and experiencing genocide, child soldiers, murder in front of them on a daily basis. They are the poor children genuinely experiencing real terror on a daily basis. It's hard to say without seeing the subject matter but I generally think a 10 year old can cope with learning about the holocaust. As long as Op talks through any questions or worries that he has.

NavyBerry · 23/07/2021 20:49

YABU
I will tell my children all I know about the WWII and the holocaust. I'm glad to hear there are teachers out there that make an effort for children to learn extra about this important and unforgettable years of our history. I'd appreciate.

restbetweentheelements · 23/07/2021 20:47

@Geamhradh but see the guidance linked by someone above.

OP posts:
EileenGC · 23/07/2021 20:47

I was also surprised about that other subject under discussion: 'murders in the news & how many women were killed by partners', may I ask: is his teacher a woman? Perhaps she has had something in her past related to this and has let it get to her.

The (potentially) female teacher's past has nothing to do with teaching about women being murdered by their partners.

I didn't grow up in the UK so I don't know how the evening news are done here, but when I was little, the national number of domestic violence victims was regularly updated on TV. And still is to this day. There used to be 1-2 victims each week, they were reported in the evening news each and every single time. This is not some obscure, developing country. It's one of the biggest countries in Europe, so fully civilised.

These women deserved to be remembered, us as kids needed to know how often this happens. Little boys needed to be taught it's an atrocity to kill your partner. It's not the best piece of news for a 10 year old to hear, but that's definitely old enough to see how both 18 and 75 year old men, and every age and background in between, are capable of killing their spouses. Simply because they are women.

Don't kids in the UK see these things on the news anyway?

restbetweentheelements · 23/07/2021 20:45

@SetPhasersTaeMalkie

The Holocaust Education Trust has a guide for schools. I am linking you to it here - www.het.org.uk/primary

The guide for Primary schools is downloadable and gives advice and guidance on age appropriate topics. There is very good training available and it really should be undertaken. At the very least the guide should be in schools or teachers made aware of it.

This is what I read after my dc told me the class content. The teacher has not followed these guidelines at all. Quote from the guidelines for people who have not read them:

"It should be evident that both the emotional impact and
intellectual complexity of learning about the Holocaust
dictate that great care is necessary when selecting
suitable content for primary school students. The Trust
very strongly believes that it is not appropriate for them
to directly study the murder of Europe’s Jews during
the Second World War. In particular, the horrifying
history of the Nazi extermination camps and other
mass killing operations should be avoided"

OP posts:
Helenluvsrob · 23/07/2021 20:45

YABU
I’m old. We learned about Anne frank and the Holocaust at primary . Yoy can’t hide the horrid of history if you want to raise kids to learn but to repeat thrm

maddiemookins16mum · 23/07/2021 20:42

My DD is still traumatised about the boy in striped pyjamas. She watched it (with me) 5 years ago. She’s now 17. That said, I think they need to know about this horrific murder of millions of innocent people.

fraddu · 23/07/2021 20:42

Responsible adults who understand the meaning of good of evil. How do we best achieve that? That's the question.

I agree

EeeppP · 23/07/2021 20:41

Way too young, imo. My son is ten, and home educated. He will learn such things, but not at this age. Plenty of time for that.