Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

10 year olds learning about the holocaust etc

258 replies

restbetweentheelements · 23/07/2021 19:48

Dc's yeargroup are 9/10
His teacher this year has told them in graphic detail about:

  • gas chambers in german concentration camps
  • terror in french revolution by showing painting of chopped off head with blood held up next to guillotine and details of what happened
  • all about the charlie hebdo teacher terrorist attack in france
  • murders in news how many women were killed by partners - they chatted about the news on fridays and dc said it was never about life affirming things (he said nice or interesting things)
DC has been affected by it, and he drew a picture of his teacher with a guillotine and children and he wrote "our teacher is killing us with terror" (he draws a lot, is quite expressive generally...) - i found the drawing screwed up in the bottom of his bag

YANBU - the teaching is not appropriate, the subject matter of treatment of Jews etc is ok in age appropriare way is okay but focusing on terror aspects is not
YABU - no problem with this

If YANBU, then WWYD
I remember learning about medieval torture methods when 10, at school. Is there some sort of theory about terror being useful for 10 year olds???

OP posts:
rainbowfairylights · 23/07/2021 22:38

We learnt this in school when I was 10. I actually read Anne Frank by choice at that age.

Then again I'm part Jewish so I grew up knowing about it - but I was fine learning about it. It's an important part of history.

user16395699 · 23/07/2021 22:28

It is not helpful to raise children in a dissociated fantasy bubble that you then burst to confront them with the miserable, scary, and painful reality of human life without the coping skills or experience to manage it.

Whose needs does that meet? The parent's need to deny their fears, not the child's needs.

Death is part of life, existing in a state of denial about that makes it harder to bear not easier.

IcedSpice · 23/07/2021 22:23

@pinkyredrose

our teacher is killing us with terror

Rather dramatic but he needs to learn. He's a good age to take this stuff in.

Guess he will be a writer when he grows up!

If we don't study history then we are doomed to repeat it

lanthanum · 23/07/2021 22:16

The holocaust is a compulsory topic at KS3. Our secondary leaves it until the end of year 9. (They then got caught out last year, as it had to be covered in lockdown, which wasn't ideal, but they emailed all parents to let us know and point us at the resources.)

Things like Anne Frank can be covered without going into the full horror of concentration camps.

user16395699 · 23/07/2021 22:12

@restbetweentheelements

These are interesting replies and I expected the mix. The subject matter was all familiar to him, he has books on history, he knew about the terror, the holocaust. Other than the charlie hebdo murder. Why tell the children what happened in gruesome detail? The detail is difficult for adults to process.

It was the way the teacher was only focusing on the terror which I thought was bizarre. For the holocaust, the recommendation for 9 and 10 year olds the advice is talk about what happened, personal responsibility and choices. Not about the grim details.

And to only talk about murder and death in the news talks?

@Geamhradh how do they disagree, can you give details?

I very much doubt that the teacher was "only focusing on the terror", though. You yourself have zeroed in on one element of what's happened in the school year and presented it as if that's all they've done. Which would be disturbing if it were true, but it's obviously not.

When covering topics that include confronting or frightening elements - despite that tough element only being a very small but necessary part of the session - I have seen children who were so affected by that small element that it was the only thing they took away from the session. Like none of the rest of it happened.

For instance, covering water safety. A brief reference to the consequences involved but the majority of the session spent on positive things they can do to stay safe and neutral things like learning about beach flags... and a child goes home telling their parent how they did a lesson about drowning (and all the stuff their imagination has added on top) and is so frightened at the thought it becomes all they can think about.

Yet the rest of the group goes home calm, some of them ask parents to go swimming at the weekend, some of them go home and teach siblings about beach flags, some want to become a lifeguard.

One child goes home and starts worrying about mum or dad or baby brother drowning and forgets all the things they learnt to prevent that because they're so overwhelmed by the fear they felt in that brief moment of realising that death could affect them.

From their perspective, because that moment of discussing the confronting element was so frightening or distressing it became the one and only thing they remembered from the session.

They then built it up even more in their minds so that when talking to them about it, to them it was truly as if that had been all that was discussed and they could not remember any of the context or any of the hopeful elements (like the Kindertransport would have been for the topic you mention). And in some cases they were so frightened that they mixed up the facts they'd been told so that they seemed even worse.

The children weren't lying when they recounted their memory of the session, it was just that it tapped into that primitive threat/survival part of their brains and distorted their experience.

Given the rest of your posts, this sounds like what's happened with your son. I sincerely, sincerely doubt the teacher has been doing sessions focused entirely on horror like you suggest.

And the teacher is patently not "killing" anyone, so that makes clear that your son's perspective is out of kilter with what is happening. That is a very, very dramatic thing to say.

Regardless, your son appears to need support. I think that would be a more constructive focus. You becoming dramatic about it yourself won't help.

gamerchick · 23/07/2021 22:03

@Mintjulia

I've thought this for a while.

Yes the Holocaust is important but it's just not necessary at 10years old. No wonder we have so many depressed children if their reading matter is gas chambers and concentration camps.

Would you prefer kids of this age to learn it first hand? Hmm

This is my point FFS. The young are the ones who will be in charge one day. Keeping them in a santitised, comfortable bubble when young, creates arrogant, do no offend me or you'll be on the breadline, arseholes.

No. We coddle our kids and I'm no exception. They need a good rattle while their brains are soft.

Shelby2010 · 23/07/2021 22:01

WW2 was my DC topic this January during lockdown & I was quite worried because they were already pretty depressed. Fortunately although they learnt a lot of facts, the more emotional side was based on the experience of evacuees. I was traumatised learning about the Holocaust at secondary school, my DC can wait a while longer, 9/10 is too young. I’d also worry that the children who weren’t traumatised ended up desensitised.

sparklingbrooke · 23/07/2021 21:51

Its normal and most get taught this at their age my DC did at their Primary School.

In your case OP show the picture to the teacher your DS has drawn so he's aware of the effect it's had.

ViciousJackdaw · 23/07/2021 21:48

Whilst 10yo is probably a little early to learn about Mengele twins and Zyklon B, I do think that children should learn about what happened but more importantly, why it should never be allowed to happen again.

BillyIsMyBunny · 23/07/2021 21:43

Were you in the lessons? You are listing all of the content your son has remembered but that doesn’t mean that is all the teacher talked about or covered in the lessons. Are you sure that the teacher only focused on the ‘terror’ or is that just all your son focused on?

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 23/07/2021 21:39

Yes the Holocaust is important but it's just not necessary at 10years old. No wonder we have so many depressed children if their reading matter is gas chambers and concentration camps

My ds was shown the film clips of concentration camps at 9/10. I was ok with this.

HelgaDownUnder · 23/07/2021 21:37

History is one thing, but the teacher sounds like a ghoul.
The hardest part of the holocaust is understanding why. The last horrors of despair the victims went through is not something kids should be encouraged to dwell on.

Mintjulia · 23/07/2021 21:36

I've thought this for a while.

Yes the Holocaust is important but it's just not necessary at 10years old. No wonder we have so many depressed children if their reading matter is gas chambers and concentration camps.

Sirzy · 23/07/2021 21:34

This is the first generation of children who will be one generation away from the vast majority of living relatives of the Holocaust and similar which makes it even more important they understand.

You can’t properly teach the Holocaust without touching on the deaths and how they happened because that is such a key part of things

TheSkatesOfCoachBombay · 23/07/2021 21:31

Can't say I'd be best pleased, mainly because DS aged 6 loves graphic detail and all I'd hear for days is about people dying 🤦🏻‍♀️ gruesome deaths on horrible histories is his favourite and he doesn't shut up about them lol

Age 10 does seem a little young for "graphic content" underating it happend ok. But maybe not the ins and outs and gas champers till the early teens would be my favoured position.

patkinney · 23/07/2021 21:29

@EileenGC

I was also surprised about that other subject under discussion: 'murders in the news & how many women were killed by partners', may I ask: is his teacher a woman? Perhaps she has had something in her past related to this and has let it get to her.

The (potentially) female teacher's past has nothing to do with teaching about women being murdered by their partners.

I didn't grow up in the UK so I don't know how the evening news are done here, but when I was little, the national number of domestic violence victims was regularly updated on TV. And still is to this day. There used to be 1-2 victims each week, they were reported in the evening news each and every single time. This is not some obscure, developing country. It's one of the biggest countries in Europe, so fully civilised.

These women deserved to be remembered, us as kids needed to know how often this happens. Little boys needed to be taught it's an atrocity to kill your partner. It's not the best piece of news for a 10 year old to hear, but that's definitely old enough to see how both 18 and 75 year old men, and every age and background in between, are capable of killing their spouses. Simply because they are women.

Don't kids in the UK see these things on the news anyway?

The point I was making was that if this teacher is female (and the chances are high - most primary school teachers are) she may have had something traumatic in her past happen, that caused her to teach this topic in a way that went beyond what is normal and acceptable for this age group.

I did not mean any offence when I said this, it was pure conjecture on my part.

P.S. as regards this: "I didn't grow up in the UK, so I don't know how the evening news are done here, but when I was little, the national number of domestic violence victims was regularly updated on TV. And still is to this day." No, we don't have that system in the UK.

Grenlei · 23/07/2021 21:27

@gamerchick

Those who don't learn from the past are doomed to repeat it.

This wiping our kids backsides these days, the bubble wrap so they don't feel intense negative emotions is what is creating these young adults with no resilience.

I completely agree.

It's ok for children to feel sad or upset about things that happened in the past. Better that than presenting them with a sanitised Disney version of history with anything upsetting edited out.

Garfunkle · 23/07/2021 21:25

My children were taught about the atrocities of Concentration Camps during WW2 at Primary school. It’s part of the curriculum. Horrific without doubt but everyone needs to learn about it to make sure it doesn’t happen again. I’d go as far as to say everyone should visit Auswitch. Absolutely barbaric and harrowing 🥺 We all need to do what we must to make sure these type of atrocities remain in the past and at the forefront of our thinking.

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/07/2021 21:21

YABU

KittenKong · 23/07/2021 21:19

Oh and I remember WW2 veterans coming on to give us take at primary too.

Cattenberg · 23/07/2021 21:19

I’m really glad I wasn’t taught these horrific details at primary school, and I hope my child won’t be.

I was taught about these events at secondary school, complete with some harrowing textbook photos of executions and emaciated bodies lying in a mass grave. By this age, I was more emotionally resilient and had a much better understanding of the historical context and of human psychology.

What’s the hurry?

KittenKong · 23/07/2021 21:18

My grandparents were active in the war and my parents were kids/teens during it, so it was a living history and part of their lives. It was mentioned (not much by those who saw fighting) and we (kids) were well aware of the horrors.

Maybe the teachers think that children like all the blood and guts in history?

Maggiesfarm · 23/07/2021 21:17

@Faranth

He's not in year 10, is he? He's 10 years old? So year 5 at primary?

I don't remember learning about ww2 and the holocaust until secondary.

As far as I remember history at primary was mostly ancient history - Romans / Egyptians etc.

I learned about it aged 12. It had a profound impact on me for all sorts of reasons, I sort of grew up a bit more.

I'm not sure I could have coped aged ten, I was very sensitive to anything horrific that I read or saw on TV, couldn't get images out of my mind or sleep properly.

Each child is different.

gamerchick · 23/07/2021 21:16

Those who don't learn from the past are doomed to repeat it.

This wiping our kids backsides these days, the bubble wrap so they don't feel intense negative emotions is what is creating these young adults with no resilience.

KittenKong · 23/07/2021 21:16

I still remember in primary 5 (so about 9) and a little boy in class saying something about Jesus, when he was tied to the cross... our teacher, a very religious type (and the most unpleasant person you’d ever meet) gave a full explanation of the crucifixion (the rest of us were Confused at the thing bit - not sure where he got that from).