Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

10 year olds learning about the holocaust etc

258 replies

restbetweentheelements · 23/07/2021 19:48

Dc's yeargroup are 9/10
His teacher this year has told them in graphic detail about:

  • gas chambers in german concentration camps
  • terror in french revolution by showing painting of chopped off head with blood held up next to guillotine and details of what happened
  • all about the charlie hebdo teacher terrorist attack in france
  • murders in news how many women were killed by partners - they chatted about the news on fridays and dc said it was never about life affirming things (he said nice or interesting things)
DC has been affected by it, and he drew a picture of his teacher with a guillotine and children and he wrote "our teacher is killing us with terror" (he draws a lot, is quite expressive generally...) - i found the drawing screwed up in the bottom of his bag

YANBU - the teaching is not appropriate, the subject matter of treatment of Jews etc is ok in age appropriare way is okay but focusing on terror aspects is not
YABU - no problem with this

If YANBU, then WWYD
I remember learning about medieval torture methods when 10, at school. Is there some sort of theory about terror being useful for 10 year olds???

OP posts:
FeedMeSantiago · 24/07/2021 08:39

We learned about the holocaust in year 5 at school so age 9/10. I was 9. They showed us photos of bodies, of very unwell people immediately after liberation and the famous photo of a man taken moments before the Nazis shot him.

We also met a holocaust survivor who talked to us about his experiences, how he survived and about all his children and grandchildren.

I read Anne Frank's diary at the same time.

Everything made an impression on me, as it should.

Children need to know the depths to which humanity can sink.

SmokeyDevil · 24/07/2021 08:34

I doubt that the teacher only spoke about the terror of it all. That's the parts that have stuck out to your son. I doubt the teacher walked into class and just suddenly launched into a speech about the different ways people were tortured back then. You weren't there, you have no idea what they actually talked about as well, it may have only been a brief part of it but it's stuck with your son. Unfortunately that is kind of the point of this.

You can't shield your son forever from the world and considering how he reacted, if sounds like that's what you are doing. He needs to know these things, they aren't nice to hear about it, but how else do we stop it happening again?

ittakes2 · 24/07/2021 08:33

I used to be surprised at what the children were taught in school. My daughter came home crying at age 4 after the first week of school because the teacher had told my daughter that one day my daughter would die.
The child are prepared for horrors through fairy tales and stories. Look at the witch in hansel and gretal who locked up the children to fatten them up to eat them. I remember a David Wallam play where the grandmother was being poisoned every day. Charlie and the chocolate factory where there greedy children had bad things happen to them.

Whiskycav · 24/07/2021 08:32

I am 40 we studied similar things at similar ages. I still remember learning about the holocaust and alot of the horrible parts of ww2. My son has just finished year 5 and also done the same. My daughter did to, with graphic detail for all of us. The graphic detail is required imo.

I have no issue with it at all. I remember feeling pretty shocked at what people had done to each other in the past. I am glad I did.

You have no idea if the graphic detail is all that was taught. It like wasn't but was the main bit that's impacted your son. Or even the bit that your son and his friends found most engaging.

The whole 'he is terrorising us with terror', to me sounds like a 10 years old classroom joke.

If you are so concerned you should have spoken to the school. Ors peak to them when it opens up and clarify wether this is the focus.

fourminutestosavetheworld · 24/07/2021 08:25

I wonder whether the statistics about women being murdered by their partners came up in a PSHE or DARE lesson. We do start to talk about healthy relationships and recognising when a relationship is unhealthy in Year 6.

fourminutestosavetheworld · 24/07/2021 08:21

Just because your child is focussing and obsessing on the 'terror' doesn't mean that that is all the teacher is teaching.

The teacher may not have intended to talk about certain things, but it is very difficult when interested children ask questions that extends their learning. I teach the primary history curriculum, including WW2, and sometimes you are thrown by unexpected questions.

Are the other parents reporting that their children are experiencing difficulties? I certainly wouldn't expect a 10yo to be so upset by talk of a guillotine - horrible histories have a super episode about the French Revolution.

Have you talked to the teacher about how he is dwelling on certain pieces of information?

It can certainly be taught in an age-appropriate way. The National Holocaust Centre has a very interesting visit for primary aged children that certainly does not shy away from the facts.

Rowgtfc72 · 24/07/2021 08:18

Dds school took the gr group to the national holocaust museum where they met a survivor. He told them his story, obviously aware he was speaking to 10/11 year olds. Dd said it was horrible to hear but she felt better knowing he had survived and not everyone had died.
Many parents kicked off about the kids watching Goodnight Mr Tom, we watched this when dd was 7 or 8, and I've got to admit I was a bit twitchy about them watching The Boy In The Striped Pyjamas.

ichundich · 24/07/2021 08:12

I think 10 is too young to learn about the holocaust in graphic detail. My daughter read Anne Frank's Diary at that age, so we had to touch on the subject, but I kept it very brief and focussed on the persecution aspect and her life in her hide-out instead.

newnortherner111 · 24/07/2021 07:49

I think it is appropriate. I think though you should be made aware when it is being taught so you can talk to your child about it should they wish to afterwards. There will be some adults who perhaps should know more about these events from history than they do, such as those anti-vaxxers in demonstrations over the last few months who have made comparisons between Covid restrictions and aspects of Nazi rule.

phlebasconsidered · 24/07/2021 07:47

As an ex secondary history teacher who is now a year 6 teacher I would not teach it in primary. I have placed the holocaust into pshe lessons and we have studied holocaust memorial day. However to do the subject ultimate justice it needs to be taught in depth in ks3 with great emphasis on the build up to it, the rise of fascism and the appalling results. I used to dedicate a great deal of thought to it. Even then some teens would not be mature enough to fully comprehend it.

I tend to agree with the Holocaust Trust who focus on ks3 and disagree with some literature aimed at younger age groups. There are plenty of ways to teach tolerance and understanding in ks2 without going into the complexity of the Holocaust. It is frankly impossible to teach the second world war with the depth it deserves in year 6. Most primary teachers are not history specialists. It's not a "this half terms learning focus"- it deserves to be more than a whistle stop in ks2. Most primaries are now aligned with the curriculum and focus on pre-history and settlers and invaders now to build up a solid knowledge of early history and historical investigation before entering ks3, which is more useful in my opionion.

SourAppleChew · 24/07/2021 02:56

I also don't think it's too inappropriate as long as they aren't shown disturbing images. Look how mollycoddled many of the youths of today are. Notifying the authorities etc if somebody says something they deem non-politically correct. 😂 They need to toughen up a bit.

SourAppleChew · 24/07/2021 02:52

The "killing us with terror" sounds really bizarre though

They were being taught about 'The Terror', a period in history. He probably didn't mean the teacher was 'killing them with fear'.

Whatafustercluck · 24/07/2021 02:21

Tbh I'd be surprised if this hadn't come up in normal conversation with a 10yo anyway. They're exposed to a lot of second hand information at that age, overhearing news, other people's conversations, the Internet etc. They learn about sex and relationships at 10yo these days when people my age (early 40s) didn't learn about it until secondary school. The conversation with my 10ds came up a long time ago. "Mum, what's the Boy in the Striped pyjamas about? What was the holocaust?" He has older cousins and had overheard a conversation. Aren't most children of that age asking lots of questions? I've gone on the basis that if they're old enough to ask, they're old enough to know.

Littlepaws18 · 24/07/2021 01:50

... easily be taken away. It's a fundamental component of twentieth century world and civil liberties.

Littlepaws18 · 24/07/2021 01:48

It's the only compulsory component of the history curriculum by law. And it also is taught in both year 9/10. It's absolutely essential for students to understand how equality and human rights c

GiantHaystacks2021 · 24/07/2021 01:48

Yep 10 years old is old enough to know about the evil of the Holocaust.

sprinkleyumnut · 24/07/2021 01:46

Obviously I agree with history being taught but at appropriate ages

sprinkleyumnut · 24/07/2021 01:45

I think that is too young to be taught about the upsetting and horrifying parts of history. If I was taught this at 10, I would of been upset. I think 13 is the earliest.

sashh · 24/07/2021 01:41

I think the subject isn't the problem but whether it is age appropriate.

Another factor is children in the class who know more and ask questions and how the teacher responds.

I think you need to raise it with the teacher, to actually ask what is being taught.

I knew more about the holocaust than I should as a small child, because my parents watched, "World at War". Wikipedia tells me the first episode was aired days after my seventh birthday.

FastFood · 24/07/2021 00:40

I'm French and can't remember a time when I didn't know about the Revolution and the guillotine. I mean, paintings of it are everywhere in city halls, history books, museums...
Just go to your local church, there's a guy hanging on a cross with nails in his wrists and feet.

History is full of violence, especially in the last century, I'd be worried if a 10 years old kid didn't know that.

If anything, 10 seems really old to hear about Holocaust. Next year, he'll be exposed to porn according to statistics.
So we prefer kids to know what a bukkake is before them knowing what happened 80 years ago?

SlothinSpirit · 24/07/2021 00:27

Too young. Many 9/10 year olds will lack the emotional maturity to process it. I remember having nightmares for days after learning about it...it affected me profoundly.

And if teachers have to 'sanitise' it to make it OK for that age group to learn about it, it loses some of its impact anyway. Much better to wait until children are older and can cope with the whole harrowing truth than to omit important parts of history.

2mutsandsomebabies · 24/07/2021 00:18

yabu

shrodingersbiscuit · 24/07/2021 00:02

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ.

accentdusoleil · 23/07/2021 23:46

I think the Charlie Hebdo is a hard one as you really need to understand a lot of context around the subject to discuss the matter. Their cartons are awful. I think will be tricky for a 10 year old in uk to grasp

But Holocaust, 100% yes although it is a harrowing subject and support needs to be there for the children. I remember having nightmares as a child thinking it would happen to my family (again)

househousehousefox · 23/07/2021 23:30

@Vodkabulary

We learnt about Anne frank as part of Our ww2 history in years 5/6 when I was at primary. We also did war time Cooking and recipes, had to dress as Evacuees and make our desks into Morrison shelters
We did too but we weren't told what concentration camps really were. We weren't even told that she was murdered, just that she died in there. My tiny little brain thought that she had been forced to go on a camping trip and I still imagine her now sat around a camp fire with other people. I also remember thinking they were a bit dramatic hiding in an attic because of camping, until I heard she had died but again I thought it was unfortunate rather than by design. I remember learning about concentration camps in year 9 I think and it finally clicking that poor little Anne Frank had to go through that.

YANBU OP I think that is too young. Children don't need to know the gruesome details.
We learnt about the vikings and Bodecia (?) and romans without going into gory detail. Teacher probably is a bit sick in the head talking about this stuff with 9-10 year old children. It isn't appropriate and you have proof that your son and his peers are not ready or enjoying it.
Speak to the head if you feel you can. You could email anonymously with a throw away account if you feel too embarrassed. There is plenty of time for the gory details. I would be concerned.