Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

10 year olds learning about the holocaust etc

258 replies

restbetweentheelements · 23/07/2021 19:48

Dc's yeargroup are 9/10
His teacher this year has told them in graphic detail about:

  • gas chambers in german concentration camps
  • terror in french revolution by showing painting of chopped off head with blood held up next to guillotine and details of what happened
  • all about the charlie hebdo teacher terrorist attack in france
  • murders in news how many women were killed by partners - they chatted about the news on fridays and dc said it was never about life affirming things (he said nice or interesting things)
DC has been affected by it, and he drew a picture of his teacher with a guillotine and children and he wrote "our teacher is killing us with terror" (he draws a lot, is quite expressive generally...) - i found the drawing screwed up in the bottom of his bag

YANBU - the teaching is not appropriate, the subject matter of treatment of Jews etc is ok in age appropriare way is okay but focusing on terror aspects is not
YABU - no problem with this

If YANBU, then WWYD
I remember learning about medieval torture methods when 10, at school. Is there some sort of theory about terror being useful for 10 year olds???

OP posts:
KittenKong · 24/07/2021 10:34

There is no ‘fun’ way. I heard first hand stories when I was a small child (and some were definitely held back and we didn’t hear the full camp details until after grandad died - he was at Auschwitz when it opened). Mum and dad were kids/teens (in heavily bombed areas) and had their own stories.

ichundich · 24/07/2021 10:27

@KittenKong

What age is Michael Murpurgo aimed at (I forget when ds read these). There was some war stories in there - a child will seek out more info on such things (hopefully not in the internet). And the whole ‘horrible histories’ - wasn’t that built around the gory stories in history?
I have never seen a HH episode about the holocaust. The genocide is on another level to the horrors and atrocities of The Tudors or the French Revolution, it also happened much more recently and shapes our political life to this day, and we're less removed from it. I can't think of any "fun" way to present and talk about it.
Sirzy · 24/07/2021 10:22

DS is 11 and loves Michael Murpurgo he has been reading his books since middle of year 5 I would say. Elephant in the Garden is one of his favourites and although it’s not about Holocaust it is certainly about the horrors of war.

KittenKong · 24/07/2021 10:17

What age is Michael Murpurgo aimed at (I forget when ds read these). There was some war stories in there - a child will seek out more info on such things (hopefully not in the internet). And the whole ‘horrible histories’ - wasn’t that built around the gory stories in history?

rainbowstardrops · 24/07/2021 10:08

@picklemewalnuts

Goodnight Mr Tom, and the Boy in blue pyjamas are Y6 books, about second world was, concentration camps, child abuse, cruelty and neglect, etc.

Both my children watched these films/read the books at school in year 5 or 6. I think it's important that they know about these things.

Heronwatcher · 24/07/2021 10:05

YABU. At that age kids will find out about stuff in many different ways, far better that they learn in the classroom. If he is finding it difficult then maybe you could start a discussion about it and chat it through.

MySecretHistory · 24/07/2021 09:44

I am David was the bbc children’s serial for schools in the 1970s-played live in assembly one a week. It was from age 5 up

A lot of my family at the time were Jewish and we later found out their relatives had been in camps (they fled in the pograms). I was seen as something of an expert as a result in our rural village

ichundich · 24/07/2021 09:37

@FatOaf

"In particular, the horrifying history of the Nazi extermination camps and other mass killing operations should be avoided"

I completely disagree with this. The more we avoid confronting people with the horror of what happened, the more likely it is to happen again.

The OP and others are not saying that kids shouldn't learn about these things at all but that they shoukd learn it at a later age. When it's actually much more likely to sink in. You can only really understand WWII, the holocaust and what led to them once you know the history of Europe from 1900 onwards, voting systems, political systems including the Weimar Republic, the economic situation prior to 1939, appeasement, etc.
LemonRoses · 24/07/2021 09:37

Do these ‘too young’ children not read newspapers or at least watch the news? Do you not discuss current affairs with them?

How are children meant to learn about the world around them, about morality, about safety if we shield them from reality?

The holocaust was beyond horror, but genocide continues today. How do children grow to understand the treatment of the Rohingya or the Christians and Yazidis in Syria?

If people don’t understand the impact of fascism and how it becomes embedded and acceptable through learning from a young age.

SGBK4862 · 24/07/2021 09:34

I don't think any of this is wrong in itself as long as the lessons are well thought out and children are allowed to discuss and process things in a supportive environment and their parents should be informed so they can also support their children at home with their reactions.

But all of those things you mention OP in one year sounds overwhelming and as if the teacher has a personal obsession or mission. And the reaction of your child suggests this. I doubt he's the only one.

LuaDipa · 24/07/2021 09:34

Completely agree op. Kids don’t need to know the levels that humanity can sink to at the age of 10 years old. There is plenty of time to share the horrific details when they are older. Yanbu.

FatOaf · 24/07/2021 09:26

"In particular, the horrifying history of the Nazi extermination camps and other mass killing operations should be avoided"

I completely disagree with this. The more we avoid confronting people with the horror of what happened, the more likely it is to happen again.

Oblomov21 · 24/07/2021 09:25

"Not about the grim details."

But teacher didn't give grim details. She plainly told them the facts. How else are you supposed to explain it. Her sentences were factual, succinct abc to the point. They sound perfect to me.

Passthecontrol · 24/07/2021 09:24

I'm on the fence. Of course history is important but I do think 10 is just a bit too young for the gory details. If you can't be worry free and ignorant to all the violence in word aged 10 then when?
My ds had to do a presentation on WW2 in p7, so age 11/12 and that seemed more appropriate (and was actually very interesting for him as his great grandad was a POW so he learnt a lot about his own family).
They learnt a bit before then but nothing graphic.

sillysmiles · 24/07/2021 09:21

As for the more recent news- this is all stuff that is on the news everyday. Do you/ your child never see or hear the news on tv or radio in their general life?

Children growing up without any concept of what's going in in the world is not great.

Oblomov21 · 24/07/2021 09:19

Ds2 did the boy in the striped pyjamas in primary. I had no problem with this. Is it just you who is outraged in principal, or is he upset by it / scared? On which case sit him down and talk him through it calmly.

fourminutestosavetheworld · 24/07/2021 09:16

And I would not pay too much heed to your son saying that other children feel the same.

Of course children will be affected by hearing this stuff - unless you are a monster, it's upsetting. The thing is whether it's a 'normal' response to processing this stuff or not.

fourminutestosavetheworld · 24/07/2021 09:13

"DC is usually accurate when relaying stories about what happened in class, his teacher would agree with that, from what she has said to me."

Just ask her then.

But I think you will find the points you raised were not taught in isolation. They were set in the context of the wider lesson or sequence of lessons. In some cases, they may have been a minute out of an hour long lesson. They may have arisen as a child asked a question.

Your child isn't lying. He is telling you his perception of the lesson, where those distressing details were writ large and took on disproportionate significance in his mind, gaining momentum at home when you displayed some disapproval or doubt about the teacher.

Such lessons are rooted in the NC and a lot of discussion goes into the level of detail that is appropriate, and which resources to use.

For me, the fact that your son is upset at a painting of the French Revolution, suggests some unusual sensitivity. I wouldn't go in from a position of thinking that the teacher is not acting appropriately, but from a position of wanting to support your son. I'm not suggesting that you ignore it btw. I have only ever had one complaint about how WW2 is taught in our school, and that little boy did go on to need an awful lot of support, so it is certainly best to investigate.

FatOaf · 24/07/2021 09:10

With the incessant spread of holocaust-denial and the fact that many (most?) UK adults have no awareness of what the Nazis did, it's vitally important that schoolchildren learn this. It's equally vital that they learn that it's still happening in some parts of the world and a significant number of people want it to happen here.

MrsArchchancellorRidcully · 24/07/2021 09:10

Sorry I misread. I though your son was 10 bit in yr 10.

YABU

my 12 year old Dd knows about the holocaust. Your yr 10 DS definitely should!!! He's old enough!!!!

ichundich · 24/07/2021 08:58

[quote restbetweentheelements]@user16395699 this thread was only about talking about terror, of course there were other things taught in the year, all of which were fine. The thread is only about teaching about terror. The fact that she thought up fantastic science projects does not detract from the fact that she told the class that a teacher had recently been beheaded by a terrorist.

I am quite surprised that so many posters think terror is ok for 9/10 year olds. The fact that some children experience terror first hand doesn't mean that all children should experience it first or second hand. And no, exposing children to terror does not mean that they will understand it and not do it to anyone else. Just as hitting does not teach a child to not hit.

The holocaust guidelines state that when teaching about the holocaust to 9 and 10 year olds, you should not teach about the details of the camps or the killing, you should focus on other elements, and introduce other aspects as children mature.

The issue isn't how my dc reacted - or how I reacted when I was told about medieval torture methods - the AIBU was whether the terror should be taught to 9/10 year olds.[/quote]
I agree OP. Our children won't automatically turn into Nazis just because they only learn about the holocaust at age 14 or 15. It makes more sense to do it then because they will have the processing power and the historical context of how it all happened. I was 9 when I learned about WWII, which resulted in me having nightmares and a fear of being bombed for years.

restbetweentheelements · 24/07/2021 08:53

Just a reminder about what the guidelines are for teaching about the holocaust to 9/10 year olds, which was quoted a couple of times upthread

^"It should be evident that both the emotional impact and
intellectual complexity of learning about the Holocaust
dictate that great care is necessary when selecting
suitable content for primary school students. The Trust
very strongly believes that it is not appropriate for them
to directly study the murder of Europe’s Jews during
the Second World War. In particular, the horrifying
history of the Nazi extermination camps and other
mass killing operations should be avoided"^

DC asked me not to talk to the teacher about it, by the way. He also said that some of the children felt like him, and others didn't seem to mind at all and came up with gruesome stories of their own to tell the class. One child came in every week with a new murder in the news to talk about, in the last few weeks of term.

DC is usually accurate when relaying stories about what happened in class, his teacher would agree with that, from what she has said to me.

OP posts:
Sirzy · 24/07/2021 08:53

How can you teach the Holocaust without talking about the deaths? Hmm

I am of the camp that doesn’t see the point in hiding things from children. Much better to discuss things with them in a way they can understand for their age then to suddenly decide “ye your an adult now here’s all the horrors of the world”

phlebasconsidered · 24/07/2021 08:50

The Boy in the Striped pajamas is not appropriate and is specifically recommended agaisnt by the Holocaust Trust. It embeds many misconceptions and is inaccurate. Please don't use it in primary.

restbetweentheelements · 24/07/2021 08:44

@user16395699 this thread was only about talking about terror, of course there were other things taught in the year, all of which were fine. The thread is only about teaching about terror. The fact that she thought up fantastic science projects does not detract from the fact that she told the class that a teacher had recently been beheaded by a terrorist.

I am quite surprised that so many posters think terror is ok for 9/10 year olds. The fact that some children experience terror first hand doesn't mean that all children should experience it first or second hand. And no, exposing children to terror does not mean that they will understand it and not do it to anyone else. Just as hitting does not teach a child to not hit.

The holocaust guidelines state that when teaching about the holocaust to 9 and 10 year olds, you should not teach about the details of the camps or the killing, you should focus on other elements, and introduce other aspects as children mature.

The issue isn't how my dc reacted - or how I reacted when I was told about medieval torture methods - the AIBU was whether the terror should be taught to 9/10 year olds.

OP posts: