Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

10 year olds learning about the holocaust etc

258 replies

restbetweentheelements · 23/07/2021 19:48

Dc's yeargroup are 9/10
His teacher this year has told them in graphic detail about:

  • gas chambers in german concentration camps
  • terror in french revolution by showing painting of chopped off head with blood held up next to guillotine and details of what happened
  • all about the charlie hebdo teacher terrorist attack in france
  • murders in news how many women were killed by partners - they chatted about the news on fridays and dc said it was never about life affirming things (he said nice or interesting things)
DC has been affected by it, and he drew a picture of his teacher with a guillotine and children and he wrote "our teacher is killing us with terror" (he draws a lot, is quite expressive generally...) - i found the drawing screwed up in the bottom of his bag

YANBU - the teaching is not appropriate, the subject matter of treatment of Jews etc is ok in age appropriare way is okay but focusing on terror aspects is not
YABU - no problem with this

If YANBU, then WWYD
I remember learning about medieval torture methods when 10, at school. Is there some sort of theory about terror being useful for 10 year olds???

OP posts:
fourminutestosavetheworld · 25/07/2021 07:29

I'm guessing he only has a couple more days in this class op, if he hasn't already finished. Hopefully you can help him process it all over the Summer holidays and he'll have a better experience at secondary in September.

gogohm · 24/07/2021 23:20

I admit I might not be typical but I took mine to Bergen Belsen at ages 9&11 - we don't sugarcoat history but we give them age appropriate information

gogohm · 24/07/2021 23:15

We learned about the holocaust in year 6 and read Anne franks diary (her dad appeared on blue Peter that year too which I remember vividly). We didn't learn that anyone other than Jews were executed though.

We learned about the Khmer Rouge which had recently happened in maybe year 5, definitely primary. Also learned about Vietnam agent orange etc

LolaSmiles · 24/07/2021 22:53

The teacher started these classes around April, and they were on a particular day and DC would say on that morning "Oh God - more trauma today" (with dark humour). How would you feel if a work colleague came in every week with some new grim details to share thinking that everyone just needed to know in order to save the world from future terror?!
If something was seriously concerning me in April I'd have raised it with school then instead of subjecting my child to something that both them and I apparently consider highly traumatic for several months.

I don't really understand why a parent would leave such a serious concern several months only ro raise it on Mumsnet. It seems a bit of an odd response given the level of trauma it's apparently caused.

fourminutestosavetheworld · 24/07/2021 12:29

" I think you are missing the point here - the guidelines say that the grim details should not be taught at all - there have been at least 4 posts upthread which say this explicitly, quoting from the guidelines"

Yes I follow the guidelines. I am asking you to consider that the odd conversation that pushed those may have been an unplanned response to a question or comment from another child, as that has certainly been my experience.

I doubt her lesson plan was to terrorise kids about Charlie Hebdo. But that attack was covered on Newsround. It can be discussed appropriately with young children.

I don't agree with the details of what experiences may have entailed in the gas chamber. At times I have wanted to push this, usually in response to children sniggering or showing a breathtaking lack of empathy. Of course, I don't.

Perhaps you need to hone your list to things that you have a legitimate grievance about, if things unfolded as your son says, and avoid muddying the water with things that do appear oversensitive (portrait of French Revolution for example), and talk to the teacher.

restbetweentheelements · 24/07/2021 12:19

To the poster who asked about the news, DC will watch some news but not all. Everything will be spoken about, but not the grim details. Covid changed things a bit because it wasn't possible to filter it at times - I htink it has affected all children.

I am going to bow out of the thread now - I wanted to know how most people saw this sort of thing and thank you to everyone who posted all their different opinions.

OP posts:
thelegohooverer · 24/07/2021 12:10

Teaching horror and terror to children desensitises them. The goal should be to cultivate empathy.

restbetweentheelements · 24/07/2021 12:04

@I8toys

The news is worse. My youngest learnt about Anne Frank in year 6 and we visited her museum in Amsterdam. Both of my 2 now 15 and 17 have a profound love of history with so much more knowledge than I have. They particularly love ww1 and ww2 history and visiting historic sites. Travel restrictions have stopped our visit to dresden, leipzig, Nuremberg, Munich and Dachau. I love their enthusiasm and passion for the subject. Their great grandfather was a pow so to me it's important.
But the museum will state what age it is appropriate for. We have a Holocaust Museum near us too - it states 10 up - and it is appropriate for 10 up. My dc already knew about Anne Frank and the holocaust and the political setting before the class - the teacher commented to me about his knowledge - he has books on a variety of subjects and reads them regularly. He isn't being shielded at all. This is the point - he did not need to be told about the grim details - and the guidelines recommend that children in primary are not told the grim details.

I wish people would read the thread before commenting as this has been said several times.

We are part Jewish - it is important to us too!

OP posts:
Sirzy · 24/07/2021 12:03

So your saying you believe your son was being traumatised in school every week but didn’t say anything from April to now? Confused and yet now suddenly it’s a massive issue

restbetweentheelements · 24/07/2021 12:00

@fourminutestosavetheworld

"DC is usually accurate when relaying stories about what happened in class, his teacher would agree with that, from what she has said to me."

Just ask her then.

But I think you will find the points you raised were not taught in isolation. They were set in the context of the wider lesson or sequence of lessons. In some cases, they may have been a minute out of an hour long lesson. They may have arisen as a child asked a question.

Your child isn't lying. He is telling you his perception of the lesson, where those distressing details were writ large and took on disproportionate significance in his mind, gaining momentum at home when you displayed some disapproval or doubt about the teacher.

Such lessons are rooted in the NC and a lot of discussion goes into the level of detail that is appropriate, and which resources to use.

For me, the fact that your son is upset at a painting of the French Revolution, suggests some unusual sensitivity. I wouldn't go in from a position of thinking that the teacher is not acting appropriately, but from a position of wanting to support your son. I'm not suggesting that you ignore it btw. I have only ever had one complaint about how WW2 is taught in our school, and that little boy did go on to need an awful lot of support, so it is certainly best to investigate.

@fourminutestosavetheworld I think you are missing the point here - the guidelines say that the grim details should not be taught at all - there have been at least 4 posts upthread which say this explicitly, quoting from the guidelines

Lessons in maths, language, science, history, sport, geography, the world around all take into consideration the child's stage of development in terms of cognitive ability and physical ability. Yet they do not across the board take on board the child's stage of development in terms of what the child can process, emotional maturity.

I think covering all these subjects is right, in an age appropriate way.
Time spent teaching children about emotional intelligence and doing projects in the community to build empathy would be time better spent than grim details about terror.

The teacher started these classes around April, and they were on a particular day and DC would say on that morning "Oh God - more trauma today" (with dark humour). How would you feel if a work colleague came in every week with some new grim details to share thinking that everyone just needed to know in order to save the world from future terror?!

OP posts:
I8toys · 24/07/2021 11:55

The news is worse. My youngest learnt about Anne Frank in year 6 and we visited her museum in Amsterdam. Both of my 2 now 15 and 17 have a profound love of history with so much more knowledge than I have. They particularly love ww1 and ww2 history and visiting historic sites. Travel restrictions have stopped our visit to dresden, leipzig, Nuremberg, Munich and Dachau. I love their enthusiasm and passion for the subject. Their great grandfather was a pow so to me it's important.

fourminutestosavetheworld · 24/07/2021 11:51

"I don't think anyone can really comment unless they were in the classroom to be honest. We dont know how the information was presented - juSt the Op's interpretation of her child's interpretation."

So true. Really wish more parents took this sensible view.

fourminutestosavetheworld · 24/07/2021 11:48

@sadperson16

Poor poor little kids in the UK. Rammed into formal learning aged 4, sitting behind a desk at 6, learning about genocide at 10.

Every minute of their lives mapped out and accounted for. Or the other end of the spectrum, roaming the streets and scrounging for food. Sleep deprived, malnourished.

For Gods Sake, when did common sense leave?

Haha I don't recognise that description of my own children or those I've taught. I'm sure there are better education systems, and plenty worse too. I don't feel that the world eyes the participants of our education system with pity really.
rantymcrantface66 · 24/07/2021 11:28

know what you mean, but I just dont think that terrorising children is the way to teach empathy and right from wrong and and diversity.

Terrorising them, really? By teaching them historical facts which I'm sure was done in a manner appropriate to the age group. The use of hyperbole doesn't help your case.

I don't think anyone can really comment unless they were in the classroom to be honest. We dont know how the information was presented - juSt the Op's interpretation of her child's interpretation.

I also agree strongly with this.

Mommabear20 · 24/07/2021 11:22

I'd rather them learn it early and be scared/shocked by it, than at a later stage and it have no effect!

KittenKong · 24/07/2021 11:21

I was more scared of ghosts and quicksand (yes really) as a small child. And the Black Panthers (I don’t know why, but I thought they were actual panthers and coming to get me).

Notonthestairs · 24/07/2021 11:14

I don't think anyone can really comment unless they were in the classroom to be honest. We dont know how the information was presented - juSt the Op's interpretation of her child's interpretation.

Worth talking to the teacher direct though.

sadperson16 · 24/07/2021 11:10

There is a shed load of research to show that starting an educational straitjacket with young children is having disastrous effects on their MH

I dont think 10 year olds need their minds burdened by detail about genocide.

BewareTheBeardedDragon · 24/07/2021 11:01

@Oblomov21

"Not about the grim details."

But teacher didn't give grim details. She plainly told them the facts. How else are you supposed to explain it. Her sentences were factual, succinct abc to the point. They sound perfect to me.

Knowing about the gas chambers and that people climbed over each other attempting to escape but all died inside is a grim detail that imo is not necessary to tell to children of this age.

I don't think that age 10 is too young to know any of these things, but focusing and emphasising the horrifying details is not necessary at this age imo.

My dc aged 7 and 9 know about the concentration camps, that millions were murdered there, but not how - yet.

They know that 2 women a week are killed by current or former partners but not details of how that might happen.

They know about the terror in the French Revolution, but only broad details.

They don't know about Charlie Hebdo but they do know about the terror attacks in London - again not in detail. They know there are bad people in the world, but they don't need to become terrified of going anywhere because a terrorist might attack - which they would if I didn't limit what they learn.

I think YANBU OP. They can learn all these things in an age appropriate way.

dottiedodah · 24/07/2021 10:58

My DGF was in the first world war,he never spoke about it once ,apart from saying he had to look after his horse first .That was all ,Obv traumitised

KittenKong · 24/07/2021 10:56

I learned more a lot the war at the knee of my parents and grandparents (until I went to secondary school and studied history).

Tossblanket · 24/07/2021 10:56

I personally think it's too young.

They've got plenty of time to learn about how fucking brutal life can be.

Can't they just be left as kids without any worry or anxiety for as long as possible?

dottiedodah · 24/07/2021 10:56

I think he is too young personally .Some children are more sensitive than others and 10 is still quite young IMO. I appreciate the need to educate children but going into gory detail like this seems like overkill to me

Geamhradh · 24/07/2021 10:50

@sadperson16

Poor poor little kids in the UK. Rammed into formal learning aged 4, sitting behind a desk at 6, learning about genocide at 10.

Every minute of their lives mapped out and accounted for. Or the other end of the spectrum, roaming the streets and scrounging for food. Sleep deprived, malnourished.

For Gods Sake, when did common sense leave?

With your post probably.
sadperson16 · 24/07/2021 10:49

Poor poor little kids in the UK. Rammed into formal learning aged 4, sitting behind a desk at 6, learning about genocide at 10.

Every minute of their lives mapped out and accounted for. Or the other end of the spectrum, roaming the streets and scrounging for food. Sleep deprived, malnourished.

For Gods Sake, when did common sense leave?