Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

10 year olds learning about the holocaust etc

258 replies

restbetweentheelements · 23/07/2021 19:48

Dc's yeargroup are 9/10
His teacher this year has told them in graphic detail about:

  • gas chambers in german concentration camps
  • terror in french revolution by showing painting of chopped off head with blood held up next to guillotine and details of what happened
  • all about the charlie hebdo teacher terrorist attack in france
  • murders in news how many women were killed by partners - they chatted about the news on fridays and dc said it was never about life affirming things (he said nice or interesting things)
DC has been affected by it, and he drew a picture of his teacher with a guillotine and children and he wrote "our teacher is killing us with terror" (he draws a lot, is quite expressive generally...) - i found the drawing screwed up in the bottom of his bag

YANBU - the teaching is not appropriate, the subject matter of treatment of Jews etc is ok in age appropriare way is okay but focusing on terror aspects is not
YABU - no problem with this

If YANBU, then WWYD
I remember learning about medieval torture methods when 10, at school. Is there some sort of theory about terror being useful for 10 year olds???

OP posts:
restbetweentheelements · 26/07/2021 18:29

[quote Taliskerskye]@Tal45
I didn’t mean from bad parenting. There are plenty of 10 -11 yr olds who have seen things via friends phones which are graphic. Lots of kids don’t have age appropriate parental control on their devices

You are deluded and naive if you think that some children this age haven’t been exposed to some kind of graphic content on a smart phone.[/quote]
No he won't have seen porn, but yes some ten year olds will have seen graphic content on phones, at home, video games. This is another thing that bugs me, to be honest. Going on statitistics, there will be children in the class who are witnessing DV, are being sexually abused, will be being neglected. I just think it is bizarre that some teachers then think it appropriate that they are taught about the blood and gore as they are. I think there should be a bit more thought about this in terms of policy, and all schools and teachers expected to follow strict guidelines.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 26/07/2021 17:46

I think the focus on terror and nothing else is too much for Y5. You can learn about WW2 without focusing on horrifying facts.

I know at that age when I was at school we had some actors come in to do a play about all the horrible things that happened to DC over history. I had nightmares and anxiety about that for ages afterwards.

Hope your DS is ok. At least he is on holidays now and his next teacher hopefully won't be so fixated on terror.

leonpride · 26/07/2021 17:38

I drew a picture of a guillotine at his age learning about the tudors. You're acting like he's going to be psychologically damaged from learning history like every other child

How do you expect him to go to secondary without knowing anything about these things? As long as it's age appropriate, it's ok. Maybe speak to the teacher

Taliskerskye · 26/07/2021 17:32

@Tal45
I didn’t mean from bad parenting. There are plenty of 10 -11 yr olds who have seen things via friends phones which are graphic. Lots of kids don’t have age appropriate parental control on their devices

You are deluded and naive if you think that some children this age haven’t been exposed to some kind of graphic content on a smart phone.

Tal45 · 26/07/2021 17:21

@Taliskerskye

He’s probably already seen porn. Yes this is what people get upset about!
Shocking that you think that, he's ten years old and unless he has unlimited access to the internet he probably hasn't seen porn. If your child is parented properly there's no reason they should have access to porn at that age.

I think a sensitive 10 year old could really struggle with the holocaust. We read a book around that age that was fictional about a nuclear holocaust and people trying to survive after. It was a really horrible book and I was really quite traumatised by it although it was written for children. Totally unnecessary to learn about these things at this age, there are plenty of years left to cover it.

Taliskerskye · 26/07/2021 17:08

He’s probably already seen porn.
Yes this is what people get upset about!

restbetweentheelements · 26/07/2021 14:45

@Maggiemay92

Also, stop calling it 'terror' for dramatic effect. It's not terror. It's history.
Just to clarify "Killing us with Terror" was a play on words - it was a reference to a period of history known to historians as The Terror - Robespierre was in charge and huge numbers went to the guillotine without trial. Dc's teacher had gone into detail about this.

There is terror in history and as others have said, you can teach history with or without the terror aspects. I do in fact think that knowing about the terror is important, but only for much older children.

OP posts:
restbetweentheelements · 26/07/2021 14:42

@fourminutestosavetheworld

I'm guessing he only has a couple more days in this class op, if he hasn't already finished. Hopefully you can help him process it all over the Summer holidays and he'll have a better experience at secondary in September.
@fourminutestosavetheworld I read your earlier posts and came back to the thread because I wanted to ask you a question. Firstly, just to confirm that dc is penultimate year of primary, next year is final year. i talked to him each time to help him process during the year. I said he was affected not that he didn't cope, he is fairly resilient, and what I said here was just a tiny snapshot of the last year. This thread is more about me reflecting and working out what to do next year.

This is what I wanted to ask you about:
For me, the fact that your son is upset at a painting of the French Revolution, suggests some unusual sensitivity. I wouldn't go in from a position of thinking that the teacher is not acting appropriately, but from a position of wanting to support your son. I'm not suggesting that you ignore it btw. I have only ever had one complaint about how WW2 is taught in our school, and that little boy did go on to need an awful lot of support, so it is certainly best to investigate just to clarify that the talk about the French Revolution went into detail about the guillotine and the "Terror" and some of the tortures and punishments and so it wasn't just looking at a work of art. It was the same thing as the holocaust, in that dc has the book "Timelines of Everything" which covers the FR and we had talked about it before the lesson, about Robespierre and why things happened and what happened afterwards, and dc came home and said his teacher had talked a lot about the blood and gore instead - the book he read had a nod to the guillotine, but his teacher had gone into detail. Yes, I do take on board all your other comments.

That said, please could you explain what you mean about investigating sensitivities - that little boy did go on to need an awful lot of support - I am just not clear about what you mean, don't worry about offending me, I just wanted more information about what you thought needed to be investigated. Or would you re-think that advice given the detail the teacher went into in relation to this subject?

Thanks

OP posts:
BewareTheBeardedDragon · 26/07/2021 08:24

You can teach children about history in stages. They do not need to know graphic details at a very young age. You can tell them that millions of Jews, as well as disabled people and political dissenters were murdered in concentration camps without telling them exactly how. Ime just telling mine the scale of it, and using the word murder has been enough to get it through to them, without traumatising them. They are horrified enough to know that children were amongst those killed without knowing exactly how.

Similarly the slave trade.

There is no need to shy away from the basic facts of history, but there is also no need to gratuitously subject them to inappropriate detail.

And OP was talking about Charlie Hebdo as well, so the word terror was completely appropriate in that context.

sadperson16 · 26/07/2021 07:33

Of course this subject needs to be taught. Just not to young children in great detail.

Maggiemay92 · 25/07/2021 23:48

Also, stop calling it 'terror' for dramatic effect. It's not terror. It's history.

Maggiemay92 · 25/07/2021 23:46

How can history be inappropriate?! This is madness. History is SO important. It's not all nice - in fact - the most important things weren't at all nice. We still need to teach it to our kids.

Whatafustercluck · 25/07/2021 23:08

A 9 year old at Belsen? What on earth were you thinking?

I was just a little older when I learned that my granddad had been part of the liberation of Bergen Belsen, complete with the horrors he witnessed there. The one thing that still cuts me to the core is that had they arrived a week earlier then Anne Frank may have survived. I have no problem talking to my 10yo ds about the evils of prejudice, ignorance and intolerance as a result.

ichundich · 25/07/2021 22:53

Still unnecessary and potentially damaging at age 10/11. German schools tend to organise a trip to a concentration camp around the middle of secondary school (14 years).

Polkadots2021 · 25/07/2021 21:53

@Aroundtheworldin80moves

When DDs went to school in Germany (a British school) Yr5/6 had a school trip to a Concentration Camp.

History should be learnt about and from, not forgotten.

Jesus that's a lot to take in at a young age. I applaud the school though. It's the kind of thing you don't forget and kids their age would've been in the camps. That's the reality and they probably will never forgot what they learned there.

I've been to the Holocaust museum in Israel and despite it all it's a positive and elegant place (heartbreaking and sad obviously but so utterly dignified and such a powerful place).

GoldBar · 25/07/2021 21:36

Teaching children about horror that they can’t change at too young an age is psychologically harmful and sadistic.

I agree. Children need the emotional tools to process this kind of information and to put it in context. Very few primary school pupils will have that kind of emotional maturity.

Children will have different responses - it will go over some children's heads, some will be fixated by the gory details and some more sensitive ones will be traumatized. Many primary school children will be unable to respond appropriately to and understand the lessons which the teacher is trying to teach. The impact would be far greater if taught at an appropriate age.

Skysblue · 25/07/2021 21:30

Yanbu. Some children are more sensitive than others. The children of less sensitive parents will never grasp the horror and trauma that this kind of ‘teaching’ causes sensitive children. My child has been given nightmares by school lessons many many times. One topic caused the whole class to have nightmares for a two weeks. There is something very wrong with English primary school topics.

Teaching children about horror that they can’t change at too young an age is psychologically harmful and sadistic.

This can be covered perfectly well at secondary school. It was taught at age 14 when I was at school.

KittenKong · 25/07/2021 21:05

Well you will want to avoid the utter sh* on tik tok who - for some reason known only to their own sick little heads - are ‘dressing up’ as concentration camp victims (to look like the awful portrait photos that were taken as they arrived).

LemonRoses · 25/07/2021 20:50

@sadperson16

It turns my 63 year old stomach.I would never choose to visit such places,nor spend time thinking about the horrors of it

How on earth can a child process this stuff? I have a choice. A 9 year old with their parents has no choice,a child in a classroom has limited choice.

Yes mine too, thank goodness. That is the reason it must be taught, to ensure it continues to horrify and remains sufficiently known to be abhorrent.
MrsSkylerWhite · 25/07/2021 20:30

“It turns my 63 year old stomach …”

Mine too, late 50s, which is precisely why it needs to be taught.

eeek88 · 25/07/2021 18:21

I teach year 5/6 and refuse to go into detail about the Holocaust because I think it will either traumatise or desensitise them. They can’t grasp concepts on this scale. We do talk about hitler and how he gained the support of ordinary people through propaganda etc. Usually some of the kids will then share what they know about the Holocaust or ask questions, and I facilitate a short discussion but tell them they really need to be older to find out more.

I think your son’s teacher has misjudged this one. Is he inexperienced? If so I’d have a friendly chat and explain the impact on your son.

sadperson16 · 25/07/2021 12:32

It turns my 63 year old stomach.I would never choose to visit such places,nor spend time thinking about the horrors of it

How on earth can a child process this stuff? I have a choice. A 9 year old with their parents has no choice,a child in a classroom has limited choice.

ichundich · 25/07/2021 11:58

@sadperson16

A 9 year old at Belsen? What on earth were you thinking?

Pandemic = trauma and loss.Therefore curriculum should be adjusted accordingly.

I was comparing that too. So many people claim kids have been "traumatised" by the pandemic, yet judging from this thread the large majority are happy to subject their primary school aged children to all the gory details of the biggest crime in history!
sadperson16 · 25/07/2021 09:37

A 9 year old at Belsen? What on earth were you thinking?

Pandemic = trauma and loss.Therefore curriculum should be adjusted accordingly.

casualnamechange · 25/07/2021 08:02

My old class were very interested in WW2. I told them some bits about the Holocaust and about the amount of people who died but not about the method of deaths. They do a whole unit of work on WW2 in Year 6 and I think that covers it in slightly more detail but even then, I don’t think they go too far into it - rightly or wrongly.

Personally I feel like I wouldn’t really have these kinds of conversations on the fly. You can never ensure that every member of the class is leaving the conversation without being confused or worried and they’re so likely at that age to take it home and say “Miss X told us about…”

I’m perfectly happy to address difficult themes with my class and we recently read a novel written for adults in our English work which dealt with a lot of challenging topics. My team and I discussed how to approach them and then we discussed them as a class, and it was really interesting. If children deliberately ask me about real life events then I don’t pretend they’re not true (I was asked about school shootings once which was tricky) but I just think it’s a difficult one. I can think of several children in my old class who would have been very unsettled by this kind of thing. It’s not always appropriate in a class setting and it can easily be handled wrong.