Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

10 year olds learning about the holocaust etc

258 replies

restbetweentheelements · 23/07/2021 19:48

Dc's yeargroup are 9/10
His teacher this year has told them in graphic detail about:

  • gas chambers in german concentration camps
  • terror in french revolution by showing painting of chopped off head with blood held up next to guillotine and details of what happened
  • all about the charlie hebdo teacher terrorist attack in france
  • murders in news how many women were killed by partners - they chatted about the news on fridays and dc said it was never about life affirming things (he said nice or interesting things)
DC has been affected by it, and he drew a picture of his teacher with a guillotine and children and he wrote "our teacher is killing us with terror" (he draws a lot, is quite expressive generally...) - i found the drawing screwed up in the bottom of his bag

YANBU - the teaching is not appropriate, the subject matter of treatment of Jews etc is ok in age appropriare way is okay but focusing on terror aspects is not
YABU - no problem with this

If YANBU, then WWYD
I remember learning about medieval torture methods when 10, at school. Is there some sort of theory about terror being useful for 10 year olds???

OP posts:
IceLace100 · 27/07/2021 12:46

@theThreeofWeevils

Ten is by no means too young to experience that 'This is real and could happen to ME (and mummy and daddy and siblings and then what would happen to poor Fido/Felix) moment. So what if the child is upset? Being upset is part of being alive.
Agree. Being upset is an appropriate response to learning about genocide.
Kanaloa · 27/07/2021 12:40

I don’t particularly think my kids learned anything from horrible histories except an appreciation of what was accepted in the past and how much things have changed. I didn’t have an issue with them learning it however.

Obviously you do, but it could be your son is just extra sensitive and needs support while learning about difficult subjects.

Silveroriole · 27/07/2021 11:45

A few years ago I went to Northern Ballet's brilliant take of The Boy in Striped Pyjamas. There was a class of 10 year olds in the audience, very engaged and well-behaved, but during the last scene in the gas chambers, choreographed and danced very sensitively, the children were laughing at the people taking off their clothes, cheering the goodies, and booing the baddies. They didn't mean to be disrespectful, they were just too young to understand properly. Surely there's plenty in history to learn about at this age without concentrating on one of the the most horrific and evil periods? Either it has to be taught fully and the children traumatised, or taught superficially and the children unaware of the outcome....neither is right. Save it for age 15/16 when its origins and affects can be properly understood.
I have Jewish heritage myself so agree that it's necessary to learn about it, but not ar the tender age of ten. I think it's immoral to fill their minds with those horrors at primary school.
Spending the time on learning about prejudice, false information, peer group pressure, scapegoating, etc. would be better at this age.

Demelza82 · 27/07/2021 09:49

I was definitely taught about the Holocaust at Primary school in the early 90s with more detail being added at secondary school.

Remember that kids have more access to extremist stuff easier these days thanks to the internet so I'd rather my kid learnt about anti-Semitism, extremism at all levels from me/at school before some fascist or incel on the internet decides to do it

restbetweentheelements · 27/07/2021 09:33

@kanaloa I have replied to that upthread. DC read about the French Revolution, the social and political aspects, ouline of guillotine, what led up to the FR, the consequences, about the personalities like Robespierre, a year before they covered it in class. I did a history degree and that is how we covered it, the torture isn't seen as a key issue, although it might be when studying other periods. About the holocaust the guidelines say that details of the mass killings should not be taught to primary aged.

So, turning your question around, what do you think your dc gained from learning about drawing and quartering before the age of 10?

Where would you draw the line - what did you not want your 10 year old to know about?

The books we have probably concentrate more on politics, economics, social issues - not avoiding gore completely but not making it the focal point.

OP posts:
accentdusoleil · 27/07/2021 09:23

@Cormoran thank you to her and all the others. Their bravery should never be underestimated or forgotten . Merci infiniment.

Kanaloa · 27/07/2021 09:03

Drawing and quartering is detailed in horrible histories, which my kids read before age 10. As I said, I think it would be difficult to teach some of these topics without the horror, how would you like it to be taught?

restbetweentheelements · 27/07/2021 08:52

As was said a few times upthread, there is no problem with the subject matter, more that it was going against guidelines in how it was being taught - this is talked about upthread and the guidelines quoted.

In relation to the picture of the French Revolution, the teacher was talking in detail about the blood and gore - talking about the guillotine but also giving examples of other methods of killing such as pulling bodies a part with horses tied to each arm and each leg - do people think that that is appropriate and/or helpful? I don't but wanted to know what other people thought hence this thread.

The other subject matter mentioned - poverty, starvation, khmer rouge - I have talked to dc about all of this without going into detail of terror or horror or blood and gore.

Being killed with the terror was a play on words as they were talking about Robespierre and what is known as "The Terror"

OP posts:
Cormoran · 27/07/2021 02:42

My grandmother was in the French resistance, got caught , tortured by Gestapo and sent to a concentration camp. She survived and holocaust, wars, gestapo torture and in general how humans have this infinite ability to inflict pain and fear on others humans is something I was told from very early age ( before primary) and I did the same with my kids.

And many more topics I believe children should be educated about , such how empires and powerful countries were built by enslaving and/ or exploiting others, apartheid, …

theThreeofWeevils · 27/07/2021 02:08

Ten is by no means too young to experience that 'This is real and could happen to ME (and mummy and daddy and siblings and then what would happen to poor Fido/Felix) moment. So what if the child is upset? Being upset is part of being alive.

DeRigueurMortis · 26/07/2021 23:34

@IceLace100

They need to know the gruesome details and be shocked / upset / horrified by them so it never happens again.

👏👏👏

DeRigueurMortis · 26/07/2021 23:34

When do you expect to learn about these atrocities and not be shocked and upset?

Would you prefer your child not to have a reaction?

I spoke to DS about this knowing it was a school topic. He was sad. He was disturbed. He was distressed. He cried.

I was glad he did.

Totally appropriate reactions.

That's exactly why we tell the history so they are visceral experiences and won't be forgotten.

IceLace100 · 26/07/2021 23:23

They need to know the gruesome details and be shocked / upset / horrified by them so it never happens again.

IncorrigibleTitmouse · 26/07/2021 22:52

@restbetweentheelements

Dc's yeargroup are 9/10 His teacher this year has told them in graphic detail about:
  • gas chambers in german concentration camps
  • terror in french revolution by showing painting of chopped off head with blood held up next to guillotine and details of what happened
  • all about the charlie hebdo teacher terrorist attack in france
  • murders in news how many women were killed by partners - they chatted about the news on fridays and dc said it was never about life affirming things (he said nice or interesting things)
DC has been affected by it, and he drew a picture of his teacher with a guillotine and children and he wrote "our teacher is killing us with terror" (he draws a lot, is quite expressive generally...) - i found the drawing screwed up in the bottom of his bag

YANBU - the teaching is not appropriate, the subject matter of treatment of Jews etc is ok in age appropriare way is okay but focusing on terror aspects is not
YABU - no problem with this

If YANBU, then WWYD
I remember learning about medieval torture methods when 10, at school. Is there some sort of theory about terror being useful for 10 year olds???

We devoted the whole of year 6 history to WW2 and learned about the Holocaust and that was in 1993! I think that's an appropriate age to introduce it. As I recall, most of the kids in a history class loved the gruesome details of death and torture.

I was a sensitive soul and didn't like it at all but I was in the minority. I suppose that's why Horrible Histories is so popular.

DeflatedGinDrinker · 26/07/2021 22:50

Non issue op sounds about the age mine were taught it.

VenusStarr · 26/07/2021 22:38

I learnt about the holocaust when I was on year 6, so aged 9. I recall watching a graphic video and a friend whispered to me that she would've taken her gask mask in the chamber and I told her she was stupid and I got sent out of the classroom.

Kanaloa · 26/07/2021 22:31

Also, having helped my kids when learning about the Holocaust, I have absolutely no idea how you would teach what Jewish people went through ‘without the terror.’ What would that look like?

Kanaloa · 26/07/2021 22:29

My 10 & 11 yo have both read a lot around the Holocaust and world war 2 - they did it in school and read Goodnight Mister Tom and also watched an interview of an elderly lady telling the story of how she had been taken away to a camp with her family - it really affected my son as the lady had brothers and sisters and they were all separated, I think one of them died too.

I think the best thing is to talk through why this is upsetting and why it’s important. Big feelings for a 10 year old to work through and sometimes they need support to understand these feelings. There are lots of books aimed at kids this age (Horrible Histories for one) that describe history in its gruesome truth.

ichundich · 26/07/2021 22:12

[quote Taliskerskye]@Tal45
I didn’t mean from bad parenting. There are plenty of 10 -11 yr olds who have seen things via friends phones which are graphic. Lots of kids don’t have age appropriate parental control on their devices

You are deluded and naive if you think that some children this age haven’t been exposed to some kind of graphic content on a smart phone.[/quote]
Whilst this is a worrying trend, I don't think these two things are at all comparable.

ichundich · 26/07/2021 22:10

@malificent7

I thought kids love this gruesome stuff...horrible histories anyone? Anyway, I thought one point of history is to reflect on the horrors that mankind is capable of.
"Love the gruesome stuff" when you mean the Holocaust? Are you for real?!!
Wantaweekinthesun · 26/07/2021 21:08

He will be in high school in a year. It's fine. I honestly think kids are mollycoddled far too much these days.

DeRigueurMortis · 26/07/2021 21:04

Frankly I think not teaching kids about these horrors is irresponsible.

Wrapping children in cotton wool does them a disservice.

The world is often not a nice place.

Even today there are children dying because of poverty.

Girls being sold as sex slaves. Children being blown up and suffering life changing injuries.

There are absolutely ways to explain these issues to 10 year old that are age appropriate.

Many families have to do this, quite simply to explain their own history.

Why they left their home country.

Why their grandparents have no living siblings.

Why their brother has no legs.

Etc etc.

It's the height of privilege to protect your child from these issues.

Maybe reflect on that Biscuit

malificent7 · 26/07/2021 18:49

I thought kids love this gruesome stuff...horrible histories anyone?
Anyway, I thought one point of history is to reflect on the horrors that mankind is capable of.

owlbethere · 26/07/2021 18:44

The ONLY part she taught was the stripping etc?

I don’t think so.

restbetweentheelements · 26/07/2021 18:30

statistics!

OP posts: