Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

10 year olds learning about the holocaust etc

258 replies

restbetweentheelements · 23/07/2021 19:48

Dc's yeargroup are 9/10
His teacher this year has told them in graphic detail about:

  • gas chambers in german concentration camps
  • terror in french revolution by showing painting of chopped off head with blood held up next to guillotine and details of what happened
  • all about the charlie hebdo teacher terrorist attack in france
  • murders in news how many women were killed by partners - they chatted about the news on fridays and dc said it was never about life affirming things (he said nice or interesting things)
DC has been affected by it, and he drew a picture of his teacher with a guillotine and children and he wrote "our teacher is killing us with terror" (he draws a lot, is quite expressive generally...) - i found the drawing screwed up in the bottom of his bag

YANBU - the teaching is not appropriate, the subject matter of treatment of Jews etc is ok in age appropriare way is okay but focusing on terror aspects is not
YABU - no problem with this

If YANBU, then WWYD
I remember learning about medieval torture methods when 10, at school. Is there some sort of theory about terror being useful for 10 year olds???

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
restbetweentheelements · 21/01/2022 20:22

*classmates'

@EdithRea thanks for your post. Also just in case you are interested for your 9 year old, and you haven't found them, DK do amazing books on the world wars (and geography! and everything else), for his age group, a lot of socio economic and political detail, details about key events and people, without gore!

OP posts:
restbetweentheelements · 21/01/2022 20:13

I was the OP - only saw these comments because I was sent an email!

DC were shown an appallingly inappropriate video first week back in Sept, I finally complained to the head and it hasn't happened since, thank goodness, and hopefully it won't. If they hadn't reacted we'd have moved schools.

The parents here saying the gore and details are fine - it isn't according to research though, it doesn't help a child learn as the shock will make the brain go offline, it won't help the child mature or grow up or understand empathy or politcs or anything better. You can teach every subject referred to here including slavery, the cambodian civil war, everything else to 10 year olds effectively without terror shock or gore.

I don't know if I mentioned this upthread but to those saying the french revolution is commonly known about for kids, if you google it i a pretty sure you'll find details you weren't aware of which will make you feel sick. Also slavery - would you read to 10 year olds real eyewitness accounts of how young girl slaves were stripped naked, made to lie face down with legs apart and arms and legs tied in a busy market place and then whipped? This is in the Guardian compendium of eye witness accounts. It is important history that we should all know about as adults, but for kids there is a line. Humans can be depraved towards eachother but you don't want your kids to know every gory detail surely.

Humans can also be outstandingly kind and powefully altruistic, and I'd prefer my 10 year old to be learning about that, doing kindness projects, so that that is his and his classmate's longterm blueprint. Plenty of time to learn about the crap in a few years from now.

Is what I think @Kanaloa but i am not judging you, as you think. Live and let live,we can agree to disagree. I am not particularly over sensitive, doubt my dc will be, they'll turn out like me, yours will turn out like you, that is fine and as it should be! I wanted to know what most people thought and why, and this thread was super helpful.

OP posts:
fuzzyduck1 · 21/01/2022 18:15

I knew about the holocaust and the horrors of war at the age of 10. I don’t think it’s unreasonable for them to learn these things at that age.
Maybe it’s different these days my parents grew up during the war it my be different these days as it’s more likely that children’s great grandparents were the ones that lived through it but they may not pass their experiences through to the kids.

The persecution of minorities still happens so it seems that people haven’t learn the lessons from the past that well.

alphabetsoup1980 · 21/01/2022 18:12

YABU.

EdithRea · 21/01/2022 18:06

I had to give my 9 year old an impromptu Holocaust chat because they were about to watch 'The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas'. This actually pissed me off, because it's a completely inaccurate and stupidly offensive book and a worse film. It clumsily makes the point that an audience can only care about deaths when a blonde kid gets involved. Such a dreadful message, and the book itself was poorly researched, poorly written and the author involved in plagiarism scandals, I believe. I basically told him "this is a crap book. When you're older you can read better ones. And better films, too."

ANYWAY the other issue is that at 9, frankly, none of the kids were equipped to comprehend or understand the matter to any depth. "Da bad man called Itler wanted to kill Jews" means nothing to a child if they haven't been taught any background - what is "the war", what is "the Jews", what is "the economic collapse after the punitive measures invoked after WWI", what is "antisemitism", what is "genocide."

My son and I read over a history book and he cried a bit, we both did, and he 'got' it, and we talked about it in some depth, but when he went in he said most of the kids just looked blank, couldn't answer any of the questions and were confused on basic aspects, like "what's Germany".

It just seemed a bit pointless. I could teach a bunch of five year olds about the events leading up to the Vietnam War and the Fall of Saigon, or the Cambodian Killing Fields, I'd have some nice Powerpoints and worksheets, but at the end of the day are they going to actually understand, or just be sat there looking blankly at me?

You need to kind of ease into it with your basic World War II knowledge. Set a bit of groundwork so the kids have some vague sense of where the events fit into modern history. You can't just be colouring a picture of a stone age house one day and the next day be like "well, good morning kids, here's Auschwitz".

Your other point is a good one. Primary schools are really keen, it seems, on using the killings of people, especially women, as a joke. See Henry VIII. How hilarious it is that a man murders two women and multiple men for his own ends. How funny saying "heads chopped off" is. Let's laugh at the rumour Anne had six fingers. It's vile. It's depressing that this is still going on, and even bringing in modern domestic violence murders? Jesus. There's a belief that "kids love gross stuff" but we should have evolved to the point that people being murdered isn't "funny" or "tee hee yucky". I mean, one minute the deaths of the Holocaust are tragic, but the deaths in the French Revolution are hilarious? What lesson are they learning there?

Kanaloa · 21/01/2022 17:43

Sorry meant that in reply to @AsYouWishButtercup

OP seemed to think I was a bit mean/was neglecting my motherly duties in not feeling worried about my kids learning these things but it’s all a part of history! If they were only going to learn a heavily sanitised version I’d sooner they remained ignorant altogether.

And the horrible histories books and tv programme are still great in my opinion! My kids absolutely loved them and it was one of those that the parent can enjoy too.

Kanaloa · 21/01/2022 17:39

@restbetweentheelements

This is a super old thread 😂 but yes I’m not sure how you would really cover the transatlantic slave trade without some violent content being included. Unless you rewrote it to resemble a Shirley Temple movie with happy slaves who love working. I guess I look for something different in history books to that review! Personally I look for accurate history.

thisplaceisweird · 21/01/2022 14:43

You need to grow a thicker skin and teach your children to do the same. The more drama you apply to the situation (stop bloody calling it 'terror' as a start) the more he will.

Those are all real things that happened. He needs to know. In 3 years he'll be a teenager and he should have a good idea of what the world is really like.

AsYouWishButtercup · 21/01/2022 14:38

[quote restbetweentheelements]@kanaloa Just checked out Horrible Histories which you recommended and find reviews are not all as positive as yours would be:

"I just found time to review the books before beginning to use them in my teaching. I am appalled to discover how much racism, violence, misogyny, and inappropriate content is depicted in these books"

"It appears that they ALL have material that is NOT age appropriate. Now I am stuck with a set of books that I cannot return any more, that I feel disgusted by...I believe book publishers need to be more responsible about their age ratings for the books they publish."

"the book about Aztecs had illustrations of their priests with human skins wrapped around their necks (an image I wish I could erase from my mind...). The book with US history in it showed African American slaves hanging from trees"

"In the Stormin Normans book, on page 12, there is a story about how William goes into a woman's room, beats her up, and then forces her to marry him...plant the seeds of domestic abuse against women in the minds of impressionable boys"

"These books are beyond disgusting"[/quote]
I’m a little embarrassed for the poster who wrote the first review TBH. Of course there’s racism and misogyny in our history! Writing about does not = condoning it. Do people really expect history to be sugar coated lest they upset little Timmy or point out something inconvenient?

AsYouWishButtercup · 21/01/2022 14:36

other methods of killing such as pulling bodies a part with horses tied to each arm and each leg - do people think that that is appropriate and/or helpful?

It’s fine - not like he’s doing a live demonstration FFS.

AsYouWishButtercup · 21/01/2022 14:35

My DD is nearly 9 and if she learnt a very valuable history lesson like this which also discussed the terror women feel every day, and made it about her in such a melodramatic way, the teacher would be the least of my problems

MarshmallowSwede · 21/01/2022 14:30

Imagine how Jewish children feel when they learn why they don’t have a large extended family.

History is important for children to learn. I they need to know the nice parts as well as the scary, horrible parts.

C152 · 21/01/2022 14:27

10 is not too young to be learning about these things. I'm actually surprised you don't talk about them at home.

Oblomov22 · 21/01/2022 14:03

Sorry what year is he? 5 or 6?
And is he a summer born - is he very young in his year?

Oblomov22 · 21/01/2022 13:56

I can't see the problem.
Ds2 learnt in year 6. Started with the boy in striped pyjamas. I think this is a fine age to start learning about it.

Simili · 21/01/2022 13:48

I think you probably haven't checked this website frenchrevolutiontimeline.com/ you can thank me later once you find the terror events majorly caused by the Robespierre that happened during the revolution.

gingerbiscuits · 27/07/2021 18:08

@warmandtoasty2day

it doesn't sound the sort of thing a 10 year old should be hearing tbh. Way too young.
It's just history & on the national curriculum! They're seeing plenty of much more inappropriate crap online, believe me!
restbetweentheelements · 27/07/2021 18:06

@kanaloa Just checked out Horrible Histories which you recommended and find reviews are not all as positive as yours would be:

"I just found time to review the books before beginning to use them in my teaching. I am appalled to discover how much racism, violence, misogyny, and inappropriate content is depicted in these books"

"It appears that they ALL have material that is NOT age appropriate. Now I am stuck with a set of books that I cannot return any more, that I feel disgusted by...I believe book publishers need to be more responsible about their age ratings for the books they publish."

"the book about Aztecs had illustrations of their priests with human skins wrapped around their necks (an image I wish I could erase from my mind...). The book with US history in it showed African American slaves hanging from trees"

"In the Stormin Normans book, on page 12, there is a story about how William goes into a woman's room, beats her up, and then forces her to marry him...plant the seeds of domestic abuse against women in the minds of impressionable boys"

"These books are beyond disgusting"

OP posts:
Emanchego · 27/07/2021 18:01

Of course kids should be learning history Hmm they should be learning about factual events that took place, not about men in dresses.

restbetweentheelements · 27/07/2021 17:55

@Kanaloa

Ok, well if you think your sons development and well-being is being damaged by learning about history, perhaps you could raise it with his teacher? Personally, I don’t think it’s an issue but appreciate that you do.
thanks kanaloa, you sound lovely.
OP posts:
Kanaloa · 27/07/2021 17:09

Ok, well if you think your sons development and well-being is being damaged by learning about history, perhaps you could raise it with his teacher? Personally, I don’t think it’s an issue but appreciate that you do.

MrsFin · 27/07/2021 16:01

We took our DDs to Dachau when they were around 10 or 12.
I think you're being a bit precious re your DS, sorry OP.

Youdiditanyway · 27/07/2021 15:45

We learnt about Anne Frank in year 5/6 and my Mum bought me the book which I enjoyed reading, still have it now. I wouldn’t say any of the above is inappropriate and I’ve told my own similar aged DC about most of it. Some children are inevitably more sensitive than others which can’t be helped, most would be unphased.

restbetweentheelements · 27/07/2021 15:10

@Kanaloa

I don’t particularly think my kids learned anything from horrible histories except an appreciation of what was accepted in the past and how much things have changed. I didn’t have an issue with them learning it however.

Obviously you do, but it could be your son is just extra sensitive and needs support while learning about difficult subjects.

It isn't in the past, though. One of DC's first questions to me was does that sort of thing happens still today. Yes it does. I asked where do you draw the line, and it was a genuine question. If your dc gets nothing positive from it, what is the point.

My opinion is as upthread, this sort of thing too young can affect the brain, future learning, development, wellbeing if it isn't properly processed. I think a number of dc in any one class are going to have vulnerabilities. Anyway, I wanted to know other people's opinions and I appreciate you giving yours.

OP posts:
Scottishshopaholic · 27/07/2021 13:12

I am going to assume that you have not actually sat in on any of the lessons and you are only hearing about it second hand from your son?

Is it possible that the gruesome elements are the only part of the lessons your son remembered/found interesting?

Surely if the teacher was only teaching history in such a morbid and disturbing way lots of other children would be traumatised and their parents would be complaining. How does your son get on with the teacher in general?

Also the drawing also sounds hilarious and very dramatic.

IMO children do need to be taught about the horrors of this sort of thing. I remember reading the Boy in Striped Pyjamas at maybe 11 and being shocked that I hadn’t learned about this sooner.

Swipe left for the next trending thread