Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Argument with dh

38 replies

Newjobnewstart · 23/07/2021 10:14

So i dont think i am being unreasonable but have to get some perspective.
Last night dh was having a few drinks with a friend. Up till about 1am. All good no issues with him catching up. My issue is that he was working this morning and has a 40 minute drive to get to work. He said he would be fine (5 pints of cider/2 beers)

I went down and told him that he wouldnt be able to drive today, he said he would be fine! I got a bit ratty here and told him i would hide his keys. I did shout a bit which im mortified and think his friend left not long after.

He is now away to work but i have no clue if he arrived ok and worried sick as well as pissed off! Am i being controlling?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
welliesarefuntowear · 23/07/2021 15:39

And yanbu OP

welliesarefuntowear · 23/07/2021 15:38

I don't think I've seen a post more relevant @Shoxfordian

NoMoreHouses · 23/07/2021 15:34

If you drink four pints of medium-strong beer or four large glasses of wine, it can take as long as 14 hours for the alcohol to clear your system. It’s not just a case of being over the drink drive limit, you are THIRTEEN times more likely to be involved in a fatal crash if you are at (but not over) the English limit. Just a small amount of alcohol slows your reaction time, inhibits judgement and reduces both concentration and co-ordination - increasing the likelihood of an accident. If you are driving the ‘morning after the night before’, test your alcohol level with a personal breathalyser – you can buy them at alcosense.co.uk

CaptSkippy · 23/07/2021 14:50

@DysmalRadius

You cant control someone elses actions, even if you believe its for the better good.

If asking someone to stop drinking to try and avoid them breaking the law is controlling, then how do you get anything done? I ask my husband to do stuff all the time - can you feed the kids, because I working, can you put the bins out because I've hurt my back - is that controlling? I don't really understand how some relationships work if one partner is allowed NO input or even to comment on the other's behaviour without being accused of trying to control them.

This 100%.

I am getting so sick of this shit. Why is it that when someone (typically a woman) expresses her opinion on something she is "controlling".

I think the 50s called and is asking for its sexism back.

Pippa12 · 23/07/2021 14:46

FWIW I’ve had crossed words with my DH on the same subject. He doesn’t touch a drop if he’s driving but doesn’t exercise the same principles if he’s drinking the night before an early drive! Really annoys me, I can’t abide drink driving- selfish and careless!

tothelakes · 23/07/2021 13:44

@Shoxfordian

I’m sorry for your loss but I don’t see that it’s relevant.

I wouldn’t tell my partner he couldn’t drive and hide his keys, he’s an adult and he makes his own choices.

If my partner drove and was over the limit I would report them to the police.
DysmalRadius · 23/07/2021 13:04

I wouldn’t tell my partner he couldn’t drive and hide his keys, he’s an adult and he makes his own choices.

Really? Does that extend to other crimes as well? Would you leave him wandering in the road drunk even if you thought he could get injured or cause an accident? Would you not help him make safe choices if his judgement were impaired in any other way such as being concussed, hypoglycaemia or feverish?

Again, I'm really surprised by how little interest some people take in their partners' wellbeing and their impact on society. I'm pretty sure I would intervene if I saw a stranger trying to drive drunk (and I have when I worked in a pub) because when someone's judgement is impaired they make choices that are dangerous to everyone. I see it as part of being a member of a community to try and help, much like finding parents of a lost child or helping someone change a tyre if you are able.

DianeCherry · 23/07/2021 12:28

@Drivingmeupthewall

What would you have preferred he did to get to work? Presumably he drives for work as you said his job would be lost if he lost his licence.
Taxi. Or a day's leave. If he does drive for his work and he's found to be over the limit I dare say he'd be dismissed for gross misconduct
lanthanum · 23/07/2021 12:22

Get a breathlyser, and then next time he has a drinking session (hopefully on a day when he's not driving in the morning), test in the morning. Either it will prove to him that he might still be over the limit, or it will reassure you that he's not. If it's anywhere close to borderline, perhaps you can agree that it's worth testing in future, or erring on the side of caution about how much to drink.
Obviously if you use this as a benchmark, you need to be aware that different timing and different amount of food could make a difference, but it might be a useful start.

Shoxfordian · 23/07/2021 12:12

I’m sorry for your loss but I don’t see that it’s relevant.

I wouldn’t tell my partner he couldn’t drive and hide his keys, he’s an adult and he makes his own choices.

tothelakes · 23/07/2021 12:08

@Drivingmeupthewall

What would you have preferred he did to get to work? Presumably he drives for work as you said his job would be lost if he lost his licence.
That's ok then, crack on driving after you've got pissed.
Sugarplumfairy65 · 23/07/2021 12:05

@Shoxfordian

Yabu

He’s an adult and you’re treating him like a teenager

I'll say that to the wife of my brother who was killed by a drunk driver who had been drinking the night before and was still 2 x over the limit and driving to work when he mounted the pavement and mowed my lovely brother down shall I?

DysmalRadius · 23/07/2021 12:02

You cant control someone elses actions, even if you believe its for the better good.

If asking someone to stop drinking to try and avoid them breaking the law is controlling, then how do you get anything done? I ask my husband to do stuff all the time - can you feed the kids, because I working, can you put the bins out because I've hurt my back - is that controlling? I don't really understand how some relationships work if one partner is allowed NO input or even to comment on the other's behaviour without being accused of trying to control them.

HocusPocuss · 23/07/2021 11:53

Dh’s friend was caught out the next morning. According to him, he hadn’t even been that drunk but he was stopped during a random stop and he blew over the limit, even though it had been 14 hours since his last drink. I don’t think people realise how long it stays in your system. He was banned from driving for a year and lost his job.

Drivingmeupthewall · 23/07/2021 11:35

What would you have preferred he did to get to work? Presumably he drives for work as you said his job would be lost if he lost his licence.

honeylulu · 23/07/2021 11:32

Don't forget he would also be metabolising alcohol during the session, its not as if all 12 units back up until 1am and only start to be metabolised then.

So say he started the session at 7pm, by 1am he will have probably metabolised 5-6 units of the 12 (6-7 remaining). Another 6-7 hours to metabolise the remainder takes him to 7 or 8am when he ought to have been clear. You posted at 10.14am inferring that he had left recently so hopefully there were some extra hours in there.

It is not purely arithmetic though and will depend on when he started, the rate at which he drank at which points (most people will tend to drink quicker at the start of a session and then slow down), his BMI, whether he had had food. So I agreed it is always best to to assume if you have had several drinks. But it sounds like he was probably fine.

You shouldn't have shouted, but I understand your concerns.

CaptSkippy · 23/07/2021 11:26

@Shoxfordian

Yabu

He’s an adult and you’re treating him like a teenager

If he acts like one, he deserves to be treated like one.
Mayorquimby2 · 23/07/2021 11:24

"There's a formula where you count the total units of alcohol consumed, add an hour to the end-drinking time ( 1am becomes 2am) and then it takes an hour to "lose" one unit of alcohol. So 12units means he would be safe to drive at 2pm"

Surely that formula would rely on you taking in all your units together at 1am.

Your body is going to start processing the alcohol when you start drinking wouldn't it? If you start drinking at 8 your body won't hold off on processing the booze until you've stopped drinking, or have I got the wrong end of the stick?

I can appreciate using it in a "better safe than sorry" approach or is it actually in anyway accurate.

Newjobnewstart · 23/07/2021 11:19

I have spoke to him and apologised. Hes at work and luckily all is fine. He may have been under the limit he may not have been i will never know.
He has also apologised for waking me up and the time.

Thanks everyone been a mixed bag and i do accept i was wrong.

OP posts:
SpindleWhorl · 23/07/2021 11:13

@Newjobnewstart

Thanks everyone. I totally accept i was wrong to say anything in front of his friend i had just been woken and was grumpy. No excuse.
I don't think you were 'wrong' as such. He woke you up at 1am, you were understandably annoyed and worried, tried to talk to him away from his friend, and then got more annoyed when you felt your concerns about his driving while over the limit weren't being heard.

I do think you need to talk this through though, not only as a communication issue but also in the sense that he's probably committing a crime and risks hurting someone, losing his licence and job, and wrecking your respect for him.

Would he have preferred you to surreptitiously hide his keys? Why couldn't he get a cab in? Does he often wake you at night?

I couldn't respect a flippant drink driver who got the huff with me.

SissySpacekAteMyHamster · 23/07/2021 11:01

I had a bottle of wine last night, and according to the online calculator I'd be ok to drive 11 hours after last drink.

I never drive until afternoon at least if I've had a night out.

I would've hid his keys.

ChunkySloth · 23/07/2021 10:54

I think you were very unreasonable. You should have waited until his friend left.

Also, it depends what time he started drinking. He could have started at 6/7 and not drunk much after 11. It also depends on what he was drinking. Some beers are only 2/3%.

I wouldn't be happy with you if you were my partner.

DianeCherry · 23/07/2021 10:52

I don't think you are being U at all. As someone who's been in a nasty car accident caused by a drink driver I find it abhorrent that so many people ignore the fact that they are over the limit to drive the next morning. If they get breathalysed and lose their jobs they only have themselves to blame. But the fact is, being over the limit makes them more likely to have an accident on the way to work and seriously injure someone, or worse. There's just no excuse.

But some people don't like being told this. It sounds like a criticism. They get defensive. It's time these people took some responsibility for the risks they are taking.

Then there the people who drink 7 cans of lager and insist that it makes them a BETTER driver because they have to concentrate more.... I divorced one of those for that.

Hide his keys or report him to the police if he drives away from the house. It's your civil duty.

ChainJane · 23/07/2021 10:39

Get an AlcoSense breathalyser, it shocked me to find out I was still over the limit first thing in the morning. If he's a reasonable person he will agree to use it after he's been drinking and will abide by its reading.

Newjobnewstart · 23/07/2021 10:35

My issue was tho i wanted him to stop as he had to drive this morning so leaving it he could have still been going at 3. I did take him aside so wasnt directly infront of his friend. Also already admitted im wrong for that. And will apologise if he hasnt been arrested or worse.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread