Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was I unreasonable to hide the cider from DH?

110 replies

dancygnik · 22/07/2021 21:21

The last 6 months DH has drunk alcohol every single day. I don't like it and we've talked about it before but he says he enjoys it. In the week it's usually only 1 or 2 cans per day but I still feel he should have at least a couple of days off alcohol per week.
I mentioned I thought he was an alcoholic and he got really nasty with me.

By Tuesday he has drunk all beer in the house so started on the cider which I had bought last weekend for us to share but there's only 2 bottles left and I haven't had any yet (I dont drink in the week so was waiting until I fancied one at the weekend) however he started on the cider Tuesday so I hid the last 2 bottles so he cousins drink them last night. He is really pissed off at me for hiding them. I do feel a bit awkward doing it and wondering if I should just apologise and shut up about him drinking every night even thought i think it's unhealthy and would prefer him to cut down?

OP posts:
Dontwatchfootball · 22/07/2021 23:00

@TableFlowerss

To those saying he can’t go a day with alcohol therefore he’s an alcoholic, that’s not necessarily true.

If someone drinks 1/2 cans every day of the week they could still be within their guidelines, obviously for a man.

Yet if he drinks only Friday and Saturday but drinks the 21 units over 2 days, it could be said that’s worse.

Even worse of someone drinks over the recommended units over 2 days as that binge drinking. Doesn’t mean they’re an alcoholic though…

Most alcoholics drink ti block out something and feel the buzz. An alcoholic wouldn’t feel the buzz after 1/2 cans.

Some people on MN think someone that can drink a bottle of wine in or night is an alcoholic 🙄

And some people on MN are in total denial about what is problem drinking. If you cant go a day without a substance non essential to life, then you have a problem.

The recommendation is for 14 units a week not 21.

Binge drinking is not good, but neither is drinking every day. Both are unhealthy and just because your drinking rate is more steady does not make it ok.

If you are drinking a bottle of wine in a night, you are drinking too much. You are disrupting your Central Nervous System, sleep pattern, taking in empty calories and affecting your liver.

Alcohol is potentially very dangerous (the worst and most dangerous withdrawal of any drug). The fact that it is legal does not make it better.

Alcoholics drink for many reasons but mainly because they feel they cannot cope without alcohol. The amount they ingest is less important than their rationale for drinking, or rather the reasons they give why they cannot manage without a drink.

pinkcircustop · 22/07/2021 22:59

YANBU, but he drinks too much and you shouldn’t have alcohol in the house.

I would just pour any alcohol he brought home away. Then it’s his choice to decide if he wants to stay at home with his family sober, or leave and drink.

HangingOver · 22/07/2021 22:58

If someone drinks 1/2 cans every day of the week they could still be within their guidelines

There's no safe amount of alcohol though - people quote those "guidelines" as if they're akin to your RDA of fruits and vegetables. It's toxic - it's a poison.

Drinking every day for 6 month isn't good. The term alcohol is outdated and not useful. Psychological dependency doesn't have a set threshold. If it's not harming his life or health then you could argue it's not doing a great deal of damage (apart from slightly raised chances of certain diseases). But I will say this, every drinker who loses everything at one point passed as a "normal" drinker. Daily drinking long term puts everyone who does it at risk of psychological and physical dependence, and unfortunately you don't know when you've passed the threshold until it's already happened.

WhenISnappedAndFarted · 22/07/2021 22:53

@TableFlowerss

To those saying he can’t go a day with alcohol therefore he’s an alcoholic, that’s not necessarily true.

If someone drinks 1/2 cans every day of the week they could still be within their guidelines, obviously for a man.

Yet if he drinks only Friday and Saturday but drinks the 21 units over 2 days, it could be said that’s worse.

Even worse of someone drinks over the recommended units over 2 days as that binge drinking. Doesn’t mean they’re an alcoholic though…

Most alcoholics drink ti block out something and feel the buzz. An alcoholic wouldn’t feel the buzz after 1/2 cans.

Some people on MN think someone that can drink a bottle of wine in or night is an alcoholic 🙄

But it's not about units and guidelines. It's about not being able to go without alcohol, being dependent on it and alcohol causing problems with relationships.

It starts with low amounts and can build up to a lot worse which is why it's the dependency on it. My DM started on a glass of wine a day, went up to a bottle a day and then finally ended up on 1.5 litres of vodka a day.

I'm not saying he is an alcoholic but the fact he can't go without it for a day is worrying

justasking111 · 22/07/2021 22:50

You lost someone to alcohol. That colours your opinion. I don't think he has a problem but he needs to be more understanding of your fear

TableFlowerss · 22/07/2021 22:48

@amelema

I'm a recovering alcoholic and trust me...I wished I could drink only 1 or 2 drinks a night in the depths of it. I don't think he has much of a problem.
This!
TableFlowerss · 22/07/2021 22:46

To those saying he can’t go a day with alcohol therefore he’s an alcoholic, that’s not necessarily true.

If someone drinks 1/2 cans every day of the week they could still be within their guidelines, obviously for a man.

Yet if he drinks only Friday and Saturday but drinks the 21 units over 2 days, it could be said that’s worse.

Even worse of someone drinks over the recommended units over 2 days as that binge drinking. Doesn’t mean they’re an alcoholic though…

Most alcoholics drink ti block out something and feel the buzz. An alcoholic wouldn’t feel the buzz after 1/2 cans.

Some people on MN think someone that can drink a bottle of wine in or night is an alcoholic 🙄

Hopeisnotastrategy · 22/07/2021 22:44

You are being ridiculous.

Even more so in this warm weather.

TimeIhadaNameChange · 22/07/2021 22:44

@samwitwicky - she bought them to share, he'd had his two so she hid hers so they'd still be there when she wanted them.

I've done the same, @dancygnik, and should have done recently. In that case it was Pimm's, which he doesn't like. He'd drunk half which I knew, but come the hot Friday night when I fancied a glass the bottle was nowhere to be found. I messaged him and yep, he'd drunk the whole lot.

He did get a friend to pop me a bottle round the next day, but it's not the point.

godmum56 · 22/07/2021 22:29

lots of stuff here I think there definitely is A problem but the question is which problem?
If he had drunk the cider could the family budget have stood buying more?...ie was it greed and thoughtlessness on a par with eating all the cake or something like that?
I do agree that if he can't go a day without alcohol even if its not much then he has a problem but....well.....if you are disapproving of it could it be "eff you" drinking?
I know from professional and personal experience that its bloody annoying to be asked if you have got an alcohol problem. I was asked by a locum GP at a time when i was virtually TT because I might have needed to drive at any point 24/7 and I pretty much ripped her a new one.
Whatever the problem is, he's not going to stop because you think he should...I mean why should he?
Your only choice is stay or go.

Happylittlethoughts · 22/07/2021 22:20

Thank goodness a few sane voices have appeared. Totally surprised by the initial comments suggesting you know nothing . I'd be unhappy with this frequency and attachment to alcohol. Only you are in the house with this man. If you are uncomfortable then please act on your own behalf , not his. You can't control this for him to fix it. Please use your energy to affect change for you.

samwitwicky · 22/07/2021 22:12

@hellcatspangle

But ultimately, it's his choice.

Well it's OP's choice to save some of the cider for herself!

She hid them to stop him drinking them. Not to save them for herself.

Read the OP again.

Hoppinggreen · 22/07/2021 22:06

Having to drink every day and getting annoyed when this isn’t possible does suggest an issue with alcahol

Dontwatchfootball · 22/07/2021 22:05

@bloodyhell19

I say this as a former drinker:

If anyone in a house is having to hide alcohol - either by the drinker or from the drinker - there's a problem.

If he can't go one day without drinking, there's a problem.

If the first thing he reaches for is nastiness when it's questioned whether or not he has a problem, he has a problem.

I've been this person and you were not unreasonable. You cannot trust him not to drink them and you cannot trust him to replace them. He doesn't care what he's drinking, he just wants to drink - so no, save the stuff you like for yourself.

This. People are so dismissive of their drinking, and these threads are always full of the whole 'well I do it, so it must be ok' brigade. This post brilliantly sums up the problem with that.
AiyaNapawithmorenaps · 22/07/2021 22:05

I think he has a problem. I would also say it's not unreasonable of you to want to save some of the alcohol which you had agreed to share until the time when you want to drink it. Swap the situation for two steaks, if he ate your steak which you were saving, you'd be angry and he'd be U. I'd say to him, if he hasn't got a problem then he wouldn't have a problem cutting down.

OneTC · 22/07/2021 22:04

You need to seriously re-think what an alcoholic is, trust me, I know.

Problematic drinking is about habit and how much impact breaking that habit has on your behaviour and those around you. it isn't purely about excessive drinking

GeorgiePorge · 22/07/2021 21:59

YANBU - but if you have lived with an alcoholic before, you will know that at the point that you are trying to control their intake (by hiding alcohol or restricting money or whatever method) then you are already fighting a losing battle.

Talk to him. Ask him, for your sake to have a few alcohol free days and see if he can manage it.

RandomMess · 22/07/2021 21:58

He does seem to be alcohol dependent if he has to drink every evening isn't that just a functioning alcoholic?

Just because he isn't drunk doesn't mean he isn't addicted?

Still at least he hasn't been bothered enough to go out and get so more himself, I guess that's a positive.

amelema · 22/07/2021 21:55

I'm a recovering alcoholic and trust me...I wished I could drink only 1 or 2 drinks a night in the depths of it. I don't think he has much of a problem.

bloodyhell19 · 22/07/2021 21:52

I say this as a former drinker:

If anyone in a house is having to hide alcohol - either by the drinker or from the drinker - there's a problem.

If he can't go one day without drinking, there's a problem.

If the first thing he reaches for is nastiness when it's questioned whether or not he has a problem, he has a problem.

I've been this person and you were not unreasonable. You cannot trust him not to drink them and you cannot trust him to replace them. He doesn't care what he's drinking, he just wants to drink - so no, save the stuff you like for yourself.

name6785 · 22/07/2021 21:51

(Just to clarify I was calling myself irrational not you)

Hunkydory99 · 22/07/2021 21:49

I don’t think you’re being unreasonable OP, you’re obviously concerned for his well-being but rather than seeing where you’re coming from he’s got ‘nasty?’
Swap alcohol for food in this house - I have to hide treats from DP. He knows I do it. Partly so when I fancy something there is some for me to have and partly I’m concerned for my other half’s health. His obese, nearly morbidly so and i’ve voiced my concerns about the implications on his health. He had a tough upbringing and would go days without proper sustenance so whenever treats are in the house he pigs out. If I don’t buy things like cakes or crisps he does so himself but makes sure to only get the flavours he likes so he doesn’t have to share. I don’t know what else I can do

Thehop · 22/07/2021 21:48

If he can’t go a day without alcohol he’s an alcoholic.

I couldn’t live with that. It’s up to you what you do next.

a YANBU to hide your own share of the cider.

hellcatspangle · 22/07/2021 21:37

But ultimately, it's his choice.

Well it's OP's choice to save some of the cider for herself!

Polmuggle · 22/07/2021 21:37

@FredBlankenship

Let me get this straight, he drinks 1 or 2 cans of an evening, during the week and you mentioned you thought he was an alcoholic. You need to seriously re-think what an alcoholic is, trust me, I know.

As regards the being unreasonable or not, I'm sorry I just couldn't get past that first bit....

Just talk to him - but retract the 'alcoholic' comment and take it from there...

He can't go a day without alcohol. He has a problem.

Op not unreasonable at all to save your share of the cider for yourself!

Swipe left for the next trending thread