Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was I unreasonable to hide the cider from DH?

110 replies

dancygnik · 22/07/2021 21:21

The last 6 months DH has drunk alcohol every single day. I don't like it and we've talked about it before but he says he enjoys it. In the week it's usually only 1 or 2 cans per day but I still feel he should have at least a couple of days off alcohol per week.
I mentioned I thought he was an alcoholic and he got really nasty with me.

By Tuesday he has drunk all beer in the house so started on the cider which I had bought last weekend for us to share but there's only 2 bottles left and I haven't had any yet (I dont drink in the week so was waiting until I fancied one at the weekend) however he started on the cider Tuesday so I hid the last 2 bottles so he cousins drink them last night. He is really pissed off at me for hiding them. I do feel a bit awkward doing it and wondering if I should just apologise and shut up about him drinking every night even thought i think it's unhealthy and would prefer him to cut down?

OP posts:
Libraryghost · 23/07/2021 00:02

@bloodyhell19

I say this as a former drinker:

If anyone in a house is having to hide alcohol - either by the drinker or from the drinker - there's a problem.

If he can't go one day without drinking, there's a problem.

If the first thing he reaches for is nastiness when it's questioned whether or not he has a problem, he has a problem.

I've been this person and you were not unreasonable. You cannot trust him not to drink them and you cannot trust him to replace them. He doesn't care what he's drinking, he just wants to drink - so no, save the stuff you like for yourself.

This! People in this thread telling you drinking everyday is not a problem are probably a being a bit defensive because they also drink everyday. In denial..
Dontwatchfootball · 23/07/2021 00:01

@TableFlowerss - there have been several detailed answers to your points from a number of people, but what it comes down to is that you do not wish to accept that daily drinking is a problem. That is your prerogative, but the medical opinion is that it is. People are free to drink every day if they want to, but don't claim ignorance or medical dispensation to do so and harp on about numbers.

As for people doing what they choose - the issue is that substance misuse affects family members too, and that is what started this thread. OP is in a horrible situation where her husbands use is causing real problems. But then, people with dependency and addiction problems are incredibly selfish and refuse to see how their behaviour affects others.

TableFlowerss · 22/07/2021 23:58

To add - for health purposes people wouldn’t drink in an ideal world, but neither would they- eat too much processed fatty foods full of sugar artificial flavours and additives - but they do.

I would hazard a guess that obesity is much more of a concern to the state than alcoholism.

Neither are great but let’s be realistic people do like a drink.

Soberanne · 22/07/2021 23:55

OP i think you have every right to be concerned. You know your partner. However hiding alcohol wont make him stop unless he wants.

On the other side i hide chocolate to stop my partner eating as its my chocolate so i don't think your unreasonable.

TableFlowerss · 22/07/2021 23:53

@Dontwatchfootball

No, *@Tableflowerss*, the bit in bold is not subjective at all, it is how problem drinking is assessed. It is the function of the drinking which is more important than the amount. And you often find most about the function by asking what would happen if people could not have a drink. Harping on about actual units is a very old fashioned way of thinking about what constitutes problem drinking and really misses the point completely.

14 units is not a safe limit. It is the least bad. There is no completely safe amount of alcohol, it is literally a toxin. So it is not better or worse to drink each day. Either is not good.

Addiction and dependency on alcohol cover a massive range of actual drinks. You can have a really bad relationship to alcohol and drink far less than someone who has a good relationship with it.

But lots of people on this thread just don't want to consider that the amount they drink may be problematic, if not to them, then in other people. I never realized how f'ed up the British attitude to alcohol was until I lived on other countries.

It makes no difference to me what anyone drinks. It’s their life and they can do what they chose.

Having a small glass of wine with a meal every night with their partner doesn’t make someone dependent.

TableFlowerss · 22/07/2021 23:49

[quote blubberyboo]@TableFlowerss

I’m a bit concerned by your interpretation of the guidelines. They are meant as guidelines for moderate occasional drinkers.
It does not mean that you can drink this amount every day for 6 months and not develop an alcohol problem.

In fact those guidelines you refer to actually state you should have several drink free days a week. It also states 14 units per week. A can of cider is 2 units , so 2 cans a day every day is 28 units a week.. twice the recommended guideline!! Still think OP has nothing to worry about?

My father has been alcohol dependent for 30 years and currently at end of life. Sometimes he could have managed on a couple of glasses a day but is still classed as alcohol dependent as his body can’t go without it.
It’s only when you stop and the body goes into DTs that you realise the dependency.
OPs partner is not willing to try a day without and got angry when she mentioned it..huge red flag for me[/quote]
I was saying one can of 2 units, each day would be 14 units.

As the pp explained, she has a glass of wine most nights with a meal, as many people do. Does that make them alcohol dependent? I don’t think so.

If units and the intake aren’t an issue and it’s more the reasons behind it, as suggests by a pp, then someone having a swine with their meal and partner, isn’t the same as someone drinking to drown out their worries etc…

Some people will become dependent, that I’ve no doubt. One of my parents was an alcoholic and we’d find bottles of vodka all around the house that they’d tried to hide an proclaim they aren’t an alcoholic- When evidently they were. They also passed away at 56.

But not everyone will become dependent and one glass of wine with a meal every night doesn’t mean someone will become dependent.

Dontwatchfootball · 22/07/2021 23:43

No, @Tableflowerss, the bit in bold is not subjective at all, it is how problem drinking is assessed. It is the function of the drinking which is more important than the amount. And you often find most about the function by asking what would happen if people could not have a drink. Harping on about actual units is a very old fashioned way of thinking about what constitutes problem drinking and really misses the point completely.

14 units is not a safe limit. It is the least bad. There is no completely safe amount of alcohol, it is literally a toxin. So it is not better or worse to drink each day. Either is not good.

Addiction and dependency on alcohol cover a massive range of actual drinks. You can have a really bad relationship to alcohol and drink far less than someone who has a good relationship with it.

But lots of people on this thread just don't want to consider that the amount they drink may be problematic, if not to them, then in other people. I never realized how f'ed up the British attitude to alcohol was until I lived on other countries.

Notwavingbutdrowing3 · 22/07/2021 23:42

It's your two bottles of cider. He's drunk his beer and his ciders. You haven't hidden his ciders from him you've taken yours as you re looking forward to them.

IIf he grumps at you , then he has a alcohol problems as he can't stop drinking til all his alcohol is gone and still wants to drink yours.

Yes, I think he has a problem

Liervik · 22/07/2021 23:33

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for privacy reasons.

godmum56 · 22/07/2021 23:32

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz

Lots of people cant go a day without a coffee. Meh.

I have a glass of wine at dinner most evenings. Sometimes I dont, often I do. I can assure you I am not an alcoholic.

yes, actually they can...they might get withdrawal headaches if they are heavy caffeine consumers but there aren't coffeeholics or chocaholics in the same way that there are alcoholics.
blubberyboo · 22/07/2021 23:30

@TableFlowerss

I’m a bit concerned by your interpretation of the guidelines. They are meant as guidelines for moderate occasional drinkers.
It does not mean that you can drink this amount every day for 6 months and not develop an alcohol problem.

In fact those guidelines you refer to actually state you should have several drink free days a week. It also states 14 units per week. A can of cider is 2 units , so 2 cans a day every day is 28 units a week.. twice the recommended guideline!! Still think OP has nothing to worry about?

My father has been alcohol dependent for 30 years and currently at end of life. Sometimes he could have managed on a couple of glasses a day but is still classed as alcohol dependent as his body can’t go without it.
It’s only when you stop and the body goes into DTs that you realise the dependency.
OPs partner is not willing to try a day without and got angry when she mentioned it..huge red flag for me

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 22/07/2021 23:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

TableFlowerss · 22/07/2021 23:28

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz

Lots of people cant go a day without a coffee. Meh.

I have a glass of wine at dinner most evenings. Sometimes I dont, often I do. I can assure you I am not an alcoholic.

I can assure you, according to some of MN you are indeed an alcoholic! Shock

I don’t think you are!

DismantledKing · 22/07/2021 23:27

No it doesn't

Indeed it does. I think that a few on this thread are saying otherwise to minimise their own drinking habits.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 22/07/2021 23:27

Lots of people cant go a day without a coffee. Meh.

I have a glass of wine at dinner most evenings. Sometimes I dont, often I do. I can assure you I am not an alcoholic.

househousehousefox · 22/07/2021 23:26

@bloodyhell19

I say this as a former drinker:

If anyone in a house is having to hide alcohol - either by the drinker or from the drinker - there's a problem.

If he can't go one day without drinking, there's a problem.

If the first thing he reaches for is nastiness when it's questioned whether or not he has a problem, he has a problem.

I've been this person and you were not unreasonable. You cannot trust him not to drink them and you cannot trust him to replace them. He doesn't care what he's drinking, he just wants to drink - so no, save the stuff you like for yourself.

This. Fucking hell this.
BlackForestCake · 22/07/2021 23:25

@DismantledKing

Drinking every night for 6 months means that he has a problem.
No it doesn't.
RealBecca · 22/07/2021 23:25

Yanbu.

timeisnotaline · 22/07/2021 23:23

I wouldn’t be happy with him thinking he can move onto your cider, or with being nasty. I don’t think it’s ok to need a drink every day, but not sure what you can do about it as he’s an adult, except agree that he’s an adult, can do whatever he likes, but it would be really greedy to take all his alcohol and yours so in future you’re buying just your own and if he can’t not drink it then he really does have a problem and needs to admit it.

bloodyhell19 · 22/07/2021 23:20

Sorry to double post but the idea of units is nonsense really. Units are the action part of it, but it doesn't account for the actual mental compulsion of drinking. Far too many people (myself included, in the beginning...) think well it's only the one - I'm allowed it. But when that one is every single night because you cannot go without, that's a dependency and that's a problem. And that one or two drinks will spiral because eventually it will never be enough.

TableFlowerss · 22/07/2021 23:18

@Dontwatchfootball

TableFlowerss · 22/07/2021 23:18

Alcoholics drink for many reasons but mainly because they feel they cannot cope without alcohol. The amount they ingest is less important than their rationale for drinking, or rather the reasons they give why they cannot manage without a drink

You do make some very good points and I don’t disagree with some of them, but the bit in bold is subjective.

If 14 units is the safe limit a week, my point is, can one can each night be any worse than drinking 14 units in one night?!

Whether or not they go on to drink more and more, that’s a separate issue, but I don’t think an alcoholic only drinks the recommended units of 14 each week. They’re more likely to drink 14 units each day…..

furiouslytyping · 22/07/2021 23:12

@samwitwicky

By Tuesday he has drunk all beer in the house so started on the cider which I had bought last weekend for us to share but there's only 2 bottles left and I haven't had any yet

I assume that means she fancies her share of the cider in the next couple of days?

DismantledKing · 22/07/2021 23:06

Drinking every night for 6 months means that he has a problem.

StCharlotte · 22/07/2021 23:04

If you didn't buy it OP, would he?

Swipe left for the next trending thread