Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS got very drunk - punishment or not?

185 replies

slyfa · 22/07/2021 21:19

Posting here for traffic

My son is 15. In the past, he's had sips of alcohol but never enough for him to get drunk. Today, he went out with a couple friends and they went to a field. Sons friends said that a few boys about 16/17 that go to their school went up to DS and asked him if he wanted to drink with them, DS said yes and left his friends. When he went back to them they said he was acting drunk which they thought was funny but then he told them he didn't feel well and he threw up, he wouldn't let them have his phone to call me or DH so one of them texted DD. When I got there, he was laying on the grass, drooling and he’d also wet himself and his friends were next to him asking him if he was ok etc. They don't know what he drank as he wouldn't tell them.

When we got home, he went to bed and we've been checking on him. DH thinks that tomorrow, when he's sober we should give him a punishment for getting so drunk, but I'm not sure if we should as surely this would be enough to stop him from getting drunk again (well for a while at least!).

Would you give him a punishment this time or just leave it?

OP posts:
Aria2015 · 22/07/2021 22:13

Similar thing happened to me at that age. It was honestly a lesson in itself, I didn't need punishing on top. In a way I'm glad that it happened because it made me much more wary of drinking. I say let him recover and then have a chat about the dangers. For me, I didn't know the difference between a beer or hard spirits and learning about alcohol content really helped. Still cannot stand the smell of the drink I drunk that day and it's been over 20 years!

SirenSays · 22/07/2021 22:12

I don't like the sound of those symptoms at all. I'd be very tempted to get him checked over by a doctor.
I definitely wouldn't punish him, he was scared to have his friends tell you, don't reinforce that, it could be deadly next time. Sometimes teens need a parent to be more of a friend than a prison warden.

gogohm · 22/07/2021 22:09

The massive hangover plus parents laughing at him is punishment enough

GoWalkabout · 22/07/2021 22:08

And let him know he can always call you and you won't be cross.

blahblahblah321 · 22/07/2021 22:08

@MazDazzle

Also, if you punish him then next time he definitely won’t call for help!

Best to reinforce the idea that you are the person to turn to when he’s in trouble.

My DM had many faults, but I always remember her saying ‘no matter where you are, or what’s happened, phone me and I’ll pick you up.’

I totally agree with this. I know everyone says you need to be the parent, and not a friend, but I stand by the fact I want my children to feel they can come to me without me biting their heads off. I'd hate them to feel they can't turn to me when they need help
GoWalkabout · 22/07/2021 22:07

Poor boy has been spiked (with alcohol or drugs) by older boys for their amusement. Be mad at them, keep checking with him if he's OK and if there's anything he can remember about how they persuaded him to drink it. A chat about peer pressure, saying no, not ditching your friends and not taking anything you don't know what it is.

FlyingBattie · 22/07/2021 22:07

Don't talk to him tomorrow, he will be hungover as fuck.
Wait until the alcohol has cleared and then discuss with him about his unsafe behaviour. Thankfully his friends managed to contact his sister- and you- but what if they had just left after he went off? (when you next see his friends, praise them!)
I'd be worried about what exactly these older kids gave him. Was it just alcohol? Was it spiked with drugs?
Reassure your son that whatever happens, whatever stupid thing he has done, he can call you and you will come and get him without judgement.

blahblahblah321 · 22/07/2021 22:06

Recently been in a very similar position, even down to wetting himself. DS is older though, just short of 18.

I didn't over punish, he knew I was upset and I had no sympathy when he was incredibly hung over the next day - to the point we forced him to come out for the family meal that was already booked in! I needed him to learn that getting that drunk doesn't mean the world stops.

He's since been to a few events/parties and hasn't touched a drop. TBH the wetting himself was something he's struggled to get over. I feel for him desperately, but inside hope it's taught him a lesson

ragged · 22/07/2021 22:02

What would the punishment be for...

defying you? But you let him have sips before anyway.

Being stupid - do you normally punish him for being stupid?

For his poor choice of friends who helped him get drunk -- but his good choice of friends let you know he needed help.

Inconvenience of collecting him own lathered -- do you normally punish him for things that inconvenience you?

I'd understand punishment if there was actual harm done.

Stern talking to about damage to his immature liver & making himself look like a fool will probably achieve more what you want than any "punishment" for non existent harm he caused. Remind him that he has hopes to achieve good things in his life -- being drunk doesn't help his ambitions to happen.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 22/07/2021 22:00

@dottycat123

I would suggest that he may have taken / been given drugs and I say that as a mental health liaison nurse who works in A&E.
A&E doctor here, and I agree. Drooling doesn't suggest alcohol at all. It's quite a worrying symptom, actually, and you should probably ring 111, as well as checking on him regularly.
Buppers · 22/07/2021 21:59

Been there and done that with teenagers, OP.

I would not be sympathetic if he has a hangover (though he might not: they bounce back incredibly quickly at that age). However, I would have a talk with him about why he made a mistake leaving his friends to go off with these other people.

I would also emphasise that his friends did the right thing when they realised how drunk he was, as it's really important that they have a group of friends who will look out for one another (even if that sometimes means calling a parent).

Also agree with PP who say your son needs to know that you will always retrieve him if he's in a bad situation. Any post-mortem can come later. I have retrieved teenagers from situations. I have been very, very pissed off with them (nobody wants to be dragged out of bed at 3AM in order to drive to collect a teenager), and they have known it, but I have always kept the conversation for later. And they have always known that however pissed off I am, I still have their backs. This is really important.

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 22/07/2021 21:55

How long was he gone for? I know a PP said he's not used to drinking, it's hot out etc but the fact that he'd wet himself and was drooling would concern me enough to think he'd been spiked

A don't think he needs a punishment as such but you definitely need a harsh conversation about it

Actupfishy · 22/07/2021 21:55

I agree, I’ve been there as a teenager - he’ll wake up hung over and mortified which is enough punishment in itself, I’d talk to him about the dangers of binge drinking and chalk it up to adolescent experimenting.

Horehound · 22/07/2021 21:54

@RockingMyFiftiesNot who says he is going to do that?
You've made up a big story on your head and planned it out, when all that is, is fantasy.

waterlego · 22/07/2021 21:54

I could have written this at the weekend as our DD, also 15, did something very similar. She has had an occasional Kopparberg or similar at home with us when we’ve had friends or family round for a BBQ, and at Christmas. This time she drank something much stronger and also, I suspect, had heatstroke which certainly didn’t help. (Was drinking on beach in early afternoon sun 🙄)

DD was extremely remorseful when she sobered up and apologised for what she saw as letting us down. To be fair, she has had a great ‘track record’ so far as a teenager; works hard at school, quite mature etc, so the fact she was sorry and we were able to have a good chat about it all afterwards helped us decide we didn’t need to issue any sort of punishment this time. We talked about choices and pointed out that spirits are particularly strong and she is quite a petite girl, so best to stick with ciders or alcopops, and have a drink at home with us rather than out so we can help her moderate it. It’s a mistake a great many of us have made at some point in our adolescence or young adulthood, and ultimately a good opportunity to learn about one’s limits!

SmellyWindows · 22/07/2021 21:53

When I was that age I did something similar (didn’t wet myself!). I’ve never drunk that much again! Never thrown up from drink since, and barely drink now. I definitely learnt my lesson. See how he is tomorrow, hopefully he will be rough enough he will learn his!

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 22/07/2021 21:52

[quote Horehound]@RockingMyFiftiesNot this just is ridiculous.
Why would you make a hungover person get up when they really need to sleep it off?
Making them go buy milk etc what a lot of bollocks.[/quote]
So when he gets pissed and has to go to work, is Mummy going to ring his boss and say sorry, he has a hangover and needs to sleep it off?

EmRata95 · 22/07/2021 21:51

Hmm I'm going against the grain slightly here and saying I do think he needs a punishment, or a very good talking to. My brother almost died choking on his vomit when he passed out drunk aged 15. My sister thankfully was able to save his life. He was in hospital for 3 days after, it was such a horrible, scary time. My brother had drank heavily before a couple of times, my parents didn't do anything as they assumed ' the hangover will be punishment enough '. They were wrong. He needs to understand that peer pressure is not a good enough reason to put his life at risk.

ScrimShawSeaShore · 22/07/2021 21:50

I think punishment risks enforcing him feeling the need to keep quiet and not want to tell anyone if it happens again in the future, and that's the dangerous part. It was good that he returned to his caring friends and that DD also contacted you so that he was looked after. His safety is the most important thing, first and foremost.

Horehound · 22/07/2021 21:50

@RockingMyFiftiesNot this just is ridiculous.
Why would you make a hungover person get up when they really need to sleep it off?
Making them go buy milk etc what a lot of bollocks.

AlternativePerspective · 22/07/2021 21:47

I would have a stern talking to Him.

For the people who say that it must have been drugs, his drink spiked etc, he’s 15, is unused to alcohol and it’s hot as hell meaning that he’s likely already partly dehydrated. It actually doesn’t take a huge amount to get drunk in that position.

Where my DS was at school it was common for the y11’s to go to the park on their last day and often the y10’s went and it wasn’t uncommon for someone to get drunk, in fact there was at least one instance where a child was carted off in an ambulance.And this was a well respected school so it’s not a class thing or anything like that.

I would tell him that you need to know what he was drinking. That not telling isn’t ok, and if I were going to be dishing out punishments it would be for that.

Me and my DS have always had an arrangement. If he’s been drinking I need to know what, and how much. That way if he’s ill I will know what I’m dealing with.

delilahbucket · 22/07/2021 21:47

I would certainly have a conversation, but I think wetting yourself in front of your mates is punishment enough.

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 22/07/2021 21:45

Get him up at his usual time tomorrow. If there are still clothes of his that need washing, or any mess he's made make him sort it (I know you might have had to do this because of the stench but if you haven't, let him do it) . If you need milk etc from the shops, send him.
He will feel like shit but needs to know if he's grown up enough to drink, he's grown up enough to learn that life goes on, no matter how bad the hangover.
The conversation about safe drinking can wait a few days, but needs to be had.

Horehound · 22/07/2021 21:45

Also, I wonder if he wasn't wanting to hand his phone over so his friends could call you was fear of your reactions.

You can't be shouting and punishing as that will make him close up and not tell you anything.

FuckingHateRats · 22/07/2021 21:44

His pals sound great - he's lucky. I would think the aftermath is punishment enough, although I'd still want to talk to him about his choices once the dust has settled.