Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS got very drunk - punishment or not?

185 replies

slyfa · 22/07/2021 21:19

Posting here for traffic

My son is 15. In the past, he's had sips of alcohol but never enough for him to get drunk. Today, he went out with a couple friends and they went to a field. Sons friends said that a few boys about 16/17 that go to their school went up to DS and asked him if he wanted to drink with them, DS said yes and left his friends. When he went back to them they said he was acting drunk which they thought was funny but then he told them he didn't feel well and he threw up, he wouldn't let them have his phone to call me or DH so one of them texted DD. When I got there, he was laying on the grass, drooling and he’d also wet himself and his friends were next to him asking him if he was ok etc. They don't know what he drank as he wouldn't tell them.

When we got home, he went to bed and we've been checking on him. DH thinks that tomorrow, when he's sober we should give him a punishment for getting so drunk, but I'm not sure if we should as surely this would be enough to stop him from getting drunk again (well for a while at least!).

Would you give him a punishment this time or just leave it?

OP posts:
Awwlookatmybabyspider · 23/07/2021 09:02

I’d say the mother of all hangovers and the embarrassment of “Oh shit. What I did I do and say. Will be more than punishment enough. That’s not to say there shouldn’t be a very long conversation about the dangers of alcohol especially in this heat. Don’t do it while he’s sick though. He’ll wont be any fit state to take a blind bit of notice.

Branster · 23/07/2021 09:02

The worst out of all this is DS not wanting his friends to contact you for help. He must have been worried that your DH will want to punish him. He was correct on that assumption.
There's nothing worse than being worried about your parents reactions. As a parent, it's awful to realise your children are afraid of your reactions.
So no, please don't punish him. Use this as an opportunity to reinforce the fact that you, both of you parents, are here to support him when he needs you, when he's in trouble, no matter what.
As regards him starting on a no return path to drunkenness; I'd day he's learnt a harsh lesson and won't be doing it again.
His friends sound really nice and it's good he has that support that he trusts.
Hopefully the way you treat him today will make him realise he can also trust you and DH in extreme situations such as this one and he will do better from now on not to create trouble for himself.
Let the boy sleep it off, he must be feeling physically awful and the embarrassment of what happened would be quite terrible for him. Both of these ate harder punishments than what your DH could possibly impose. Your DH must have been as worried as yourself and wants to fix this with an action (natural reasoning) but building trust for the future is longer lasting and more beneficial.

Choconuttolata · 23/07/2021 08:47

In my case at that age my mum telling all her friends who then all asked me how my head was repeatedly was embarrassing enough. I was hungover and mortified.

Think she also grounded me and withdrew allowance, but to be honest the constant adult teasing whilst I still felt so awful did more to put me off.

She also didn't let me sleep it off.

Mind you it was the first time, I had got home by myself and wasn't in such a dangerous state as your DS. Once he is less hungover have a serious conversation about the dangers of alcohol.

LavenderAskew · 23/07/2021 08:41

What punishment does your DH like it should be?

Personally, Iif it were mine i'd wake him before 12 (to drink water) and to clean up what ever was consequence of his drinking (like wash the pee soaked and puked on clothes) the let him back to bed as a hungover person is annoying and it's pointless trying to resason with them.anyeay

The chances are he'll be feeling mortified if his friends don't think it's funny or cool that he drank. He does seem to have sensible enough friends seeing they made contact because they were concerned, rather than ignore it and not know what to do.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 23/07/2021 08:39

A stinking hangover, not to mention wetting himself, will v likely be punishment enough, won’t it? and a lesson for the future.

I was only 14 when I threw up in our snowy front garden after a party, and this was a very very long time ago. IMO my folks were right to think that feeling dreadful was punishment enough. In fact IIRC they found it mildly amusing.

JungleBeats · 23/07/2021 08:37

How is he this morning OP?

x2boys · 23/07/2021 08:28

@EvilPea

Yes young women can be very vulnerable So can young men Confused
Im very aware of that @Evilpea i was replying to a previous postould er who thought the Ds should have a moral lesson about how it would be worse for a young women.
ChainJane · 23/07/2021 08:28

Punish him not for the drinking of alcohol which is perfectly normal but because of the vulnerable state he put himself in, going off with strangers and taking unknown substances - refusing to tell his friends what he'd taken is the main problem here.

I think you need to share part of the blame though, if he's 15 but only had "sips" of alcohol it was bound to get out of hand when he first drank unsupervised. From about 12 he should be having low alcohol stuff eg shandies, by 14 he should be allowed a couple of cans of low strength beer like Foster's or Carlsberg. It's the only way he will be able to build up his tolerance and understand how much he can handle - otherwise he'll be the 18 year old making an ass of himself and getting himself into dangerous situations in a few years.

EvilPea · 23/07/2021 08:25

Yes young women can be very vulnerable
So can young men Confused

EvilPea · 23/07/2021 08:23

I’d have more of an issue with the leaving his friends and going off thing.

TempleofZoom · 23/07/2021 08:20

Cant

TempleofZoom · 23/07/2021 08:20

@dottycat123

I would suggest that he may have taken / been given drugs and I say that as a mental health liaison nurse who works in A&E.
That was my first thought. Jesus Christ can believe the OP is thinking of punishment rather than medical help !
x2boys · 23/07/2021 08:18

@TheNestedIf

For clarity, before I get reported, I want the son to think about the fact that if a female had ended up in that state and something far worse had happened to her, it's deemed to be her that's in the wrong, as per the Ched Evans case.
Whilst the Ched Evans case was terrible Not everything has to be a moral lesson, hes not female Yes young women can be very vulnerable, but im not sure how or why that fact is relevant here.
x2boys · 23/07/2021 08:12

No. I wouldnt punish him, neither would i be making him do chores, poor kid threw up and wet himself in front of his friends i think that is punishment enough
I would have a serious chat about how dangerous alcohol can be.

SilverRoe · 23/07/2021 08:08

God no don’t punish him! He’s young, not used to drinking, it was a heatwave! No he should not have drunk alcohol underage but he had no experience of what would happen and how drunk you can get and how quickly. He’ll feel terrible today and need tlc and serious rehydration. And he will always remember how shit he feels on his first hangover.

It’s normal teen behaviour to experiment and i don’t think he can be blamed for it going so wrong, this heat has been a killer and an inexperienced person like him would have had no real idea of how fast that, unfamiliar people and unfamiliar alcohol can mess you up.

Thank goodness his friends looked out for him.

nolovelost · 23/07/2021 07:56

I think in this instance, educate not punish.

LibrariesGiveUsPower45321 · 23/07/2021 07:53

He wet himself and was drooling- I’d be very concerned he got spiked. How is he this morning?

He needs a stern conversation but wetting himself in front of mates is punishment enough tbh.

cricketmum84 · 23/07/2021 07:49

I would have a very frank discussion with him about it. But I think the hangover this morning will be punishment enough!

rishisboater · 23/07/2021 07:45

I find this a bit suspicious. It's not easy for 16/17 year olds to get hold of booze these days, not to mention the cost of it. So they thought they'd share (copious amounts by the sound of it) their alcohol with an unknown 15 year old? Hmmm

Why did he leave his friends and go off with them?

Was he is danger from the sun?

I don't think a punishment is suitable because he's suffering enough but I do think you need to get to the bottom of exactly what happened and go through some what-if scenarios as he's making some dodgy decisions here

Rainbowqueeen · 23/07/2021 07:45

Why would older kids who don’t know him suddenly invite him to go off drinking with them. I assume they provided all the alcohol at their own cost???
I would be worried about their motivations, especially as he can or won’t say what he drank. Highly possible they wanted to know what would happen if you mixed alcohol and a particular drug and decided to test it out on a third party.
I agree, it’s not the getting drunk that’s the problem here, it’s the circumstances. Very risky behaviour

HerMammy · 23/07/2021 07:24

No punishment, the Fear will be lesson enough.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 23/07/2021 07:23

How's he doing, OP? Hope he's fine apart from just enough of a hangover to put him off doing it again Smile

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 23/07/2021 07:22

I very much doubt his drink was spiked, out drinking with his mates/other kids

His drink probably wasn't spiked, but he may well have voluntarily tried ketamine or some other pills.

Teens know that parents see drugs as a bigger deal than booze, so will often admit to alcohol but not anything else. However, parents need to get their heads round the fact that, for teenagers, drugs are not seen as more taboo than booze - almost the other way round, in fact. Teens are highly likely to try both.

Derbee · 23/07/2021 00:33

No punishment. A serious talk about the dangers of alcohol. But I’d always want my kids to know they can call me if they’re in a situation that they need help from, without getting a bollocking.

These kids have all had a really tough and strange year, and are likely to make some bad choices when “letting loose”.

No sympathy for his hangover. And to be honest, the embarrassment of wetting himself infront of his mates is a better punishment than anything you could do. Bless him, but that’s really made me chuckle. At least he’s ok, that’s the main thing

TheNestedIf · 23/07/2021 00:32

For clarity, before I get reported, I want the son to think about the fact that if a female had ended up in that state and something far worse had happened to her, it's deemed to be her that's in the wrong, as per the Ched Evans case.