Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

He wants to leave them alone in a hotel room

262 replies

OrangeIsTheNewRed · 22/07/2021 19:36

I have twin dc (6) with my ex and we mostly manage to coparent quite successfully. Occasionally though we have difficulties because of our parenting styles are very different.

In a couple of weeks he is taking them on holiday with his family and new partner. They're staying in the UK but far away and will need to stay in a hotel overnight.

When we were together and stayed in hotels with his family, his sister would routinely leave her young dc alone in the room while the grown-ups had dinner elsewhere in the hotel. She and her partner would check on them every half hour or so throughout the evening. I always thought this was totally wrong and irresponsible and when ex and I had our own dc, I refused to leave them alone and would stay in the room with my dc whilst everyone else got drunk over a long dinner/wedding reception/whatever. He and his family told me that I was paranoid and ridiculous.

We are no longer together (thank God) but now they're going to stay in a hotel and I won't be there. I have asked him to promise me that he won't leave them on their own, but to know avail.

There are so many dangers. Fire, they might wake up and be scared, they could hurt themselves, a member of staff who could be anyone could access the room. Not to mention Madeleine Mcann.

What do I do? Can I stop him taking them altogether? Help.

And yes, name changed but I am a long time regular. Penis beaker, have you cancelled the cheque yet, etc.

OP posts:
Teenagehorrorbag · 23/07/2021 00:24

And bear in mind that children are allowed to walk to school alone from Year 5. They don't stay toddlers forever......

CanofCant · 23/07/2021 00:24

Jesus Christ, again with the thread derailers. Glad to see you are getting legal advice OP. Good luck.

Rocketearth · 23/07/2021 00:22

This happened to me when I was 7. My DF took me to visit his family and we stayed a night in London before continuing travelling to them. I went to sleep and woke an hour later to find him not there. He didn’t come back for three hours and had been in the pub. I was petrified in that hotel room by myself and have never forgotten such a shocking lack of judgement. This was 40 years ago.

Teenagehorrorbag · 23/07/2021 00:21

@Pallisers

But you would leave your children sleeping in their bedrooms while eating downstairs - you might even have friends round for a BBQ outside while they sleep? What is the difference, really?

Can you seriously not see the difference? (well I think you can't which is why you made the decisions about leaving your children alone) Did you stay only in hotels which were 3/4 bedroom houses?

And laughing at your we know our own children and my children would never do this that and the other (and are superior to those other children who are too dim to be left alone).

The reality is you don't know what your children will do until they do it. That is why parents do risk assessment rather than assessing whether their own 6 year olds would actually open the bottle of tablets/pull the kettle down/choke on a grape/flood the bathroom

you got lucky.

Oh come on - I'm not sure if they were 6 or maybe even 7 (woo) but they were certainly past the age of opening bottles of tablets or pulling the kettle down. They weren't three!

I assume your children have grown up and you've forgotten what they do at each age - but get a grip.......

Teenagehorrorbag · 23/07/2021 00:15

@Pallisers

but my DTs were happy to be left for an hour or two and we didn't have any concerns about that.

I think you mean YOU were happy to leave your 6 year old DTs for an hour or two and they survived. They hardly proposed the idea did they? "hey mum and dad why don't you go and have a lovely dinner because we are perfectly happy being here in a hotel room on our own and feel perfectly safe, no no, go, we'll be fine" I doubt it.

at least own who made the decision here.

And yes I own the decision - but I would never have left my kids if they were worried or upset. We asked them and they were fine.

I only have these twins so maybe it's a bit different from some children - they are very comfortable with each other where perhaps other children rely more on their parents?

Pallisers · 23/07/2021 00:15

But you would leave your children sleeping in their bedrooms while eating downstairs - you might even have friends round for a BBQ outside while they sleep? What is the difference, really?

Can you seriously not see the difference? (well I think you can't which is why you made the decisions about leaving your children alone) Did you stay only in hotels which were 3/4 bedroom houses?

And laughing at your we know our own children and my children would never do this that and the other (and are superior to those other children who are too dim to be left alone).

The reality is you don't know what your children will do until they do it. That is why parents do risk assessment rather than assessing whether their own 6 year olds would actually open the bottle of tablets/pull the kettle down/choke on a grape/flood the bathroom

you got lucky.

Teenagehorrorbag · 23/07/2021 00:08

But you would leave your children sleeping in their bedrooms while eating downstairs - you might even have friends round for a BBQ outside while they sleep? What is the difference, really?

Kids are probably more likely to roam around their own familiar house while left alone - and any Maddie style pervert can case your house as easily as a holiday apartment, and far more easily than a one night hotel.

I always risk assess everything we do with our children - and DH thinks I am over cautious, with many things. But actually - apart from the fire alarm, and given my knowledge of my own kids - I would assess this as extremely low risk. Hence our decision to do it - and I stand by that.

As I said before - we all know our own children. Mine are not 'curious' or wanderers. They don't fiddle with stuff. They sleep well and don't get anxious. If one was upset or ill the other would be quite happy to come and find us, having been shown where we would be.

I realise many kids are completely different and their parents wouldn't want to leave them in case they did all the things suggested in previous posts - but that's fine too.

Cleverpolly3 · 23/07/2021 00:07

@Teenagehorrorbag

OK - slightly different view. DH and I did this with our DTs from about that age. Probably only a handful of times ever, and always in small hotels where they were fairly close by, and I would check on them every half hour or so. We weren't getting drunk but having a meal and a social evening without disturbing their sleep in our family room.

No-one could get in, but they could get out if they needed and we showed them where we would be if they wanted us (never big hotels). They were tired and were asleep before we left them, and never stirred. We knew our children - they wouldn't drink the mini bar or run riot when we were gone. We had no concerns about that sort of thing at all.

The only thing that shook me rather when I mentioned it to my sister a few years later - was when she said that if there was a fire or an alarm, we wouldn't be allowed to go upstairs to get them. All guests would be expected to leave, and we would have to rely on the staff/firemen to escort them out. That would be horrific - but hopefully the risks are minimal.

The Madeleine thing is irrelevant as PPs have said - no-one is going to get into a hotel room unless ground floor and windows open. The mini bar and taps etc will depend on your knowledge of your own children. There are so many variables, I don't think you can say it's fine or it's dreadful, without a lot more context.

But if you aren't comfortable with his plans, then that's all that counts. And it doesn't sound as though he is bothered about how you feel, or trying to compromise in any way, so he's a thoughtless pig. I don't know what your/his rights are though legally - but I hope you can sort things so you can relax....Flowers.

The very fact you have gone to such lengths to describe why it’s ok suggest you know deep down what you did in fact is anything but
Pallisers · 23/07/2021 00:02

but my DTs were happy to be left for an hour or two and we didn't have any concerns about that.

I think you mean YOU were happy to leave your 6 year old DTs for an hour or two and they survived. They hardly proposed the idea did they? "hey mum and dad why don't you go and have a lovely dinner because we are perfectly happy being here in a hotel room on our own and feel perfectly safe, no no, go, we'll be fine" I doubt it.

at least own who made the decision here.

Whydoiwearsomuchleopardprint · 23/07/2021 00:00

I so agree with you, I would never leave young children on their own in hotel room ever, I feel so sorry you are having to face this for your kids but I 100 percent agree they should not be left alone.

beigebrownblue · 22/07/2021 23:43

@FlyingBattie

Of course there is a hierarchy of risk. Risk is likelihood x probability. I'm not sure why you want to make it into an argument of which risk is greater. We've pretty much all agree that leaving children in a room alone is a risk we'd not take.
You made it into a hierarchy of risk Flying Battie, with your

which risk is 'primary'.

I didn't thank you. All risks are equal and none should be discounted or put into any kind of hierarchy. that's the point.

Its a poker game. And not one which any responsible parent should be taking part in.

beigebrownblue · 22/07/2021 23:38

@FlyingBattie

Also meant to add- I had a job once where I needed DBS checking as I went into schools for part of it. My manager made it quite clear she didn't trust them and felt they lured people into a sense false of security- as she said, they only prove you haven't been caught doing anything, nothing else.
This. What I was trying to say, even DBS checks don't cover all.
FlyingBattie · 22/07/2021 23:37

Likelihood x impact, I meant!

FlyingBattie · 22/07/2021 23:37

Of course there is a hierarchy of risk.
Risk is likelihood x probability.
I'm not sure why you want to make it into an argument of which risk is greater.
We've pretty much all agree that leaving children in a room alone is a risk we'd not take.

beigebrownblue · 22/07/2021 23:34

@FlyingBattie

*That is not too small to worry about. The risk is there, enough said*

Of course it is there, but it wouldn't be my primary worry at all. Not that would leave my children in a room alone, of course! But abduction would be very low down my risk of worries (although as you said, if it's on the list at all, thats enough)

Oh well done Flying Battie

But actually there isn't a hierarchy of risks, so let's not make it into a hierarchy shall we, that is truly pathetic.

Whether 'primary' worry or not, it;s a fucking worry and shouldn't be tolerated, along with the rest of the fucking list of safeguarding shit.

Teenagehorrorbag · 22/07/2021 23:32

@Sadiecow

Also *@Teenagehorrorbag* you've covered off the stranger danger element, not that I think it's acceptable.

But you confirmed that you checked every 30 minutes, but what if one or both or your DTs was crying for 20 mins before you returned?

Awoken, in a strange place and frightened?

You're happy with that?

Please don't come back with "but they always slept" because we all know that children get ill quickly, have nightmare etc

But you could relax and enjoy your meal?

There were two of them, so if one was upset the other could come and get us. But they weren't in the habit of being upset at night, they always slept well wherever we were, they weren't anxious children.

Not sure I would leave a single child, or two of different ages if one was quite young.

As I mentioned - we all know our own children. They were OK with that and knew where to find us, and being twins are very resourceful. Every child and every parent is different - but my DTs were happy to be left for an hour or two and we didn't have any concerns about that.

Dogvmarmot · 22/07/2021 23:25

6 is a terrible age to be left alone. Old enough to get about and move/open things but too young to be able to stop themselves from doing stuff. leaving room, locking themselves out, burning themselves on hot water taps, fillling tub with water - flood or getting in and getting into difficulties. hurting themselves, opening windows, wandering out of hotel 'looking for their dad', ending up on road.. etc. etc. I would not let them go unless I had the name of the hotel and personally checked if the hotel had a babysitting services - letting them know there are twin 6 year olds who must not be left alone. I really wouldn't rely on 6 year olds to use a mobile phone.

Sadiecow · 22/07/2021 23:22

Also @Teenagehorrorbag you've covered off the stranger danger element, not that I think it's acceptable.

But you confirmed that you checked every 30 minutes, but what if one or both or your DTs was crying for 20 mins before you returned?

Awoken, in a strange place and frightened?

You're happy with that?

Please don't come back with "but they always slept" because we all know that children get ill quickly, have nightmare etc

But you could relax and enjoy your meal?

ODFOx · 22/07/2021 23:22

They are six. It isn't old enough to be sent off backpacking but it is quite enough to be told that if they wake in the night someone will will need to wake X if they aren't asleep yet x

FlyingBattie · 22/07/2021 23:18

Also meant to add- I had a job once where I needed DBS checking as I went into schools for part of it. My manager made it quite clear she didn't trust them and felt they lured people into a sense false of security- as she said, they only prove you haven't been caught doing anything, nothing else.

GAHgamel · 22/07/2021 23:16

I wouldn't leap to the solicitor route immediately, but start by emailing him asking him to confirm the contact details of the babysitting service that he will be using at the hotel, so you can arrange to make a goodnight phone call to the kids. If he mails back that he won't be using one because he doesn't see the need, then you've got a bit more evidence on your side if you want to go down that route.

I second the suggestion for a cheap nokia for calling the kids on too.

FlyingBattie · 22/07/2021 23:15

@beigebrownblue

he Madeleine thing is irrelevant as PPs have said - no-one is going to get into a hotel room unless ground floor and windows open. The mini bar and taps etc will depend on your knowledge of your own children. There are so many variables, I don't think you can say it's fine or it's dreadful, without a lot more context.

Quote as above.

No it isn't far from it. It isn't irrelvant.

Someone tracked Madeleine McCanns parents and what they were doing and their habits. They checked the restaurant diary and found out when the kids were alone.

Nothing to stop that happening here.

If people thing all hotel staff are DBS checked in this day and age and with covid shortages they are naive through and through.
And even if they are DBS checked it doesn't necessarily help.

Access to hotel keys is easier than you think

Abductions of children by strangers are incredibly rare is what pp's (including myself) were trying to say. Yes, it is still a risk, a very small one. How individual people respond to that risk is up to them, of course. For me personally it isn't something that would be my top concern in this situation, as I feel that the risk of something like a fire or accident would be higher. In other situations, I would take it into more consideration (like that poor girl who was abducted from a tent in her garden- I think the risk of someone being able to gain access to a garden is much higher than that of someone gaining access to a hotel room, even if it's still statistically unlikely). Everyone judges risk differently and it may not rational, but that's fine. I think the one thing most people can agree on is that it's not a good idea to leave children unattended in a hotel room for a whole range of reasons.
Hugoslavia · 22/07/2021 23:15

As an aside, I know a hotel in the UK that provides 'iPads' to both children and parents that act as a child video monitor so that the parents can eat in the restaurant downstairs and keep an eye on their children. The staff at reception also ask to be kept informed of any children left unattended in rooms. That said, it was a large hotel with multiple exits and I just wouldn't have felt comfortable using their system because if there was a problem, it would take 3-4 minutes to reach them.

endofthelinefinally · 22/07/2021 23:15

There is a reason there is a safe in a hotel room for valuables.
A colleague left her little girl having a nap in the hotel room when attending a family wedding. She was checking every 30 minutes.
The second time she checked, a bag containing her purse and some jewellery left in the bathroom had gone. Thankfully the child was still asleep. Hotel rooms are not secure. I always double lock/ put the chain on when I go to bed. I would not entertain the idea of leaving my children alone in a hotel room, ever.

Eeiliethya · 22/07/2021 23:13

Hell to the fuck no.

I don't think I could even let them go now. You could speak to him, he could agree not to leave them but could just be paying you lip service and still have every intention of leaving them alone.

I just can't fathom how anybody (especially a parent) can be this dense when it comes to their children and risk mitigation. Fuck me.