Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to think Dsis was not broke and shouldn't have accepted lunch!?

205 replies

everythingyouneed · 22/07/2021 18:31

Long story short we were out for the morning...my dsis kept saying she wanted to get home for lunch time to feed the kids and wouldn't have lunch out as she was broke. Fair enough. Anyway timings went awry and we ended up in the middle of town at prime lunch time. I wanted lunch and so did my dc. Dsis said no she was going to get back to the car as she couldn't afford it. I said " oh come on I'll pay it's not a big deal!" So I bought lunch. All good. It was nice, all was eaten.

The very next day I rang my Dsis and as we were talking she said, my tyre got a puncture this morning so I'm in getting a new tyre as it can't be fixed. I said "oh dear are you ok for money?" She said "ah yeah I just transferred it out of the savings!

Aibu to think she could have done that the day before at lunch rather than letting me pay? I know I was happy to and I offered but I'm just a bit...Hmm now!!

OP posts:
NotanothernamechangeforMN · 22/07/2021 18:44

YABU

Notaroadrunner · 22/07/2021 18:44

Her savings are likely for emergencies. If she got into the habit of transferring money from her savings to cover lunches then she'd be in trouble when an emergency arose. So I think YABU.

LeroyJenkinssss · 22/07/2021 18:44

Out of interest, how are your finances? Not asked in a snidey way but do you not need to budget for these sorts of things and therefore see them as different?

DysmalRadius · 22/07/2021 18:43

I said " oh come on I'll pay it's not a big deal!" So I bought lunch. All good. It was nice, all was eaten.

What you should have said is 'this is a massive deal and by insisting that I pay for the lunch you clearly stated you didn't want to buy, I am reserving the right to judge all your future spending and decide on your behalf whether you can afford things or not.'

everythingyouneed · 22/07/2021 18:42

Did you only offer to pay for lunch because you took her saying she was ‘broke’ completely literally and thought she didn’t have a penny to her name

Yep..."broke" to me means literally no money...I assumed she had no money whatsoever. I wouldn't say I was broke if I had savings I would just say I don't want to pay for a lunch out.

OP posts:
TooWicked · 22/07/2021 18:42

The tyre was a necessity, the lunch out wasn't.

If she used her savings every time she wanted lunch out she probably wouldn't have savings for very long.

ChequerBoard · 22/07/2021 18:41

YABU - she said she was going home, you insisted on lunch out. If you had not have said you would pay, she would have gone home.

Tyre is irrelevant, a necessity to be paid for out of rainy day money - not an avoidable extravagance.

chunderwunder · 22/07/2021 18:40

It's a different budget innit. Day-to-day living vs savings for emergencies.

The first pot can be empty, the second full. If you keep using the second to top up the first, you've got a problem...

Marshmallow91 · 22/07/2021 18:40

Yabu. Hope that helps.

Actually you are more than unreasonable because it's you who essentially forced her to get the lunch you paid for- for what? Just so you could moan about it?

gingerbiscuits · 22/07/2021 18:39

@TwoAndAnOnion

So, she has an emergency fund for things like tyres, and didnt want to dip into it for a lunch she could make at home. You offered to foot her lunch bill, she didnt ask.
I agree.
MrsTophamHat · 22/07/2021 18:39

YaBU. One is an essential repair, one is a luxury.

She repeatedly said she didn't want to have lunch but it sounds like you cajoled her into it.

Somarefuser · 22/07/2021 18:39

You hassled her to stay, when she had a plan to avoid spending money.
You potentially patronised and embarrassed her into accepting lunch.
Now you can’t tell the difference between essential equipment and an optional lunch and are being snide.
You come across as a difficult sibling.

WomanStanleyWoman · 22/07/2021 18:38

If she’s reliant on her car, getting the new tyre is an essential. Lunch out isn’t, which is probably why she planned to go home. Maybe she has savings precisely because she assesses whether a purchase is essential or not before making it.

Did you only offer to pay for lunch because you took her saying she was ‘broke’ completely literally and thought she didn’t have a penny to her name?

Pebbledashery · 22/07/2021 18:38

Sorry you're being unreasonable. You offered to pay, she said no twice and you pressured her. Presumably her emergency fund is for emergencies and not to fritter away on lunches.

WildWestWanda · 22/07/2021 18:36

Yeah yabu

LeroyJenkinssss · 22/07/2021 18:36

Actually I’m impressed by her - it’s easy (particularly if there’s peer pressure) to dip into savings for a ‘treat’ which then becomes a habit which then means you don’t have money for tyres.

She didn’t ask for you to offer and was perfectly prepared to go home but you insisted. She wasn’t asking for handouts so yabu

Blinkingheckythump · 22/07/2021 18:36

Why would she spend her savings on lunch out? She was very clear in saying she couldn't afford to buy lunch. Which she obviously can't if she would have needed to use savings for it. It sounds like you have a poor grasp on money management if you seriously think it's good to use savings that way

TheBigFatMermaid · 22/07/2021 18:36

She has savings for emergencies, needing a tyre is an emergency, lunch out is not.

Zealois · 22/07/2021 18:35

Big difference between dipping into savings for a new trye, and for an unnecessary lunch out.

I've said no to a meal out this evening as I don't have the money, but did just use my savings today to make up the difference on our car insurance payment that turned out to be more expensive than we thought it would be.

Poptart4 · 22/07/2021 18:35

YABU she said she wanted to go home for lunch several times. You insisted on eating out AND offered to pay. She did nothing wrong.

Also its one thing dipping into savings for a new tyre as that is a necessity. Lunch out is not.

TotorosCatBus · 22/07/2021 18:35

I agree with your sister that replacing a tyre is more important than eating out so calls for money out of savings. Eating out is a luxury where as a car might be needed for necessities like work and the nursery run.

Sister isn't unreasonable to accept your offer to pay imo. You offered. If she'd hinted that she was broke and would you pay then she'd be unreasonable

StarryStarrySocks · 22/07/2021 18:35

As others have said, nobody dips into their savings to buy themselves lunch!

MagnoliaBeige · 22/07/2021 18:35

Isn’t that called budgeting?! She had no spare money to spend on lunch and had to dip into her savings (ie rainy day fund) for an unexpected expense. And there is nothing more annoying than telling someone you can’t afford something and they then bang on about doing it anyway.

LadyPoison · 22/07/2021 18:34

I wouldn't want to dip into savings for a lunch out so I'd skip it like she was going to do but I would if I had to replace a tyre.

Lunch is discretionary spending but my car is vital so yes I think you are being unreasonable here.

JustLyra · 22/07/2021 18:34

There's a huge difference between a tyre that needs fixed and lunch. Dipping into a small amount of emergency savings, especially if they are struggling at the moment so unexpected expenses could become an issue, makes absolute sense for the tyre, not at all for the lunch when she was prepared to go home.