Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not allowing my 17 year old son to go to London

338 replies

Toooldforschoolruns · 22/07/2021 10:36

Me and dh are away in Scotland for a short holiday from tomorrow. My 19 yr old dd will be home with 17 yr old son and "in charge".

My problem is that ds wants to go to London with a group of his friends while we're away. We live about an hour from London on train so ordinarily if there was a problem we could be down there pretty quick. However, we'll be on west coast of Scotland, so not so convenient.

Are we being unreasonable for not letting him go? He's not happy with us "treating him like a child" but he's a young 17 and not very street smart.

Advice please 🙏

OP posts:
ConstanceGracy · 22/07/2021 13:46

Yikes .. he’s 17, let him go.
Me and my friends used to go a lot from the age of about 12/13 and we were 45 mins away by tube

NK346f2849X127d8bca260 · 22/07/2021 13:46

Let him go, only an hour away from home and you obviously feel his sibling is able to cope with a crisis as you have gone on holiday

It is good he has told you, if you say no he won't be so up front next time.

My son, we also live about an hour from London used to go there fairly regulary on sight seeing trips with his friends at that age.

TheOriginalMrsMoss · 22/07/2021 13:45

@GreyhoundG1rl

The 17 year old's living in London are still allowed out... 🤷🏻‍♀️
LOL! Yup a house full of teens who are allowed out in London gasp. He will be fine - you need to allow him some freedom. In his shoes I would just go anyway.

My children (raised in London) have been allowed to travel unaccompanied from the age of 11. they are very shrewd and streetsmart. We have also allowed them freedom to go off when abroad too. I think it's been really beneficial for them.

Jem57 · 22/07/2021 13:37

My sons started going on holiday abroad with friends at 16,you have to let go one day.

BuffySummersReportingforSanity · 22/07/2021 13:36

My parents left me alone in the house for a week when I was 17 to go to a conference. In lieu of advice I would probably have ignored "in case something happens", they left me something actually useful: some money.

Well, something did happen; part of the plumbing went wrong and I suddenly had water pouring through a ceiling. I didn't want to disturb their holiday, so I sorted it out. Admittedly a friend's dad talked me through raising the stopcock in the attic over the phone to drain the system, but I did it, and I got an emergency plumber in and sorted it all out.

And it did me a world of good. There are people reading this right now going "oh, but I would never want my precious baby to struggle like that on their own with the stress and the pressure! They should call me! I have trained my little one to always call me!" And I'll tell you the truth; having called my parents rather than sorting it out myself would have taken away from me something immeasurably precious and valuable. I proved to myself I was capable and could think my way through a minor emergency. I felt responsible and grown up. I tackled a new challenge successfully. That did far, far more for me than my parents sorting it out remotely would have done.

Haffdonga · 22/07/2021 13:29

How would you have known if he'd lied to you?

My dh had a very over-protective mother who didn't let him or his sister go anywhere more than walking distance from home. So what did they do? Of course they lied to her, went anyway and were probably at far greater risk because they were never where they'd said they'd be.

If your ds feels he can tell you honestly where he's going and who with because you trust him to be sensible, he's far more likely to keep telling you the truth and be safer.

TiredButDancing · 22/07/2021 13:25

OP sounds like you realise you're being a bt precious. It does sound to me though like your DH's bad experience might be having a far more long term effect than just this one trip - is your DS lacking street smarts because you (both) haven't allowed him to get out and about and learning how to navigate?

DH had very over protective parents and it has taken a lot of effort on his part to break the patterns. Intellectually, he totally sees that it's up to us to give our children the skills he didn't get. But it has been hard for him to do it. But he's doing a really good job of changing. Sadly, same can't be said of his sister who has absorbed all the "world is dangerous" messages to an extreme degree and whose DS, I suspect, won't be allowed out of the house alone until he's 21.

FindingMeno · 22/07/2021 13:25

I wasn't even living at home at 17!

Maggiesfarm · 22/07/2021 13:24

I don't see how you can stop him going, frankly. He's old enough to leave home without persmission. Presumably he and his friends have plans regarding what they will do in London and have found somewhere decent to stay.

It's quite normal for 17 year olds to go away with friends to all sorts of places.

melj1213 · 22/07/2021 13:23

I went to London for 4 days from a tiny town in the Lake District 3 days after my 18th birthday with a friend to meet up with some other friends to go to a huge fan convention.

My parents were very unhappy about it and tried to persuade me not to go, but the more they fought against it the more I was determined to go and the less information I gave them (because the less they knew the less arguments they could make for me not to go).if I had had issues then my parents would have been the last people I would have called for help for fear of the "I told you so"s, fortunately it went without a hitch and we had a great time.

The best thing is to do is agree that he should call or text a couple of times (when he arrives in London and when he's heading home) and if he gets in trouble, obviously, but otherwise leave him to it.

azimuth299 · 22/07/2021 13:23

If he's not streetwise then the way to improve this is surely to practise in low-stakes situations - a bit like this. He'll have a lot of friends around him so he won't get lost on his own or anything. This is the perfect situation to improve his confidence and street awareness, so you should encourage it.

I would have laughed if my parents had told me that I couldn't go on a trip with my friends at 17. It's really too much control to have over someone who is nearly an adult. You say that he's a 'young 17' but what do you expect if you don't allow him to take his own risks?

paddlingon · 22/07/2021 13:22

At 17 I was a University hundreds of miles from home.
This seems rather over protective.

titchy · 22/07/2021 13:21

@Highfivemum

I wouldn’t let him go. Not if I wasn’t in a reasonable distance to help if needed. That’s just me though and I think I am over protective due to life’s experiences.
That's understandable, as is the OP's dh's view given his experience.

But the only way our children can learn to recognise situations and deal with the unexpected is by experiencing life, and having those apron strings loosened bit by bit.

There is no one more vulnerable than a newly freed young person who has never been allowed to go anywhere without support. Surely no one wants their adult children to remain vulnerable?

TabithaTiger · 22/07/2021 13:16

At 17, I wouldn't have even expected my DS to tell me he was going to London if I was on holiday, let alone ask. I'd no doubt find out when he posted a pic on Instagram! We live an hour from London by train too. What do you think is likely to happen?

depthdespair · 22/07/2021 13:16

It's not your choice to make, he's 17. He needs to do his own assessment of the situation and make his own decision.

Parky04 · 22/07/2021 13:15

I went for a weeks holiday in Ibiza with mates when I was 15! When my two DSs reached 16 I let them do whatever was legal!

bringincrazyback · 22/07/2021 13:13

At your DS's age my parents thought I was young for my age and not street smart. Neither of those things were true. I was out clubbing frequently in a party town at your DS's age, and this made me develop street smarts and an ability to handle myself pretty quickly, but because my parents had never seen me in that 'mode' they perceived me in an inaccurate/incomplete way.

Obviously you know your DS and none of us do, but the sides of him that you see at home don't necessarily embody everything about his character, that's all I'm saying.

FGTR3 · 22/07/2021 13:13

Over protective to me that. 17 is old enough to be out on your own.

Highfivemum · 22/07/2021 13:11

I wouldn’t let him go. Not if I wasn’t in a reasonable distance to help if needed. That’s just me though and I think I am over protective due to life’s experiences.

cansu · 22/07/2021 13:11

If he did wander into 'gang territory and get into trouble, what exactly would you be able to do about it? I assume him calling you on your mobile and you jumping into your car to collect him? Oh hold on very violent drug gang, I am just going to call my parents, they'll be here in about an hour.

NewModelArmyMayhem18 · 22/07/2021 13:10

FWIW 17 is assuredly old enough to go to London with friends unless you know the group is likely to be getting up to mischief (do they have form?).

silverbubbles · 22/07/2021 13:10

You are being over protective. Let him go.

cansu · 22/07/2021 13:09

FGS he is 17 and he is going to central London. You are being ridiculous.

NewModelArmyMayhem18 · 22/07/2021 13:08

Yes, completely irrational on my part, I’d worry that as a young man, he’d be in danger of things like mistaken identity and wandering into gang turf and other stupid shit like that. Unlikely unless deliberately seeking out dodgy neighbourhoods.

JustDanceAddict · 22/07/2021 13:07

Of course he should go into London!