Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To leave 8 week old baby for the weekend?

390 replies

SheABitSpicyToday · 22/07/2021 10:30

My best friend is having her hen weekend 8 weeks after I’m due to give birth. Will likely be more as I think I’m being induced early. It’s only 20 minute drive away and am taking my own car so can be home if I need to be or can get taxi.
Husband is actually looking forward to having the weekend to bond with baby by himself. Didn’t think anything was wrong until my sister said it was a disgusting thing to do and that the baby will be traumatised by it. I think she’s being Ott but do you think this is a terrible thing to do?

OP posts:
WorraLiberty · 22/07/2021 23:48

@SheABitSpicyToday

Not our first baby no. With the first we left her overnight at 5 weeks and it was fine. I’ve no committed 100% as obviously can’t account for any complications etc. Not breastfeeding so that’s not an issue.
And....

I clearly don’t have the maternal instincts then because I’ve never been bothered about leaving my first baby and we’ve always had an incredible bond. She’s 7 now.

So why are you asking then, I mean other than to start a controversial thread?

IncludeWomenInThePrequel · 22/07/2021 23:40

@DrinkFeckArseBrick

There is nothing wrong with it at all but most of the mums I know ended up crying in the local shop the first time they left their young baby alone for 20 min. So maybe have a couple of practice runs and dont commit to anything til you've seen how you feel. It's weird to having a baby inside you then permanently on you or next to you for 10 or 11 months then be away from them
Most of the mums you know have cried in the local Spar because they nipped out for milk without their baby?

Fuck me Grin

ScrollingLeaves · 22/07/2021 21:54

“ Babynanes2
And typically an 8 week has not formed an attachment with a primary caregiver,”

I don’t know who said that but I doubt it is true.

It sounds like the sort of scientist like the one in the 1950s or 60s who took a baby chimp from its mother, left it alone and then proved ‘scientifically’ that it got distressed - he needed to do the experiment. Or the old mantra, ‘ children are resilient’.

It am sure an 8 week old baby could also feel safe and happy with its father if he had been fully involved with care from the outset.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 22/07/2021 21:16

As long as the baby’s being fed, cuddled, and looked after properly, it will be fine.
Must say I could never have left mine for a weekend - or even more than a few hours - at that age, though, no matter well I’d known they’d be looked after - it was an entirely visceral thing

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 22/07/2021 21:16

Just seen your updates, if you know it wont bother you then why not

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 22/07/2021 21:15

There is nothing wrong with it at all but most of the mums I know ended up crying in the local shop the first time they left their young baby alone for 20 min. So maybe have a couple of practice runs and dont commit to anything til you've seen how you feel. It's weird to having a baby inside you then permanently on you or next to you for 10 or 11 months then be away from them

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 22/07/2021 21:10

The baby will be fine but you might find you just dont want to.

If you are planning to breastfeed this would be difficult. Few people would be able to pump enough to leave baby for a whole weekend, and you'd have to pump all the time to protect your supply and avoid football boobs, it would be a nightmare.

AnUnoriginalUsername · 22/07/2021 21:09

Also, like fuck could I be arsed with a hen weekend right now. I feel silly staying up past 11pm!

AnUnoriginalUsername · 22/07/2021 21:06

Mines that age now, I feel uncomfortable going to the shop without him, no way could I go away for a weekend. My dad is having him in a couple of weeks while we have a meal and I don't plan on being away from him for more than a couple of hours. I don't think he'd be traumatised but I just might be!

Kitkat151 · 22/07/2021 20:59

@Havaword

Is this your first child? I wouldn’t have felt comfortable leaving my child for the whole weekend at 8 weeks old but I wouldn’t judge anyone who did. Also for me I was still exhausted and physically recovering but everyone’s different.
Yes everyone is different
Rubyrecka · 22/07/2021 20:55

Judgmental twit comes to mind.

Babynames2 · 22/07/2021 20:45

But people telling you that the baby won't notice & it makes no difference to them are scientifically incorrect and displaying a poor understanding of early development.

Actually they aren’t. Yes babies can recognise a mothers heartbeat, smell and voice from birth. But this isn’t a newborn, it’s an 8 week old. And typically an 8 week has not formed an attachment with a primary caregiver, that happens nearer the 12 week mark. Usually at 8 weeks, provided their basic needs are met, they’re happy regardless of who they’re with. Primary caregiver attachment typically starts nearer 12 weeks and usually by 6/7 months a baby will display separation anxiety. And then stranger anxiety a few months after.

Obviously for a breast-fed baby (although not an issue here) it’s trickier as many won’t take a bottle at this stage, but that’s because they expect the boob, not bottle. They want the boob, not mom. If you could stick that boob on dad they’d be equally happy!

Babynames2 · 22/07/2021 20:38

Babies know their mother’s heart beat, smell and voice. A baby might feel a bit empty at some level if those things were not there

Yes they recognise those, but to suggest that they might feel ‘empty’ without them is ridiculous. The baby will be fine being consoled by their own father! By then they will know their fathers voice and smell and be able to distinguish him from another. If the the father isn’t capable of dealing with the baby on his own by then it’s usually because they’ve left mom to do all the main work. Ive plenty of videos showing both my DDs smiling and cooing at DH at this age, they were also forming an attachment to him and he managed just fine being left with them at this age.

The guilt tripping of a mom wanting to enjoy herself and have a bit of time to herself on this thread is bloody awful.

Millionnewnames · 22/07/2021 19:57

@Bythemillpond
Wow. Your daughter sounds so like mine. Almost identical situation .
DD was highly academic , gifted in maths but really couldn’t handle college life and dropped out very quickly. I was concerned about what that might mean long term , but the little madam has proven us all wrong and literally ‘levelled up’ through the company at lightening speed.
Her brother will benefit from this as I’ll be more inclined to trust his wishes when the choices arise and let him chase whatever path he wants .

fiorentina · 22/07/2021 19:46

I did this, but I had stopped breastfeeding/expressing by then. I had fun, was nice to have time with friends and DH had a good time with DC, however he’d been hands on from day 1.

TwatyKaty · 22/07/2021 19:43

@SheABitSpicyToday

I have just seen that it's not your first baby. That being the case, you could probably go on a three-week cruise and not feel too bad about it. Grin

I couldn't have done it either physically or emotionally, with any of mine. But that might also have had something to do with XH being a twat who couldn't be trusted to keep them alive.

ScrollingLeaves · 22/07/2021 19:41

“Sparepantsandtoothbrush
An 8 week old baby isn't going to care who's looking after them as long as they're being fed and changed.”

Babies know their mother’s heart beat, smell and voice. A baby might feel a bit empty at some level if those things were not there.

Bythemillpond · 22/07/2021 19:40

BFrazzled

So you think it's university or failure?
Nope, I never wrote it

I just answered a poster who boasted that her daughter "owns her own home" as a benchmark of life success that most people wouldn't consider it as such. I'd much rather my kids study or prepare for their careers in other ways than pay a mortgage at this age

Dd works in a managerial role managing those that went to university to do the job she has been doing since she was 18
She has been offered eye watering amounts to work in an office managing projects but has turned them down.
She probably has ADHD (getting assessed) and would probably walk out of any sort of office work after a few days.

Dd owns a little flat outright. She doesn’t pay a mortgage.

DifferentHair · 22/07/2021 19:20

Also I think it's worth considering what 'mental health' means to different people and in different contexts.

There's a big difference between 'I'll enjoy this and it's nice to have a break' and 'I'm unwell/at risk of becoming unwell and this will make a difference.'

Both could be said to be for 'mental health', but would be weighted differently when considering what's best for the family as a whole.

JollyJlly · 22/07/2021 19:20

I think you’ll feel different when the baby is here. I thought I would feel like you, but my daughter was nearly 2 before I spent a night away. If you’re comfortable then your baby will be xxx

BFrazzled · 22/07/2021 19:14

So you think it's university or failure?
Nope, I never wrote it.

I just answered a poster who boasted that her daughter "owns her own home" as a benchmark of life success that most people wouldn't consider it as such. I'd much rather my kids study or prepare for their careers in other ways than pay a mortgage at this age.

Maggiesfarm · 22/07/2021 19:13

@Iwantcauliflowercheese

I had to travel over an hour to London for a court case when my DD was a week old. She was EBF, but there was no choice. My XP gave her formula and she didn't seem to have missed me at all. It was good for him to have time alone with her as he hadn't wanted a baby and he bonded with her that day.
You had to go, you didn't choose to. There are always emergencies.

I'm glad it all worked out well and that your husband bonded with your baby. That's lovely.

I would have left mine with their dad but not overnight. However I make no judgement on the op (& she hasn't done it yet).

DifferentHair · 22/07/2021 19:12

@SheABitSpicyToday I don't know, that's what I'm saying.

If you feel you need this for your mental health (which I suppose is a call you would need to make closer to the time given you don't know how you will be feeling 8 weeks post partum) then that's a question answered by you, not strangers on the internet.

But people telling you that the baby won't notice & it makes no difference to them are scientifically incorrect and displaying a poor understanding of early development.

SheABitSpicyToday · 22/07/2021 19:04

But how do you know that the hen party isn’t for my mental health?

Also, I agree that the sudden disappearance of a mother can be traumatic but I’m going to be gone for 2 days. It’s not the same as abandonment.

OP posts:
DifferentHair · 22/07/2021 18:58

OP literally asked people for their opinions on this. It is not 'shaming' for people to honestly answer her question.

There is also a lot of nuance between being a 'martyr' who forgoes all their personal needs forever and someone honestly saying they think an 8 weeks old is too young to be separated from their mother for the sake of a social engagement.

If you observe mammals in nature- they stay close to their babies at this stage. that is what newborn humans are geared to want and need. There is a lot of science showing that the touch, smell, sound of the person who carried them for 9 months is developmentally important. The baby absolutely knows who it's mother is at that age. What they won't know or understand is why their mother is suddenly gone.

That's not to say that someone who needs a break for their mental health shouldn't take it. Everyone's situation is different and we're all best placed to observe our own situation and family dynamics.

I just don't think a bachelorette party is worth it.