Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To leave 8 week old baby for the weekend?

390 replies

SheABitSpicyToday · 22/07/2021 10:30

My best friend is having her hen weekend 8 weeks after I’m due to give birth. Will likely be more as I think I’m being induced early. It’s only 20 minute drive away and am taking my own car so can be home if I need to be or can get taxi.
Husband is actually looking forward to having the weekend to bond with baby by himself. Didn’t think anything was wrong until my sister said it was a disgusting thing to do and that the baby will be traumatised by it. I think she’s being Ott but do you think this is a terrible thing to do?

OP posts:
aimss4777 · 23/07/2021 10:09

Not a terrible thing to do at all! Go for it. Baby is and will be perfectly fine!!

I feel like there's so much judgement on the mother to always be with the newborn 24/7 and I'm expecting my first in a couple of weeks and already feel like this, I actually have a day trip planned when they're around 8 weeks also, just go for it and enjoy yourself!!! Grin

Wizzbangfizz · 23/07/2021 10:07

Good on your DH you read too much on here that men won't step up and women who haven't had a night away from their DC ever. I left mine and continue to do so and there is no trauma here. Go enjoy the weekend and don't give it a second thought.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 23/07/2021 10:01

[quote Babynames2]**@BFrazzled

where breastfed babies and mother share a bond for the first year of life

Formula fed babies also share a bond with their mother for the first year of life. It’s not like sticking a bottle in its mouth means it doesn’t bond to the mother. And I have no issue with breastfeeding, having breastfed myself, but saying stuff like that makes it sound like breastfeeding makes a superior bond compared to formula feeding.[/quote]
This. I was adopted at a few months old and funnily enough had a bond with my mum for the first year of my life too... and the following thirty and counting!
It was disingenuous or silly of @BFrazzled to compare a breastfed baby to one calming itself down in a bouncer while their mum 'pops off' on holiday. Because the baby in this scenario will be with its father. You know, the other parent in its life who is perfectly capable of keeping the baby feeling safe and loved instead of leaving it in a bouncer to calm itself down if distressed!

Babynames2 · 23/07/2021 09:57

@BFrazzled

where breastfed babies and mother share a bond for the first year of life

Formula fed babies also share a bond with their mother for the first year of life. It’s not like sticking a bottle in its mouth means it doesn’t bond to the mother. And I have no issue with breastfeeding, having breastfed myself, but saying stuff like that makes it sound like breastfeeding makes a superior bond compared to formula feeding.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 23/07/2021 09:56

[quote BFrazzled]@youvegottenminuteslynn well yes, this was obviously intentionally rude in response to intentionally rude poster who wrote something to the point of babies being near vegetables guzzling their milk in bouncers oblivious to their surroundings. Why is it ok to be sneeringly rude towards one way of parenting (where breastfed babies and mother share a bond for the first year of life) but not to the other (where a happy bottle fed baby calms himself down in a bouncer while mum pops off for a holiday for her mental health)?[/quote]
It wasn't just one post though, your posts throughout the thread have had a similar tone which has made people react negatively to you. Isn't it worth you considering that might be something to work on to communicate more effectively instead of focusing your energy on being 'intentionally rude' to people you feel deserve it? You were patronising and sneering about people's life choices in plenty of posts previous to that one.

You've also ignored my point that owning a home at 20 shows someone has worked hard, earned well and taken their responsibilities seriously. That was a chance for you to perhaps say yes, those are positives to show that you can see merit in decisions that don't involve higher education.

If lots of people have an issue with the way you express yourself, it's always worth reflecting on why that is. Either they are all getting the wrong end of the stick or you are expressing yourself poorly.

Babynames2 · 23/07/2021 09:53

@DifferentHair Well okay, hardly going to post my qualifications here. But I think people are confusing attachment (which forms over time) with a babies innate survival instincts, which can be met by anyone. A mom could go back to work as soon as she wanted and have a dad (or other person) meet those needs and the baby would not be traumatised, they would develop that primary caregiver attachment to whomever provided that main care. And more recent research has actually suggested that babies are capable of attaching to more than one person earlier than was thought a few decades ago.

Blossomtoes · 23/07/2021 09:51

it can be quite tricky to determine if baby is happy or stressed because babies cannot tell you

Of all the bollocks I’ve read on MN - and there’s been plenty - this takes the biscuit. Babies are hardwired to make it impossible to not notice when they’re unhappy - they bawl. Very loudly. Trust me, they definitely tell you!

Tiny babies are very simple organisms. They need to be fed, warm, clean and cuddled. When their needs aren’t met they make it clear in a very effective way that’s difficult to ignore.

MaryShelley1818 · 23/07/2021 09:47

I couldn't have been bothered personally but your baby will be fine - if you are happy then go and enjoy yourself!

SheABitSpicyToday · 23/07/2021 09:35

Your friend will probably divorce and have another hen some years down the line, so nothing lost

What a fucking weird thing to say.

OP posts:
DifferentHair · 23/07/2021 09:35

@Babynames2 I don't believe you, sorry.

BFrazzled · 23/07/2021 09:35

@youvegottenminuteslynn well yes, this was obviously intentionally rude in response to intentionally rude poster who wrote something to the point of babies being near vegetables guzzling their milk in bouncers oblivious to their surroundings. Why is it ok to be sneeringly rude towards one way of parenting (where breastfed babies and mother share a bond for the first year of life) but not to the other (where a happy bottle fed baby calms himself down in a bouncer while mum pops off for a holiday for her mental health)?

SVRT19674 · 23/07/2021 09:33

Wait to decide until you actually have your baby in your arms. How you imagine you would feel and how you will actually feel is totally different. I didn't want to leave my baby, and said no to any invitation to do anything. I also had a cesarian section. And I didn´t breast feed, I just wanted to dedicate that time to being with baby. Your friend will probably divorce and have another hen some years down the line, so nothing lost.

Finknottlesnewt · 23/07/2021 09:31

Nope OP . Your sister is talking bollox. I have left all of mine at that age for weekends away with DH, a family party and for a minor operation. Each was between 6-10 weeks. DH or Granny stepped in.

They are now in their 20s and no one has needed trauma therapy !

Don't let the mummy martyr brigade stop you from living a life that isn't all consumed by motherhood. It doesn't make you a 'better' mother - in fact in most cases it makes you a much more annoying one.

Enjoy your hen party.

BFrazzled · 23/07/2021 09:20

@Babynames2 it can be quite tricky to determine if baby is happy or stressed because babies cannot tell you. So they could have been the same since the down of time but our knowledge of them (what we think of them) has changed. It happened with many things, not just with babies (you can probably think about examples yourself)

But I have to tell you, even without tricky scientific words like "attachment" and "separation anxiety" (which by the was haven't been with us since the down of time but are rather recent concepts) I have seen enough babies who refused to settle without mother for a long time and the whole experience has been stressful for the baby and the person trying to settle it. It is true, they haven't tried to stick a boob in babies mouth...but I think for most purposes this won't be practical.

ButteringMyArse · 23/07/2021 09:19

Clearly you aren't as maternal as other folk are, not that there is anything wrong with that. But yeh, I wouldn't want to be without my little baby for a weekend and I'm sure they'd prefer you to be around too. But I'm sure you'll have fun at the hen do.

Shame for your baby really, with that attitude they'd probably benefit from you not being there for a while.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 23/07/2021 09:18

@BFrazzled

I just answered a poster who boasted that her daughter "owns her own home" as a benchmark of life success that most people wouldn't consider it as such. I'd much rather my kids study or prepare for their careers in other ways than pay a mortgage at this age.

Owning a home at 20 is a great achievement and suggests that someone has worked hard, earned well and made sensible decisions. I would say that is a success.

YOU would rather your kids took a different path but everyone is different. You also may have the ability to fund a child through university while others don't.

You sound incredibly patronising and the way you speak suggests you're doing so from a place of privilege.

While you claim you didn't say the only choices were university or failure, you absolutely come across as believing that a child not taking up higher education is a failure or lack of care on the parents' part.

As someone who presumably sees yourself as intelligent with critical thinking skills, do you not think it's worth considering that if a number of people have pointed out you come across as highly judgemental, as patronising and as sneering... it could be that you do present as that way to others and it's something you could work on?

After all, education and self reflection are important life skills.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 23/07/2021 09:17

What is this nonsense about 20 ml per breast feed?

I breastfed both of mine in the days when (depending on birth weight) 3 or 4 hourly feeds were the thing, so they were having a lot more each time. It worked fine, and as very small babies they mostly slept between feeds.

If the dad has been reasonably hands-on with cuddles, I don’t see why the baby wouldn’t have bonded with him, either. Maybe my SiL was unusual, but I’ve got pics of dd’s young babies in just a nappy, sleeping on his bare chest.

Though having said that, as per my pp, I’d have hated to leave mine at all at that age.

Babynames2 · 23/07/2021 09:13

@DifferentHair

Well, it’s what I’ve been taught in both my undergraduate and masters degrees in child development in the last 10 years. I’ve also read plenty of recent research papers thanks. But I’ll let all of my lecturers know that you know better Hmm

There’s a difference between a baby recognising it’s mother, and being attached. A babies attachment style to its primary caregiver is usually not fully formed and established until near 12 months, it takes time for the attachment to fully develop.

Also, recent research will tell you that babies are capable of recognising their own fathers voice (and siblings) from birth or very soon after as well. And provided the father has been involved from birth the baby will not be even remotely bothered by being left with him for a few days at 8 weeks.

Blossomtoes · 23/07/2021 08:40

[quote DifferentHair]@Babynames2 that's just not correct. Please consult a resource that has been published in the last 40 years. [/quote]
Babies haven’t changed in the last 40 years. They’ve been the same since the dawn of time.

mistermagpie · 23/07/2021 08:39

I don't think the baby will be traumatised, neither will you be. But I wouldn't have done it myself.

I've had three children and with the third I was happy leaving her for a few hours quite early on, but not a couple of nights at 8 weeks. I just wouldn't have wanted to do it and I wouldn't have had a good time.

That's me though, and if you think you'll enjoy it then you should go!

Sceptre86 · 23/07/2021 08:34

I left my 8 week old baby boy with my mum to attend a wedding for 2 nights. I was heavily bleeding and couldn't sleep as I missed him so much. If I could rewind time I wouldn't have left him but that was a wedding on my dh's side whereas this is a hen for a close friend. If you think you will be sufficiently recovered, go for it.

DifferentHair · 23/07/2021 04:11

@Babynames2 that's just not correct. Please consult a resource that has been published in the last 40 years.

FortniteBoysMum · 23/07/2021 01:10

I was 4 months old when my mum fell pregnant with my brother. She spent 6 months of that pregnancy in hospital on bed rest because of kidney problems. My dad was working abroad in Saudi Arabia. As a result my auntie looked after me. I'm not traumatised by that so no way will a weekend affect your baby.

Dogvmarmot · 22/07/2021 23:55

@SheABitSpicyToday

Not our first baby no. With the first we left her overnight at 5 weeks and it was fine. I’ve no committed 100% as obviously can’t account for any complications etc. Not breastfeeding so that’s not an issue.
not breastfeeding. your dh is going to be with your baby. your a quick drive back if there is an issue. have a great time. traumatised - that's ridiculous.
WorraLiberty · 22/07/2021 23:49

There is nothing wrong with it at all but most of the mums I know ended up crying in the local shop the first time they left their young baby alone for 20 min.

Fuck me, you must know some very unusual mums.

I mean for just one to burst into tears in their local shop is strange, but most of the mums you know?

Where on earth do you know them from? Confused