Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To leave 8 week old baby for the weekend?

390 replies

SheABitSpicyToday · 22/07/2021 10:30

My best friend is having her hen weekend 8 weeks after I’m due to give birth. Will likely be more as I think I’m being induced early. It’s only 20 minute drive away and am taking my own car so can be home if I need to be or can get taxi.
Husband is actually looking forward to having the weekend to bond with baby by himself. Didn’t think anything was wrong until my sister said it was a disgusting thing to do and that the baby will be traumatised by it. I think she’s being Ott but do you think this is a terrible thing to do?

OP posts:
me4real · 22/07/2021 12:06

YANBU they'll be too young to really know what's going on, and will have their dad.

HavelockVetinari · 22/07/2021 12:05

Oh, and my baby had a mix of expressed milk and milk directly from the breast - no bottle preference at all, in fact he infinitely preferred the breast.

HavelockVetinari · 22/07/2021 12:04

@Ozanj

*This isn't my experience at all. I had to express on one side for about ten days and would do so whilst my baby was feeding on the other. Both boobs would be comfortably drained to the same extent then next feed I'd use the expressed milk. It was always around 90 mls and I've no reason to believe that that wasn't comparable to what he got directly from the breast.*

90mls is oversupply. Most women only express 20ml of milk per feed from both sides - even if baby gets far more than that from the breast they have to work harder for it. Bottle feeding a child 90mls in one go is just asking for them to have a bottle preference. Rubbish advice like this is why I am so glad I paid for professional advice instead of taking anecdotal advice from people on MN.

20ml from each breast?! That's not my experience at all, or my sister's, and neither of us had oversupply or mastitis. I used to get around 90ml at first, raising to 200-300ml per session by 8 weeks (if I missed a feed and needed to express).

20ml would be adequate in the first week maybe, but it goes up dramatically as baby's demands increase, and the extra suckling increases the mother's supply.

wombatspoopcubes · 22/07/2021 12:04

I wouldn't have wanted to. Wait till the baby is here and see how you feel.

ancientgran · 22/07/2021 12:03

Leaving the baby to fend for himself would be a bit harsh, as he's being left with a responsible parent who is looking forward to it I think it is fine. Go and enjoy yourself. I had one of my GC for a few days at this age, mum needed to go to see her mum who was in hospital and then help her get set up at home. The baby was fine.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 22/07/2021 12:03

I agree with cinammonbuns - and also you, OP.

It's not a competition between parents and which one is 'better' or 'more important': you're an equal team. It may be that neither of you want to leave the baby, but it sends dads such mixed messages - which then end up putting a great big long-term burden on mums - if you tell them that, as a dad/man, they aren't competent/suitable/appropriate/trustworthy to look after a child and then later criticise them for assuming looking after the children is the woman's job.

LemonRoses · 22/07/2021 12:03

I'm camp sister. Babies need their mothers and mothers usually need their babies.

eurochick · 22/07/2021 12:02

It's fine if you want to. The baby won't be traumatised!

I did an all day assessment centre for a job when mine was eight weeks. I felt fat and tired and my boobs were leaking. I'm not sure I would have felt up for a weekend partying. I also missed my baby. I think you need to wait to see how you feel. You might just want to go for an afternoon or something.

m0therofdragons · 22/07/2021 12:02

Baby won’t remember and it’s very personal. I wouldn’t have wanted to but wouldn’t criticise others if they did.

MuckyPlucky · 22/07/2021 12:01

Crikey, I’d have LEAPT at the chance to leave my 8week olds with their other parent for a weekend of relaxation, fun, & friends. Seriously, I’d have bitten your hand off for it.

But I know friends who still didn’t feel comfortable going out for a meal without their LO’s until they were 2.5yr old (no judgement here. Well, a bit of judgement Wink).

It’s so individual & can’t be planned before the baby is here as you’ll have no idea how it’s going to pan out until then.

Good luck with it all.

FeltCarrot · 22/07/2021 12:00

How lovely to hear about a new father wanting to spend time alone with his child!

cinammonbuns · 22/07/2021 12:00

@BoxHedge no I don’t really see many obvious reasons except breastfeeding and we have no idea if the OP plans to do so or not.

Anyway OP I have made my position clear but I agree that you should tentatively agree and decide how you feel closer to the time.

HavelockVetinari · 22/07/2021 11:59

Babies are biologically programmed to want their mother - it's a survival instinct. Similarly, mothers often get huge surges of bonding hormones that make the thought of being away from their baby anxiety-inducing.

Everyone is different, baby will likely be fine (albeit unsettled) but you might not feel able to leave the baby for so long. I wouldn't commit to anything definitively.

Ozanj · 22/07/2021 11:59

This isn't my experience at all. I had to express on one side for about ten days and would do so whilst my baby was feeding on the other. Both boobs would be comfortably drained to the same extent then next feed I'd use the expressed milk. It was always around 90 mls and I've no reason to believe that that wasn't comparable to what he got directly from the breast.

90mls is oversupply. Most women only express 20ml of milk per feed from both sides - even if baby gets far more than that from the breast they have to work harder for it. Bottle feeding a child 90mls in one go is just asking for them to have a bottle preference. Rubbish advice like this is why I am so glad I paid for professional advice instead of taking anecdotal advice from people on MN.

Bananas52 · 22/07/2021 11:58

My baby is 11 weeks and I couldn’t imagine leaving her overnight, never mind a weekend. However, I’m exclusively breast feeding and have only recently been separated for 1 hour so I could attend a medical appointment, and I was thinking about her the whole time. That may just be me being super clingy to my baby though!

Somethingsnappy · 22/07/2021 11:57

[quote Ozanj]@NerrSnerr - lactation consultant advice when I was expressing for a baby of a similar age. More than 20ml of expressed has the same effect as formula in stretching stomachs and putting babies off breastfeeding. If you want a baby to comfortably feed across bottle and breast they shouldn’t have more than 20ml from a bottle in one go per feed. You give them a break and top up. So like they would do on the breast if you offered both.[/quote]
This advice is true for a newborn baby in the first few days of life, but by 8 weeks, a baby's stomach has grown a lot and can take anything between 75 and 150ml per feed, on average.

Wineandroses3 · 22/07/2021 11:57

Think your sister was wrong to say it was “disgusting”, it’s your choice but as your asking for opinions - would I leave my 8 week old to go on an overnight Hen party? No I wouldn’t, I think 8 weeks is too young. I can’t make out from what you have said whether it’s an overnight thing or just for the day. Also, it makes a difference if you are breastfeeding or not, I hated having to express milk and found it really uncomfortable so I couldn’t really go anywhere without baby in the first few months, but it didn’t bother me, I loved having a newborn.

Hankunamatata · 22/07/2021 11:57

Ds1 had his first sleepover at nans at 6 weeks. He was combo bottle and breast.

You what feel right for you

3WildOnes · 22/07/2021 11:56

20ml of breastmilk is a tiny amount. I’m pretty sure my babies were drinking over 1000ml of breastmilk a day at that age. That would mean I would have to feed them 50 times a day. I think my babies were drinking closer to 150ml x 8 a day at that age. There were all babies that gained weight very quickly.

BoxHedge · 22/07/2021 11:55

@cinammonbuns

Love how Mumsnet is all for equal parenting for women and men until it’s a situation like this. Yes it is perfectly fine. A man would not think twice about leaving their child with the mother at 8 weeks.
I don’t think many people think mum and dad are interchangeable in the first few months, for many obvious reasons.

It’s the last thing I’d have considered doing with mine due to breastfeeding and being physically exhausted.

If not breastfeeding I still wouldn’t have wanted to, but if you have an easy baby it might be possible, or you could drive back and forth a few times, it’s only 20 minutes away.

(With one of mine I couldn’t have safely driven 20 minutes due to the prolonged sleep deprivation.)

MissingThePoint1 · 22/07/2021 11:52

Totally upto you and how you feel, there's nothing wrong with leaving baby with dad if you're happy to go.

You may not want to though, 2 of my good friends had hen parties soon after I had my babies. I left my first with his dad for the weekend at 10 weeks and felt happy to do so. I didn't feel ready to leave my second at 12 weeks though for another friends hen weekend, he was a difficult baby with reflux and reoccurring choking episodes.

You won't know until baby arrives! I agreed to both, paid and accepted I'd lose my money if I didn't want to go and I explained to them both i wouldn't make my mind up until the week before. Good friends will understand.

Arghlife · 22/07/2021 11:49

Baby won't be traumatised aslong as dad is hands on from birth. However im going to be in the same time frame from when I'm due to give birth till a friend has her hen do and I've already backed out of it. I can't imagine leaving my baby at the age.

Somethingsnappy · 22/07/2021 11:47

@Ozanj

If you express then make sure your DH knows not to feed baby the whole lot in one go. Breastfed babies should take in no more than 20ml of expressed breastmilk per feed.
The baby will be 8 weeks old! They will need rather more than that by then Smile
hawkehurstgang · 22/07/2021 11:47

Also if you're breastfeeding it's literally impossible anyway.

chunderwunder · 22/07/2021 11:47

[quote Ozanj]@NerrSnerr - lactation consultant advice when I was expressing for a baby of a similar age. More than 20ml of expressed has the same effect as formula in stretching stomachs and putting babies off breastfeeding. If you want a baby to comfortably feed across bottle and breast they shouldn’t have more than 20ml from a bottle in one go per feed. You give them a break and top up. So like they would do on the breast if you offered both.[/quote]
This isn't my experience at all. I had to express on one side for about ten days and would do so whilst my baby was feeding on the other. Both boobs would be comfortably drained to the same extent then next feed I'd use the expressed milk. It was always around 90 mls and I've no reason to believe that that wasn't comparable to what he got directly from the breast.

Feeding him from the bottle took about the same time as feeding directly and I can't see any logic whatsoever in the idea that the method of delivery affects whether a stomach is stretched or not.

Sounds like anti bottle feeding nonsense to me but there you go.

OP, having a small baby is the perfect excuse to not have to attend hideous things like hen weekends Grin