Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sad about DC relationship

85 replies

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 22/07/2021 09:16

I'd love some perspective from parents who've had this and people who've been the kids in this station. I have 2 DS and I know deep down they love one another but there is a lot of squabbling, unkind words, particularly from the oldest towards the youngest. There's no sense of 'looking out for his younger brother'. Just dropped them to camp and eldest just walked on ahead of youngest (5) despite a 100m walk in same direction. I don't want to make them feel they must get on but it does make me sad to see that. He does say he feels youngest is preferred, of course that's not the case, but I hear him out and reassure him etc. Has anyone has this and come through? Is the hands off, bar obviously putting in limits with behaviour, the bear approach or should I be more insistent? Feeling a bit despondent this morning, would appreciate opinions and experiences.

OP posts:
tinydancer88 · 22/07/2021 09:44

How old is the oldest one? Is the age gap simply big enough they are at different stages with different interests? Are you possibly expecting too much of him in terms of your ideals of a brotherly relationship? It sounds a bit harsh but the choice to have a sibling was presumably not your oldest son's, so although you might have had a lovely vision of him 'looking out for his little brother' he might not be on the same page!

I'm probably a bit biased because I'm the eldest one who had got very used to being an only child, who then suddenly felt a responsibility pushed upon me to entertain and almost protect a smaller, annoying, occasionally destructive person who took all the fuss and attention away from me Grin

Unkindness is obviously not OK, so that needs to be stamped out firmly if it occurs, but otherwise I think you need to let them both have space and not expect them to be best buddies. They might well be when they're older! Definitely disagree with the concept of always treating the younger one more favourably regardless of circumstance - what a perfect way to make the oldest feel rejected and replaced - but of course there will be a higher standard of behaviour and thoughtfulness expected from the oldest. Younger siblings can be very effective at winding up elder ones to get a response from parents, so that needs to be dealt with properly too.

LordyPie · 22/07/2021 09:42

I think it depends on the age gap whether it's appropriate to always take youngest at their word.

My DSC are 9 & 11 and youngest absolutely does play on the fact that they tend to be believed by their Dad more than the eldest. I've witnessed it with my own eyes. I also hate when DH always uses 'you should know better because you're older' when 9 is also perfectly old enough to know better as well. For example the other day there was a squabble about something or nothing, youngest called eldest a name and eldest said one back but apparently eldest should be the one to know better. I don't agree with that, BOTH are old enough to know better and one shouldn't be punished whilst the other is let off simply because he happens to be 2 years younger. If the age gap was much bigger I could understand.

Things like that do make the eldest feel the least favoured and to be honest, from an outsider's perspective I can see why.

GoWalkabout · 22/07/2021 09:42

I found my two developed codes - yes the eldest often came out on top in brute strength but youngest developed powers of manipulation and persuasion. With disputes I tried to be fair but you don't always see exactly what is happening - don't by default punish eldest because that way low self esteem lies. Do lots of sorting it out together. As they got older if I was unsure if youngest could cope I would ask 'do you need me to step in or can you handle this yourself?' I am sensitive to fighting because of my own childhood experiences and I have to know where the boundary lies. Let your eldest be his own man, your youngest will have to win him over, he's not owed anything.

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 22/07/2021 09:40

Thanks for reassurance TimeforTeaandG! I've read Siblings without Rivalry before and thí K need to root it out again. I feel dh came down too hard on OB in first years, when he was still so young himself, and this has only upped the feeling of being the lesser one.

OP posts:
HeyGirlHeyBoy · 22/07/2021 09:38

Response to ChainJane above. And yes thistimelastweek, that was my point really. It's a hard one.

OP posts:
Dillydollydingdong · 22/07/2021 09:37

It's pretty common for the two to resent each other. The oldest resents the youngest because he feels supplanted. The youngest resents the older one because the older one got here first. I know a pair of twins where the older one resents the younger one (and bullies him). You can't let him get away with it though. Maybe talk to him about it? It's not YB's fault that he's here, and it's not OB's place to punish him. If he does, you will punish OB!

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 22/07/2021 09:36

Yes I have this very much in my mind and I do call it out but I feel it's resulting in your second point exacerbating the first iyswim - he feels more and more the younger is favoured and given the benefit of the doubt while he is come down on... Seems to have only fed into the resentment more if that makes sense.. He is adored and was adored before younger sibling arrived at 3 remembers life 'before' etc. He can see too that youngest is incredibly kind hearted and I think this makes it harder again for him and puts him, in his own head, firmly in the 'worst brother' corner Sad. He even said to him once 'Why are you so kind to me when I'm so mean to you?' Now youngest of course plays his part to, riles him up, and is the initiator of bother plenty. I know though if eldest gave the kindest, he'd respond immediately.

OP posts:
thistimelastweek · 22/07/2021 09:34

Couldn't disagree more with ChainJane. That path leads to real problems.

You can't force them to be pals. The older is not responsible for his brother, that's your job. Stay out of it unless you see overt bad behaviour on either side.

TimeForTeaAndG · 22/07/2021 09:32

What's the age gap? My sister is 5 years younger than me and we haaaated each other. Full on screaming and fighting over who had more space on the couch, get out of my room, you hit me first!

So much better once I'd moved out and we'd both matured. Now we still have moments but basically have a normal relationship.

ChainJane · 22/07/2021 09:29

I think this is more common than you'd think. It's pretty normal for the elder sibling to resent the younger one because they feel the younger one is getting the attention that would be lavished upon them if they were still an only child. This tends to lead to bullying at best and outright abuse at worst.

The best advice is to come down like a ton of bricks every time you see the elder child behaving badly toward the younger one. Take the younger one's word above the elder one's if you are unsure who is to blame in any situation. As with "male privilege" and "white privilege" there is such a thing as "eldest privilege" - the eldest child has inherent advantages in every situation and therefore the younger sibling needs to be treated more favourably simply to be treated equally.

You really need to tackle it head on and call it out every time you see it. Otherwise the elder child will see your inaction as a green light to continue his behaviour.