Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sad about DC relationship

85 replies

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 22/07/2021 09:16

I'd love some perspective from parents who've had this and people who've been the kids in this station. I have 2 DS and I know deep down they love one another but there is a lot of squabbling, unkind words, particularly from the oldest towards the youngest. There's no sense of 'looking out for his younger brother'. Just dropped them to camp and eldest just walked on ahead of youngest (5) despite a 100m walk in same direction. I don't want to make them feel they must get on but it does make me sad to see that. He does say he feels youngest is preferred, of course that's not the case, but I hear him out and reassure him etc. Has anyone has this and come through? Is the hands off, bar obviously putting in limits with behaviour, the bear approach or should I be more insistent? Feeling a bit despondent this morning, would appreciate opinions and experiences.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HeyGirlHeyBoy · 24/07/2021 09:02

No I won't ever force closeness, though of course I hope they would be. Big blow up this morning over who got to pick their TV programme first. Oh for two channels and no choice!! Great day yesterday at least. Feel like I'm fire fighting sometimes but will keep reading book.

OP posts:
LizzieW1969 · 23/07/2021 10:30

This is all very familiar to me. My DDs are 3 years apart in age (12 and 9 now). They’re also adopted and birth siblings; we pushed hard for DD2 to come to live with us, because we thought it would be important to them to be together eventually. DD1 was nearly 4 when DD2 came to live with us at age 1.

It has been very difficult at times, though they do appear to be closer now. DD1 has always been extremely jealous of DD2 and has constantly accused us of only caring for her. This previously had a lot to do with the fact that she was violent towards her (she was violent towards me as well).

In addition, she’s always tried to cling tightly to her, especially at school. She’s always struggled to make friends, due to SEN and attachment issues, and used to try to hang around with DD2 and her friends (which wasn’t appreciated).

Things have improved between them since DD1 moved up to high school. They still have blazing rows at times, but there is nevertheless a strong bond between them now. DD1 still accuses us of favouring DD2 and siding with her (and tbf DD2 is very bright and well capable of being manipulative so I do try to remember that).

It’s a minefield at times, isn’t it? But at the end of the day, you can’t force siblings to be close to each other.

Imissmoominmama · 23/07/2021 09:50

I care for two boys (4&6) and find that the elder can behave in quite a mean way toward the younger.

I present his behaviour back to him factually, and without emotion or judgement- just describing it. He often gets the point immediately (he is intelligent) and takes a different tack. Then I praise him for his kindness and empathy.

It will be different, because I’m removed, being their carer, rather than their mum, but she says she’s noticed a difference in their behaviour.

Merryoldgoat · 23/07/2021 09:39

@slashlover

Mine was 8 years younger so it’s a bit different.

Once she pulled me around to the floor by my hair so hard I got a migraine and vomited.

She still wasn’t reprimanded.

I was being a ‘drama queen’.

I get that rivalry is normal and it’s largely fine if the underlying relationship is healthy.

If it’s not then it needs addressing properly.

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 23/07/2021 08:40

Yes thanks, I do that. Its tricky with the wanting more time, I agree and yet he is naturally spending more time with friends and sports now so there simply isn't the time left in the day sometimes. However I will do best and be mindful of it.

OP posts:
Snog · 23/07/2021 08:38

The oldest probably wants more of your time and attention. If he feels he has this in abundance he is much less likely to feel resentful of his sibling.

I would also be sure to notice and reward when he does something nice with his bro.

Quietcrown · 23/07/2021 08:15

I have a younger brother with a 4 year gap, we never got on as children. The best thing our parents did was let us have our own space and ignore each other. We weren't forced to interact or be nice, we just couldn't be unkind or hurtful.

It got better in our teens and we get on fine as adults. Still not super close but we don't argue or anything.

Insert1x20p · 23/07/2021 08:06

Mine war and have a 22 month gap. Tbh they're just really different people. I think they will get on better when they're older and I intend to send them to different secondary schools to give them a bit of space from the other, especially as they're in consecutive school years so there is friendship group overlap.

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 23/07/2021 08:06

Mm, I don't know but I can't do anything about it anyway! Grin I do think a pp's previous point above re reacting with kindness is an important one and I do try this 9 times out of 10 (and then I'm a dragon the one time!) but DH has no time for this overall, says OB is 'getting away with it' and yet, and I've told him, sometimes the way he speaks to YB reminds me of DH speaks to him when annoyed! I'm going to watch carefully looking at what sets things off and how different handling at the time helps.. Siblings without Rivalry really is good so I've a few chapters reread already. Most of all I don't want him to grow up with resentment or a wedge between him and his brother that is caused by our handling of it now..

OP posts:
TheSockMonster · 23/07/2021 07:56

I wonder if it’s to do with the age gap?

DS and DD are 18 months apart, don’t remember life without each other and are like twins. They are 11 and 12 years old, so still time for it to go horribly wrong I suppose!

DSS was 5 when the oldest was born and adores them both. He said he remembers the odd moment of jealously when they were very small, but it didn’t affect their relationship.

I am 5 years older than my DB and was very protective over him. I used to save up my pocket money to buy him presents and take the blame for things so he wouldn’t get told off!

DH is almost 6-years older than his DSis and he hates her. I’m pretty sure that’s a parenting thing though.

I’ve noticed lots of the warring siblings on this thread have a 3-year age gap.

slashlover · 22/07/2021 23:37

@Merryoldgoat

Ok. I’ll give you an example.

My sister used to goad me quietly. Over and over. Eventually I’d snap. Shout and lose my rag.

Smug gloaty smile which disappeared when mum arrived.

Used to hit herself and get a red mark then tell mum I did it.

I was never taken seriously.

I’m not projecting.

You can leave kids to sort it out if they’re generally close but the fact is yours aren’t and this combative environment will drive them further apart imho.

My sister is 2 years younger and used to do things like that, prod me in the arm over and over until I lost it. We would also just be watching TV and she'd randomly start shouting for me to leaver her alone, I was nowhere near her. I would have sworn blind that she was the favourite and she would have sworn that mum always took my side, looking back it was probably equal though as I also did mean stuff to her. We shared a room and I would tell her there were monsters in the cupboard etc. until my mum or dad had to take her round the whole house to show her there was nothing there. We also used to hit each other and say the most vicious things, we knew exactly what would hurt the most.

Love her to bits now, us moving out and not living together any more was a big help.

EmeraldShamrock · 22/07/2021 23:29

Most siblings grow out of the immature competitive behaviour.
I'm really close with my sisters, i couldn't stick my older Dsis, now we have such a laugh.
I was close to the younger ones, we all had daily squabbles between us.
I have an understanding of how miserable it must have been for DM at times.

SGBK4862 · 22/07/2021 23:26

I am the eldest of 3 and my mother always exhorted me to look after the otger two, especially the youngest who was 5 years my junior. She must have approached it in the right way as I wasn't resentful at all and liked the older sister role. I think it made me into someone who has always coped well with life's problems, but maybe also too self sufficient and unwilling to bare all (or maybe that just my personality).

As an adult I get on well with both siblings though have always been closer to the one 2 years younger as we shared more early experiences. Youngest and I have a lot more on common though.

So it's not always that the eldest is jealous and resentful.

My two are 4 years apart and very different in many ways. They've never consistently got on, but do definitely have a bond. I found that getting them to try to solve their own disputes and backing off where it was safe to do so, was the best way to deal with it. They are jealous of each other, so removing my attention made it easier for them as they didn't view the other as being favoured by my intervention.

TheSockMonster · 22/07/2021 23:03

DH genuinely dislikes his sister. He’s made a few attempts to rekindle the relationship, but a childhood full of the sort of overt favouritism ChainJane describes has doomed it.

My guess would be that your older child does not yet have the skills needed to react correctly to the annoying things younger siblings are wont to do and that this, coupled with a little jealousy and insecurity, are fuelling the problem. My advice would be to model good conflict resolution skills to him. If you react angrily or impatiently to his misdemeanours, the only skills he’ll have to deal with his brother’s annoying behaviours will be anger and impatience. If you can react with kindness and sympathy each time you will be teaching him to do the same.

chunderwunder · 22/07/2021 22:40

Only get involved in a fight between siblings if there's blood or asphyxiation.

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 22/07/2021 22:38

Agree completely Smile Thank you!

OP posts:
Bimblybomeyelash · 22/07/2021 22:23

My two have the same gap and they squabble some of the time and IT DOES MY HEAD IN so I sympathise. I generally find that things are better during holidays as they aren’t as tired and irritable. They have a behaviour chart for the summer and ‘being kind’ is on there as a target! It makes me sad when the eldest is so short tempered, but the youngest can be bloody annoying so I get it! The best thing is to find things to do that they enjoy doing together. Especially if it involves the kids teaming up on the parents! Mine love playing ‘It’ and ‘hide and seek’ and in this hot weather playing with water pistols in the garden - especially when it is ‘everyone get dad’! I try to encourage anything where it is the two of them as a team. Even if it’s silly things like sometimes the eldest getting the youngest to sneak into their room at bedtime to jump on the bed, or steal an extra chocolate from the Christmas tree, all these are little events that bond them and (sorry for the cheesy expression) ‘make memories’.

HeyGirlHeyBoy · 22/07/2021 22:03

My two DSis were as close as you can be in age but had absolutely nothing to do with one another as children and teens but in their 30s became really close through shared time with their children. So I do know it can change too. The feeling you can't leave them for 5 minutes is wearing though.

OP posts:
HeyGirlHeyBoy · 22/07/2021 22:01

Ah thank you so much all. I'm smiling reading these. Fabulous to have the eldest child's view. I do absolutely let him do his own thing etc, he doesn't play with dB outside the house and that's OK etc however I've definitely got into the habit of dismissing the small things and I think acknowledging would mean a lot to him. As it happened it was YB who caused the small bother in the afternoon and OB was very good not to retaliate, except in words but he quickly cooled. At bedtime YB was upset about a match attack he'd lost and OB basically showered him with his... Couldn't believe it and I could see the joy he got from being that person too. He and I had a good chat at bedtime, this has fallen by the wayside as he reads independently now and it used to be a really special time so while I thought I was doing all I could I can see there are some subtle efforts I can make that might help OB.

OP posts:
IWantT0BreakFree · 22/07/2021 21:42

No advice on your specific situation but just wanted to offer a glimmer of hope and tell your that sibling relationships have the potential to completely transform with time.

My DB and I absolutely hated each other growing up. We fought like cat and dog and we couldn't even look at each other without getting the rage. This went on until I left home for uni. As adults we are best friends!! He is my closest friend in the world and we speak or text almost every day. We live quite a distance apart but we've always got plans in the diary to spend a weekend together. He dotes on my kids and I love his wife like a sister.

I would have laughed my arse off if you'd told me all this when I was 15 😂

I'm not saying this will be the case for your kids, but it's proof that it's a possibility. They aren't necessarily destined to have a poor relationship forever.

thewreckingcrew · 22/07/2021 21:33

@ChainJane

I think this is more common than you'd think. It's pretty normal for the elder sibling to resent the younger one because they feel the younger one is getting the attention that would be lavished upon them if they were still an only child. This tends to lead to bullying at best and outright abuse at worst.

The best advice is to come down like a ton of bricks every time you see the elder child behaving badly toward the younger one. Take the younger one's word above the elder one's if you are unsure who is to blame in any situation. As with "male privilege" and "white privilege" there is such a thing as "eldest privilege" - the eldest child has inherent advantages in every situation and therefore the younger sibling needs to be treated more favourably simply to be treated equally.

You really need to tackle it head on and call it out every time you see it. Otherwise the elder child will see your inaction as a green light to continue his behaviour.

I didn't realise my mum was on mumsnet Grin
Theyimplantedapsycho · 22/07/2021 21:32

I'm the eldest of three, 2.5 years between me and my sister. We had a terrible relationship as children and teens. I'm sure I instigated most of the fights. I always had this fear that my parents loved her more. My parents always meticulously treated us fairly, but it was a deep-rooted, almost primordial fear. What I'd say is that your eldest might feel anxious and worried about being second best, even if you are not treating your youngest more favourably in any way. I should also add that I wouldn't have been able to verbalise any of these emotions. I just lashed out, at my sister and my parents. The other thing I'd recommend is asking your eldest how he wants to do things. My parents often made assumptions about how I preferred things (sleeping arrangements on holiday, hobbies etc) and I ended up feeling left out/ othered even though that was the complete opposite of what they had intended. And lots of 1-2-1 time.

EmeraldShamrock · 22/07/2021 21:16

Yes it is pretty normal. The one thing the older brother needs reminding of is always look out for family, have their back.
Give DS1 lots of positive comments, if DS2 isn't sensitive I wouldn't worry so much.
My DC are 12 and 6 they bicker too.
I found taking myself the prize out the way improved their relationship, a tiny bit. Grin

thebookworm1 · 22/07/2021 21:15

You can’t force children to be friends. Sometimes they are just different - I’d suggest allowing the eldest to have his own activities and not expect him to involve the youngest.
My mum grew up an only child and was really disappointed when I wasn’t close to my two younger sisters. We’re all so different - if we were not related, we would never have been friends. Civil and respectful, but not drawn to each other in any way.
I used to really resent being forced to share my hard earnt friend circle with my first sister, as she made no effort to find her own friends and I felt she was a constant spoilsport (I was more of a daredevil)
I use to treasure my time walking to school with the neighbour’s kid and deeply resented being forced to walk with my sister- I couldn’t get away fast enough.
The youngest did seem spoilt to me at the time - younger children often benefit from slightly more lenient parenting, it’s well documented. And small details feel big to a child - shifts in bedtime by age, start age of receiving pocket money etc… even if small feel like a massive deal. Kids remember everything.

There’s also the sense that as the eldest, you had to figure everything out yourself- so why be expected to assist the sibling? They should also figure it out themselves, fend for themselves, walk alone etc

As adults my sisters and I are supportive and respectful of each other. We communicate about life events and exchange gifts for birthdays and Christmas. We don’t choose to phone each other up for chats or share personal info. We’re totally different and that’s ok.

Darbs76 · 22/07/2021 21:04

My Ds (nearly 17) and DD 13 have grown apart and barely speak at all. Not because they have fell out but because they have nothing much in common now. They were so close and it does upset me and their dad. Annoying we have missed out on holidays as that could be a bonding time. We should be going to Florida next week, instead we are home with Covid! Might try and get away in august and hope that helps a bit - though if like last time DS went off and found some friends!