Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think parent groups should be representative of schools ethnicity

35 replies

sportsshop2 · 22/07/2021 08:33

DSs primary school is quite diverse - over 50% but in an area that was very white until recently. 20 parents in year group of 60 have been organizing prom etc and have asked for help but then ignored all offers from anyone not white or possibly even European. As they are on a private facebook group it is not obvious to those individuals who has been included.

The school itself is integrated, kids mixed and staff are great. I would like to raise this to try to improve things for future years. Would HT think it is outside their remit? Would governors help or as it is all volunteers is racism impossible to prevent?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 22/07/2021 14:59

If they have organized something outside of school and are all set I’m not sure why they should accept more people to the group, too many cooks in the kitchen and all that.
If they have asked for volunteers and then only accepted people based on ethnicity obviously that is not on. If they have added people first come first serve or based on what help they were actually offering then fine.

dameofdilemma · 22/07/2021 14:10

I would recommend gathering detailed facts before raising with the school. Any allegation of racism in any environment (work, school, whatever) would require that.
The whole thing could be embarrassing (not to mention offensive) if it turns out to be a misunderstanding.

My experience at dd's school (and I say this as an ethnic minority) echoes others - it's generally a struggle to get volunteers and it tends to be the same people who volunteer over and over. And yes the majority have been white and female.

I would have loved it after the various school fairs if more people volunteered to clear half eaten plates of food off the ground (as some parents couldn't be bothered to use the bins) or wipe tables, clean floors, heave chairs around etc.
It was the same people 3 years in a row volunteering for the worst jobs - only two parents of colour (including me) volunteered. And its a very diverse South London school.
Its not exactly exercising white privilege to volunteer to unblock the toilets.

TotorosCatBus · 22/07/2021 13:54

I agree with the theory that a couple of alpha mums (or class reps) have recruited their friends and told their friends to invite their friends and ignored any interest slips sent in by other mums. My experience of the playground was that people tended to be friends with people from their race so if the mums who started the group were white British then most of the group would be too.

I suspect they thought that if anybody else wanted to join then they'd send a FB message or talk to someone in the group in person so that they could be included.

NailsNeedDoing · 22/07/2021 13:46

It sounds like it’s just an informal group of parents getting together to try and organise something nice for their children and their classmates to celebrate the end of primary school. That’s not the sort of group that should have to think about diversity quotas. If it’s led by the parents, then it has nothing to do with the school, and they shouldn’t be expected to get involved.

234Pepperplant · 22/07/2021 13:43

What help are people offering? A massive group of parents all wanting to “be involved” sounds like a bloody nightmare. Although obviously any “committee” type thing should be organised fairly, if I was doing it (I often seem to end up doing this kind of thing) I know I’d pick the three or four parents I already know, who already do all the boring tedious crap at pta events and I can rely on to get stuff done. They are all with one exception white stay at home mums, because they are the people who have time and offer to do book sale every Wednesday lunchtime, cake sale on Thursday after school, making tea/coffee for six nativity performances, turning up on a rainy Saturday to weed the school garden etc etc. Diversity would be great and I wouldn’t actually turn anyone away, but my priorities would be getting it actually done. I would however absolutely welcome a parent/group of parents, of any colour/background who wanted to actually take on the whole thing, rather than “be involved”. I’d happily hand it over wholesale.

Wanting to “be involved” in my experience often translates as “turn up for one meeting to make the interesting decisions and express opinions about the fun stuff” not “I’m offering to organise the printing and selling of tickets” or “I will keep the accounts and arrange to pay the suppliers” or “I’m offering to make 800 yards of bunting” or “I’ll come and clean up at 11pm after everyone else has gone”. If that sort of help has been turned down I’d be stunned.

onemouseplace · 22/07/2021 13:39

@bobcatbobcat

Definitely worth mentioning to HT?

Have they actually ignored offers of help? If so that's not great at all.

I find in the school I work in that often parents of minority groups don't offer as much and it can be hard to help them to feel included. Equally you cannot make people volunteer for stuff!

This is my experience as well.

It's actually less parents of minority groups, more any parents who aren't middle class, from whatever ethnicity, who are harder to make feel included.

Hereward1332 · 22/07/2021 13:25

Have they not accepted offers from only non-white parents?

mindutopia · 22/07/2021 13:19

I would expect what's happened is that the couple of parents who started this have engaged with only their friends and friends of friends rather than opening it up to all parents (who they don't necessarily know). If the leader or leaders are white, I imagine they probably just have white friends. I know our parent's organisation is very cliquey. They all go out for drinks with each other and meet up. I've never been invited and am never asked directly for help with anything. I'm very middle class and white, btw, but clearly just not one of the gang (which actually is fine by me!).

bunnybuggs · 22/07/2021 12:36

Not racism

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 22/07/2021 12:34

Also have you tried simply messaging the facebook group, saying "hi, I would like to help, my DC is x in class y. Please can you add me on the group?" Keep a record of the message, send a follow up to the organiser on whatsapp too. If you don't get any reply, send a copy of your messages to the school and pta and ask them to investigate why you were ignored

BiBabbles · 22/07/2021 12:30

Was the school organizing the prom (which I still find weird for Y6) and these parents were part of that or was it something they were organizing separately without the school's involvement?

In both cases, letting the headteacher know might be worthwhile, but in the latter, then the school may take a hands' off policy for things that they're not actively involved in. I know at my DDs' school, the school does not get involved in parents facebook or other groups other than their general policy about what can be posted about the school / pupils / staff online that the admins adhere to to prevent some of the chaotic hell last year where some were gunning for everyone.

I agree with others that to volunteer, parents need to do more proactive than tick a box, and many activities this last year haven't been the sort that type of volunteering would involve. I also agree with Blankiefan that it's so hard to get consistent volunteers and those who do may go to those they know because it's pretty common for people to volunteer for the fun party making, but not really stick around when there is a lot more to it that though.

I am a bit surprised by the composition, though that's because at my DD's school, when there was a request for volunteers, every single parent who put their name forward was an immigrant. It still had the same issues Blankie talked about of quick drop off and people being a bit narrow about what they're willing to help with, but - maybe because of the chaos we had last year was well known locally which I think definitely killed some's desire to step forward - it's been even harder to get in British-born parents of any ethnicity at her school. We're hoping the new influx in September might have a few more.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 22/07/2021 12:30

Ignoring offers of help sounds bad.

But it can be really hard increasing diversity on voluntary committees etc. We want to increase diversity on our pta committees but it's hard enough get any volunteers at and harder still be be choosy about their ethnicity

sportsshop2 · 22/07/2021 12:26

mustlove - sounds very relevant. It is a newly formed group to arrange leavers events and year group has over 50% non white British in our specific situation which is what i was discussing.

OP posts:
mustlovegin · 22/07/2021 10:56

It’s American

Then not relevant to the UK and it's apparent the OP is talking about a school in the UK.

white parents take over the PTA and exert their influence on multi ethnic schools

The proportion of different ethnicities can differ by area, by school and by year. So it's inappropriate to say that anyone is 'taking over' without understanding the details in each specific situation, and also unhelpful to make accusations without taking all of this into account and understand how make ups of these groups may have evolved over the years also

Angelica789 · 22/07/2021 10:48

There’s an interesting podcast called Nice White Parents which discusses some of the issues raised when white parents take over the PTA and exert their influence on multi ethnic schools. It’s American but very thought provoking.

Hont1986 · 22/07/2021 10:30

I think unless you know that they are actually excluding non-white parents I would not make any accusations. Most likely explanation is that there are a few type-A parents pushing the whole thing and they include other parents they know from their circle, and people's circles often happen to be largely their own race.

sportsshop2 · 22/07/2021 10:25

This is a facebook group specifically to organize events for year 6 leavers it is nothing to do with school fund raising hence nearly all the parents wanting to be involved to cheer up the kids after the last 18 months. I agree with PTA fund raising there is always the opportunity to do another event but this all needs to be coordinated and is for whole year group.

OP posts:
Hoppinggreen · 22/07/2021 10:19

If they were ignoring offers of help then that’s completely wrong BUT in a lot of cases you just need to take whatever volunteers you can get.
I used to be involved with The PTA at the DCs Primary school and we were always short of volunteers anyone and everybody was more than welcome.
Despite the school being mixed it was usually white women who were helping. There was an Indian lady who came once but was never seen again and another lady who I think was of Pakistani origin who used to bake for events.
When I resigned as Chair though a Romanian man took over though

mustlovegin · 22/07/2021 10:12

have been organizing prom

Also, could you clarify whether this could be a long-standing ad hoc 'unofficial' group that could have been formed to organise events for that particular year (which may perhaps be in line with the proportions which could be different for that year - as you say that the school changed recently) or is it the aim to cover the whole school?

MissyB1 · 22/07/2021 10:09

I wouldn't assume this is deliberate exclusion, it could be more about how people offer their help. But also what's to stop non white parents organising something? Rather than waiting to be asked? My experience of schools (as a parent and member of staff) is that its always the same parents who have to organise everything - and other parents are happy to let them.

Dishwashersaurous · 22/07/2021 10:02

I wonder if this is about perceptions. If some parents think that they will be asked to help if they have indicated that they would. Whereas at pretty much all pta things the expectation is that people will actively put themselves forward to help if they want to do so.

EmeraldShamrock · 22/07/2021 09:52

People who want to get properly involved in organising events etc need to actively offer help, not just wait to be contacted.
100%.

NailsNeedDoing · 22/07/2021 09:45

If all the people you are worried about have done is tick a box, they aren’t really going out of their way to give offers of help that have been turned down like you made it sound in your OP.

There haven’t been many events that parent helpers could get involved with helping at with covid restrictions for the last year, and ime, thats the sort of thing that the box tick on the form is for. People who want to get properly involved in organising events etc need to actively offer help, not just wait to be contacted.

EmeraldShamrock · 22/07/2021 09:40

Hmm not sure. I have ticked the box every school years and have never been asked.
I am white, my DC school is very diverse the committee is mostly white though DM's from different cultures help with the bake sale and different events.
I'd speak to the FB administrator for details first.

mustlovegin · 22/07/2021 09:31

The OP and the responses are slightly ambiguous.

OP, are you concerned about the fact that the proportions are off in relation to that specific school or that the group should be per se more diverse (in which case I see where Blankiefan is coming from)

Swipe left for the next trending thread