Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think son could have spent £7.50 on me?

289 replies

Whyamivirtuallyinvisible · 22/07/2021 07:35

My son has just started work, admittedly it isn't the greatest wage, however he's been very lucky to get a job as an apprentice p,umber on 15K. He gets picked up every day so won't need fuel for his car at all during the working week. Incidentallly we bought the car, insured it for him for the first year and husband also gave him half towards his first big repair bill which cost us £200.

Times have been extremely tough financially the last few years, made worse by Covid, like many people. Our DD dances to a very high standard and it goes without saying that this costs an awful lot of money, but we manage somehow like no fancy expenditures and no holidays for the last five years. I've recently had an ankle op so I've also lost money from work.

About two months ago my son had desperately needed new clothes. Smart for interviews and some casual which had cost around £180/200 which we had paid for. He has had part time jobs but nothing since January due to Covid and then studying for A Levels

Last Saturday I'd gone into town with him, my first venture on crutches and he was going to buy himself a few things to wear with his first salary. He'd probably spent around £70 on himself before we decided to head for lunch and a rest as I was shattered. Without thinking I said I'd buy lunch. Force of habit really as not used to him working. However when we had almost arrived at the food place he remembered they only took cash. I waited outside for him as he needed to walk further up the road to withdraw cash. I gave him my card and PIN number and even as he walked away I honestly thought he'd come back and say he was treating me out of his first wage packet.

We ordered food and sat down and he told me he'd taken £20 out of my account. I think mine was £7.50 as I'd ordered small but his was more, possibly £9/10. He put the change on the table and then in his pocket as I had no bag or pockets. He kept the change but I am sure he'd just forgotten about it and I wasn't going to ask for £2 back.

Being honest I felt really hurt and ashamed to admit I shed a tear (pathetic I know) as it made me feel kind of crap. I've always felt guilty about DD's dancing as she has had more spent on her but that isn't my fault. I've tried to make it up to him in other ways and the year before I'd bought him an off-road bike £1000 and £500 worth of clothing, boots, helmet etc. It's not even the money, it's the gesture and I think it felt worse because I'd stood in the street on crutches whilst he'd gone to withdraw money from my own account. Even if he'd said 'Do you mind if we have a packet of sandwiches each, I'll treat you' that would have felt better.

AIBU to think this was a bit mean after 18 years of trying to always give him what we could afford or was it my fault for inadvertently saying I'd pay.

OP posts:
BikeRunSki · 22/07/2021 07:57

He’s not old enough, socially experienced enough or used to having an income for it to have occurred to him to pay, particularly as you said you’d pay.

Greenhillfaraway · 22/07/2021 07:57

YABU although your health and tiredness may have made you more emotional.

This sentence stood out for me: I've always felt guilty about DD's dancing as she has had more spent on her but that isn't my fault. You’re one of her parents so while you might not be the driving force, you’re certainly complicit in facilitating this by restricting common family practices to pay for it.

ikeepseeingit · 22/07/2021 07:57

It’s probably stress getting to you OP, he’s only 18 and you told him you would pay. Next time say he can pay, and you can swap paying like adults. My mum still tries to pay for me and I’m 23 with a house! In fact, I lost the last battle of ice cream payment with my dad because he was so insistent Grin. They’re not rich, none of us are. But I offer and always get refused. I would be quite stressed if I thought that their offer wasn’t genuine and I’ve been offending them all of these years! At 18 I wouldn’t have thought to insist, I would have thought insisting with my mum was rude tbh. Just let him know you’d like him to pay next time and that you can swap each time you go out.

daisypond · 22/07/2021 07:56

Five years without a holiday purely because you need to pay for your daughter’s dancing lessons is a long time. Did the DC know this was the reason you didn’t have holidays? How old is your daughter? What sort of dancing does she do?

SushiGo · 22/07/2021 07:55

No.

You are being very unfair. You told him you would pay but were expecting him to know to offer. He's not a mindreader. If you want to set up that kind of social expectation you must actually say it out loud to him. He's still young and isn't going to learn these kinds of social rules unless you teach them.

Equally, he probably doesn't know the ins and outs of your finances, and it's unfair of you to expect him to subsidise you because you are funding his sisters dancing. He has already lost out on other experiences he might have had over the last few years because of that and is used to being 'compensated' by you buying him stuff.

You have a whole new dynamic to work out.

Lokdok · 22/07/2021 07:55

What? You said you’d pay so he assumed you’d pay. Not sure why you’d cry about that.

Youdiditanyway · 22/07/2021 07:54

YABU because you offered. It would have been nice of him to think to argue against it but he’s young and I know at that age it wouldn’t have entered my mind to either.

stellaisabella · 22/07/2021 07:54

@MiddleParking

I've always felt guilty about DD's dancing as she has had more spent on her but that isn't my fault.

In what way could that possibly not be your fault?

This. You have chosen to pay for her to continue an overly expensive hobby, and your ds has lost out on family holidays and hasn't had the same spent on him. They've been treated completely differently. She never should have had so much spent on her if you couldn't afford to do the same for your son. It's a bit unbelievable after all that, that you're complaining about £7.50.
SnarkyBag · 22/07/2021 07:53

You offered to pay so YABU to be shedding tears over it.

Bluntness100 · 22/07/2021 07:53

@MiddleParking

I've always felt guilty about DD's dancing as she has had more spent on her but that isn't my fault.

In what way could that possibly not be your fault?

Yes I’m curious about this too.
riotlady · 22/07/2021 07:52

YABU, you offered and it’s not going to occur to an 18 year old to argue

FatOaf · 22/07/2021 07:51

You might be underestimating how long it takes for the relationship between parent and child to change as the child moves towards independence. It is quite a big step from being someone who parents provide for to someone who makes a contribution. My youngest finds this very difficult and I often have to tell her - in as casual a manner as possible - "As I paid for xyz, you can buy me a sandwich for lunch."

Ughmaybenot · 22/07/2021 07:51

YABU. You offered. The way you keep track of what was spent on him and when is very weird, he’s your son!

bongbigboobingbongbing · 22/07/2021 07:51

Honestly I find it quite weird to list out all the things you've paid for for your children. That's what having children means, surely? Most parents spend lots of money on their kids. Appreciate times have been tough and you are probably feeling a bit sensitive at the moment. I think YABU to offer to pay for lunch then be upset when he takes you up on it. Next time just say "would you like to treat me now you're working?". It probably just didn't occur to him. Don't set imaginary tests then get upset when he doesn't "pass" them.

NoraButty · 22/07/2021 07:51

If he’s anything like my son when he first started earning it likely just did not occur to him to pay. Not because of meanness or malice or anything like that but because he was used to me, mum, taking the lead or the responsibility for things like that. It’s like auto pilot.

Cattitudes · 22/07/2021 07:50

I think it takes a while for the dynamic to change to be honest. Does he use his own money for presents etc? Maybe start with suggesting that you would like to be treated to coffee out for your birthday so he starts to think about food out being swapped around, or don't jump in and say you would buy him lunch, suggest that you split it. I don't think he can be expected to know that you saying you would buy lunch would mean he should buy you lunch. If a friend said to you that they would buy you lunch you might possibly suggest that you split it but it would be fairly rude to say no I am buying you lunch, unless you generally take turns and you have remembered it is your turn.

I would try to focus away from that incident and think more about how you might encourage him to find a good balance of generosity and money management. Although I paid rent at that stage it was quite a long time before I would buy my parents a meal because they had more disposable income than I did.

Sleepinghyena · 22/07/2021 07:50

Yabu. You offered to pay. And if he took the change because you had no pockets, then you could have asked for it back.
It sounds like you have spent a lot more on your daughter's dancing than on equivalent for him. You are very defensive about this :"It's not my fault "
Well, yes, it is your fault if you haven't treated your children equally. You mention you have had no holidays for the last 5 years because of paying for dancing. Well, as the is now 18, that would be his teenage years with no holiday when you admit there could have been if it wasn't for DD's dancing,
I would imagine he he keenly aware of the financial inequalities in your spending on DC. And yet you are tearful because he didn't buy the lunch that you offered to pay for?
Be honest, is there a definite golden child in your family??

daisypond · 22/07/2021 07:50

You said you’d pay. I wouldn’t expect my 18-year-old child to treat me with their first pay check or to buy me a meal. That’s just miserly. Obviously, it sounds that money is tight all round, so that might skew things for you.

NoNobramma · 22/07/2021 07:50

It’s not you. Or him really. It’s teenagers and boys in particular.
But you could have a chat with him and suggest gently that it would have been nice for him to offer to pay. And talk to him about your daughters dancing to see how he feel about that too? My four children have had vastly different amounts spent on them - I’d never try to be equal in amounts- only in fairness. What they needed they got. What they wanted we always considered and they often got too. But did they get the same £x spent from age 0-18? Ridiculous! No.

MiddleParking · 22/07/2021 07:49

I've always felt guilty about DD's dancing as she has had more spent on her but that isn't my fault.

In what way could that possibly not be your fault?

Willwebebuyingnumber11 · 22/07/2021 07:49

He’s on a low wage and hasn’t had a holiday in 5 years because you’ve chosen to use the family money and his sisters dancing.
YABU to begrudge buying him lunch. If you didn’t want to then you shouldn’t of offered.

Whinge · 22/07/2021 07:48

I think YABU to expect him to pay when you've already said you would. He's not a mind reader.

I also think the money spent trying to compensate for DDs hobby shouldn't be a factor. Buying the car, bike, clothes was your choice, and shouldn't have any bearing on how he spends his money.

TheOnlyLivingBoyInNewCross · 22/07/2021 07:47

You’ve carefully listed all the money you’ve spent on him as if you’re keeping score. If you wrote a similar list for how much you’ve spent on your DD, what would that look like? And presumably the no fancy holidays because of her dancing meant no fancy holidays for your DS growing up either, so you can pay for a hobby that’s not his and he gets no benefit from?

If I’ve read the post right, your DS is 18 and has just left school and was out spending money from his first wage packet? I’m not surprised it didn’t occur to him to pay, tbh. They’re very used to mum and dad picking up the bills at that age - force of habit as you say yourself. And you said you would buy lunch as well and gave him your bank card to get cash out! - he probably didn’t think it through any further than that. I’d have probably made a light joke of it - next time, lunch is on you, mate, now you’re earning!

I think the fact that you’re recovering from your op is perhaps making you feel a bit vulnerable and low, but I don’t think your DS has done much wrong here.

Jumpingintosummer · 22/07/2021 07:47

You offered, he accepted. If you hadn’t wanted to pay you shouldn’t have suggested it really.

ForeverSinging · 22/07/2021 07:46

18 year olds don't necessarily think like that. He's used to being paid for by his parents for necessities, it's how it's always been.

You also said you'd pay so unless you want him to read minds and start playing games with you where you don't say what you actually mean and then say you're hurt, yabu.

Swipe left for the next trending thread