Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think son could have spent £7.50 on me?

289 replies

Whyamivirtuallyinvisible · 22/07/2021 07:35

My son has just started work, admittedly it isn't the greatest wage, however he's been very lucky to get a job as an apprentice p,umber on 15K. He gets picked up every day so won't need fuel for his car at all during the working week. Incidentallly we bought the car, insured it for him for the first year and husband also gave him half towards his first big repair bill which cost us £200.

Times have been extremely tough financially the last few years, made worse by Covid, like many people. Our DD dances to a very high standard and it goes without saying that this costs an awful lot of money, but we manage somehow like no fancy expenditures and no holidays for the last five years. I've recently had an ankle op so I've also lost money from work.

About two months ago my son had desperately needed new clothes. Smart for interviews and some casual which had cost around £180/200 which we had paid for. He has had part time jobs but nothing since January due to Covid and then studying for A Levels

Last Saturday I'd gone into town with him, my first venture on crutches and he was going to buy himself a few things to wear with his first salary. He'd probably spent around £70 on himself before we decided to head for lunch and a rest as I was shattered. Without thinking I said I'd buy lunch. Force of habit really as not used to him working. However when we had almost arrived at the food place he remembered they only took cash. I waited outside for him as he needed to walk further up the road to withdraw cash. I gave him my card and PIN number and even as he walked away I honestly thought he'd come back and say he was treating me out of his first wage packet.

We ordered food and sat down and he told me he'd taken £20 out of my account. I think mine was £7.50 as I'd ordered small but his was more, possibly £9/10. He put the change on the table and then in his pocket as I had no bag or pockets. He kept the change but I am sure he'd just forgotten about it and I wasn't going to ask for £2 back.

Being honest I felt really hurt and ashamed to admit I shed a tear (pathetic I know) as it made me feel kind of crap. I've always felt guilty about DD's dancing as she has had more spent on her but that isn't my fault. I've tried to make it up to him in other ways and the year before I'd bought him an off-road bike £1000 and £500 worth of clothing, boots, helmet etc. It's not even the money, it's the gesture and I think it felt worse because I'd stood in the street on crutches whilst he'd gone to withdraw money from my own account. Even if he'd said 'Do you mind if we have a packet of sandwiches each, I'll treat you' that would have felt better.

AIBU to think this was a bit mean after 18 years of trying to always give him what we could afford or was it my fault for inadvertently saying I'd pay.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Eveningtwilight · 23/07/2021 09:57

Grabby not granny

Eveningtwilight · 23/07/2021 09:57

My mother in law tried to engrain in DH that he owes her because she raised him - and she did a lot less for him than for example my mother did for me.

I have managed to stop that way of thinking cos it’s shit and can mutate into granny (again like my MIL). Don’t put him through that emotional garbage.

Porcupineintherough · 23/07/2021 09:27

@daisypond

There are specialist schools for talented dancers. You shouldn’t have to pay much at all/anything if you are on a low income. Don’t pay more than you can afford on one child’s hobby.
Yes, there's one in every town and village. And for all styles of dancing.

Dance is like music. You dont get far unless your parents can pay.

Wheresthebeach · 23/07/2021 09:24

What strikes me is you not taking responsibility for your actions or words.

The money on your DD's dancing 'isn't your fault'.

You said you'd pay but claim it was 'inadvertently' and then get the hump when you're expected to pay and then get emotional and teary.

You are choosing to spend the money on your DD, and you said you'd pay.

Now you're getting arsy when people are frustrated and confused that you've not been back to the thread you started 12 pages in with the passive aggressive 'not glued to MN'.

Gah.

daisypond · 22/07/2021 21:04

There are specialist schools for talented dancers. You shouldn’t have to pay much at all/anything if you are on a low income. Don’t pay more than you can afford on one child’s hobby.

Sunflowers095 · 22/07/2021 18:46

It doesn't matter how much you spent on him - you've brought him into this world and he doesn't owe you anything. Your children, regardless of age, don't really owe you anything just because you did what a parent should do (provide for them).

YABU to be upset and YABU to spend so much on a hobby for your daughter if it really leaves you that tight for money. How old is she? Can she not get a job?

hulahooper2 · 22/07/2021 18:18

It would have been a nice gesture , but I would’ve joked with mine about them treating me , they’d offer ,then I’d insist on paying

RightYesButNo · 22/07/2021 17:09

To be fair, I thought about it (after I thought the card thing was a bit odd), said I wasn’t calling you a troll, and I meant that, and just pointed out that people shouldn’t risk their emotional well-being more than they felt was wise, especially when a thread is 300 posts deep and the OP hasn’t been seen. The problem is, when you post a thread and then just leave it and very huffily say upon return, “Well, I’m not glued to Mumsnet,” fair enough, but how can you possibly read all 280 answers to your thread? If you’re going to spend an hour or so (or two) reading them all, good on you, but otherwise, I don’t think it’s unfair to say people who put a lot of emotions in their posts may still have it lost in the shuffle.

Whyamivirtuallyinvisible · 22/07/2021 16:36

Rule number 1

If you think I'm a troll then don't bother replying. Go and do something more useful with your time! I have actually just been picked up by DH from work.

Yes I will respond but that will not be until much later. Apologies if my not being glued to MN 24/7 makes me a troll.

OP posts:
KentuckyCriedFricken · 22/07/2021 15:09

Did he drive you there? Who paid the petrol and parking? If you’re going to split hairs over the cost of a sandwich then you need to look at other things in the same light too. He got you out of the house got the first time in days/weeks. Yes he’s cost you money over the years but that’s what parenthood is. Has he not given you joy over those 18 years?

You want to hope that when you’re old and frail and need his help with household chores, shopping, etc that he doesn’t keep a mental tally of all the hours and money he spens on you then.

Martyitsyourkids · 22/07/2021 14:56

You told him you'd pay for lunch.

Anonymous48 · 22/07/2021 14:47

You are being incredibly unreasonable. You said you would pay for lunch for your 18 year old son and then cried when he took you up on it? Get a grip!

RightYesButNo · 22/07/2021 14:39

I’m not saying OP is a troll.

I’m simply saying to bear in mind this is her first post on the site, it’s FULL of things that hit emotional triggers (favoring one child, emotional manipulation, passive aggression, unnecessary pathos in storytelling like the crutches, spending all the family money on something unnecessary and to the detriment of only one child) and so far the OP has not returned to the thread.

MNHQ always tells us not to give more than we’re comfortable with and that means emotionally, too. Some people have written wonderful, top-notch posts (@OldTurtleNewShell , @AudacityBaby , many more) trying to stop OP from ruining her relationship with her son. So just please think about how you’d feel if OP never read them, and don’t spend your emotions if it’s hard on you, or maybe until OP returns to the thread (after these first 300 comments).

pinkyredrose · 22/07/2021 14:24

Tbh i think it's rather appalling that you haven't had a family holiday for 5 years to fund your daughters dancing. Is she the next Darcy Bussell?

pinkyredrose · 22/07/2021 14:22

I've always felt guilty about DD's dancing as she has had more spent on her but that isn't my fault

Hmm Seriously? Why does her dancing cost you so much? Can she get a job?

Porcupineintherough · 22/07/2021 14:02

I think I was closer to 30 before I started insisting on treating my parents. Partly through habit but partly because it took me until my first mortgage to realise the difference bw income (I knew they earnt far more than me) and disposable income .

OnGoldenPond · 22/07/2021 13:54

DD never offers to pay for lunch and I wouldn't accept it if she did. She is a student and can't get a part time job in term time as her course requires attendance 6 days a week 9am to 5pm. However, she sends back the monthly money we send her to top up her minimum maintenance grant as she says she has enough saved from her holiday jobs so I don't think she is a freeloader or entitled. It's just that lunch has always been Mum's treat and we then don't need to be too worried about eating in a slightly more expensive place.

Blossomtoes · 22/07/2021 13:37

@Bluntness100

I’d not expect my daughter to by me lunch no, certainly not on that low salary and I don’t think she owes me because I raised her either.
Really? I went out with my son last week. I bought the train and exhibition tickets, I thought the least he could do was pay for lunch.
AudacityBaby · 22/07/2021 13:33

[quote WalkingOnTheCracks]@OldTurtleNewShell

It was only as an adult that I realised that there's this whole set of unwritten rules that differ completely from person to person, and you're supposed to be second-guessing all the time and working out what they really mean and if you get it wrong, they'll be offended because they expect you to do the opposite of what they've said they want.

In fact, it's even more complex and manipulative than that. I think that quite often the person doing it isn't really sure themselves what they want, so they're leaving all the options open until after it happens, and then they can see whether they like it.

So, "Do A."

You do A.

"No, no - obviously anyone with any sensitivity would realise that whatever I said, what I meant was 'do B'. You're such a cloddish arsehole."

As opposed to...

"Do A."

I do B, on account of trying to avoid being a cloddish arsehole.

"Why did you do B? I mean, when I specifically told you to do A?Obviously you don't actually care at all what I want. You're a selfish prick."

If people don't say what they mean, they're not only stripping all usefulness from language they're also giving themselves plenty of ammunition to use later against the bewildered and defenceless.[/quote]
Fantastic post.

I grew up with this, and it's taken me a long long time to unlearn it as a behaviour in myself, too. It's absolutely horrible to be around.

Gilead · 22/07/2021 13:28

You did exactly what my mum used to do, setting him up to fail. You said you would pay, he took it that you meant it. If you wanted him to pay you should have said something along the lines of , come on, treat Mum from your first pay packet, but you didn’t and now you being sulky about it. Unless he’s a mind reader, accept that you made a mistake and move on.
If this is really harsh, apologies, my mum is a cow and that’s the nicest thing I can think of to say about her.

TheSoapyFrog · 22/07/2021 13:27

YABU. You said you would pay.
I remember when I was younger and started earning money, I never thought to offer because I was so used to my parents paying for me and it was sort of a habit! They did eventually talk to me about it one day though and things changed.

AudacityBaby · 22/07/2021 13:25

Speaking as someone who actually has cut contact with their parents, couple of things I'd encourage you to think about.

Don't set secret emotional tests for your children and then get upset when they're not met, and then tell them how upset you are. My mum did this persistently throughout my teenage years and well into adulthood, and it massively affects your ability to trust that other people mean what they say. This is particularly important for a young man who in time is likely to want to settle down with a woman, and may struggle if he's learned to expect dishonest communication with women.

Don't do the thing where you expect to be paid back for raising your children. "I didn't ask to be born!" is often derided as hysteria, but it's absolutely true. You had children because you wanted children. Raising them (including the financial responsibility) is not a favour to them. It is you discharging the duty that you signed up for. It's absolutely lovely to have grateful children who show their love and appreciation via gifts/treats/lunches out etc. but we know when you expect it - and gratitude won't be genuine if you've made it clear that it's required in a certain form.

Be less passive. If you want something, ask for it (except gratitude - you can't demand someone be grateful to you and if you do, chances are they won't anyway)! If you don't want to pay for your DD's dancing, then say so! Life is much better when you take ownership of your choices, needs and wants - and when you communicate those clearly and respectfully to others. Passivity encourages people to think that they don't have control over things, which leads to resentment of the people who seem to exist only to burden them. When, in fact, the better approach is to be clear about your expectations and don't do things you don't want to do.

catfunk · 22/07/2021 13:20

He's a teenager so probably a bit thoughtless, you said you'd pay, send him off with your card and then cried because he did what you told him to do?

PrinnyPree · 22/07/2021 12:49

Sorry OP he's 18 and you offered to buy him lunch. He's not mature enough with money to be arguing about who's turn it is, as others have said until he is actually properly responsible for his own bills and out goings he won't "get it" and he's still a teenager so is still riding that mother and child dynamic where of course his Mum buys him lunch and he hasn't developed the intuition to offer.

I totally understand why you are disappointed though, he's just immature and thats not really his fault. X

gogohm · 22/07/2021 12:27

I generally pay for my young adult DD's but Dd2 does occasionally bug a round of drinks. My parents don't let me pay when out with them!