Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this man stingy?

62 replies

oreo2020 · 21/07/2021 21:03

Asking for a friend.

She has been exclusively dating this man for nearly a year.

He got ill with Covid but his business is still running so he asked my friend if she could get some supplies for him from a supermarket. She of course was happy to help out.

She then drove to a specific supermarket and then to him to deliver the supplies to his front door. The receipt came up to £43.90. He transferred her exactly that.

I cannot helped thinking that for all the mileage she's done (15 miles altogether perhaps?) he should have at least rounded up to £45. Or £44. Or offer to cover the fuel. I don't know. It seems stingy to me.

If they go out they normally split the bill or alternate paying.. he always seemed calculated, but fair... On this occasion I think it's a bit of red flag which I pointed out my friend.

What do you guys think?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Nietzschethehiker · 22/07/2021 15:53

My DF is like this. In fact financially he is incredibly generous (I mean there is a lot of other issues but financially ). He is incredibly literal. He would have less than no issue if you said it cost me 48.50 (or whatever) for the food and 11.20 for the petrol. That is exactly what he would transfer. My DM would round it up. Df would not begrudge the money at all but his brain works on specifics. It doesn't matter if you asked him for 55.60 or 5000.60 , he would transfer you exactly that.

Definitely not necessarily a red flag at all.

If I'm honest I've fallen into the same trap if I'm busy with other things. DP will say he needs something for 8 pounds. I will happily tell him to take my card and go and spend what he needs and I would not care in the slightest how much but if he asks me to transfer and I'm busy or working it will stick in my brain the amount and I will transfer him exactly that. He knows I would give him every penny I had (excepting if DC needed it ) if he needed it but my brain doesn't work with implied things if I don't really concentrate and analyse it.

NatSab · 22/07/2021 15:47

Seems an odd thing for you to be worried about! He gave her what she spent.. totally normal!

SpeckledlyHen · 22/07/2021 15:39

@19lottie82

DH and went out buying teachers gifts today and the shop was having trouble with my Amex card so DH paid and I said I would transfer the amount to him when ^we got back.

It came to £22:95 but he said just give us
£20.

See, I think this is really bizarre! There’s no way I would bother asking for £20 back from my DH and vice versa 😕

I think this is bizarre also.
Flowers500 · 22/07/2021 15:37

WTF how is this a red flag? Also he probably paid from a business account??? I'd pay the exact amount, then get them a drink or something for thanks later on. But I'd find it patronising if my BF tried to give me a tip when I'm not his employee????

Direstraitsmates · 22/07/2021 15:17

It is fine. I think it is stranger waiting for your petrol money for doing your partner a favour.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 22/07/2021 15:14

@Bluntness100

Why are you so heavily involved in her relationship? That’s the bigger issue.
"friend" 😏
Skiptheheartsandflowers · 22/07/2021 15:13

The easiest and most sensible thing given that he's got Covid would be to book a supermarket delivery of the things he needed, distanced to not expose the delivery driver to risk. Of course then he'd have to pay a delivery charge, say £3-4 ish, on top. Wonder why he didn't do that?

RandomLondoner · 22/07/2021 15:12

The idea of rounding up to the nearest whole number only makes sense for cash payments. The people who would transfer £1 instead £0.99 are using their cash-based custom in a context where it no longer serves any purpose.

RandomLondoner · 22/07/2021 15:06

I cannot helped thinking that for all the mileage she's done (15 miles altogether perhaps?) he should have at least rounded up to £45. Or £44. Or offer to cover the fuel. I don't know. It seems stingy to me.

I completely disagree.

Firstly, if he's only reimbursing for groceries, the only reason for rounding up to give an extra 50p or £1.50 would be if paying with cash and neither recipient nor receiver can be arsed with calculating and finding small change. If he's paying by transfer, then there's no reason to type in anything other than the amount owed.

If he is going to give her extra money, then the amount needs to be something like ten pounds or more. Giving her 50p or £1.50 would be hugely insulting.

Calculating what to give someone (if you feel you should give something) is difficult, possibly even stressful. It would be very easy to give double or half what they think is reasonable. In a relationship it makes much more sense to just mentally owe them a favour.

I wouldn't give or expect money (other than the exact amount owed) in this scenario.

Tiredandstressedworker · 22/07/2021 14:55

I would be more worried if he didn't transfer any money at all to her.

arethereanyleftatall · 22/07/2021 14:53

I've just seen it was for his business!! Of course he transferred exactly the right amount!! You were totally wrong to say it's a red flag (and may need to up the quality of your chats with your friend).

Bluntness100 · 22/07/2021 14:51

Why are you so heavily involved in her relationship? That’s the bigger issue.

arethereanyleftatall · 22/07/2021 14:48

If I'd been with someone for a year, I wouldn't charge them for this, I'd just do it.

And, if they wanted to pay me paid me the exact amount, I wouldn't even think about it.

So, what's stingy for me here, is your friend. For giving this a second thought, and for complaining To a friend about it.

19lottie82 · 22/07/2021 14:34

DH and went out buying teachers gifts today and the shop was having trouble with my Amex card so DH paid and I said
I would transfer the amount to him when
^we got back.

It came to £22:95 but he said just give us
£20.

See, I think this is really bizarre! There’s no way I would bother asking for £20 back from my DH and vice versa 😕

Zorinindustries · 21/07/2021 23:36

If he would have rounded up to £44 as you suggest, OP, that would have been so so so patronising.
It would be almost understandable for cash, but to deliberately pay 10p extra on online banking would have felt like he was tipping a paperboy in the 1950s (here, lad, have 10p for your troubles. pat on the head )

gamerchick · 21/07/2021 23:26

Loving the posts saying it's ok. Grin

As a pp said. She needs to ask him, if the situation was reversed, would he charge her for fuel. Since that's how his brain works.

Freddiefox · 21/07/2021 23:25

@GrandDuchessRomanov

Yeah it's stingy.

DH and went out buying teachers gifts today and the shop was having trouble with my Amex card so DH paid and I said I would transfer the amount to him when we got back.

It came to £22:95 but he said just give us £20.

This is not an example of being generous. He’s your husband. They are his children’s teachers. He should not have asked for the money.
Travielkapelka · 21/07/2021 23:19

It sounds completely normal and not remotely red flag. I would never expect my partner to pay me mileage, that’s just weird. Today I got my DP something he asked for which was £29. It’s not something I particularly want to pay for so I’ll ask him to transfer me, erm £29 and he’ll transfer me £29, not £30 and not an extra fiver for my effort

Ughmaybenot · 21/07/2021 23:11

@m00rfarm

if it was paid from the company account then he would have to transfer exactly what was on the receipt. what is the issue?
This.
Saidtoomuch · 21/07/2021 23:07

I think it would have been weird to charge him mileage. He probably assumed she was getting a few bit and bobs for herself whilst she was there. She told him what it cost and he transferred it. Now I always tip the takeaway driver a couple of £, but it would feel a bit odd to tip a partner?

Sandinmyknickers · 21/07/2021 23:01

If your friend wanted a contribution to mileage she could have asked (doesn't have to be awkward, just a heads up that she's out of pocket). I don't think you can blame someone for not doing exactly what you'd do and then not being a mind reader.
I round up when I owe people money, but also I wouldn't expect my boyfriend to pay for my time of doing him a favour. I'm sure he would do me one back when the situation arises
(Havibg said that, we clearly live in very different places as I live in a city and can't fathom how a round trip to a supermarket would be 15miles and am not even sure what petrol cost that would be. I always offer to pay petrol on the odd occasion a friend will drive us somewhere, but I am dependent on them telling me how much that is as I have no clue as I rarely drive. Your friend should have just specified how much he owed her but she chose to only specify the shop cost. She could have said something like "it came to 43.90 and probably about and extra fiver in petrol..so around 48 quid"

NewlyGranny · 21/07/2021 22:57

She should invoice him for her travel. 40p a mile is a reasonable minimum. It's not just fuel, is it, it's wear and tear. 40p is what I charge my business. Might be time to look at that again. 😉

Divebar2021 · 21/07/2021 22:52

@GrandDuchessRomanov

I can’t believe you would pay your DH anything at all!!! He can buy the teacher gifts surely - even if you don’t have shared finances.

I really can’t stand people who are pernickity about money. I don’t care if someone has a mathematical brain or not the thought of them sitting in the restaurant splitting the bill down to the last penny is so unattractive. I’d rather just pay the damn thing myself. Much better to loosely ( not rigidly) alternate.

HollowTalk · 21/07/2021 22:52

@GrandDuchessRomanov

Yeah it's stingy.

DH and went out buying teachers gifts today and the shop was having trouble with my Amex card so DH paid and I said I would transfer the amount to him when we got back.

It came to £22:95 but he said just give us £20.

That's even weirder, though, if the children belong to both of you.
Iminaglasscaseofemotion · 21/07/2021 22:44

@ButYouGottaHaveASkillJeff

Not a red flag per se but it amuses me when people transfer the exact amount down to the penny, I don't know why. I always round up to the pound. My flatmate bought a film off my Amazon account and transferred me the exact 99p. Yes it was 99p but I probably would've transferred a quid.
Se I always wonder if I should round up, but then I think we'll why would I because its not like they have to go and try and find me change like with cash and you just say "oh don't worry, its only 50p" etc. There's no need to round up when sending money.
Swipe left for the next trending thread