Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to talk to son about thoughts of identifying as a girl

112 replies

SummerBreeze1980 · 21/07/2021 20:10

I'm worrying a lot about this and just don't know how to approach it/what to do for the best. Things seem so different from when I was a teen.

About 3 months ago my DS (14) was on a trip with his best friend. While he was there he sent me a message 'I think I might be trans' and then immediately deleted it but I had already seen it. Tbh I thought him or his friend were just messing around and so I replied 'Shall I call you [girls version of his name]? He replied saying 'Actually I like Izzy' (not actual name)

When he got back from the trip I gently broached the subject and asked if that was how he really felt. He said yes but also he wasn't sure. I asked who knew about his feelings and it was only his best friend. He asked me not to tell his dad which I agreed to. His dad isn't prejudiced but he can be a bit blunt and a bit dismissive. Also his grandmother might then hear about it and she is very prejudiced.

Anyway, I told him I was glad he told me and he could talk to me about it anytime. He was very quiet and it seemed a difficult subject for him to talk about. Well, since then he's not brought it up but has seemed pretty happy although increasingly likes spending time in his room at home. Can be a bit withdrawn, eating and sleeping lots. Typical teen behaviour I guess.

Then a week or so ago his dad was over and he started talking about puberty and how our DS's voice is breaking and how he was turning into a man. I noticed my DS put his hands over his ears. I wondered if it was because of these feelings. A few days later I asked him if he was still having those feelings about being a girl and he said yes. I talked a bit about how his feelings were completely valid and I would support him no matter what. I also spoke about society's stereotypes of masculine/feminine and you could still be a boy and like feminine things etc. I also reiterated he could speak to me anytime. Again it was a really awkward conversation, he was very quiet and hardly spoke.

I want to give him the right support but I have no idea what that is. I can't talk to anyone about it as he wants me to keep it between us and it just means my worries go round and round in my head. I worry that he is worried about it, that it is making life hard for him. I want to help him to feel better about it. I just don't know how. I don't know whether these thoughts come from a feeling inside or from relating to friends. For context he has a friendship group of 4 (including him). His best friend is a girl who identifies as gay and the other 2 are girls who identify as boys. I'm not sure if this is relevant or not. Also he is Autistic again not sure if that is relevant but not to drip feed. Oh and he is home-educated but mixes with lots of other DC although this has of course been restricted due to Covid.

Any advice welcome!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
KatieinVT · 02/03/2022 15:29

Feeling sad and overwhelmed, my DS just returned from a school trip (he was away a week), and sent us an email stating that he's a trans girl. He hasn't spoken about it, to either of us. We've always been the family that says "I love you!" multiple times each day and that hasn't changed. He wants to hang up a trans pride flag in his room, which is fine. I guess what I wondering is, how do you deal with the feelings you have?

UndertheCedartree · 15/08/2021 21:20

@beastlyslumber - ah, thank you Smile Good idea about Prince and Bowie - it would be good for him to see other males that haven't felt the need to stick to the masculine stereotype.

@PrincessNutella - I think he is definitely struggling with puberty. As I said before I have seen him cover his eyes when people have commented on his voice getting deeper and that he is becoming a man. I have discussed stereotypes with him and that that is all they are and we can express ourselves however we wish without it meaning we are a different sex. It is interesting you suggest reassuring him that 'being a man is a good thing to be'. I wonder if there is something in that. Sadly, he witnessed DV from his father aimed at me when he was very small. I have tried to get support for him around this issue for many years - not because he appeared to have a problem due to it as such but just that I felt a small child can't witness this and it not affect him. He doesn't particularly want to engage with this but would do as I feel it is important. Unfortunately it looked like something would be put in place but then Covid struck. I also don't have a particularly good relationship with my father. There is my brother who I would describe as a good role model - we don't live nearby unfortunately but we are going to stay next weekend. I think maybe he needs good male role models more than ever. Thank you - a lot of food for thought.

PrincessNutella · 15/08/2021 14:21

Since it isn't physically possible for a boy to grow up and become a woman, I would interpret his feelings as a psychological cry for help. I would assume he is feeling uncomfortable about puberty in some way he is finding hard to express. It might be helpful to reassure him that being male does not mean that he has to be limited in the way he expresses himself (whether that is what we would traditionally call "feminine" or "masculine" ways), just that he will grow up and become a man, and that being a man is a good thing to be.

beastlyslumber · 15/08/2021 11:58

That sounds like such a lovely trip out! I agree that this sort of time together will be key. It probably feels very comforting and reassuring to him to have closeness with you at a time when the world is becoming more and more confusing and there is some pressure to 'grow up', whatever that means. It's lovely that you've given him some gentle options for how he dresses and grooms himself and shown him there's no judgement there. He might enjoy looking at pop stars like Prince and Bowie and the new romantics and others who were creative and courageous with their style. It's good to separate fashion and creativity from any dogmatic ideas about gender and identity, I think!

UndertheCedartree · 14/08/2021 20:52

I took my DS on a shopping trip and we had Mexican food and a frappe in a cafe. We talked loads. I decided not to raise the issue of 'gender identity'. I wanted to listen to him and just connect. So we chatted about video games, Taiwan and a paleontologist with scoliosis! He always has interesting things he's watched on You Tube! I asked him if he uses any SM aside from You Tube and he said he didn't which I was quite pleased about.

So he wanted to look for some t-shirts - we went in a few different shops and looked in the women's section - he chose a few t-shirts in plain black, navy and grey - so exactly the same as he already has! 😂 We got some face masks and curly hair shampoo but nothing different to normal. I also got him some witch hazel/tea tree oil cleanser and a 'spot wand' and got him to pick out some deodorant and he chose a fruity smell one from the women's section. He doesn't use deodorant yet but I said it was good to have it there for when he does need it. I offered nail varnish as I was getting some but he wasn't interested and even asked if he wanted his ear(s) pierced but no! So bless him, life continues as normal for now and he said he enjoyed the trip. I think regular 1:1 time may be the key to him knowing he has the time and space to share whatever he wants and to be himself whatever that may entail.

UndertheCedartree · 14/08/2021 00:24

@RichPetunia - yes, this could indeed be the case.

RichPetunia · 14/08/2021 00:10

It’s a phase and a fad. He thinks he identifies as a girl but it’ll only be hormones and confusion. He’ll grow out of it.

UndertheCedartree · 13/08/2021 22:16

@grey12 - yes, at this point I don't think anything can be said for certain. Questioning/exploring your identity is normal adolescence. I'm not jumping to any conclusions and will encourage my DS not to either.

grey12 · 13/08/2021 10:29

@BlatantlyNameChanged

I also spoke about society's stereotypes of masculine/feminine and you could still be a boy and like feminine things etc. I also reiterated he could speak to me anytime

The most important thing you can do is exactly this - be there for him, keep the lines of communication open, and reiterate that he can tell or ask you anything without fear of judgement.

This seems good advice

IMO (which is not professional or experienced tbh) if someone isn't sure they are trans then they are not. One thing is wishing you didn't have these feelings, another completely different thing is being influenced into thinking you are different and this may be the answer, and it isn't

Can you get yourself to imagine having surgery to change your sex organs? I can't. No matter how much I prefer men's fashion to women's Wink people confuse gender stereotypes with transexuality a lot these days, it's concerning

UndertheCedartree · 13/08/2021 09:48

@MummBraTheEverLeaking - thank you so much

UndertheCedartree · 13/08/2021 09:46

@Theghostofchristmasarse - sorry to hear your DD and you are struggling. Ridiculous you can't get a pediatrician appointment just because she is 'good' at school and bright - many ASD DC are like that - it is at home it shows! I hope things improve. Showing our DC we love and support them is the most important thing, I think.

UndertheCedartree · 13/08/2021 09:40

@onelittlefrog - tbf I've found this thread incredibly helpful. So I'm glad I asked Mumsnet! Smile

MummBraTheEverLeaking · 12/08/2021 22:18

And definitely don't read "irreversible damage" It is hateful garbage.

It most certainly is not. This sounds like 'everyone I don't like is Hitler' hyperbole.

A lot of stuff online especially social media won't be good, especially if his view is that females deserve female only spaces. If he goes to a group setting with that view also he might find himself being told he's wrong, or a bigot, or 'helpfully' re-educated.

OP, sounds like you're a great mum and doing fine on your own. Exploring feelings and encouraging critical thinking while being supportive, taking him shopping, all sounds good to me.

Theghostofchristmasarse · 12/08/2021 21:45

I am ina very similar situation, I'm very GC, (and I'm just ignoring the posts on here by users who are pushing their own trans agenda, for whatever reason).

DD is possibly ASD, 11, coming to terms with my separation from her dad, her female role models, me included, are mostly mums who she's seen do the grunt work of a relationship, she's just started periods, she's coming to terms with her changing body...and this week, she thinks she's trans...last week she wanted to buy a pretty pink dress, have her ears pierced, etc...she's not into traditional boy things, she's alternative, she's a bit emo, a bit gothy, as I was at that age....she's not in any way trans. I'd be fine with it if she were, or if she liked girls, or boys who think they are girls, or whatever...I really don't care...but all this started with her anxiety increasing, her sense of being not quite right in her body, being a bit of a geek etc...it's just her way of labelling herself, fitting in.

I've told her I love her regardless, I've taken her to the GP and she's been referred to CAMHS, unfortunately they won't look at the concern I have about ASD or possibly ADD because she's 'good' at school, and bright...plus they e barely been there and she's moving up to secondary...but it's just bloody social media and the internet and her friends...I'm hoping that by being open with her, trying to get her help with dealing with her emotions, trying not to get annoyed or het up about it all, she'll just find her place and forget about it all. I wish her life were less complicated but I think it's just the times we live in. It boils my piss to hear all the shit that gets thrown about though, the whole trans thing is a tiny minority of people but to be GC is seen as such a bad thing, when in reality no one I know in real life buys into it...and I know a whole range of people, from all walks of life...the majority agree it's bullshit, just be who you want to be, girl, boy, doesn't mean if you're a girl who likes girls and more masculine things you're automatically a bloody boy..🤦

onelittlefrog · 12/08/2021 20:47

Step 1.... Don't ask mumsnet. And definitely don't read "irreversible damage" It is hateful garbage.

Step 2. See if there are any local LGBTQ+ youth organisations. I know your son doesn't want to talk to anyone about it at the moment, but with some gentle encouragement from the right place, he might.

Even if you just speak to the organisation yourself, they will have ideas on how you can broach it (and they will be better informed than the people on this foreum).

UndertheCedartree · 12/08/2021 20:40

Oh and also we have planned a day to go out shopping. I'm going to try and make it really fun - I'll treat him to his favourite Boba tea and a nice lunch. As well as having a look for some clothes if he wants I said we could have a look for any hair products or face cleansers etc he would like. I've framed it as a nice day out for just us and getting some things he might need as he's a teenager now.

UndertheCedartree · 12/08/2021 20:33

@ShortBacknSides - thank you so much for those videos. I agree the stereotypes are so rigid nowadays - if you like long hair and pierced ears you must be a girl. It goes against everything many parents have tried to instill in their DC.

ShortBacknSides · 12/08/2021 13:40

I think this is part of the issue with the current regression back to what seem to be quite rigid sex stereotypes in the last 20 years (neo-liberalism in action, I think). It's so binary - if you don't want to be a "masculine" man then you must be a girl ... instead of questioning what it is to be a boy or man.

The US feminist writer bell hooks (she doesn't use capitals for her name) has started to say a LOT about this. Her stuff is often on YouTube, and it moves me to tears to hear her talk about men & love. Here's a video in which she says some very powerful stuff about men & patriarchy:

She's an extraordinary woman, and a hero of mine. Maybe your son could be inspired by her?

And here's a very recent conversation between Michael Conroy & Julian Vigo (Michael Conroy is a bit of a hero of mine):

savageminds.substack.com/p/michael-conroy

UndertheCedartree · 12/08/2021 12:15

@ShortBacknSides - yes, I think this is definitely at least part of it. He has never been a 'macho' boy if you can use that word for a boy. He didn't really like the rough and tumble that lots of boys like. He has had long hair most of his life but would tell people who questioned it that 'boys can have long hair too'.I brought him up to play with any toys he wants not just typical 'boy' toys.

I will try to have a chat about 'gender non-conforming'. Thanks for the ideas and resources. I feel that this is the place he is in currently. There doesn't seem to be a great desire to actually be seen as a girl on a daily basis. This is why I think letting him explore the idea of wearing some 'girls' clothes might be enough for him to feel happier in his self.

ShortBacknSides · 12/08/2021 11:43

It sounds as though he’s uncomfortable with masculinity more than anything. Can you talk to him about all the gender non-conforming men and women over the centuries? Starting with women cyclists who wore Bloomers, or divided skirts in the 1850s, or the suffragettes, or male pop stars such as Boy George.

Or show him pictures of hippy men wearing velvet and satin in the 1970s. I was a teenager then and they were everywhere.

it’s such a pity that such male role models don’t exist - it’s all hyper masculine and that can shift into a toxic version of what it is to be a man.

Of course that must be uncomfortable. Could he be fired up by social justice to change that notion of what it is to be a man?

Michael Conroy runs really good workshops on this. I think it’s called The Man Box. He works with young men I think you can find him on Twitter.

UndertheCedartree · 12/08/2021 11:30

UPDATE

I just wanted to give an update as to where we are and continue a bit with this really informative thread, if possible.

So since I wrote this post I've had a good few conversations with my DS. I started by talking to him about why many women do not believe that 'transwomen are women'. His view was that transwomen are women but they are not female. I was so worried as it seemed he had read a lot on the topic and also though puberty blockers just 'paused' puberty and I was really worried and felt he might feel influenced to want to do all sorts of things as only 14. He thought that most teens who identified as the opposite gender stayed that way and didn't change their minds etc.

However, I then started talking about women-only spaces and was relieved that he believed these should remain as female only spaces and trans-women should have their own spaces. I talked to him about the CEO of the Edinburgh rape centre disagreeing about women being able to ask for a female to do an examination on them and he completely disagreed with this and felt the CEOs stance was way too extreme. He didn't think most trans-women have these extremist views.

He told me he finds it difficult when people talk about him turning into a man and also that he would like to wear more female clothes. I asked what was holding him back but he said he didn't know. I told him I was quite happy to take him on a shopping trip if he wanted (I actually said it would be fun as I think boys clothes for his age group are so boring!) or to give him some money to go shopping with his friends.I feel for him so much because he obviously finds it so very difficult to talk about.

Finally, just wondering if someone can tell me anything more about the Autism link with trans?

SummerBreeze1980 · 22/07/2021 20:37

Thank you for answering. I mean thank goodness you did have look! But it is tricky that line between respecting their privacy and safeguarding. I wish his SW would support me more with this. He's a bit of a golden boy to her so she seems to gloss over any concerns.

OP posts:
KOKOagainandagain · 22/07/2021 18:35

NAS is national autistic society. I know he was accessing inappropriate stuff because I snooped when he had gone to his dads but left his computer on. Didn't delete his browser history. Some may think it was invasion of privacy but I think it's safeguarding.

I am his carer. Literally. I receive CA because he has DLA. He has a f/t EHCP, can't attend school and has a bespoke package via PB.

This is not a case of an NT young man resisting being gay.

I raised concerns with the LA at his recent annual review but they won't touch it with a barge pole.

SummerBreeze1980 · 22/07/2021 18:23

@Notcontent - that's lovely that she can just be herself.

OP posts:
SummerBreeze1980 · 22/07/2021 18:12

@ShortBacknSides - it's always a possibility but I thought kids nowadays saw being gay as completely normal? I'll have a look at Genspect, thanks

OP posts: