Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are other mums like this?!

90 replies

PumpkinKlNG · 21/07/2021 17:41

Are all mums like this or is it just mine, no matter what happens or what I tell my mum she will always twist it on me to blame me, or she will always say what she would have don’t better than me and how whatever I did was wrong. Another example is that she buys my kids clothes sometimes and she has moaned in the past that she’s never seen them in them after, yet the other day she came and my daughter was wearing one of her dresses that she bought her, she said “You would think she has no other dresses, do you ever put her in anything else?” It was only the 2nd time she wore it Hmm basically I can’t do anything right, just wondering if other mums are like this?!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
candycane222 · 22/07/2021 13:56

Btw it might be 'cultural' as in the culture of some families. But I don't think its generational. My parents were both born in the 1930s and were never like this.

candycane222 · 22/07/2021 13:53

Hard to imagine why these mums are like this - unless they are perpetually anxious about their daughters,and/or subconsciouly very self-critical about how they brought them up.

Its tempting to suggest you say something like "it's ok mum, I've forgiven you for making such a terrible job of bringing me up. Obviously if you'd done a better job I wouldn't be making all these mistakes,but what's done is done eh?" But I doubt it would help in practice sadly!!. I suppose it might help to think it while they are going on though...

I wonder if grey rocking them might also be helpful. It would make it quite boring for them.

Peaplant20 · 22/07/2021 13:48

@MsTSwift

No mine is the direct opposite. Everything my sisters and I do is marvellous even if it’s things they previously disapproved of. I reckon if we became drug dealers mum would find a positive spin.
Same 😂
marmaladehound · 22/07/2021 13:44

Yeah I think it's not at all down to age. It's more likely what they grew up with so kind of goes full circle without even thinking about it.

Mary46 · 22/07/2021 13:35

Mine is so draining.79. Then comparisons x takes their mum away. I do think some are just used to their own set ways at this age. But maybe some people just difficult op. Husband mother so easy.

TreeSmuggler · 22/07/2021 13:18

I think it's just a personality trait rather than an age thing, my mum isn't like this. She's not perfect or anything, she does critisize at times, but it's more like occasionally overstepping rather than a seemingly compulsive need to do it.

CornishPastyDownUnder · 22/07/2021 13:14

no-mine was an alcoholic who neglected her kids,drank herself senseless &we were homeless by mid-teens.
I swore id do better&fortunately have a pretty great relationship with my dc..
In your shoes id struggle to seea reason to maintain a relationship that is emotionally/mentally unhealthy.

thesunwillout · 22/07/2021 12:21

@pigsDofly

Thanks for responding. Take care.

DotsandCo · 22/07/2021 11:26

I'm saddened to read about so many unkind/thoughtless parents on here...obviously we are all different, but it's still very sad to read 😢

My mum wasn't like this, and I'm not (as a mum of married children). I am their biggest champion...I can't imagine being anything else!

I'm so sorry that some of you have had such awful experiences...I wish I could put it right ♥️

marmaladehound · 22/07/2021 11:15

[quote Littleheart5]@marmaladehound why on earth are you letting that happen to your daughter?? Stop it now before her self-confidence is ruined[/quote]
Believe me I am trying and have been for years, including his sister and his mother! but yeah thanks for blaming me for my OH's behaviour!

pigsDOfly · 22/07/2021 11:10

@thesunwillout

Well I take back that you don't sound 'nice or kind'; thank you for your response to my post.

There's so much ageism on MN, it's generally aimed at older women, I find it such a negative way to look at older people and I tend to jump on it, I'm afraid, in the same way I would jump on racism or sexism.

I do know that a lot of very old people can get a bit negative, but maybe their lives aren't great or they wake each day with aches and pains with not a lot to look forward to; it would probably get most people down.

Having said that, obviously that's never a reason to put their adult children down, ever.

I'm sorry if I sounded cross and unpleasant.

ArsenicNLace · 22/07/2021 11:08

@thesunwillout

It's not an age thing. If you read the posts this criticism and negativity started when the posters were children therefore their mothers were of child bearing age and not old when it started.

My mother was 24 when she had me and she's been the same critical person all through my life. Although to be fair so has my father so I do think it may be a generational thing.

Oneearringlost · 22/07/2021 10:19

@MayorGoodwaysChicken

I know it’s not always this simple when it’s family, but honestly why would you entertain this? If a friend treated you this way would you continue to be friends with them? So why on earth tolerate it from the person who should love you more than anyone in the world? Have you ever stopped to consider that you’re not obliged to just meekly accept someone treating you so nastily, and in front of your child??? Tell her to get out of your house next time she’s so unpleasant!
This!
Littleheart5 · 22/07/2021 10:11

@marmaladehound why on earth are you letting that happen to your daughter?? Stop it now before her self-confidence is ruined

thesunwillout · 22/07/2021 09:53

@pigsdofly

I was honestly asking if it was a medically proven part of ageing, but should have clarified that I know it doesn't apply right across the board to every person who gets older.

I'm sorry if I upset you.

I have a mil who is wonderful. A gran who is kind.

I was wondering if there was something that kicks in in some women, I've thought that perhaps my mother can't cope with things, is it dementia, is there a hormonal process or chemical difference in some people. That exacerbates something.

Sorry I wasn't clearer in my thoughts.

pigsDOfly · 22/07/2021 09:44

And actually you don't sound 'nice or kind' with those sort of ageist remarks.

pigsDOfly · 22/07/2021 09:41

@thesunwillout

It baffles me. How old are these mothers, sometimes you hear oh it's a generational thing.

Mine is 70. Is it part of ageing, the negativity?
Like is it a thing?

How the fuck did we all end up as relatively nice kind people/mums ourselves with these mean old cows for guidance.

I'm getting to the can't be bothering with her stage.

I've just come out of hospital having been checked out for something potentially life threatening. Based on an actual thing I had to have done to save my life 5 yrs ago.

Made to feel like I was over reacting.

Just a total bitch comment.

Arghhhhhhh

No it isn't 'part of ageing, the negativity?'

I'm 72. I have never been like that and I never will be.

Why does someone always go with ageism on threads about mothers and bad behaviour. Just because you get old doesn't mean you're going to turn into a complete bitch.

Perhaps these women are just nasty, there's plenty of nasty people around of all ages.

If someone starts a thread about someone they know being a nasty no one comes on and asks if they're in their 30s or 40s because, you know, 'women in their 30s or 40s can be really horrible sometimes'.

My exh was like that with our children the whole time they were growing up, so nothing to do with his age, some people just like to put people down, especially their own children.

It was one of the reasons, among many, that we divorced.

Maybe try to spend less time with her OP.

41stars · 22/07/2021 09:29

My best friend and I often have this conversation and have promised to keep each other in check if we ever become like Monica's mum to our daughters. It's like mums got a handbook when having a daughter, thankfully I didn't.

My mum, God rest her soul, was a kind and caring woman, everyone loved her, and I did too but she did make life difficult. She wanted me to always do what she wanted, she was so controlling so we constantly butted heads over everything. I miss her, I really do, but I can't sometimes help feeling slightly relieved at the less aggravation I have to deal with, life is far more peaceful now because I'm not constantly being argued with over my life choices from my career to the colour of my walls.
I'm aware how awful that sounds. I do miss her goodness but not the bad parts.

ArsenicNLace · 22/07/2021 09:26

@Mumvschildren

This is my mother Too many to list but I was once sexually assaulted and the first words out of her mouth was ‘what the hell did you do to lead him on?’ She’d buy crap clothing from car boots (stuff I’d be ashamed to put in the bin) and forget she’d bought it I’d either be in trouble as they didn’t wear it or because it looked shabby If I got rid of anything she’d bought I was in for a 20 minute yelling even though I didn’t have the space for all her crap

I went nc with the lot of them

Omg! My Mum is exactly the same! Re the sexual assault comment I was raped by a masked man who broke into my house with a knife.

My mother's comment, ' Well you were sleeping naked. He probably couldn't help himself'!!!

She genuinely doesn't believe in praising children especially. It's a conscious thing too. When my son was about 3 they went to pick up my son at nursery and got talking about him going to 'big school' and choosing a good school. The manager said some v positive things about my son and said something along the lines of that he'd be fine wherever he went because he was so clever. My Mum was really annoyed and said she told my dad to take my son to the car because, ' He shouldn't hear things like that'! I asked 'Like what? Positive comments?' Apparently according to my mum children shouldn't hear praise as they will become big headed and stop working.

Unfortunately that resulted in me always feeling I'm never quite good enough and lots of other insecurities because the one person who you expect to have your back always left you feeling inadequate in some way.

MrsToothyBitch · 22/07/2021 09:25

I also forgot her recent jaw droppingly rude comment. She wants to meet DPs dad. He's very shy, we have warned her. He has a beard. We mentioned this in passing.

She immediately wrinkled her nose, looked directly at DP and said "oh... I don't LIKE beards". She can't understand why we are reluctant for my parents and his dad to meet! Confused

lazylump72 · 22/07/2021 09:23

Another one here too! Mine is so bad, I do and say nothing for I know what she is going to say before she even says it so its not a surprise anymore,I do take great joy in th epredictability of all the critisism,It used to hurt so much but now its like water off a ducks back.I am a much better parent than she has ever been and what I do for her is out of absolute duty nothing else,Its not done out of love or anything else its done and I think no more of it then get on with my life,I take pleasure now from the fact that due to her being her with her nasty ways she has missed so much of the good lovely happy moments of my life and my families life, I do the minimum,visits are kept to a minimum and I do not feel guilty at all.I switched off from her years ago and she will not be missed when she shuffles off this mortal soil.She has tried and nearly succeeded in driving me insane with her constant critisism and fault finding and general nastiness over the years and she thinks she is matriarch personified..she isnt and I tell her only what I want her to know no more.I do not share my joys or triumphs she really doesnt know me and I am keeping it like that,My life only includes her when she needs something which I will help with but its done with no thought or care or respect,She needs shopping ok do me a list I will get your shopping ..theres your shopping see you next week..thats it..fuck her and its all her own doing and she is too stupid to see that.I actually feel quite sorry for her but not sorry enough..she made her bed with me years ago and she can lay in it. Chin up OP its not you at all,

Sandinmyknickers · 22/07/2021 09:16

No. My mum is not like this at all. I'm so sorry to hear yours is, all your comments are making me very sad. I hope you have other supportive friends and partner in your life- everyone needs a cheerleader or someone to turn to who will listen no matter what, even if it isn't your mum. Flowers

SharpLily · 22/07/2021 09:11

My husband and I have actually started testing my mother on her behaviour - it's petty but it helps to reinforce the idea that she's the awful one rather than me, so I (while my husband is not there) will tell her about a plan or idea I have, or something we're doing or buying and, as expected, she'll criticise and criticise. My husband, while I am not there, tells her the same thing and the reaction is completely different. Why does it have to be this way?

MrsToothyBitch · 22/07/2021 09:02

I love my mother, she is generous, funny, kind and I know she'd take on a lion for me- I would for her. BUT... as I have got older, I am no longer blind to her flaws. She can be domineering, loves to stick the boot in, turns on you/snaps quickly and she has back doors if she isn't getting her way. She doesn't always have it easy with my dad but that's not an excuse for everything. I realised there was a problem when I found myself answering repeated friends & my DP saying "she is jealous of you" with "no she's not, why would she be? She's thinner than me, she says my curvy bum ruins the look of clothes; I'm not chic". DP has since taken her to one side to tell her not to comment on my body anymore. She went a good few months before bashing my appearance after that.

Nasty, unneeded asides are her bread & butter. The one I can't forgive her for was made when I was buying my flat and bounced some storage/furniture ideas around, thinking aloud. She just said "well I know what I would do with it. If I had it, it wouldn't look like a doss house". Any trait she dislikes in me is attributed to being inherited fron different relatives- her least favourites.

If anyone has ever watched Outnumbered, the episode where Karen called out Sue for her "mummy promises" resonated deeply. My mum will try to majorly change the terms of things after she has offered and I have accepted- usually to completely change the whole premise of what we had agreed, if she thinks I am getting a better deal than her. I just say to DP now "lets see if that's a mummy promise , shall we?"

I love to death but I was a pliant teen and I've had to work to detach myself as an adult. I get accused of being aggressive and suspicious for sticking up boundaries or asking her questions- she says I'm like her mother. I see a cycle, I'm trying to break it. What I do do now is call out her spite. I either stay in neutral tone or go sickly sweet as if she were a naughty toddler. Always phrases like "there was no need for that", "did you need to say that?", "you are unkind". I've noticed she's a lot more careful since I've started telling her when she's unkind or pointing out that she frequently makes fun of me and can come across as a bully. I ask for apologies now and won't move on til I get one. There's still the odd blow up, and my refusal to acknowledge her til she apologised almost ruined Christmas and made her cry, but she is much better now. I refuse to be a target or take abuse for being a different person to her.

PaperMonster · 22/07/2021 08:50

Yes, mine is very critical.

Swipe left for the next trending thread