Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Car service and MOT

42 replies

DontWatchThat · 21/07/2021 14:42

Can I just check im not going mad?!

Bloody old rust bucket in for its service. Got a phone call saying there are loads of things that need doing 'red' alerts

Bear in mind last year I spent about a grand on the thing with brakes etc.

I asked what all these things are. They said as the car is now 9 years old there are lots of things the manufacturer says need doing. It's a low mileage. About 45k. So we've not hit the milestones for changing them mileage wise.

I asked why they weren't mentioned last year. Or the year before. Or even at the six year check. He doesn't know.

I asked if they're all physically okay - brake fluid, valve clearance, spark plugs etc. And he said yes it's just how old they are.

Am I going mad?! Is this just insane? I want to Replace the car soon anyway so spending nearly two grand in two years seems excessive.

Any help appreciated...

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
FinallyHere · 21/07/2021 19:55

main dealership.

'Fraid this is one way they make money. I had my car under a deal that included the first x years servicing. The day that agreement was over, they came up with a list a mile long of things , including replacing the headlight remote adjusting system which required a lot of replacing very complicated wiring out

I took it my local garage, who used an Allen key to adjust the headlight and said they wouldn't charge me for that. No complicated rewire necessary.

Find an independent who will provide a much better deal for you.

KirstenBlest · 21/07/2021 19:50

In my experience its best to take cars once they're out of the warranty to independent places or even places like Formula One autocentres/ National Tyres/Kwik Fit etc as they have a much more pragmatic approach to replacing things not being reliant on the manufacturer's schedules.

Absolutely not. I once had new tyres in one of those 3 places and they said the brakes were worn down to the calipers and that the car was not safe to drive.

Probably because they thought that I was a young dumb blonde.

Elieza · 21/07/2021 19:41

I’d google the car and what needs done for services at what mileage and see if the infos online.

If not google main dealers and pick one out of town and phone them. Ask them. Don’t tell them your registration number just ask if they can email you what all needs done and at what intervals on a 9 year old jazz or whatever it is.

Then you’ll know a) if your own mob are telling porkies and b) what all to tell your local independent dealer you’d like done.

billyt · 21/07/2021 19:26

@teass

If its like my car (and other cars I've had) unfortunately there are things that manufacturers advise doing at the 100,000 mile mark or if you dont do so many miles at the 9-10 year mark. This is just super cautious regular maintenance - a stitch in time saves nine type thing but it can be a bit excessive.

At 10 years things like cam belt, spark plus, exhaust pipe, tyres etc will probably need replacing almost regardless of mileage . You will more than likely be fine not replacing them but the manufacturers rely on people fearing that they will suddenly go.

Its only certain components such as the cam belt that are actually crucial - if it goes it will probably destroy the engine costing several thousand to replace. Others such as brakes, exhaust etc will be obvious if they need replacing as you will be able to hear the noise/ feel the brakes not working. If you have had it regularly serviced there shouldnt be any problems.

As long as your car passes its MOT you dont need to do anything but bear in mind as others have said that if you are planning on selling a new buyer will want to be sure that the cam belt has been replaced or will want a discount in anticipation of this known cost.

In my experience its best to take cars once they're out of the warranty to independent places or even places like Formula One autocentres/ National Tyres/Kwik Fit etc as they have a much more pragmatic approach to replacing things not being reliant on the manufacturer's schedules.

I've driven cars for over 40 years and would never, ever let F1, NT or Kwik Fit anywhere near them no matter whether they were newish or getting on a bit. Next you'll be recommending Halfords! These chains have reputations for trying to sell unnecessary repairs. Just go on any car forum and see if they suggest/recommend using any of these!

As said upthread a good independent garage, hopefully personally recommended, is worth their weight in gold. Many of them employ manufacturer-trained mechanics.

And any garage can keep your warranty intact by using manufacturers parts and complying with the manufacturers service requirements. (I think they need to be VAT-registered as well)You do not have to use the
-main stealership-, sorry, dealership. On my present car a dealership service is nearly £400. For the exact same standard of service at my usual garage it's £265. I get nothing extra by going to the dealership except poorer.

And on every car I've sold on the buyers have been more than happy with the full service history.

KirstenBlest · 21/07/2021 19:10

If the dealership made you wait as you said they do not deserve your custom.

KirstenBlest · 21/07/2021 19:02

@DontWatchThat, don't get rid of the car.

You have looked after it and you'll get naff all for it.

Find yourself a decent independent local garage. Start looking now by asking around. They won't necessarily be the cheapest but they won't try to scare you.

You can always give them a ring or pop round and have a chat.

Your dad isn't completely wrong, but a dealership will probably be £££ for labour.

You might get another 12 years out of your car, it's done all the depreciation, so won't cost you much.

If you look at honestjohn web site he LOVES Honda Jazz

Hollowgast · 21/07/2021 18:39

AS an aside, I've heard things said such as "you need to change your brake pads, they're 60% worn".

I can get a set of pads to last 80,000 miles so on this basis I'm throwing away parts that woudl still be good for 32k miles. I daresay that may be badged as "urgent"

Hollowgast · 21/07/2021 18:28

Urgent my eye. If I was to rack my brains trying to think of a small, economical and reliable to the point of being able to carry on through an extinction event I'd say Honda Jazz, especially if it's petrol.

I would love to know the urgent things - really!

YesClemFandango · 21/07/2021 18:23

The service schedule will be in the handbook, and if that's missing it will be online. The dealership should have a record of what's been done at each service, ask for a print out of the car history. Remember the MOT and service are two different things. The MOT bits are essential or will be shortly, and the service items more optional but based on the schedule. A failed timing belt or water pump can knacker the engine so worth doing on schedule. Use that to figure out if the dealership are having you on. Forewarned is forearmed as they say. And yeah, at this point your dad is wrong, no benefit to dealership servicing if you can get generic parts and cheaper labour elsewhere.

DontWatchThat · 21/07/2021 18:00

I'm being punished for saying no to everything by keeping me waiting to pick the car up while everyone busies themselves ignoring me...!

Thanks for all the advice everyone.

First car. So all advice is welcome.

And to be fair to my dad he taught me to check oil, tyres etc. So he's not all bad.

It's a Honda jazz. Bless it. I've never had any problems with it (apart from when my ex left the lights on and wondered why the battery went flat...)

It was over a grand last year (big service apparently). This year they were proposing with the service, mot and 'urgent' stuff would be another grand... I'm going to get rid of it soon. I only do school runs etc.

OP posts:
KirstenBlest · 21/07/2021 17:32

It would be interesting to know what make car it is, and how much the dealership is charging for MoT and Service.

If you have an MOT, there may well be things listed as advisory, and these are probably what the garage has mentioned.

A 9-yr old car will have things that need doing even if the mileage hasn't reached the average mileage of a car that age. Timing belt change, that sort of thing.

It will probably be in the handbook.

TheViewFromTheCheapSeats · 21/07/2021 17:11

Also, my cars 20, 75k and has lots of original bits I’ve never changed. Only wheels, brake pads, the odd vacuum hose or join really. Even the original fuses in their entirety

TheViewFromTheCheapSeats · 21/07/2021 17:07

My car is 21 years old, pretty low mileage. I’ve always fixed only when things are broken, or when is sensible. My biggest advice is to never ever go to a main dealer and find a local expert (use fb to find out) who is trustworthy.
I’d have spent a crazy amount over the years otherwise. Realistically it’s mine until it’s scrap so I don’t care about sales, and it doesn’t make much difference after the first 5 or so years anyway.
It’s roadworthy, that is my only criteria for caring about work on it.

adawong · 21/07/2021 17:07

What car is it? Every fucking time on these threads ! No one can tell you anything unless you say the model of car.

SweatyBetty20 · 21/07/2021 17:03

Find a local independent. I've had one for ten years now and I take their word as gospel. When my 9 year old Corsa had a service and MOT they suggested I replace it and trade it in over the next twelve months as things would start to go, or need to be replaced. Traded it in for £1500 to a 2 year old Focus.

Do you mind saying where you are based? Someone may be able to recommend an indie close to you. Mine is the Salford/Trafford Park area if you need details.

KirstenBlest · 21/07/2021 16:51

@Shade17

It's the main dealership.

Why on earth are you taking a 9 year car to a main dealer? That’s half your problem!

This.

If you don't know a decent local garage, get on Nextdoor and ask.

Someone did that on my Nextdoor and all the replies bar 1 named the same garage. I've been going there for nearly 20 years and drive a well cared for old banger.

There's a thread on it today someone needing a recommendation for an independent BMW garage, and the responses are pretty much unanimous. I only replied to point out that topping up the oil with castrol was not an oil service.

Oblomov21 · 21/07/2021 16:32

You dad is talking rubbish. For an old car, dealership service is not required. You need a very trustworthy local mechanic that does all the bits you need for £300 at a time, for eg.

Hollowgast · 21/07/2021 16:27

Good Garage Guide. Find a local member.

Hollowgast · 21/07/2021 16:25

Bollocks to resale. There's no point getting an extra £200 for a car that's cost you an extra 5 grand in needless main dealer charges!

Etherel · 21/07/2021 16:24

Get a mech you can trust. This may take a while. My car is 15 years old and still ging strong. But then I bought a reliable brand, with a full service history, which may also play a role in this.

My mechs tell me exactly what needs doing, why and, if expensive, phone me up with a quote, get my okay, and then show me the parts afterwards. Because they are that good I stayed with them and now they will even do the odd job for free to keep my custom. You just need to find your tribe.

OhRene · 21/07/2021 16:06

I hate to say this but you're less likely to be ripped off if it's a bloke who books it in and takes it too.
I've rung around garages for quotes before and DH always manages to pay less. Thing is, DH knows less about cars than I do.

PheasantsNest · 21/07/2021 16:02

@teass Kwik Fit are very well known for ripping people off. I would advise anyone to stay away from them.

PheasantsNest · 21/07/2021 15:59

Never go to the main dealer. They just rip you off. Go to a local independent garage.

BarbaraofSeville · 21/07/2021 15:55

^See above. My dad reckons it's better for resale

This is my first car. I only learnt to drive a few years ago. When I was married my ex (reluctantly) did most of the dealings. Not because he has more knowledge but because they were less likely to screw him over^

Unless it's a large and/or high end model, it's worth a couple of grand or so at that age, if that, so sorry, but your dad is talking out of his arse as it's really not worth paying main dealer prices to service a 9 YO car when you can get it done at an independent for far less.

teass · 21/07/2021 15:48

@AdobeWanKenobi

In my experience its best to take cars once they're out of the warranty to independent places or even places like Formula One autocentres/ National Tyres/Kwik Fit etc as they have a much more pragmatic approach to replacing things not being reliant on the manufacturer's schedules

I know my schedules, and personally I think everyone should, but when something is due I can ring around for the best prices. The service I mentioned above is niche and I called a few places where it varied from £350 to almost £700.
The places you quote tend to get a bad reputation on here but tbh when I've called National for simple stuff like oil and filter or brake fluid changes etc they have been extremely cheap.

I know a trusted local garage/mechanic is best for not being ripped off but I've never had any problems with the chains - have used them all and always been confident they knew what they were doing.

Only problem we had recently was sourcing a specialist part for our power steering (Peugoet) but that seemed to be a problem with importing due to covid/brexit/Easter, they said I could try the local Peugeot dealer who would probably have it but when I contacted them I was quoted a price double what I was being charged at the chain so I was happy to wait a day or two for it to arrive. And you cant argue with a £26 MOT test!

Swipe left for the next trending thread