Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Corona dillema

266 replies

Coronanamechangie · 21/07/2021 11:20

Hi all. Name changed as don't want real life hatred.

We've been isolating for 8 days as DH tested positive. We count the 10 days from when he first showed symptoms. Were sending DC1 and DC2 back to school tomorrow.

However just lateral flowed them and DC2 is stongingly positive. We're tempted to send DC1 to school as it's their last couple of days of year 6.

Is this horribly irresponsible? Should we sit out another 10 days as a family? Sposed to be going to Devon on Sunday.

If we should send DC1 to school what should we tell them?

IBU - should do more isolation NBU should carefully proceed with life.

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 21/07/2021 16:12

I’d get everyone PCRed first of all. Then go from there.

The actual rules do say that’s DC1 can go to school, but I think it’s a horrible risk to take with everyone else’s lives and plans.

SoupDragon · 21/07/2021 16:10

@cantkeepawayforever

The OP is considering sending in a child who is released from isolation and testing negative.

If we consider everyone in the UK in this position to be some kind of pariah grandmother-killer, then a lot more industries are going to be grinding to a halt than already are.....

A child who has been in prolonged very close contact with two confirmed cases (assuming a positive PCR will follow the positive LF)
cantkeepawayforever · 21/07/2021 16:08

The OP is considering sending in a child who is released from isolation and testing negative.

If we consider everyone in the UK in this position to be some kind of pariah grandmother-killer, then a lot more industries are going to be grinding to a halt than already are.....

pastafeend · 21/07/2021 16:07

@kitkatsky

Why do you think your child is more important than all the other kids who didn't get to finish Y6 last year and this year and are you ok with him going in and giving it to any other child who might then hospitalise a sick, pregnant or elderly relative?

I don't even understand why you think OP is suggesting her child is more important?

cantkeepawayforever · 21/07/2021 16:06

@kitkatsky

Why do you think your child is more important than all the other kids who didn't get to finish Y6 last year and this year and are you ok with him going in and giving it to any other child who might then hospitalise a sick, pregnant or elderly relative?
Why do YOU think that the OP should go over and above what the government says they must do, just because you think it would be a good idea?
kitkatsky · 21/07/2021 16:04

Why do you think your child is more important than all the other kids who didn't get to finish Y6 last year and this year and are you ok with him going in and giving it to any other child who might then hospitalise a sick, pregnant or elderly relative?

pastafeend · 21/07/2021 16:03

As far as I can see, August16th is the earliest date children start returning to schools (in Scotland), and they want all isolations to end then so that they can maximise the in-school infection rate as early as possible - but that is just me being cynical!

We have been following slightly different guidelines in Scotland. Mine go back on the 12th August anyway.

cantkeepawayforever · 21/07/2021 16:02

@MGMidget

Yes from August the 16th it is a ‘free for all’ when they are satisfied that enough of the over 40s and vulnerable groups are double vaccinated. Before then we are supposed to ‘be patient’ and accept the chaos.
As far as I can see, August16th is the earliest date children start returning to schools (in Scotland), and they want all isolations to end then so that they can maximise the in-school infection rate as early as possible - but that is just me being cynical!
Candleabra · 21/07/2021 15:57

@cantkeepawayforever. Thanks very much for the clarification. I was thinking we could potentially be in isolation for weeks if we caught it from each other sequentially.

MGMidget · 21/07/2021 15:43

Yes from August the 16th it is a ‘free for all’ when they are satisfied that enough of the over 40s and vulnerable groups are double vaccinated. Before then we are supposed to ‘be patient’ and accept the chaos.

cantkeepawayforever · 21/07/2021 15:42

Agreed in an ideal case! However, I am used to reading schools' guidance (written on the back of an envelope by someone with no knowledge of schools a couple of days after it has already been announced, and released at 10 pm on a Friday) and so saw this as - by that standard of comparison - pretty clear!

MGMidget · 21/07/2021 15:40

Ps Cantkeepawayforever, yes the ‘tests positive’ reference appears on a different section of the guidance so does cover it. However as some have pointed out on the thread, there is guidance on the 10 day isolation which appears on a different page/section and it doesnt anticipate testing positive following a lateral flow test whilst isolating because a household member had previously tested positive! It only mentions ‘symptoms’ so there’s a hole on the guidance they ought to fill on that section.

cantkeepawayforever · 21/07/2021 15:38

You really can't think that at the moment, lots of people are calling their employers and saying 'Oh, I'm really sorry, T&T and everyone says that my isolation has ended, but I think i need to stay at home for another week because X tested positive 5 days ago'??

People HAVE to go back to work when not isolating. And many, many, many of us do close contact work, and have done throughout.

cantkeepawayforever · 21/07/2021 15:36

@MGMidget

Cantkeepawayforever - if teachers are going back into school in the circumstances you anticipate then no wonder there are 1 million children isolating at the moment. I think its awful but I cant see what the difference is between picking up covid from someone in the same household and picking it up from elsewhere. It presumably still has the same transmissibility!
It isn't just teachers, is it? ANYBODY, in any workplace, who has been released from their isolation is expected back in work. NHS ICU staff, teachers, supermarket workers, tradespeople...everyone.

And from August 16th, nobody has to isolate at all except the actual cases - and yes, cases in schools will be utterly ridiculous, but that's the aim - to gain herd immunity in children as fast as possible.

MGMidget · 21/07/2021 15:33

Cantkeepawayforever - if teachers are going back into school in the circumstances you anticipate then no wonder there are 1 million children isolating at the moment. I think its awful but I cant see what the difference is between picking up covid from someone in the same household and picking it up from elsewhere. It presumably still has the same transmissibility!

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 21/07/2021 15:32

Well the OP disappeared after saying she'd cancelled her holiday and booked a PCR test. I don't think she's done either of those things

cantkeepawayforever · 21/07/2021 15:31

@MGMidget

I looked at the isolation guidance on the government website and I would say there is a glaring hole which is what happens if a hiusehold member subsequently tests positive as a result of a lateral flow test! They need to make that clearer because I would say those notes were written without the regular lateral flow testing being condidered that is now widespread. The guidance on lateral flow tests would be to get a PCR test if you test positive and that will be sitting in guidance somewhere else. They need to put the two together so that people cant claim they are following the rules because they are following what is written in one part of the government’s covid guidance but ignoring another!

It would be bonkers to ignore a lateral flow test because the whole point of them is to pick up the asymptomatic cases. You still need to arrange a PCR test for your DC in my view and continue isolating in the meantime. Lateral flow tests are supposed to be good at picking up positive cases early so your DC may go onto develop symptoms. Presumably their schoolhas requested regular lateral flow tests which is why you are doing them so you still need to report the result on the NHS website.

I don't think it is a hole - it's under the 'tests positive' strand of the diagram, isn't it? Any positive LFT must be conformed by a PCR anyway, so all the LFT does is take the place of symptoms - both are a clear indication that a PCR test is needed. the date taken is the date of the positive LFT, anyway, just as if it is the date of symptom onset.
cantkeepawayforever · 21/07/2021 15:29

@Candleabra

Can I ask a question about the isolation timings?

We're all isolating due to a positive covid case in the household. Everyone else negative and symptom free so far. If someone else tests positive before the 10 day period ends, why doesn't the clock reset for everyone apart from the original case?

I was thinking that if DC1 is the original positive, then DC2 tests positive on day 8, I could still catch covid from DC2 so would need to do another 10 days.

Or are those diagrams based on the assumption that everyone can fully isolate separately within the household for the original 10 days.

No, the guidance applies to 'normal' households.

I seem to remember that the thinking was that after the first 10 days, everyone had had a 'good opportunity' to be infected, and that someone who hadn't become infected already was likely to have some level of immunity, therefore making them isolate for a further period for a second case linked to the first was not proportionate.

Whereas a case arising after the original 10 day isolation was likely to be a new infection, potentially with a slightly different version of the virus, and there could be no assumption that others were not immune so the isolation had to re-start.

MGMidget · 21/07/2021 15:24

I looked at the isolation guidance on the government website and I would say there is a glaring hole which is what happens if a hiusehold member subsequently tests positive as a result of a lateral flow test! They need to make that clearer because I would say those notes were written without the regular lateral flow testing being condidered that is now widespread. The guidance on lateral flow tests would be to get a PCR test if you test positive and that will be sitting in guidance somewhere else. They need to put the two together so that people cant claim they are following the rules because they are following what is written in one part of the government’s covid guidance but ignoring another!

It would be bonkers to ignore a lateral flow test because the whole point of them is to pick up the asymptomatic cases. You still need to arrange a PCR test for your DC in my view and continue isolating in the meantime. Lateral flow tests are supposed to be good at picking up positive cases early so your DC may go onto develop symptoms. Presumably their schoolhas requested regular lateral flow tests which is why you are doing them so you still need to report the result on the NHS website.

Candleabra · 21/07/2021 15:24

Can I ask a question about the isolation timings?

We're all isolating due to a positive covid case in the household. Everyone else negative and symptom free so far. If someone else tests positive before the 10 day period ends, why doesn't the clock reset for everyone apart from the original case?

I was thinking that if DC1 is the original positive, then DC2 tests positive on day 8, I could still catch covid from DC2 so would need to do another 10 days.

Or are those diagrams based on the assumption that everyone can fully isolate separately within the household for the original 10 days.

cantkeepawayforever · 21/07/2021 15:19

For example, would you like every teacher to be out of the classroom for up to a month if their family has Covid one after another? We've sailed close enough to the wind in terms of staffing this term at times as it is.

cantkeepawayforever · 21/07/2021 15:17

Given the complaints there already are about e.g. empty supermarkets, food production, NHS workers etc who are LEGITIMATELY isolating under current rules, asking everyone to isolate for, potentially, 2-4x longer just isn't going to fly.

Not everyone can just 'stay indoors' for 10-40 days just because others would like them to.

cantkeepawayforever · 21/07/2021 15:15

@TonkinLenkicks

Haven’t RTFT because these tedious threads where the OP was validation for being selfish are frustrating.

You have a responsibility. The government has washed its hands of any so just do the right thing and stay indoors until none of you are infectious. It’s literally that simple.

Unfortunately, for many people, that's utterly impossible because their employers (as is their right) asks people to return after the end of their isolation.

Taking up to another 30 days (for a 4 person household where each person catches Covid in succession, each time on the final day of isolation) off work just because others would like them to is not reasonable.

And of course from August 16th, nobody AT ALL will have to isolate except the index case for any period at all, as long as they are double jabbed or under 18 and say they have no symptoms.

cantkeepawayforever · 21/07/2021 15:12

To be absolutely precise (and OP will have had this, because it is what the positive test message says, and then all the follow-up communication from T&T):

Isolation is from midnight of the day the symptoms started / test was taken, until midnight of day 10.

So for us, DD's symptoms started & test was taken on a Thursday.

Isolation counted from midnight that night, so Day 10 (and isolation) ended midnight Sunday.

I was back at work in close contact with 30+ children with no social distancing by 8.45 am on Monday morning....

TonkinLenkicks · 21/07/2021 15:09

Haven’t RTFT because these tedious threads where the OP was validation for being selfish are frustrating.

You have a responsibility. The government has washed its hands of any so just do the right thing and stay indoors until none of you are infectious. It’s literally that simple.

Swipe left for the next trending thread