Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

10 Years and Nothing!!

211 replies

GreatBigHooAndToodaloo · 21/07/2021 08:37

I don’t even know what my AIBU is. My head is spinning. I’ve name changed for this because it could be outing.

I’m furious. My DH has worked for the same man for 10 years. He is a highly skilled tradesman (engineer) His bastard boss refused to take him on as an employee even though he wears the uniform, drives a sign written vehicle, works set hours and doesn’t do any other private work. He is essentially an employee without any of the benefits. The bastard boss hides behind the CIS scheme so that he can get all the benefits of having an employee without the faff. My DH hasn’t had a single day of paid holiday or sick leave for nearly 10 years.

Bastard boss comes to the house after work on Friday and announces that he is closing the company and moving overseas in a weeks time. One week!

He has also made it clear that there will be no redundancy pay. He got the work vehicle evaluated and has said my DH can buy it from him. He showed the evaluation to my DH. He is refusing to give him any discount on it. Not a single penny. I’m furious and heartbroken. I don’t know what we’re going to do.

Does anyone have any advice? Is there anything we can actually do? Ten years of loyalty. Ten years!

OP posts:
HopeHappy · 21/07/2021 15:11

[quote GreatBigHooAndToodaloo]@HopeHappy I can’t thank you enough! This is so so helpful. Thank you. He is a Gas Engineer so definitely falls within the construction industry category.[/quote]
You're more than welcome. I hate people that are so bloody selfish like that!

Definitely could fall within the realms of CIS then, but I think the fact that he's worked exclusively for them for over 10 years means the employment versus self employment trumps this.

Speak with ACAS and/or an Employment specialist solicitor on a no win, no fee basis. I would suspect he's got excellent grounds to sue for some form of unfair dismissal/redundancy pay and the historic leave.

Also, contact HMRC here - www.gov.uk/report-an-unregistered-trader-or-business - it's not just for unregistered businesses, but for reporting tax evasion, which deliberately keeping someone on a CIS basis when they should have been an employee is.

As mentioned above, the amount of employer's NI he would have had to pay if your DH was an employee is not insignificant. Even if HMRC only went back 6 years, which is their main limit, they would likely be interested in pursuing it.

Husbandswife · 21/07/2021 15:09

Be very careful before reporting the old boss to HMRC. You’re husband probably paid less tax through not being an employee (he would be on a much lower national insurance rate) and HMRC could potentially come after him for 7 years worth of back tax. It’s not a route I’d go down.

thinkingaboutLangCleg · 21/07/2021 15:09

Best of luck with the new business, OP. I visualise the old director's new home being plagued with unfixable rising damp ...

GreatBigHooAndToodaloo · 21/07/2021 15:01

@Hoppinggreen Thank you! It is perfectly legal unfortunately, I’m just having a moan because it’s just not ethically right is it? It’s incredibly frustrating. I have a feeling this IS going to be a brilliant new start for us. After today I’m only going to look onwards and upwards. I think I just needed a few other people to tell me that this guy is a total dickhead and that karma will get him at some point. I’m sorry your DH was screwed over too.

OP posts:
Ooodlesofboodles · 21/07/2021 14:59

If your DH can effectively take over the business then I am not sure it is worth your energy going after the shitty boss. It will be a massive distraction at a time when you need all your focus on getting the business going.

DynamoKev · 21/07/2021 14:55

@ramamamadingdong

I'm no expert but you might want to google 'IR35' which is about companies not formally employing people who are working as employees would be.
IR35 has no relevance here - it relates to people operating their own limited companies which OP has made clear her DH is not.
2389Champ · 21/07/2021 14:54

Sorry, pressed post too quickly.

Your DH clearly has plenty of evidence to support this claim - the signed van being a pretty significant one! There’ll clearly be evidence from invoices of work undertaken on behalf of the company too. I think his case is a very strong one against this nasty piece of work.

Hoppinggreen · 21/07/2021 14:53

I’m so sorry OP, this is shit
I would advise you against taking any legal advice from anyone on here though (including me). A lot of people don’t understand the CIS scheme and can’t see how this may have been perfectly legal.
I doubt IR35 would be applicable either.
I hope this turns out to be a brilliant new start for you - my DH was screwed over by a Dick head boss around 10 years ago and in some ways it as great as it pushed DH to do certain things that mean we now have far more money and flexibility
Good luck to you both

BlokeHereInPeace · 21/07/2021 14:53

What exactly does he do and what part of London are you? Probably a lot of work to be had at the moment, so crack on with that.

2389Champ · 21/07/2021 14:51

This sounds like you need legal advice from solicitors who specialise in employment law. I think your DH have a good case for pursuing “Implied Contract” I’ve copied and pasted a simple definition of IC which his scenario would seem to fit:

“Implied agreements create enforceable legal obligations between parties when honest business people would expect the business reality to be legally enforceable, and there is no express agreement.

Implied contracts mitigate against cases where one would-be contracting party acts as if there was a contract in force, and then, when it suits them denies a contract exists because the legal documentation does not satisfy the usual requirements of express contract.“

GreatBigHooAndToodaloo · 21/07/2021 14:49

@CastawayQueen I did not say it was illegal. I said it was unfair and shitty of him not to take care of someone who has worked for him for 10 years.

OP posts:
QforCucumber · 21/07/2021 14:46

Yes but you're saying he doesn't meet the criteria for a subcontractor. I really don't know how else to explain it to you

That is the contractors liability and responsibility, to confirm their subcontractors are appointed meeting the requirements - not the subcontractors!

CastawayQueen · 21/07/2021 14:42

You said that your tax returns etc are all in order after an audit - that means that the boss hasn’t done anything illegal.
Unfair, but not illegal
Quite naive of you to let it go on frankly?
Also doesn’t make sense to complain. Your DH never got any sick or paid leave but still stayed at the same company. Because the ‘money was good’. So you decided that the money was fair compensation. That’s completely on you?

Posters with more in depth knowledge feel free to correct me but w.r.t the general state of the employment OP’s DH made his own bed - no leave etc for 10 years is irrelevant because you kept quiet. There’s no free lunch in life…

GreatBigHooAndToodaloo · 21/07/2021 14:42

@StrongArm thank you for the advice. We have also just registered as an employer so if we take someone on in the future we will make sure they are never taken advantage of.

OP posts:
GreatBigHooAndToodaloo · 21/07/2021 14:38

@QforCucumber Thank you so much! We employed an account this morning.

@BarbaraofSeville I won’t be reporting him. I’m just really upset because I never thought he’d do something like this to us. With him leaving the country there is no point really and we can’t afford a lawyer. Not a good one anyway. This guy is very wealthy and we wouldn’t stand a chance.

@DonnaPruMcCullough That’s really sweet of you to say, thank you so much. You’re right, it could be fun and incredibly rewarding. Thank you for the motivation 💐

OP posts:
Waitrosedisaster · 21/07/2021 14:37

[quote GreatBigHooAndToodaloo]@Waitrosedisaster he absolutely hasn’t! He has submitted returns as a CIS contractor which is exactly what he is. In the description box on the tax return we say exactly what he does and we list his company’s details. We’ve been doing it for 10 years and HMRC has never said it’s wrong. Even after an audit 3 years ago.[/quote]
Yes but you're saying he doesn't meet the criteria for a subcontractor. I really don't know how else to explain it to you

StrongArm · 21/07/2021 14:35

you've got the suppliers on board, take all the customers - make sure he gets all the details in the last week he's there - start the company as you plan to do, run it better and legally do the right things with HMRC.

I would make sure the name isn't anything like the old business though given the stuff the boss was doing wrong! If he was doing dodgy things with workers, you can bet the VAT/other things were not correct too.

GreatBigHooAndToodaloo · 21/07/2021 14:33

@Waitrosedisaster he absolutely hasn’t! He has submitted returns as a CIS contractor which is exactly what he is. In the description box on the tax return we say exactly what he does and we list his company’s details. We’ve been doing it for 10 years and HMRC has never said it’s wrong. Even after an audit 3 years ago.

OP posts:
QforCucumber · 21/07/2021 14:33

They aren't false if the contractor provided him with a statement confirming they have found him within the scope of CIS for subcontract purposes.

DonnaPruMcCullough · 21/07/2021 14:28

@GreatBigHooAndToodaloo

I don’t even know what my AIBU is. My head is spinning. I’ve name changed for this because it could be outing.

I’m furious. My DH has worked for the same man for 10 years. He is a highly skilled tradesman (engineer) His bastard boss refused to take him on as an employee even though he wears the uniform, drives a sign written vehicle, works set hours and doesn’t do any other private work. He is essentially an employee without any of the benefits. The bastard boss hides behind the CIS scheme so that he can get all the benefits of having an employee without the faff. My DH hasn’t had a single day of paid holiday or sick leave for nearly 10 years.

Bastard boss comes to the house after work on Friday and announces that he is closing the company and moving overseas in a weeks time. One week!

He has also made it clear that there will be no redundancy pay. He got the work vehicle evaluated and has said my DH can buy it from him. He showed the evaluation to my DH. He is refusing to give him any discount on it. Not a single penny. I’m furious and heartbroken. I don’t know what we’re going to do.

Does anyone have any advice? Is there anything we can actually do? Ten years of loyalty. Ten years!

You sound like a strong woman. Could you help with driving the business forward and do admin, dealing with suppliers, marketing etc. You could both make a great team ! It will be fun. I work with my husband.
Waitrosedisaster · 21/07/2021 14:26

[quote QforCucumber]@Waitrosedisaster it is not the 'employee' who is in the wrong here, it is the contractor - they submit a monthly return confirming they meet the requirements for Subcontracting labour, and that the subcontractor meets those requirements.
HMRC take this up with the contractor due to this declaration, not the subbie.[/quote]
He has deliberately submitted false returns for ten years!

BarbaraofSeville · 21/07/2021 14:26

@Newkitchen123. SEISS grants weren't payable to anyone earning over £50k, which is entirely possible for a hardworking gas engineer in London who doesn't take any holidays.

OP, as PPs have eluded to, I would be extremely cautious about making a fuss with HMRC because the fact is that the amount of tax and NI payable by a SE person is lower than someone on PAYE with the same gross salary. It's not a huge amount now, especially given the lack of employment rights, but going back 10 years, the difference was more significant and could add up to a significant sum, especially if fines and penalties are added.

QforCucumber · 21/07/2021 14:25

@Waitrosedisaster it is not the 'employee' who is in the wrong here, it is the contractor - they submit a monthly return confirming they meet the requirements for Subcontracting labour, and that the subcontractor meets those requirements.
HMRC take this up with the contractor due to this declaration, not the subbie.

QforCucumber · 21/07/2021 14:23

[quote GreatBigHooAndToodaloo]@Waitrosedisaster Yes ‘sweetie’ you have missed a lot. Did I at any point say anything was illegal? Did I say I am suing the guy or reporting him? Or am I just saying he is an unethical dickhead who has exploited my husband and that I am upset that he hasn’t rewarded his loyalty for 10 years of service?[/quote]
Tbf - as a self employed subcontractor under the CIS scheme then your husband could, and should, have been claiming expenses - laundering of uniform. Home office space (for the completion of invoicing and tax returns) Mobile phone (if used for business use)

This is why people should pay accountants!

Waitrosedisaster · 21/07/2021 14:23

[quote GreatBigHooAndToodaloo]@Waitrosedisaster Yes ‘sweetie’ you have missed a lot. Did I at any point say anything was illegal? Did I say I am suing the guy or reporting him? Or am I just saying he is an unethical dickhead who has exploited my husband and that I am upset that he hasn’t rewarded his loyalty for 10 years of service?[/quote]
Urm right so nothing you've said here actually answers anything in my last post. So I will go ahead and presume my summary is correct. As I said, two pairs of dirty hands.

And if you're that convinced your husband has done absolutely nothing wrong, if you did report to HMRC and they asked why he's kept a lid on it for ten years, would you be happy to say, as you've done here, because he earned a lot of money by keeping quiet and getting on with it? Out of curiosity of course