Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

10 Years and Nothing!!

211 replies

GreatBigHooAndToodaloo · 21/07/2021 08:37

I don’t even know what my AIBU is. My head is spinning. I’ve name changed for this because it could be outing.

I’m furious. My DH has worked for the same man for 10 years. He is a highly skilled tradesman (engineer) His bastard boss refused to take him on as an employee even though he wears the uniform, drives a sign written vehicle, works set hours and doesn’t do any other private work. He is essentially an employee without any of the benefits. The bastard boss hides behind the CIS scheme so that he can get all the benefits of having an employee without the faff. My DH hasn’t had a single day of paid holiday or sick leave for nearly 10 years.

Bastard boss comes to the house after work on Friday and announces that he is closing the company and moving overseas in a weeks time. One week!

He has also made it clear that there will be no redundancy pay. He got the work vehicle evaluated and has said my DH can buy it from him. He showed the evaluation to my DH. He is refusing to give him any discount on it. Not a single penny. I’m furious and heartbroken. I don’t know what we’re going to do.

Does anyone have any advice? Is there anything we can actually do? Ten years of loyalty. Ten years!

OP posts:
GreatBigHooAndToodaloo · 22/07/2021 20:20

Contractors obligations

10 Years and Nothing!!
OP posts:
GreatBigHooAndToodaloo · 22/07/2021 20:19

Directly from HMRC

10 Years and Nothing!!
OP posts:
GreatBigHooAndToodaloo · 22/07/2021 20:15

www.litrg.org.uk/tax-guides/self-employment/what-construction-industry-scheme-cis

10 Years and Nothing!!
OP posts:
WallaceinAnderland · 22/07/2021 19:58

My DH has worked for the same man for 10 years. He is a highly skilled tradesman (engineer) His bastard boss refused to take him on as an employee even though he wears the uniform, drives a sign written vehicle, works set hours and doesn’t do any other private work. He is essentially an employee without any of the benefits. The bastard boss hides behind the CIS scheme so that he can get all the benefits of having an employee without the faff. My DH hasn’t had a single day of paid holiday or sick leave for nearly 10 years.

OP it sounds like you are angry that your dh was not an employee but surely that was his choice? It sounds like he knew he wasn't entitled to redundancy just as he wasn't entitled to paid holiday or paid sick leave. This is why he should have been putting some of his earnings away over all those years.

I'm not sure what is it that you are upset about. If he was unhappy with the terms of his employement, surely he would have looked for something else in all that time?

Waitrosedisaster · 22/07/2021 19:21

[quote GreatBigHooAndToodaloo]@DameCelia I’m refusing to engage with those that don’t know what they are talking about and have absolutely no idea how CIS works. Thanks again for trying though 💐[/quote]
OP, throughout this thread you repeatedly demonstrated an extremely poor understanding of business, I'm not sure you're in a position to comment on people's understanding of CIS.

GreatBigHooAndToodaloo · 22/07/2021 19:16

@DameCelia I’m refusing to engage with those that don’t know what they are talking about and have absolutely no idea how CIS works. Thanks again for trying though 💐

OP posts:
WallaceinAnderland · 22/07/2021 19:14

@User112

Your husband was ok with those terms all along? Why didn’t he move to something more suitable?
That's what I was wondering. Ten years is a long time to stay in a job where you think you're getting ripped off.
Waitrosedisaster · 22/07/2021 18:56

@DameCelia

Okaaaay *@LizzieMacQueen* *@Waitrosedisaster* *@Watchingyou2sleezes*

One more time!
He was on the CIS scheme. Not a subcontractor.

There was no tax avoidance.
There was no financial benefit to him other than ensuring he was paid evenly through the year regardless of contracts.

He wasn't pulling a fast one.

His 'employer' may not have been meeting the rules of the scheme but that did not implicate DH in wrong doing. The only reason it is relevant is that it might mean DH would have a redundancy claim.
Tax returns, IR 35, having your cake and eating it = all irrelevant.

And breathe......

You do realise that by its nature CIS (not the CIS scheme as you keep stating) relates to self-employed subcontractors working for a contractor? And subcontractor literally means the contractor delegates to them that they have been contracted for? I can only assume you're the OP with a name change.

As for benefits, he certainly sounds like he was being compensated for being a subcontractor - why else would the OP say he didn't look for work elsewhere because the money was too good?

User112 · 22/07/2021 18:52

Your husband was ok with those terms all along? Why didn’t he move to something more suitable?

DameCelia · 22/07/2021 18:28

Okaaaay
@LizzieMacQueen @Waitrosedisaster @Watchingyou2sleezes

One more time!
He was on the CIS scheme. Not a subcontractor.

There was no tax avoidance.
There was no financial benefit to him other than ensuring he was paid evenly through the year regardless of contracts.

He wasn't pulling a fast one.

His 'employer' may not have been meeting the rules of the scheme but that did not implicate DH in wrong doing. The only reason it is relevant is that it might mean DH would have a redundancy claim.
Tax returns, IR 35, having your cake and eating it = all irrelevant.

And breathe......

Watchingyou2sleezes · 22/07/2021 18:02

Other thing I would say is van residuals are high at the moment, we sold a 3 year old one just above what we paid for it new 2 weeks ago so this guy definitely will not be inclined to do any favours regarding buying the van

Watchingyou2sleezes · 22/07/2021 17:49

Tough shit. He's clearly been a hidden employee but there won't be anyone around to chase about this.
In the meantime if your old man was in anyway half sharp he would have barely paid a penny in tax for the entire period..
If he'd had sense he'd have put aside 7% every week for holiday"pay" , put his tax return away every year as rainy day money..
Now I've just read that he didn't get an Self employed grant yet your claiming that he's been self employed for 10 years??
Something doesn't smell right....

Waitrosedisaster · 22/07/2021 17:47

I also don't believe for a second the 'employer' was paying for expenses for her husband, then reimbursing himself from the husband's wages, then also claiming those expenses in his own tax return. There's not a chance he was the subject of a compliance check three years ago and that behaviour would go unnoticed.

Waitrosedisaster · 22/07/2021 17:44

@LizzieMacQueen

Can I just comment on this.

It wasn’t up to him to make sure he was following the rules of CIS. That was up to the company.

By making a self assessment tax return you are, in effect, declaring everything to be correct. So I'm not sure he is off the hook, legally.

I’m also really confused about the ‘benefits’ of being self employed? He paid his taxes at 20% just like everyone else and has literally never claimed a single expense.

But isnt the tax rate variable, up to 45% for some?

Yes, the very basis HMRC work on is that the customer is solely in charge of their own tax affairs. That is why when tax returns contain inaccuracies, the accountant cannot be blamed (they may be reported, but that's a different story). The OPs husband was fully aware he should be treated as an employee but continued to submit self-assessments as in the OPs own words 'the money was too good' to be honest about his affairs.

I do feel for those who find themselves working for tax-dodging employers. However, I reserve my sympathy for those who are on a low wage and have few other options but to suck it up. OP's husband was on an excellent wage by the sounds of it and stuck around for a decade. That is calculated and deliberate.

LizzieMacQueen · 22/07/2021 17:05

Can I just comment on this.

It wasn’t up to him to make sure he was following the rules of CIS. That was up to the company.

By making a self assessment tax return you are, in effect, declaring everything to be correct. So I'm not sure he is off the hook, legally.

I’m also really confused about the ‘benefits’ of being self employed? He paid his taxes at 20% just like everyone else and has literally never claimed a single expense.

But isnt the tax rate variable, up to 45% for some?

DameCelia · 22/07/2021 16:17

@GreatBigHooAndToodaloo pleased you're feeling more positive today.
@Teenagehorrorbag is another poster who doesn't understand the difference between sub contracting and CIS Hmm.
With so many not understanding CIS it is easy to see how your DH's 'employer' sailed so close to the edge of the rules without being challenged by anyone.

GreatBigHooAndToodaloo · 22/07/2021 15:53

@Skiptheheartsandflowers you’re right. We should have known and been smarter. Hindsight is always 20/20 isn’t it! We’ve done an HPI check, it’s all above board.

@fakeplantsdontlookreal thanks for your input. The tip about putting taxes into savings is great! Thanks so much.

@Teenagehorrorbag I’m not sure how my DH has broken the law? It wasn’t up to him to make sure he was following the rules of CIS. That was up to the company. I’m also really confused about the ‘benefits’ of being self employed? He paid his taxes at 20% just like everyone else and has literally never claimed a single expense. Literally nothing. Even any training he did was paid for by the company and then deducted from his wages, the company then used it as a tax deduction on their tax return, not my husband. We pay both voluntary and involuntary (I think that’s what it’s called) NI contributions so as far as I know we have paid the same as everyone else. Last years bill was nearly £5k! I’m genuinely asking and not being arsey when I say I’d like for someone to explain how we benefitted from this arrangement? What benefits would he have been falsely claiming? It seems like his pay was on par with what he’d get from an employer like British Gas so it’s not like he earned loads more than other people who are employed. Anyway, we’re not going to HMRC, I have said that repeatedly.

OP posts:
Teenagehorrorbag · 22/07/2021 15:09

I expect this has been mentioned - but I think it's the IR35 rules that prevent self employed people from working for only one 'employer'? Many people used to choose to be 'self-employed' as it's often more beneficial, so they made it illegal.

Your DH has missed out on things like holiday pay but that may have been reflected in his rates. He has broken the law by claiming all the benefits that go with being self employed - if you go to HMRC now you may find that comes back to bite him big time!

He could (and maybe should) have raised this years ago as from what you have said, he clearly was an employee. But you would need to look at all the expenses he's claimed, any additional pay he's been given, etc etc and weigh that up against lost holiday and sick pay, and redundancy. It may not be worth the battle - and he could possibly be fined for breaking IR35 rules anyway.

Good luck with the new business.

fakeplantsdontlookreal · 22/07/2021 14:58

I would say that the other company has breached GDPR rules unless they had the contractors permission to send copy invoices to you. But anyway...

As others have said, you are in business to make money. You will need to do this yourself in order to make money, you will need to charge the companies you work for, far far more than you pay to your employee.

The contractor has other expenses to pay for , materials, tools, Public Liability Insurance, Membership fees, vehicle costs, Accountancy fees, advertising, and lots of other things, so all of that needs to come out of what you charge to your customers.

So when you employ somebody, and well done for saying that you are going to do that, employing them means that they will get holiday pay and sick pay, and hopefully you will pay them a decent wage, but you will not pay them anywhere near what you charge to your customer.

Of course it seems unfair, but all your DH had to do was turn up and work, he didn't have any of the other costs that the contractor did.

Good luck with everything ongoing, and my best tip for you, is to ensure that you put away your tax money each month, into a savings account, so that it is there when you need to pay your tax.

Skiptheheartsandflowers · 22/07/2021 14:54

I hope you are able to turn this into an opportunity now, and it seems like you could. Though might be best to at least try and check the van is rightfully the boss's to sell! I would also make a lower offer as it's the boss who wants to sell the van quickly.

However
I never thought he’d do something like this to us
I think after 10 years of this and how you've said the boss handled furlough last year, then you could have guessed he wasn't going to be handing anything out. Shouldn't have been a surprise. You may need to keep an eye on how your husband runs it as his own business to avoid him taking the 'easy option' that means you lose out later.

GreatBigHooAndToodaloo · 22/07/2021 14:53

But yes.. I completely accept that we were stupid and naive and that we allowed this guy to get away with it. Onwards and upwards and moving forward now.

OP posts:
GreatBigHooAndToodaloo · 22/07/2021 14:51

@sasparilla1 thank you so much for that! I am feeling so positive today. We have already secured a few contracts and things are going to be better than ever.

@DameCelia thank you for trying to explain it to people. No one really seems to get it. It wasn’t subcontracting there were no contracts. He went to work for the guy in his uniform, in his van, for his clients, on his terms and conditions, a normal 8-5 start and finish, no time for personal work, no personal expenses and a set wage. Just like a normal employee. Except he had none of the perks. The company even deducted his taxes every week. We have been looking at jobs today just to compare and his salary could easily be matched by the likes of British Gas etc. I don’t know where someone up thread got £90k because it was nowhere near that figure. Thanks again!

OP posts:
sasparilla1 · 22/07/2021 14:01

Honestly, you may find that this is the best thing that has every happened to you!

My dh is a roofer and 5yrs ago had quite a serious accident that meant he couldn't work for a number of months. He was on a similar CIS lark!

He set up on his own, it was odd jobs at first as that was all he could physically do, but not he's got worked booked in months ahead, leases a van and has a really good reputation. He's finally taken the plunge and taken a labourer on recently. He's also earning more than ever!

I work full time +, so I don't do much for him, but you sound really on the ball. I'm sure it will work out for you, good tradespeople are very much in demand and he already has a whole heap of contacts.

DameCelia · 22/07/2021 13:52

Yes @rwalker but the point made excellently up thread is that the CIS rules may have been breached, many an employment situation arose and therefore the redundancy situation may be different.

rwalker · 22/07/2021 13:49

@DameCelia self-employed (cis) / subcontractors don't get redundancy .
CIS is deemed selfemployed