Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To insist the cat goes back to the RSPCA?

358 replies

Hellvelyn · 20/07/2021 22:40

We got a rescue cat from the RSPCA just over two years ago. Much wanted by dd and seemed like a good idea. DS and DD are now 16 and 18 ( years 11 and 13)
Cat is sweet natured and friendly but OMFG she's caused havoc and cost us hundreds of pounds. She just won't reliably pee outside or in the litter tray. She's ruined two carpets. I've spent hours cleaning up after her and we've tried everything to persuade her to wee where she should (multiple vet investigations, different litter and litter trays, products to help her relax, products to deter inappropriate weeing, advice from RSPCA. You name it. We've tried it.) End of last year she was doing better. We then had a long planned downstairs extension. Cat was in a (lovely) local cattery for 10 weeks as we didn't want her upset by all the disruption and for the peeing to get worse. On her return she was so settled and found her spot in the sun in our new conservatory and was weeing reliably in her tray. Suddenly last week I saw her weeing up the wall of our lovely new extension and all over a laptop. Closer inspection and sniffing indicated this wasn't the first time. Today she weed up our bookcase onto precious photo albums. I've just had enough. She's damaged one thing too many now. We had a family talk tonight. DCs are upset at the thought of her going, DS in particular who said " but she's part of our family....." AIBU to just want her to return to the RSPCA? Will my kids ever forgive me? Aaaaagh!

OP posts:
ilovebagpuss · 21/07/2021 15:03

My DB cat was like this and in the end they made him a lovely outdoor house and he has access to a cozy shed/office in colder weather. He’s still loved and fussed but he cannot go in the house and piss on everything.
He’s perfectly happy outside and everyone can enjoy him.

CastawayQueen · 21/07/2021 14:57

@Doodlebug71 this comment was made in the context of comparing pets to elderly parents. And the whole ‘we wouldn’t get rid of a sick child/old parents who are incontinent, why would you even consider doing so a cat’?
I would spend everything I had (and go into debt) to save my family but I wouldn’t do that for a pet no matter how much loved. There’s a clear limit to how far I’d be willing to go for a pet. That’s all. So they are most definitely the same as my family.

sleepismyhobby · 21/07/2021 14:54

My rescue cat used to do this . The vet suggested putting tinfoil down at his favourite peeing place so far it's worked. Apparently they don't like the feel and sound of tin foil

I8toys · 21/07/2021 14:48

YABVU - I hate people who give up pets because it becomes difficult. Its with us until death in this family even if they are incontinent and have wobbly legs. Numerous accidents with missing limbs and I adore them even more.

AuntLucy · 21/07/2021 14:40

I'm surprised what a hard time you've been given on this thread. Yes it's very unfortunate the adoption didn't work out, and of course the kids are pro keeping the cat, for so long as clearing up after it isn't their problem. But living in a house saturated in stinking cat urine is enough to test any love to the limit, and yours for this cat has run out. Take it to a shelter, give them a huge guilt-inspired donation (maybe calculate the lifetime value of her food and inoculations) and hand her over to take another chance at a loved-life with a new owner. Then vow not to adopt again, and move on with your life. You are not the antichrist, You are a person who adopted the wrong cat for your family, and dealt with it.

Bargebill19 · 21/07/2021 14:33

@Mother40

Have you been to the vet? Sadly at this age it’s likely to be a medical issue. 18/19 is a very good age.

Mother40 · 21/07/2021 14:30

One of our cats is about 18/19 years old and has started peeing in the house. It is really not very.nice and has ruined a lamp whichever have had to throw out. We don't know how to stop him doing this. We won't consider getting rid of him as we have had him for a long time, but I might have felt differently if we had only had him for a couple of years.

WhatMattersMost · 21/07/2021 14:21

@Crunchymum

You put a nervous / untrained cat in a cattery for 10 weeks?????
Yes, I was thinking this too. I think it was well-intentioned, and the OP was stuck between a rock and a hard place wrt options, but it will still have had an impact, possibly profound.
Crunchymum · 21/07/2021 14:07

You put a nervous / untrained cat in a cattery for 10 weeks?????

Doodlebug71 · 21/07/2021 14:05

@Maggiesfarm

Doodlebug, I agree with what you said. My husband felt the same way, we took the cats on and it was up to us to do our best for them, which we did.

They didn't all become incontinent and mostly lived to old age.

However a couple of them had to be put down because they were ill; they had treatment which was successful for a while but eventually they became ill again and it was the kindest option.

Now I am on my own with no cats and I will not have any more but I did love having them.They gave us an awful lot and were great characters, very individual.

For the record, I do not (knowingly) eat anything that is factory farmed, only buy free range eggs and milk from cows that are free to graze, and am committed to animal welfare.

Fish is a difficult one but I do my best there, some grocery chains are committed to ethical and humane practices. I would never eat shell fish or crustaceans.

One of ours had to be euthanised at age 10. Poor sod had kidney failure.

@234Pepperplant: You're assuming a whole lot. Don't. That false equivocation malarkey is a really pointless and juvenile discussion tactic, especially when you have no idea about the lives of the people you're aiming it at.

@CastawayQueen. A cat is just an animal that hasn't done you any favours quite the opposite [sic] No, they're not, and oh yes, they do. They're part of our family. If I/we didn't feel that way, we wouldn't bother adopting them in the first place. They give so much when properly cared for. Shame you feel that way. You're missing out on so much.

Bythemillpond · 21/07/2021 14:04

LizzieW1969
You couldn’t have found someone to take her?

LizzieW1969 · 21/07/2021 13:43

If you adopt an animal from the RSPCA and can no longer keep it, you are supposed to return it to the RSPCA. Thats standard for all reputable breeders and rescues.

That isn’t always possible. My first cat as an adult came from a rescue in London, she was nearly 4 years old then. I moved up north when I got married and then we adopted DD1 (now 12) 7 years later.

My cat couldn’t adjust to the change when DD1 came to us at age 1. She developed a stress related illness, which manifested itself as over-grooming and pulling chunks of fur out. I took her to the vet regularly for medication, but she kept starting again. She’d also suffered from chronic gingivitis ever since I first had her, and this became far worse along with developing thyroid problems.

She never adjusted to my DD being there, despite my best efforts and despite her attachment to me; she used to love bounding upstairs to me in the morning. After 18 months, I came to realise that I was being completely unfair on her and I had to do the right thing by her.

I discussed returning her to the rescue with our vet, who felt that she wouldn’t survive the move. It would have been possible to keep treating her, but the vet strongly recommended that it would be kinder to PTS. And I was with her at the end. (It was completely heartbreaking.)

Bythemillpond · 21/07/2021 13:24

The thing with cats is, at some point they become incontinent. It can happen when they are old or sooner

No they don’t
I have had a 23 year old cat and a 21 year old cat and at no point did they become incontinent

I would look at anti anxiety medicine because something is making her stressed.

I am wondering about why you put her in a cattery for 10 weeks. I had massive building work done and my cats (8 of them at the time) made friends with the builders. Only problem we had was when they put the floorboards down and then had to take them up again as one of them ended up under the floor
Any dust or heavy machinery and they were in another garden.

lovemenot · 21/07/2021 12:58

Is she neutered?

Thelnebriati · 21/07/2021 12:57

If you adopt an animal from the RSPCA and can no longer keep it, you are supposed to return it to the RSPCA. Thats standard for all reputable breeders and rescues.

Bluesheep8 · 21/07/2021 12:45

I adopted an older cat from a breed specific rescue. I told them, no urinary issues - that's a deal breaker for me. The cat then proceeded to wee everywhere and it was horrible. I returned the cat to the rescue and they were going to keep her as one of their permanent guests, as they realised that perhaps she was not adoptable. I think it is perfectly reasonable to have your limits with pets. This time round, I got a kitten from a breeder.

And what if the kitten goes on to develop a problem? Due to stress/illness/old age? Is the kitten then not suitable either?

Maggiesfarm · 21/07/2021 12:28

Doodlebug, I agree with what you said. My husband felt the same way, we took the cats on and it was up to us to do our best for them, which we did.

They didn't all become incontinent and mostly lived to old age.

However a couple of them had to be put down because they were ill; they had treatment which was successful for a while but eventually they became ill again and it was the kindest option.

Now I am on my own with no cats and I will not have any more but I did love having them.They gave us an awful lot and were great characters, very individual.

For the record, I do not (knowingly) eat anything that is factory farmed, only buy free range eggs and milk from cows that are free to graze, and am committed to animal welfare.

Fish is a difficult one but I do my best there, some grocery chains are committed to ethical and humane practices. I would never eat shell fish or crustaceans.

Eustaciavile · 21/07/2021 12:06

@Hoppinggreen

So you stuck the poor thing in a cattery for 10 weeks and then are surprised she’s upset and disturbed?
Yep. Poor kitty
CastawayQueen · 21/07/2021 12:01

Also to add - the cognitive dissonance between family pets and food animals baffles me too.

Humans are selfish in the end and it’s only emotional attachement not moral principles that they follow

CastawayQueen · 21/07/2021 11:51

@234Pepperplant

So on the one hand society reckons it’s ok for a chicken to live a fairly miserable life in a shed for a few weeks, be put in a truck at a few weeks old and then be slaughtered (I'll spare the details but it’s not like they get quietly injected while sitting on someone’s lap) in order for me to enjoy a single roast dinner for an hour or so.

On the other hand it’s absolutely appalling to put a “healthy” cat down, humanely by a vet, as a last resort to avoid 15 plus years of living in a house covered in stinking cat pee.

I don’t get it. (And no, I don’t have pets, I don’t see the point.)

Exactly. Humans with toilet issues understand what’s going on, have nappies etc so don’t wee all over the house. Also parents have taken care of and raised their children. So you can’t abandon them. A cat is just an animal that hasn’t done you any favours quite the opposite. DP loves cats but also comes from farming stock. And understands that animals are put down to spare them needless suffering. If it’s peeing everywhere and can’t be corrected then it’s clearly still suffering. Confining it to certain parts isn’t going to help.
sfeirical · 21/07/2021 11:27

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ for repeating deleted post. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

LizzieW1969 · 21/07/2021 11:24

This is the worst response so far, please never put cats for rehoming on Gumtree, or any other selling site, your cat would really be better off pts, than this, you never know where they will end up.

Not necessarily. When we rehomed my male cat two years ago (he was aggressive towards my DDs as explained earlier), I used Pets for Homes. I found the perfect home for him. He’s now a single cat living the most pampered existence imaginable.

They send us photos of him in his new home, he looks very happy, much happier than he was in our busy home here with 2 DDs and 3 other cats.

markmichelle · 21/07/2021 11:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Couchbettato · 21/07/2021 11:14

@Charlieiscool

It’s a cat, it isn’t a family member and it’s up to you whether you want to go on having things ruined, cleaning up the wee and having a stinking house. Maybe your DS will take the cleaning on if he feels so strongly about it. Why are you the one doing it all?
Yep, this is my thinking too.

I wouldn't want to deal with this for the next 15-20 years.

Ceara · 21/07/2021 11:12

We have a rescue cat with a wee-ing problem. He had recurring bouts of feline idiopathic cystitis, which made urination painful and caused urination outside the litter tray. He got in the habit of weeing everywhere but the litter tray even in between bouts of cystitis - we think he learned to associate the litter tray with pain.

I totally sympathise. It is grim.

But there will be a reason. If the cat is otherwise healthy, go back to the vet and press for more help.

Not saying it's idiopathic cystitis but FWIW things are much better here now, with a combination of:
Painkillers during acute bouts
Making sure he is well hydrated - switched to a mainly wet food diet
Reducing stress - that included us working on our own stress (!) as well as making things totally calm and predictable at home
Age and maturity - he's just chilled out more as he's got older, isn't out challenging and scrapping with the other cats in the neighbourhood so much, etc.
A lot of patience and really good specialist detergents.
We didn't get as far as anti-anxiety meds but they would have been the next option.

In relation to giving your cat up, my grandma got rid of my mum's cat when she was a child. It still festered with my mum 60+ years later and I don't think she ever quite forgave her mother...!