Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my mum should've asked me before moving abroad?

114 replies

salviapages · 20/07/2021 20:02

This happened a few years ago and I feel kind of petty for still thinking about it but it's really impacted the way I feel my mum views me.

A few years ago, my mum moved abroad with her partner. He'd applied for a job out there (she didn't tell me he was doing this) and after he accepted the job she rang me all excited and told me they were moving abroad in a few months time.

I was about 24 at the time and had been living with my partner and financially independent since I was 18 so it's not like I still relied on her. But we were quite close and saw each other regularly, a few times a month.

I just feel like she should have said 'partner is applying for this job, how would you feel if we moved away?' I never would have told her not to go but I just feel like she should've checked in to ask how I felt about my mum moving to another country. Is that unreasonable of me? She's an adult and can do what she likes and doesn't have to consult me. It just felt like she hadn't considered me

OP posts:
HaveringWavering · 20/07/2021 21:48

You mention that you were (are?) living with a partner. Perhaps your Mum felt that you had your own life, own family unit, so it was not such a big deal for her to move away as it might have been if you had still been single and she was the closest person available to give you support in life?

Also, how long had she been with her partner? Was it fairly recently that she had settled down with him, or were they a long standing couple? I ask because if he was quite new you could imagine she might be worried you had doubts about him and be protective of her. Is your Dad involved in your life?

NeverDropYourMooncup · 20/07/2021 21:33

Did you run the idea of moving in with your DP past her before making a decision? As if she'd said 'that's not a good idea, I don't like it', you'd have decided not to because she'd be unhappy?

If not, it's really not something you will benefit from still holding resentment/hurt for.

lastqueenofscotland · 20/07/2021 21:32

Completely U
you’re allowed to miss a person but thinking you should have in some way had a say is ridiculous

friendlyflicka · 20/07/2021 21:31

I do understand what you are saying: that you are hurt that she didn't prepare you a little bit and take you into her confidence, because if the situation was reversed, you would have done that to her.

And, no, I don't think you are unreasonable at all. I sometimes wonder about people who do things very differently from the way I would have treated them.

i am surprised at the answers here, but maybe it is because you have placed it on AIBU and the title of it. I do think, I understand and I don't think you are being unreasonable at all.

LemonRoses · 20/07/2021 21:30

How could you be quite close and this not be everyday discussion? Odd dynamic for really close.
Our children want to know if we’ve gone to the Isle of Wight for a long weekend.

Xmasbaby11 · 20/07/2021 21:27

I think it would have been good if she'd planted the seed so it wasn't a total shock. It's not really the same the other way round - parents expect and want their children to move away for work / study / adventure. Of course it's fine for your mum to move but she must have understood it's a big deal for you, and you saw each other often - I think it's OK to feel hurt she didn't bring it up.

My parents have never moved since I left home. I moved abroad and changed countries 5 times in my twenties and always discussed a move with them. At times they probably didn't want me to go but we still talked things through and waved me off with good will. We are close and I valued their input.

I also think there is another dimension if your DM has left behind her own mother who you now have caring responsibilities for. Perhaps she hadn't intended for that to happen but old age is fairly predictable .. it must have crossed her mind. So YANBU.

Ninkanink · 20/07/2021 21:26

I totally understand why you’re upset. It would have been nice if she’d at least considered that it might be a big deal for you, and if she’d have let you know it might be happening you could have got used to the idea, and you could have felt like she cared about you and how it might affect you.

thisplaceisweird · 20/07/2021 21:25

Completely unreasonable OP. You were an adult living independently.

When I moved abroad (15 years ago) I just told my parents and they were delighted for me. I would never ever have thought to 'ask their opinion'.

mindutopia · 20/07/2021 21:22

I don't know. I think it's good for her to tell you in advance, but I certainly wouldn't ask permission.

I moved abroad when I was in my late 20s (first to work, and then eventually to live with dh, who I met working abroad and lived in a third country). I've never moved back to my home country (now in my 40s). I'm an only child. Never once asked my mum permission, because honestly, it's my life. I have always been welcoming to her for visits and I have tried to visit her when possible. I actually think it's lovely your mum is out there experiencing new places. Mine is just sitting at home retired, going to the pool every day and not leaving the house much. I'd love to know she was out there doing new and exciting things.

reluctantbrit · 20/07/2021 21:10

Discussing it would mean one party thinks they can influence the other.

When DH and I decided to move abroad my mum did a lot of negative talking to me, actively trying to discourage me.

Every large event or decision I made since then was affected by it, in the majority of times I didn’t say anything until everything was set in stone. She wanted to discuss, I felt like she wanted me to change my mind.

Your mum may have realised you would be more upset than supporting and therefore thought it is better to wait until the decision is being made.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 20/07/2021 21:09

I might be biased though. I didn't ask anyone how would they feel about me emigrating. I just told them I am emigrating and all planning went from there.

BuffySummersReportingforSanity · 20/07/2021 21:07

If she was upset at the idea that we couldn't see each other as much anymore, I'd suggest having a weekly call, or starting to write letters and be pen pals to have something exciting to look for in the post, or we could together look into how much flights are and if she could stay with me or if she'd need to find nearby accommodation. Not because I need to ask her permission, but because I care about her and would want to show that our relationship is important.

You can do that anyway, when you tell her you are going.

Look, you've seen from here that most people think you ABU. You've admitted yourself that the "asking" would be a completely empty gesture; you wouldn't be asking, you'd be telling. You've been quite clear that you wouldn't actually say "okay, I won't go" if they weren't happy, although now you've led your theoretical friend to think you might, and you've had confirmation that the vast majority of people wouldn't see it that way. So you can let it go, or you can continue to stew on your mum not having the same attachment as you to empty gestures. Your call.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 20/07/2021 21:07

The thing si when the decisoon haa been made there is really no "discussion".

Did you not talk about calls and how things will be in the months before she moved???

And sorry, bit there is a fine line between caringa nd controll and having this "I wasn't asked about it" so much on someone's mind is imho going into a control thing rather than care

HowManyToes · 20/07/2021 21:05

@salviapages

Honestly sometimes on mumsnet it feels like some people don't read the whole post before replying 😅 I'm happy to admit it seems like I am being over sensitive, and maybe it would unnecessary for me to tell people I care about beforehand if it was the other way around. But nowhere did I say she had to ask for my permission, I'm not THAT unreasonable!
The title of your post is literally “my mum SHOULD’VE ASKED ME” 🙄
Athinginitself · 20/07/2021 21:03

I dont think you are unreasonable. I'm 40 and definitely not in my mums pocket..she lives 2 hours away, but I'd be very hurt if she decided to move abroad without chatting to me about it first.

GnomeDePlume · 20/07/2021 21:02

When we moved abroad we didnt tell anyone until it was a done deal (job offer made).

DPiL were very positive when we told them. DM was devastated.

We carried on with the plan despite DM's upset. What would have been the point in starting DM's upset before we were certain we were going?

CambsAlways · 20/07/2021 20:57

I don’t think she has to run anything by you, they have made their decisions to move, why should she ask how would you feel if we moved away, would you expect her to stay if you told her you weren’t happy about it, I’d be happy that my mum was doing something that she wanted to do( both my parents have died) but I would never try and stand in their way, and throw a strop you are an adult aren’t you, you are being unreasonable,

salviapages · 20/07/2021 20:56

@CharleyChook

Maybe I am being unreasonable, sounds like I am

Yes. You have no say in your mums future happiness.

I don't mean to be argumentative but I really don't understand this attitude, and that of some other posters here. Like @ViceLikeBlip says she can't imagine doing that to her children.

No I don't get a say in what my mum does, she's an adult as am I and we don't have to consult each other on anything. But we're family and we care about each other. I had no say in whether she moved abroad (not that I would stop her) but surely as my mother she would care if I felt upset by it? Would want to discuss it with me?

Someone asked above why I would bother telling my best friend before I moved if how she reacted had no impact on my decision. But it would be to show I care. If she was upset at the idea that we couldn't see each other as much anymore, I'd suggest having a weekly call, or starting to write letters and be pen pals to have something exciting to look for in the post, or we could together look into how much flights are and if she could stay with me or if she'd need to find nearby accommodation. Not because I need to ask her permission, but because I care about her and would want to show that our relationship is important.

I can admit I'm being unreasonable that it still bothers me now a few years later. She probably knew I'd think it was a good idea. But I just don't get the attitude of 'you can do what you like and so does she and neither of you gets a say in it whatsoever' - this is not how I treat the people I care about

OP posts:
MyDogCalledMax · 20/07/2021 20:54

I think you’re being unreasonable for still being upset about it years later.

DeRigueurMortis · 20/07/2021 20:52

[quote salviapages]@DeRigueurMortis I think this is a good point, her moving away has left me to look after her own mother who is increasingly unable to do things for herself. She never asked me how I would feel being responsible for looking after her[/quote]

I think it's issues such as this that many posters don't consider (and to be fair you didn't include in your OP).

It's fine to live your own life, but when those decisions have consequences for other people, yes, asking is appropriate.

Otherwise it's up to her to put suitable care in place in conjunction with her mother.

IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves · 20/07/2021 20:51

You wanted your mum to ask you how you felt and if you were ok with it even though whatever you replied, she would have gone ahead and had she asked you if you were ok with it you would have said yes even if you actually didn't want her to go?

What would have been the point of her pretending that how you feel could change her plans and you pretending that you were fine with her plans if you weren't? Or you actually being fine but wanting her to ask anyway even though she didn't intend to base her decision on whether you were for it or against it?

I've confused myself even trying to figure it all out 😁.

It's like the
'how are you?
Fine thanks, you?
Fine' thing isn't it?

I don't want to know how you are but I'm going to ask and I don't want you to tell me.
I know you are only asking to be polite and I'm going to tell you I'm fine even though I'm not and I'll ask how you are even though I really don't want to know.
I'll tell you I'm also fine even though I'm not because I know that you don't want to know how I am any more than I want to know how you are.
Thank god this interaction is over, we have fulfilled our social obligation to make polite enquiries and we can go about our day. 😁

It's the symbolism of the question that matters.

Did I get it right? 😁

CharleyChook · 20/07/2021 20:48

Maybe I am being unreasonable, sounds like I am

Yes. You have no say in your mums future happiness.

ViceLikeBlip · 20/07/2021 20:46

I get that of course she didn't have to ASK permission etc. But still, I'd be really upset if my parent just sprang this on me, and I would have been even more devastated if I were only 24. I can't imagine ever doing this to my own kids.

Frankola · 20/07/2021 20:46

It could be that the decision was riding on the job offer?

I can't see the point in asking how you'd feel though. She obviously wanted to go because she didn't ask you how you felt or your permission (which, to clarify, she didn't need to).

What would you have expected her to do if you had said "I don't like the idea"?

You say you wouldn't have wanted her to stay for you but then what's the need for her to ask?

SchrodingersImmigrant · 20/07/2021 20:44

[quote salviapages]@DeRigueurMortis I think this is a good point, her moving away has left me to look after her own mother who is increasingly unable to do things for herself. She never asked me how I would feel being responsible for looking after her[/quote]
That's a totally different issue to just moving

Swipe left for the next trending thread