Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my mum should've asked me before moving abroad?

114 replies

salviapages · 20/07/2021 20:02

This happened a few years ago and I feel kind of petty for still thinking about it but it's really impacted the way I feel my mum views me.

A few years ago, my mum moved abroad with her partner. He'd applied for a job out there (she didn't tell me he was doing this) and after he accepted the job she rang me all excited and told me they were moving abroad in a few months time.

I was about 24 at the time and had been living with my partner and financially independent since I was 18 so it's not like I still relied on her. But we were quite close and saw each other regularly, a few times a month.

I just feel like she should have said 'partner is applying for this job, how would you feel if we moved away?' I never would have told her not to go but I just feel like she should've checked in to ask how I felt about my mum moving to another country. Is that unreasonable of me? She's an adult and can do what she likes and doesn't have to consult me. It just felt like she hadn't considered me

OP posts:
LillianGish · 21/07/2021 00:16

I’m astonished by some of the responses on this thread. I moved abroad myself when I got married, but talked about it with my parents beforehand. Now I’m getting to the stage where DH and I might do a foreign posting once the kids have left home - I wouldn’t dream of springing it on them out of the blue without talking about it first. I can’t imagine making a life-changing decision like that without talking to my family about it - not to give them the final say, but just to get their input and take their feelings into account. I don’t think you are being unreasonable at all - it does sound as if your mum hadn’t even considered you. I find that really odd.

toconclude · 21/07/2021 00:01

@tallduckandhandsome

I can see why you’re upset with being presented with a fait accompli.

And yet if the opposite had happened and you posted that you had done this to your parents, people would tell you YABU.

No they wouldn't.
Skysblue · 20/07/2021 23:58

If she was seeing you several times a month and suddenly ditched that to permanently move abroad without at least asking how you’d feel, then yes I think that’s hurtful.

I suspect she was worried you’d ask her not to go and she was avoiding dealing with her responsibility for hurting your feelings.

Yanbu.

LifesNotEnidBlyton · 20/07/2021 23:46

YANBU OP and I think how you feel is understandable. People are trying to say it like you wanted her to ask you if she could, but you're asking if she should have talked to you and asked what you thought and I think that's normal really. When you do something like move to another country most people talk about it with friends and family and ask what they think, not because they're aking if they can but becuase it's quite normal to be like "Oh this big thing might be happening in my life what do you think?". Most people would be a bit shocked if their mum said, without any backstory where you knew it might be happening, "I'm moving abroad!", some people on here are still living with adult kids and treating them like children at 24, so it's a bit harsh to say your mum isn't being unusual by not talking to you first to see what you thought, not if she could, but because most mums would want to talk about how much you think you could fly out to see her if she did and because she wants you to know about her life before it happens not when it's obviously been months in the making of just waiting to see if hed got the job and knowing they might be going.

olidora63 · 20/07/2021 23:32

As a mother I personally would never move away from my children but if they moved away I would be absolutely heartbroken but also understand why . Back in 1988 I decided to stay in Australia…my lovely Daddy gave me the heads up and said he was ok …he died suddenly…it was a very sad long trip home 😢

candycane222 · 20/07/2021 23:31

Well i think its odd she didn't twll you what they were planning/hoping to do, even though as you accept, you didn't actually have a say.

I felt a bit the same when my father remarried without telling me. Just - oddly secretive and a bit hurtful. I get what you feel OP.

WendyYourExcellency · 20/07/2021 23:28

I’ll go against the grain here. I would be very sad if my mum moved abroad. If it came out of the blue I would be hurt on top of sad.

What I would say though is that for me this comes out of a difficult relationship with my mum, where I feel anxious and seek her approval. I wonder if I felt more comfortable with her if I’d feel more relaxed about this hypothetical moving away, but part of me would sense it as a rejection. It doesn’t really matter if that’s unreasonable, it is how you feel. I think I would try to reflect more deeply on your feelings about this relationship to get to the bottom of this.

dappymonster · 20/07/2021 23:28

I haven't read all your replies but I kind get how you must feel. But I have small children so I do think I am more aware of lack of family around. My mum lives 2 hours from me and my brother, dad cousins all moved abroad. Not close by, China, America, Hong Kong, France is the closest. I have no family left except my mum and she's in her 60s. My husbands family all live at least 5 hours away over the Scotland / England border. It's been a lonely year for many and I suppose you're more aware of it after the year we have had. You must miss her, but I suppose it's her life and her choice. You're all grown up now I guess so she is free to make her own choices.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 20/07/2021 23:23

Tbf to the mum, the interview etc wasn't particularly her info to share, isn't it though.

Planty13 · 20/07/2021 23:20

I can’t vote cause I do get you. My
mum would LOVE to move away. And it would break my heart but I’d support her. However I know 100% she would talk me through the process as it was happening. She would want to know my feelings and they would matter and we would talk about them but I wouldn’t hold her back.
Your mum hasn’t communicated well. MN forgets people have attachments to their relatives sometimes so ignore that.

campion · 20/07/2021 23:12

@audweb

I hope when my kids in her twenties that I don’t have to ask permission to live my life. She told you in advance. What else did you want?! What if she had raised it as a possibility, would you have tried to persuade her to stay? Better just to tell you as a final decision.
She told OP when it was a done deal. OP would have liked to be part of the conversation before that because it has left her feeling insecure about how her DM actually feels about her. I can see why she'd feel that.

It's really not about asking permission or stopping anyone from living their life. It's about their relationship.

hellcatspangle · 20/07/2021 22:55

What would be the point of discussing it though? She'd made up her mind to go, so how you felt about it wouldn't have made any odds.

If I was planning to move abroad, I'd speak to my adult dc to let them know what I was planning but I wouldn't be looking for approval.

junebirthdaygirl · 20/07/2021 22:51

I think it's strange she didn't discuss it with you and not because she needed your permission but because you are an important part of her life. I understand how you feel.
Years ago my dh and l were moving across country and l was in counselling at the time. She advised me that it was so important that anyone impacted by our move be brought on board so that the whole thing was done well and there be no bad feelings. This was parents/ friends/ one auntie who lived nearby and depended on us a bit etc. Children were coming with us. We were still going but keeping everyone on side was hugely important to us. This proved wise as we moved back several years later and were able to take up where we left off.
I could not imagine us moving abroad without keeping our ..in their 20s..dc onside. They would be shocked.

audweb · 20/07/2021 22:47

I hope when my kids in her twenties that I don’t have to ask permission to live my life. She told you in advance. What else did you want?! What if she had raised it as a possibility, would you have tried to persuade her to stay? Better just to tell you as a final decision.

Colourmylife1 · 20/07/2021 22:42

I clicked YABU but I would definitely consult my adult offspring if a move overseas was on the cards. Of course your DM doesn’t need your permission but it would be nice if she had discussed it with you. I understand why you would feel hurt.

HotPenguin · 20/07/2021 22:36

Realise I'm in a minority here but I would feel the same, if you are close to someone, a member of your family, you don't expect them to just up and leave. Especially your parents, they should be there for you. We have some family members abroad, it means there are fewer people to turn to in an emergency, fewer to help babysit, and of course we hardly see them. It totally changes the relationship and makes things harder when you have kids.

Just10moreminutesplease · 20/07/2021 22:29

I don’t think YABU OP. I’d be really upset if my mum did this and wouldn’t contemplate moving that far away from my child, even if he was an adult.

(If he wants to move away that’s fine, but it feels different to choose to leave him.)

Notmoresugar · 20/07/2021 22:22

YANBU
Your DM didn't consider your feelings at all and IMO handled it in a very tactless and emotionally inept way.

PlasticDinosaur · 20/07/2021 22:08

I'd be gutted. It's a big deal and deserves talking through with those 'left behind'. No she doesn't need your permission but that's not really how I read your post. Child or adult we have a responsibility towards the emotional health of our children.

Bagamoyo1 · 20/07/2021 22:02

YANBU.
I’d be very upset if my Mum arranged a massive change like that, and announced it as a done deal. I’d expect her to running he idea past me first, partly to gauge my opinion, and also to give me warning. I’d do the same for her. It’s what you do with people you love and are close to.

IncessantNameChanger · 20/07/2021 22:01

Mil moved abroad over a decade ago. What gets to me is that she presumed so much and didnt discuss the presumptions with us.

She presumed we would fly over every year in school time ( she was back here over the summer).

She presumed she could live with us for three months of the year as a base without helping to buy her food, to cook ever or clean up after herself.

She presumes that once she needs the NHS, gets infirm, runs out of cash she will live with us.

So if your mum is like my mil steamroller I dont think yabu at all. Each one of her presumptions when pulled up on has caused her much distress and tantrums. She didnt think it through, didnt discus with us but insists we accommodate her 100%

It wouldnt be as bad if your mum expects nothing like the above unless I'd worth you first?
My mil also had a fit when I wanted to sell my house. She needs her backup plan. She is living her best life ever so hats off to her but all of her presumptions haven't been accommodated. God know I might want to emergrate myself

Abhannmor · 20/07/2021 21:56

I think I know how you feel , as a parent. Can you get over there to see her often Enough?

Spidey66 · 20/07/2021 21:55

I'm going against the grain here.

She didn't need to ask permission, no, but I would have thought she'd discuss it with you first. Again her decision but tbh your opinions would have been appreciated.

Sometimes I think MN is some kind of parallel universe. This is her Mum, not the woman who works in Tesco.

FrownedUpon · 20/07/2021 21:53

YABU. You really need to move on. I don’t understand why this is still upsetting you.

WildRunner · 20/07/2021 21:51

I have a bit of sympathy here, OP. It's not about permission, it's about the impact on those left behind.

My mum also moved abroad - no problem with that whatsoever. I do however have a problem with the fact she then instantly announced she was never coming back to the UK, so the onus, cost, and holiday allowance impact falls to everyone else except her. She constantly slags off the UK, and makes up stories about it. And has done no planning whatsoever about how care is managed as she gets older. There is very little social care or infrastructure where she is.

So moving abroad is not the issue as far as I can see. It's expecting everyone else to deal with the consequences that's the real problem.

I am possibly projecting though Wink

Swipe left for the next trending thread