Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have chosen not to send him

68 replies

tarapinn · 20/07/2021 15:41

Sponsored walk today for year 7 at school. 4 hours duration between 10-2. 30 degrees. They sent an email out last night saying lots of the walk is in the open but they would also be stopping for plenty of shaded rests.

He was getting texts today from friends saying they were 'dying' 😄

I chose to keep ds at home.
My mum thinks I should have sent him.

Who is being unreasonable?

OP posts:
Sunshineandflipflops · 21/07/2021 08:56

I love the sun and my kids are used to going on holiday in the sun but being on holiday where you can cool down easily (pool/sea) and just chill when you need to is different to walking for 4 hours in the midday sun. My ds walks home from school and has been getting home dripping with sweat. That's about 30 mins walking. I have been picking him up when I can in this weather as it's not fun.

Mumoftwoinprimary · 21/07/2021 08:46

@DroopyClematis

I'm just wondering what some posters do on holiday in Cyprus, Greece and southern Spain. Probably stay in their hotel rooms all day, every day.
We spend the morning in the pool. We have sun beds in the shade. We have lunch in an air conditioned dining room and then go and sit in a shady cafe and play games. Then we go to the beach and swim in the sea. From about 4pm the kids play on the beach. If we want to go for a walk we do it at about 6pm.

It is pretty easy to have a lovely holiday whilst avoiding being silly in the sun.

Thebookswereherfriends · 21/07/2021 08:38

The other difference between children in these hotter countries is that they have some acclimatisation to the heat. Here in the UK we get the odd week where the heat is like this and then the rest of the time it’s either chilly or bearable.

warmfluffytowels · 21/07/2021 08:32

YANBU.

People talking about Portugal or Australia are missing the point. Kids in those countries have PE first thing in the morning and don't go and sit in the midday sun, let alone go for a long walk in it Hmm

People die every year from heatstroke and dehydration in this country - and it really doesn't need to be that hot either. The same applies for dogs and another animals.

Nohomemadecandles · 21/07/2021 08:26

In hot countries they are sensible enough to do their strenuous exercise NOT at the hottest point of the day.
There becomes a point where stoicism turns to insanity

brokenbiscuitsx · 21/07/2021 08:10

People have died on hikes in hot weather in Northern European countries. Dehydration and heat injury are real things.

Very fit, military people too.

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 21/07/2021 08:09

We lived in Cyprus for two years.
School was 7.30- 1pm
The playground was shaded
PE was done first thing.
Sports day was in March
We had air conditioning

People have died on hikes in hot weather in Northern European countries. Dehydration and heat injury are real things.

Qwerty789 · 21/07/2021 08:04

@DroopyClematis

I'm just wondering what some posters do on holiday in Cyprus, Greece and southern Spain. Probably stay in their hotel rooms all day, every day.
Of course we don't stay in our hotel rooms all day...neither do we walk for 4 hours at the height of the day!
Qwerty789 · 21/07/2021 08:03

@IBelieveInAThingCalledScience

Portuguese, Spanish, Italian, Australian kids wouldn't do much for about 7 months of the year!

If they had sunscreen/hats on,.plenty of water and rest breaks they'd be fine!

You wouldn't find Australian or Spanish schools doing a 4 hr walk in the hottest part of the day either. Hmm
brokenbiscuitsx · 21/07/2021 08:01

@junebirthdaygirl

Surely children in hotter countries are more used to the high temps and don't just go from regular to 4 hours in scorching sunshine in one day. My nephew was visiting us from a very hot area and played golf in middle of the day in very strong heat. He got sunstroke! My ds who rarely had been in such heat was fine. There will be some fine and others could actually be quite sick. A four hour walk is quite long for a school group at a regular time but ridiculous in unusual heat wave and totally unnecessary.
I have family in a hot country, they can’t bear the heat here because it’s ‘wet’ and muggy and the sweat doesn’t evaporate off you properly. Whereas they are used to dry heat.

I mean, it’s true. 30 degrees here is so much worse than 30 degrees in Greece for example.

junebirthdaygirl · 21/07/2021 07:53

Surely children in hotter countries are more used to the high temps and don't just go from regular to 4 hours in scorching sunshine in one day. My nephew was visiting us from a very hot area and played golf in middle of the day in very strong heat. He got sunstroke! My ds who rarely had been in such heat was fine. There will be some fine and others could actually be quite sick. A four hour walk is quite long for a school group at a regular time but ridiculous in unusual heat wave and totally unnecessary.

brokenbiscuitsx · 21/07/2021 07:51
  • I was born and raised in Portugal and then moved to Australia where I lived for over a decade.

They are well educated about protecting their skin, staying hydrated and being sun smart.

Bearing in mind that temperatures in both countries can easily reach the 40 degrees in the summer, people still get on with their normal life and children play outside and engage in sports.*

Yeah, difference is they’re used to the heat, their bodies are acclimatised.

What don’t people understand about this, Britain is a Northern European country. Look at where it is, if it wasn’t for the Gulf Stream too we’d be a lot colder!

Saying people who are used to the heat, are, used to the heat isn’t the flex you think it is.

brokenbiscuitsx · 21/07/2021 07:48

In the 90s my class did a similar walk but in freezing temperatures. We had to wear PE kit and the girls were only allowed our netball skirts on. Two girls collapsed, one on the walk (an ambulance was called) and another in the changing rooms. As I was a child I had no idea what followed but imagine lots of parents complained. Mine were horrified.

Can’t believe this crap is still going on.

Manista · 21/07/2021 07:09

Children in hot countries are acclimatised, it's that simple. We've experienced sudden changes in weather and temperature in a short space of time. The two situations aren't the same.

Micemakingclothes · 21/07/2021 00:48

I would keep my child home, but that is because the school has already shown they can’t be trusted to keep her safe from severe asthma attacks during physical activities.

She goes to other places and enjoys time outdoors, even in group activities without us, but unlike at her school, has real opportunities for breaks and is never pressured to keep going when she needs one.

Sparklfairy · 21/07/2021 00:46

I've always hated sponsored walks, they seem cruel when there are other ways to raise money. Can't believe schools still do them tbh. I was really shy and had to go begging friends and family for money which was so embarrassing, and then have to walk 10 miles for the priviledge!

However, ours was always end of September when the weather was much cooler which seemed sensible.

tarapinn · 21/07/2021 00:41

I do appreciate that children in hot countries just get on with it. They kind of have to seeing as it's this hot for months there.
But this is just one day. It's not necessary. He wasn't learning anything and we will make a donation instead of sponsorship money.
I would have hated doing it and so would he.

OP posts:
Skysblue · 21/07/2021 00:00

Yanbu. I kept mine at home for the same reason, she was supposed to do 4 hrs of PE in a field with no shade. No way.

Kids have died from dehydration and heat exhaustion on school exercises more than once. Trust your judgement. Particularly on a day when the government told everyone in South England to try to stay out of the sun 11am-3pm. Do the school not read the news?? Or perhaps their timetable is more important.

JoborPlay · 20/07/2021 23:29

@DroopyClematis

I'm just wondering what some posters do on holiday in Cyprus, Greece and southern Spain. Probably stay in their hotel rooms all day, every day.
I don't holiday in these temperatures. I prefer to go late or early in the season when temperatures are low 20s. So I can enjoy doing stuff.
IBelieveInAThingCalledScience · 20/07/2021 23:10

I was born and raised in Portugal and then moved to Australia where I lived for over a decade.

School aged children do not have a mid day break. That's just not true.

They are well educated about protecting their skin, staying hydrated and being sun smart.

Bearing in mind that temperatures in both countries can easily reach the 40 degrees in the summer, people still get on with their normal life and children play outside and engage in sports.

ChocolateFlamingo · 20/07/2021 22:54

Pffft! I sweat my tits off just walking out my front door to my car!!Grin
I wouldn't have sent my DC in either so YANBU

FangsForTheMemory · 20/07/2021 22:17

@IBelieveInAThingCalledScience In Spain, Portugal and Italy they also have a long break in the middle of the day when they stay in the shade!

melj1213 · 20/07/2021 22:12

@IBelieveInAThingCalledScience

Portuguese, Spanish, Italian, Australian kids wouldn't do much for about 7 months of the year!

If they had sunscreen/hats on,.plenty of water and rest breaks they'd be fine!

Nobody is saying that they shouldn't do any physical activity, just maybe make sure it is appropriate to the weather conditions.

I used to live in Spain and my DD (and every other child) did PE and sports ... just not during the hottest part of the day.

At my DDs school PE was only scheduled for thr first periods of the day (8.45-10.30) or the afternoon (3-5pm) . The only exceptions were for classes/lunchtime extracurriculars that happened indoors. Additionally the sports courts were all built with the heat in mind (plenty of shade, access to water etc)

DroopyClematis · 20/07/2021 21:26

I'm just wondering what some posters do on holiday in Cyprus, Greece and southern Spain.
Probably stay in their hotel rooms all day, every day.

IBelieveInAThingCalledScience · 20/07/2021 20:52

Portuguese, Spanish, Italian, Australian kids wouldn't do much for about 7 months of the year!

If they had sunscreen/hats on,.plenty of water and rest breaks they'd be fine!

Swipe left for the next trending thread