Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask if this is cultural appropriation or appreciation?

192 replies

HappyDays40 · 20/07/2021 10:23

Ever since the death of George Floyd and the Black Lives Matter movement came into a more public sphere in the UK. Im looking at the world in a different way. Trying to consciously notice things that I may have said in the past which although I thought were showing an interest in other cultures are now termed as micro aggressions as they "other" people and reinforce that white as the default "normal".
An example of this is " where are you from?" Although this was not said with an aggressive tone I totally cringe when my friend looked at me pointedly and said Manchester. What I was asking about was her cultural heritage and I could have worded this better and won't do it again.
I also realise now what the terms white privilege and white savoiur mean. In the past I have spoken up for my friend if they have been abused and have taken charge when my friend has been perfectly able to speak for themselves. I am learning to stand with not stand on behalf of people unless they ask me to.
Its my responsibility to reflect and thinksnthings through not for people to educate me. Yes it makes me feel uncomfortable facing myself and questioning my past actions but I feels its the only way for change. So here is the AIBU bit: My son has a Carribean themed day at school today the children have gone in in themed clothes yellows, reds and greens. The children have been learning Bob Marley songs and generally all about different Carribean foods and cultures which I think I have felt okay with.
This morning when I took him in Reggae msuci was blasting forth from the speakers and the teachers who are white were outside welcoming the children in.

The children were having a great time. There are some children in the class who are black and one dad took one look at the whole thing dropped his child off and as we walked out he said he is going to complain to the school as this is cultural appropriation. I dont know him so I couldn't ask him about it and Im trying ro get my own thoughts in order.What do you guys think?

OP posts:
BrozTito · 20/07/2021 12:45

Again, the US isnt made up of 15 different countries, and theres more culture in a tramps hat

Greenrubber · 20/07/2021 12:44

@EssentialHummus

I picked Italy because it isn't a race

So if you are white everything seems to be stereotyping but if you are dark your clearly being racist!

But it isn't necessarily is it being racist but everyone jumps straight on it

Ozgirl75 · 20/07/2021 12:41

Agree @VladmirsPoutine - people ask me sometimes and if I feel like chatting I’ll say “Sydney but originally from X in the U.K.” but if I’m not I’ll just say “Sydney”.

Greenrubber · 20/07/2021 12:40

@BrozTito

OK take American then lots of different cultures there

But if the teachers let the kids eat hotdogs wear cowboy hats and America flags would you see that as racist?

Alot of history is disgusting if we can't move forward how do we get out the other side?

VladmirsPoutine · 20/07/2021 12:39

Wrt "Where are you from" I have found it's quite easy to discern someone's intentions. If you were 16 then there's really no need to castigate yourself for it years later. I have this question a lot - some people I just say "London" and leave it at that because I just don't want to talk about my heritage but with some others I'm happy to explain I'm from XYZ. It's really all circumstantial.

plodalong12 · 20/07/2021 12:39

@BrozTito

plod Im 31, i think it was on the national curriculum at the time maybe? think it was in year 6, I went to school in driffield
Ah ok, I’m 3 years older than you and not in Driffield but the national curriculum thing makes sense!
worktrip · 20/07/2021 12:37

OP. Yes, 16 year olds can be forgiven lol

EssentialHummus · 20/07/2021 12:36

green - If that was all Italy Day consisted of I'd be minded to have a word with the school - this in itself is stereotyping (not least because "Italian" isn't a race, afaik), but it reflects something about the culture/things we easily associate with Italy imo. You'd hope the school then put a bit of life into the stereotype by explaining anything from the Romans to the history of pizza to a few Italian words/phrases to family life in Italy or whatever.

choccohoopz · 20/07/2021 12:33

On the Simpsons thing, wasn't every single character stereotyped? Lazy, dumb, fat American male, subservient wife at home, smart girl child, naughty boy child, nasty, rich white man.. that argument seems redundant.

The only way this might possibly be justified by the school if they are doing a 'holiday to the Caribbean day'. The holiday resorts really do go with the stereotype but I'm guessing this isn't what they are doing.

Wouldn't be a bad way to end the year though! And they could have done a world trip thing instead which would have been fun, but also probably problematic.

Partin · 20/07/2021 12:31

How old are the kids here? Primary I’m guessing? How would you have liked the teacher to summarise 700 islands in a way that would still be engaging to kids and not just a list of facts? Maybe the teacher played calypso straight after reggae followed by other genres of Caribbean music? How many do they need to play before it stops being culturally insensitive? How many poets? How many different foods?
I think this is teachers trying to do something fun at the end of term here , would you rather they just stuck a PowerPoint or video up? I would hope they’d try and give some context as to WHY there is such diversity there but past that I think you are asking a lot.

And I know there’s not the same history here, but I can’t believe anyone would be offended by American kids having an English day where they learnt about the queen some iconic London buildings and drank tea. And I’m a northerner who hates the London centric attitude of this country. I’d expect more from highschool age but it’s just a bit of fun for kids.

BrozTito · 20/07/2021 12:26

Is italy made up of 15 countries?

BrozTito · 20/07/2021 12:25

Awa- i dont recall the scottish being layed flat like cargo on disease ridden ships to go live there as slaves. Though scots did play a massive part in that industry to the carribean. Possibly theey may feel a bit annoyed about that.

Greenrubber · 20/07/2021 12:25

If they had an Italy day
Served pizza to everyone
Kids wore the colours of the flag
Hung flags
And played pavarotti

Would this be racist or stereotyping?
Because there's no difference

I think some people are easily offended and its why we are in such a weird no body knows how to respond to anything attitude!

Was the offended parent Caribbean? Or of Caribbean mix?
You said you felt uncomfortable why?

I apologise I've not read the entire thread but it would be interesting to see any actual Caribbean people who can tell us why it's racist and not presume we are bing racist because someone was offended

Ozanj · 20/07/2021 12:24

@OneTC

The fact people were in uproar about Apu yet Groundskeeper Willie (who is taken the piss out of all the time and mocked relentlessly because of his nationality) seems to be OK? Double standards really.

And virtually no Scottish people gave a fuck either, then some people seemed to get retroactively offended when they realised other people were

The problem with Apu was never that he was Indian or a stereotype. It was that Hank Azaria, a white man, was putting on an Indian accent to play him. When you consider India’s colonialist past and how many actors with real Indian accents are trying to compete for what little acting work there is, it is racist and disgusting. Racist because as always Hollywood lets a white actor shove himself into any role while actors of colour often have to wait for an advertisement that specifies their race. Disgusting because it wasn’t even an attempt at an authentic Indian accent (and this is why Azaria was forced to apologise) it was the white man’s stereotype of one. When you consider his background I just can’t believe he thought it acceptable to accept the role.
EssentialHummus · 20/07/2021 12:18

I agree with singingsands - wait and see how the rest of the day panned out. It's near the end of term, everyone is absolutely knackered; if anything does need addressing I'd raise it next time they announce Caribbean Day (or whatever) and suggest a few things that might be done differently, and perhaps offer some practical help if you can.

I'm a white-passing ethnic minority who was born in one African country and grew up in another. I think it's quite easy to distinguish curiosity/making conversation from racism/stereotype.

BrozTito · 20/07/2021 12:17

plod Im 31, i think it was on the national curriculum at the time maybe? think it was in year 6, I went to school in driffield

RaindropsOnRosie · 20/07/2021 12:14

It's not cultural appropriation, it seems more like racism. It's sterotyping all people from the carribean to be rastas who listen to popular reggae (Most reggae they played probably would've only been the stuff popular in England). There's a lot of negative stereotypes regarding rasta culture and I can't imagine they were discussing those.

Whether the teachers or children were white or otherwise, it could have been a much more thoughtful day of appreciating all Carribean culture, not just the culture white people like.

angstriddenhipster · 20/07/2021 12:13

Hmm to buck the trend here, I don't think that it is inappropriate to play reggae on a Caribbean theme day. It's the most famous musical genre to come out of the islands. Assuming that there are other aspects of the day, then I think this is perfectly appropriate.

Getting kids to dress up in Rastafarian colours is definitely off though.

Greenrubber · 20/07/2021 12:09

It's not racist! Come on its stereotyping with a bit of ignorance thrown in but it's not racist

OneTC · 20/07/2021 12:07

The fact people were in uproar about Apu yet Groundskeeper Willie (who is taken the piss out of all the time and mocked relentlessly because of his nationality) seems to be OK? Double standards really.

And virtually no Scottish people gave a fuck either, then some people seemed to get retroactively offended when they realised other people were

Wondergirl100 · 20/07/2021 12:07

We have a lot of Jamaican / heritage children in our school and they are often in school wearing Jamaican colours etc - talking about Jamaica and reggea and the food and the love of cricket there - they would love a day like this. My kids have one eastern european parent - they would love to talk about it on a 'day' if there was ever an east european day.

Wondergirl100 · 20/07/2021 12:06

Our school did an "africa' day recently and many children with african heritage really loved it - parents got involved cooking food, showing traditional dress. Now - on one level I think its very naff - i mean 'africa' - its like having 'europe' day it's ludicrous. But the kids loved it, it made them think about the big wide world they live in and the parents of african heritage were involved and got to show elements of their own culture.

I think caribbean day sounds fine - kids to take things in on a simplistic level

Snoozer11 · 20/07/2021 12:04

You're basing all of this on the few minutes (or seconds?) of Reggae music you heard before the school day had started.

MostlyMaple · 20/07/2021 12:03

@AwaAnBileYerHeid I agree with you completely, especially regarding Apu from The Simpsons. It is a cartoon and shouldn't be taken seriously. I was speaking with my husband about this actually, and pointed out the unfairness between some of the characters. The fact people were in uproar about Apu yet Groundskeeper Willie (who is taken the piss out of all the time and mocked relentlessly because of his nationality) seems to be OK? Double standards really.

SusannahSophia · 20/07/2021 12:03

Hmm, my DSes’ primary school used to do a country themed day every year. French day, dress as the Eiffel Tower, wear red, white and blue, dress as a garlic seller, eat baguettes, etc, Spanish day, dress in red and yellow, dress as a bull fighter, (my DS wore a white T shirt with a marker pen crap sketch of the Don Quixote drawing by Picasso) Indian day, saris and bindis, eating samosas and bhajis.

Basically they costumes and ‘celebrations’ were all really stereotyped. They were seen as a bit of a chore by the parents, like World Book Day, but generally enjoyed by the kids. A bit of a party day. They never did Germany day, though, but they did do a Scandinavia day. And Norway, Sweden, Finland and Denmark are different countries.

So I’d see Caribbean Day in a similar light. Stereotyped, a bit cringe, probably annoying for anyone from that region, but a bit of fun for the kids.

Swipe left for the next trending thread