Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask if this is cultural appropriation or appreciation?

192 replies

HappyDays40 · 20/07/2021 10:23

Ever since the death of George Floyd and the Black Lives Matter movement came into a more public sphere in the UK. Im looking at the world in a different way. Trying to consciously notice things that I may have said in the past which although I thought were showing an interest in other cultures are now termed as micro aggressions as they "other" people and reinforce that white as the default "normal".
An example of this is " where are you from?" Although this was not said with an aggressive tone I totally cringe when my friend looked at me pointedly and said Manchester. What I was asking about was her cultural heritage and I could have worded this better and won't do it again.
I also realise now what the terms white privilege and white savoiur mean. In the past I have spoken up for my friend if they have been abused and have taken charge when my friend has been perfectly able to speak for themselves. I am learning to stand with not stand on behalf of people unless they ask me to.
Its my responsibility to reflect and thinksnthings through not for people to educate me. Yes it makes me feel uncomfortable facing myself and questioning my past actions but I feels its the only way for change. So here is the AIBU bit: My son has a Carribean themed day at school today the children have gone in in themed clothes yellows, reds and greens. The children have been learning Bob Marley songs and generally all about different Carribean foods and cultures which I think I have felt okay with.
This morning when I took him in Reggae msuci was blasting forth from the speakers and the teachers who are white were outside welcoming the children in.

The children were having a great time. There are some children in the class who are black and one dad took one look at the whole thing dropped his child off and as we walked out he said he is going to complain to the school as this is cultural appropriation. I dont know him so I couldn't ask him about it and Im trying ro get my own thoughts in order.What do you guys think?

OP posts:
HappyDays40 · 20/07/2021 14:40

No I was merely saying that the teachers are white as I think this is relevant to the whole cultural appropriation/ appreciation discussion.

OP posts:
Whiskycav · 20/07/2021 14:35

the teachers who are white were outside welcoming the children in.
Who normally greets them? How many teachers of Caribbean heritage do they employ? Who should have met them?

I was wondering about this. Should it have bene only black teachers? Black teacher from the Caribbean area? If they have enough teachers of that background to greet all the children....it couldn't possibly be CA or even offensive.

Did op expect them to employ people from the right culture and right skin colour to stand at the doors?

MrsMop1964 · 20/07/2021 14:33

I get asked where I'm from quite a lot, but I'm a White English Muslim who wears hijab. Obviously hijab = foreign in some people's eyes.

SleepingStandingUp · 20/07/2021 14:30

However the Dad has every right to complain and that's for school to sort

SleepingStandingUp · 20/07/2021 14:30

the children have gone in in themed clothes yellows, reds and greens. i agree its a random choice to pick these colours over others. O suspect they though"Caribbean themed clothes" would lead to parents complaining about having to buy specific stuff

The children have been learning Bob Marley songs... did some poetry and language with one of the parents.... and generally all about different Carribean foods and cultures... a guy who lives locally who is from St. Kitts who does catering and he did some cooking wih them
unless you're saying that alll the language and poetry was also only from Jamaican culture, then it sounds like they're selected different aspects from different regions

Reggae msuci was blasting forth from the speakers they dont really have tome to play a song from every nation though so they've picked one. Which genre of music would you be comfortable with?

the teachers who are white were outside welcoming the children in.
Who normally greets them? How many teachers of Caribbean heritage do they employ? Who should have met them?

VladmirsPoutine · 20/07/2021 14:26

Using Bob Marley is strange. He wasn't a typical Jamaican. He was a relative of my husband who is white.

Can I ask what on earth does this even mean?

Whiskycav · 20/07/2021 14:21

@Iwantcauliflowercheese

Using Bob Marley is strange. He wasn't a typical Jamaican. He was a relative of my husband who is white.
And?
Cam77 · 20/07/2021 14:19

@toconclude
presenting them out of context.
That isn’t appropriation, it’s mild ignorance. It would only be appropriation if they were being purposeful presented out of context for profit.

Cam77 · 20/07/2021 14:15

@PingedAgain
Because it’s easier to revert to lazy stereotypes, and that is especially true where black cultures are the topic.
Not really. People in the UK generally have a reasonable knowledge of Europe and N.America due to reasons of culture, history, geographical proximity. For the same reason, people in China tend to have better cultural and historical knowledge of Japan and S.Korea than they do Australia. Nothing to do with race.

JonahofArk · 20/07/2021 14:14

[quote Greenrubber]@BrozTito

No I'm not! There are mixed race posters on this thread saying they don't find it offensive!
And you're saying it's offensive!

Your bringing racism into the pot and stirring it[/quote]
I'd just like to point out that just because one person of a particular ethnicity doesn't find something offensive does not mean that somebody else of that same ethnicity is not allowed to be offended by it.

Ethnic minorities are allowed to have differences of opinion just like any other group of people, so saying that other mixed race posters have said something is not racist and therefore it cannot be racist is not an acceptable argument.

SleepingStandingUp · 20/07/2021 14:14

So they've involved appropriate adults in the cooking and cultural aspects and made it about the whole Carribbean and actually learning about the different aspects?

But today they chose to play music from one part of the culture and so suddenly the whole thing is racist and inappropriate?

And you also 5hinl it was wrong they were greeted by white teachers? How many teachers with Caribbean culture do they have? Who should have met them?

toconclude · 20/07/2021 14:11

@Genderwitched

We'll it's a day to celebrate aspects of popular Carribbean culture, the school has not suddenly become Carribbean. So of course it's appreciation not appropriation.
That's not what appropriation means. Appropriation is lazy picking of other cultures' traditions and passing them off as one's own or presenting them out of context. What the school is doing may be well meaning but it's clumsy and inappropriate.
ThanksIGotItInMorrisons · 20/07/2021 14:06

I’m Scottish. And we have worn kilts. We do eat haggis- even if only on Burns night. And we do actually have bagpipes and some people do actually play them. I wore kilts when I was little. I think they’re incredibly cute. I actually think that they should bring kilts into schools here as uniform. That way everyone, boys girls and whatever’s’ are all wearing the same thing. I happen to think that kilts can be incredibly smart and handsome looking. I wouldn’t be offended by these stereotypes. I just don’t know what their is in that to be offended by?????

PingedAgain · 20/07/2021 14:06

If they were studying Russian culture it wouldn't be cultural appropriation if they listened to Russian folk dance tunes, or classical ballet music, would it?

I agree it’s not appropriation, but it’s lazy and reductive.

Why not Jamaican or Trinidadian or Guyanese folk tales, then? Or music other than reggae - Caribbean musical culture is SO rich? Or a focus on great figures from Caribbean nations other than Bob Marley? Because it’s easier to revert to lazy stereotypes, and that is especially true where black cultures are the topic.

Cam77 · 20/07/2021 14:06

If you want to rally learn about and understand a country then learn the language, or go and live there for a couple of months, or read a 1000 page book (or if in school, spend a whole term studying the history, geography etc). Anything else, including primary school Country X Days, is just a bit of fun. As long as there aren’t any offensive/demeaning stereotypes it’s all a mountain out of a mole hill.

JonahofArk · 20/07/2021 14:05

@blacksax

They've been studying the Caribbean as a topic in primary school for ages, my dd did it about 15 years ago. They looked at tourism (benefits and disadvantages), culture, food, all sorts. What's wrong with listening to some music typical of the region?

If they were studying Russian culture it wouldn't be cultural appropriation if they listened to Russian folk dance tunes, or classical ballet music, would it?

Seems to me that white people are considered to be in the wrong whatever they do.

The Caribbean is a region made up of many different nations each with their own history, culture and traditions. Comparing an entire region to one country is disingenuous.

It would be like a school in say Japan having a 'Europe' day and only focusing on England. It's lazy.

Iwantcauliflowercheese · 20/07/2021 14:04

Using Bob Marley is strange. He wasn't a typical Jamaican. He was a relative of my husband who is white.

PrincessNutella · 20/07/2021 14:04

Yes, it's hard to tell what they did all day long from what happened as they entered the school.

HappyDays40 · 20/07/2021 14:02

@ThanksIGotItInMorrisons why so angry? We are just having a conversation. I was just saying im trying to gather my thoughts. The dad who was angry used the term appropriation and it just me think about things and the terms we use.

OP posts:
JonahofArk · 20/07/2021 14:01

@AwaAnBileYerHeid

Would it be racist or cultural appropriation if the theme was Scotland and they played bagpipes, wore tartan kilts and had haggis for lunch? Or is it only certain races whose offence is catered to?
@AwaAnBileYerHeid

This whataboutery is hilarious to me.

First point: if you are concerned about the way that Scottish people are treated by the wider world then why don't you do something about it? The reason racism is such a big talking point at the moment is because those who suffer racism are spending day after day relentlessly campaigning for their rights. So if you are concerned about prejudice towards Scottish people then I'd suggest getting off your arse and doing something about it.

Second point: I would actually think that a Scottish day that just focused on bagpipes and haggis etc. was ill-thought and only focusing on stereotypes.

blacksax · 20/07/2021 14:00

They've been studying the Caribbean as a topic in primary school for ages, my dd did it about 15 years ago.
They looked at tourism (benefits and disadvantages), culture, food, all sorts. What's wrong with listening to some music typical of the region?

If they were studying Russian culture it wouldn't be cultural appropriation if they listened to Russian folk dance tunes, or classical ballet music, would it?

Seems to me that white people are considered to be in the wrong whatever they do.

Whiskycav · 20/07/2021 13:58

I am really surprised that a parent from that culture used the phrase 'cultural appropriation'.

Because its not. It only would have been if the school or teachers were trying to portray they were from one of these cultures, profit off it or make fun of it. CA is also pharae more used by very young people or white people, thinking they know.

But also because he clearly he isn't involved enough, to know wether what the school was doing was appropriate or not. He saw a tiny snippet.

Just seems an odd phrase to be used, loud enough for someone else to hear, when it's not the right word or and they donr know enough about it.

But @HappyDays40, if he is complaining you don't need to do anything unless he asked you to. He is complaining. He can speak for himself, if he wants people to support it he will speak up again.

ThanksIGotItInMorrisons · 20/07/2021 13:55

I’m amazed you have the ability to know what’s going on inside the school
Throughout the rest of the day, after only having experienced the first 5 minutes of their day. You don’t know what they’re being taught right now. You don’t know what they will learn today. I honestly think you need to get a grip. The school have consulted people of that heritage in their plans - obviously as they have authentic food , at the very least. Get a massive grip people. School cannot teach every single part of every single thing. You are perfectly entitled to follow up in this lesson at home should you wish to do so. Atop looking for bloody problems and issues on every goddam thing in the world. Cultural appreciation/ appropriation. Who really truly gives a shit?!? I like this thing therefore I wear /use/whatever this thing. What’s the ducking problem? Honestly. Stop shit stirring.

BiBabbles · 20/07/2021 13:42

I'd need to see and would likely ask for a wider picture of the day, that snapshot is a bit stereotypical (wouldn't really call it appropriation, but mostly because that term has become very blurry), but I could see how it could fit into a wider picture with primary age children where this sort of thing can be part of a set-up though these things will always have their limits.

With the 'where are you from'/'cultural heritage' question - yeah, your friend handled it great and as did you when you read her reaction quickly. We all make mistakes. For me, as a pp said, I've learned to read intent there quickly though from me you'd get very different answers depending on how you worded it. Where I'm from (or even where my parents are from or name or other ways people dance around it) doesn't say much about my cultural backgrounds.

Again, the US isnt made up of 15 different countries, and theres more culture in a tramps hat

No, it has a relationship somewhat similar as the UK does with its Crown dependency with hundreds of different nations within its borders.

Some have more official recognition than others, but if we're talking about reconsidering racist attitudes and everything, then what we consider a nation or culture might also be up for question too. It's actually a large part of the issues with 'Caribbean Days' and 'Africa Days' - it's not just the many different recognized nations, but the groups within them. Nation-states are a pretty weak way of defining any culture.

Culture is the ideas, customs, social behaviours, and creations of a group. That you look down on it doesn't mean a group doesn't have any of those.

Greenrubber · 20/07/2021 13:32

@BrozTito

No I'm not! There are mixed race posters on this thread saying they don't find it offensive!
And you're saying it's offensive!

Your bringing racism into the pot and stirring it

Swipe left for the next trending thread