Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask if this is cultural appropriation or appreciation?

192 replies

HappyDays40 · 20/07/2021 10:23

Ever since the death of George Floyd and the Black Lives Matter movement came into a more public sphere in the UK. Im looking at the world in a different way. Trying to consciously notice things that I may have said in the past which although I thought were showing an interest in other cultures are now termed as micro aggressions as they "other" people and reinforce that white as the default "normal".
An example of this is " where are you from?" Although this was not said with an aggressive tone I totally cringe when my friend looked at me pointedly and said Manchester. What I was asking about was her cultural heritage and I could have worded this better and won't do it again.
I also realise now what the terms white privilege and white savoiur mean. In the past I have spoken up for my friend if they have been abused and have taken charge when my friend has been perfectly able to speak for themselves. I am learning to stand with not stand on behalf of people unless they ask me to.
Its my responsibility to reflect and thinksnthings through not for people to educate me. Yes it makes me feel uncomfortable facing myself and questioning my past actions but I feels its the only way for change. So here is the AIBU bit: My son has a Carribean themed day at school today the children have gone in in themed clothes yellows, reds and greens. The children have been learning Bob Marley songs and generally all about different Carribean foods and cultures which I think I have felt okay with.
This morning when I took him in Reggae msuci was blasting forth from the speakers and the teachers who are white were outside welcoming the children in.

The children were having a great time. There are some children in the class who are black and one dad took one look at the whole thing dropped his child off and as we walked out he said he is going to complain to the school as this is cultural appropriation. I dont know him so I couldn't ask him about it and Im trying ro get my own thoughts in order.What do you guys think?

OP posts:
blubberyboo · 20/07/2021 16:10

I think schools do all these sorts of days as it’s the only way to really show kids that there are other cultures and types of counties without actually taking them there.
I wouldn’t say it is racist but it certainly is stereotyping as there is such a short window in a day you can’t show all areas of a country so they tend to pick out the stereotype stuff.
Eg
Irish days or st Patrick’s always comprise of lots of Green, big hats, leprechaun images and Irish stew or soda breads
French day is always baguettes etc
Spanish day the usual dancing
Scottish Haggis and kilts
Danish pastries

There is so much more to these countries than this imagery so the Caribbean version is no different.
It’s a pity there just isn’t more time and knowledge to get more in-depth

JonahofArk · 20/07/2021 16:08

@Nengineer

I am racking my brains to remember the educational aspects to the Norting Hill Festival. Do they also meet in silence and watch videos about colonialism? Thought not.
Notting Hill Festival is not an educational event that is run by a school. Stop being ridiculous.
Nengineer · 20/07/2021 16:05

I am racking my brains to remember the educational aspects to the Norting Hill Festival. Do they also meet in silence and watch videos about colonialism? Thought not.

paddlingon · 20/07/2021 16:04

@JonahofArk I'm not saying that the school was totally right in its approach.
I think involving parents more is sensible and would avoid these difficulties.

I do think that "days" can be valuable however even if they are just stereotypical snapshots. Which is one of the things being discussed.

JonahofArk · 20/07/2021 16:02

@Getawaywithit

In this particular instance, it could be argued that a focus on all the lovely aspects of the Caribbean (the food, music and etc), without also spending time teaching the children about windrush etc. is unacceptable because it completely ignores a significant aspect of the contemporary experience of Caribbean people in the UK. School is about education after all

so, in your opinion, what should have happened in those 10 minutes or so as the children arrived at school? No music? Children should have arrived at school on Caribbean Day and be greeted in exactly the same way as they are normally? What music would have been appropriate? Should it have been sombre to reflect the experiences of Afro-Caribbean people in the UK? Or should it have been....someone like Bob Marley, a globally reveered musician from Jamaica, a Caribbean country?

How do you know these children were not taught anything at all during the day about Windrush? Because the school played Bob Marley for 10 minutes in the morning and had white teachers greet the children?

You're right, I don't know how the school ran the event, but I do know that if I was a parent there I would be asking some questions about it.
Greenrubber · 20/07/2021 16:01

@CastawayQueen

But why now is it deemed as inappropriate when it doesn't mean anything other than that person likes that style?

We take things from all over the world we share food, music, clothes etc why can't a white people have the braids in question but a black person can dye their hair blonde and make it straight instead of keeping their natural afro hair and no one cares?
Personally I think it's your hair do whatever you want with it I just don't see that as anything else

I know I'm coming off topic I don't mean to I just feel racism is being pushed and we should be trying to stop it (impossible I know) but it's like we are finding new things all the time to top stuff up and we are missing the bigger picture

Getawaywithit · 20/07/2021 15:59

In this particular instance, it could be argued that a focus on all the lovely aspects of the Caribbean (the food, music and etc), without also spending time teaching the children about windrush etc. is unacceptable because it completely ignores a significant aspect of the contemporary experience of Caribbean people in the UK. School is about education after all

so, in your opinion, what should have happened in those 10 minutes or so as the children arrived at school? No music? Children should have arrived at school on Caribbean Day and be greeted in exactly the same way as they are normally? What music would have been appropriate? Should it have been sombre to reflect the experiences of Afro-Caribbean people in the UK? Or should it have been....someone like Bob Marley, a globally reveered musician from Jamaica, a Caribbean country?

How do you know these children were not taught anything at all during the day about Windrush? Because the school played Bob Marley for 10 minutes in the morning and had white teachers greet the children?

JonahofArk · 20/07/2021 15:59

@paddlingon

My dc go to an international school. In primary school one of the most popular days was international day, many of the parents run stalls promoting their countries heritage, there are over 30 of them.

I ran the Scotland stand one year.
We had all the things that Scotland is famous for.
Yes on one hand they are stereotypical but on the other hand Highland Cows are actually Scottish, so is shortbread.
Dc and parents learned our national animal is the Unicorn.

My dc learned basic things about other countries and tried common foods from them.

Did they end up with a detailed knowledge of the history and current issues in these countries, no they didn't.

But they realized that different countries value different things, eat different food, have different flags, dance different ways and have different landscapes.

It is a lot of work for the parents, it takes weeks of planning but it one of the most popular days in school calendar.

But that's the whole point-the event at your DC's school focuses on giving a snapshot of different countries' traditions-there's nothing wrong with that. The OP is talking about something else. The Caribbean is a region not a country. Do you think that England represents Europe for example?

I find it interesting that you are happy to make the distinction between Scotland and the rest of the UK but not between the numerous separate countries that make up the Caribbean.

paddlingon · 20/07/2021 15:59

Got distracted by squabbling dc.

So for this school the solution is for the school to request parental support for running these things.

My school has a multi cultural committee with parental involvement. Then you either get involved so you are happy with what is happening or you lose your right to complain about others who are leaning in.

paddlingon · 20/07/2021 15:53

My dc go to an international school.
In primary school one of the most popular days was international day, many of the parents run stalls promoting their countries heritage, there are over 30 of them.

I ran the Scotland stand one year.
We had all the things that Scotland is famous for.
Yes on one hand they are stereotypical but on the other hand Highland Cows are actually Scottish, so is shortbread.
Dc and parents learned our national animal is the Unicorn.

My dc learned basic things about other countries and tried common foods from them.

Did they end up with a detailed knowledge of the history and current issues in these countries, no they didn't.

But they realized that different countries value different things, eat different food, have different flags, dance different ways and have different landscapes.

It is a lot of work for the parents, it takes weeks of planning but it one of the most popular days in school calendar.

JonahofArk · 20/07/2021 15:49

@CastawayQueen your comment about the hair braiding is spot on.

VladmirsPoutine · 20/07/2021 15:46

I think on this site short of someone calling someone else the n-word, or literally waving nazi flags outside their house a lot of posters wouldn't 'see' racism. And even then there'd be some 'devil advocates'. Maybe the nazi flag waver was having a bad day!?!

CastawayQueen · 20/07/2021 15:42

Also to add - braiding itself is not an issue every culture with long haired women has braided their hair with beads

CastawayQueen · 20/07/2021 15:41

[quote Greenrubber]@JonahofArk

If course everyone can have their own opinion but telling people this is racist is not right either? Is it?

I'm asking why people find it racist and no one is saying why they feel that it is? Just delving back into the history but that isn't relevant to this thread the thread is about a kids class

So please tell me where the racism is because all I see is ignorance and stereotyping

I have had my hair braided (long time ago) but apparently that's cultural appropriation or some shit now a days actually no I didn't offend anyone back then and I wasn't doing it to be horrible or rude or any other reason other than it was fashionable at that time

I'm scottish so I think if an English person was to be offended by a stereotyping of a Scottish person and I wasn't I would think that it was rediculous

We don't know who is on this thread or what colour they are but unless they are from that culture why are we being offended by something we don't know would even offend them?[/quote]
I think the point about braiding is that hairstyles suitable for the hair of certain ethnicities was deemed unprofessional/unkempt when it was just their natural hair. Of course it was a bit galling that it came to be accepted as ‘trendy’ when white people did it….

Greenrubber · 20/07/2021 15:40

@JonahofArk

Sorry I know you didn't say it but it has been said previously on this thread that's why I mentioned it

I just can't see it myself

Fangsalot89 · 20/07/2021 15:38

@ChainJane

How is it racist? Surely reggae music is a huge musical part of the Caribbean (or at least I remember it being from the various trips I’ve taken.)

SleepingStandingUp · 20/07/2021 15:34

@HappyDays40

No I was merely saying that the teachers are white as I think this is relevant to the whole cultural appropriation/ appreciation discussion.
So they needed a Jamaican person present to play Reggae? Or just any token black person? Are you generally concerned about the lack of diversity in the staff team or just think we should only celebrate or learn about stuff we have a cultural link to?
JonahofArk · 20/07/2021 15:33

[quote Greenrubber]@JonahofArk

But where is the racism in this?

Why is it being brought up?[/quote]
I didn't say it was racist-but again, that's only my opinion. However, I do think it's lazy and cliched.

I think the most important thing is that people are having these sort of discussions more regularly, and are talking things through as this thread demonstrates. I have these sort of discussions on a regular basis IRL, and I have noticed that when I am speaking to a white person about this sort of thing, there does seem to be a tendency for them to get very defensive. It really isn't necessary. These discussions are not personal attacks. It's about working together to create a society that can work for all-it's that simple.

Greenrubber · 20/07/2021 15:24

@JonahofArk

But where is the racism in this?

Why is it being brought up?

JonahofArk · 20/07/2021 15:16

[quote Greenrubber]@JonahofArk

If course everyone can have their own opinion but telling people this is racist is not right either? Is it?

I'm asking why people find it racist and no one is saying why they feel that it is? Just delving back into the history but that isn't relevant to this thread the thread is about a kids class

So please tell me where the racism is because all I see is ignorance and stereotyping

I have had my hair braided (long time ago) but apparently that's cultural appropriation or some shit now a days actually no I didn't offend anyone back then and I wasn't doing it to be horrible or rude or any other reason other than it was fashionable at that time

I'm scottish so I think if an English person was to be offended by a stereotyping of a Scottish person and I wasn't I would think that it was rediculous

We don't know who is on this thread or what colour they are but unless they are from that culture why are we being offended by something we don't know would even offend them?[/quote]
Why wouldn't it be right to say that this is racist if that was the case?

I disagree with you that the history should not be the focus because it's a kids' class-that is exactly why it should be a focus-it's education.

In terms of your hair braids-how do you know that they didn't offend anybody? Maybe they did but they just didn't tell you?

It's perfectly acceptable for you to think something is ridiculous, just like it's perfectly acceptable for somebody else to be deeply offended by the same situation.

For what it's worth, the reason that cultural appropriation (which I actually don't think is what happened here) is such a hot button issue at the moment is because it is directly linked to racism. Basically it smacks of people taking from and appropriating aspects of other peoples' cultures that they deem palatable and acceptable, without addressing the rampant racism (both historical and contemporary) that people from those cultures continue to face. That's my understanding of it anyway.

In this particular instance, it could be argued that a focus on all the lovely aspects of the Caribbean (the food, music and etc), without also spending time teaching the children about windrush etc. is unacceptable because it completely ignores a significant aspect of the contemporary experience of Caribbean people in the UK. School is about education after all.

Fairyliz · 20/07/2021 15:11

@orinocosfavoritecake

Yeah - first step of planning that sort of day should have been asking parents with Carribbean planning for advice.
But how do you do this? If you say you want to talk to them about the Caribbean they might say ‘I’m from Manchester’. It’s turned into a minefield, I’m so scared of saying the wrong thing I don’t say anything, but then that’s excluding people.
1forAll74 · 20/07/2021 14:52

I will just be a brief day of some things related to the Caribbean islands culture, as in the music and colourful clothes,and types of food etc. There will be no time for anything in depth to learn about. All other things relating to the Caribbean countries,and any other countries, have to be taught in general Geography and global lessons.

Greenrubber · 20/07/2021 14:51

@JonahofArk

If course everyone can have their own opinion but telling people this is racist is not right either? Is it?

I'm asking why people find it racist and no one is saying why they feel that it is? Just delving back into the history but that isn't relevant to this thread the thread is about a kids class

So please tell me where the racism is because all I see is ignorance and stereotyping

I have had my hair braided (long time ago) but apparently that's cultural appropriation or some shit now a days actually no I didn't offend anyone back then and I wasn't doing it to be horrible or rude or any other reason other than it was fashionable at that time

I'm scottish so I think if an English person was to be offended by a stereotyping of a Scottish person and I wasn't I would think that it was rediculous

We don't know who is on this thread or what colour they are but unless they are from that culture why are we being offended by something we don't know would even offend them?

Whiskycav · 20/07/2021 14:44

@HappyDays40

No I was merely saying that the teachers are white as I think this is relevant to the whole cultural appropriation/ appreciation discussion.
You said the teacher who are white were greeting them.

Teachers greet kids on a morning.

Regardless of their skin colour. Did you not expect then to greet the children that day because they are white?

I really don't see the relevance of pointing out the skin colour if who was there, greeting the kids

Do you just mean 'the teachers are white'. I, mean doesn't mean they can't be from Carribean as well. But isn't that why they got people from the cultures they are exploring in, to support? Because they are not from those cultures?

TabithaTap · 20/07/2021 14:42

We can’t possibly know because we don’t know what was taught.

Rastafarianism should be covered because it is a religion that comes from Jamaica, and not that many countries globally have created new religions, so it is of high cultural significance.

Swipe left for the next trending thread