Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not wanting DH to live away for work

167 replies

MisterMeaner · 20/07/2021 09:03

DH (20 years married) is currently job hunting. He has found a job that will require him to live away from home for at least a couple of nights a week. I think that this is likely to expand into most of the week - effectively making him a weekend DH. We currently have a very close, loving relationship with two children in early teens. He's always worked long hours, occasionally needed to be away for a week now and then, but never been away from home overnight routinely.

I can think of four relationships off the top of my head where a couple lived separately for work purposes, and every one of them ended in the marriage failing or coming under massive stress. I can't think of an example of this arrangement where the marriage has thrived.

AIBU to think that this could be a really dangerous move, in terms of our relationship? I'd be interested to hear others' experiences.

OP posts:
warmfluffytowels · 20/07/2021 13:25

It's true that we don't make choices in a vacuum.

So living in an expensive area might be beneficial in some ways (like you say, lots of jobs and family support) but you have to balance those benefits with the negative side which is often long hours, a long commute and a poor work/life balance.

Some people would rather trade some of their free time for job security and family support. Others would rather earn less money elsewhere and have more free-time to spend as a couple or a family.

Neither is better than the other - they're just different. I really don't like inference on here that you must have a better/more secure marriage if you're happy for your partner to work away through the week, though.

Different people are happy with different things. I don't want a lifestyle where I work 12-14 hours a day and have a stupidly long commute, even if that means I sacrifice some job security and family support.

sst1234 · 20/07/2021 13:24

OP you are not happy about him doing something that presumably needs to be done. Thanks hat are you doing to ease the situation and make up the difference in pay if he stays at home in a lower paying job?

pleasedonttextmyman · 20/07/2021 13:20

Equally, many people choose to live in expensive areas of the country because it means they're near friends or family

or simply.. because there are JOBS.
I don't know anyone who spent more than a couple of weeks without a job in London. It's a simple fact. It might not be the job of your dream, it might be something to do until you find better, but there's work.

When you don't have family support, where else in the country are you guaranteed employment like that?

But central london means ... having to live further.
So there. The idea of "choice" is laughable. Yes, you could chose to go on the dole or be unemployed for months. I don't call that a choice personally.

It's much less stressful to know you will always have a back up and you never going to be stuck!

TotorosCatBus · 20/07/2021 13:19

My h worked working away Tues-Thurs for many years and it worked ok tbh. He usually came home around the children's bedtime so during the week it wasn't massively different. He wasn't the type to go and play football or golf at the weekends so he was 100% available then.

Have you considered moving to where he'd be working ?

QueenBee52 · 20/07/2021 13:16

@babybopella

My partner is working away at the moment, it's a one off thankfully and I've realised I couldn't cope with it being a regular thing! We do have 6 young kids though all under 12 so bit different for me, but yeah I miss him and it's not easy.

well tbf 6 kids under 12 is pretty demanding 🌸

Ultimatecougar · 20/07/2021 13:16

My ex did this. It killed our marriage. And I thought we had a strong marriage before.

warmfluffytowels · 20/07/2021 13:15

good if you have the luxury to have a short-hour well paid job - most of us don't.

Neither do we. Neither of us are amazingly well-paid, but we've picked a lifestyle that means we don't have to work silly hours just to get by. I work 25-30 hours a week (self-employed, so it varies) and DH works on average 4.5 days a week (also self-employed). We live in an area that always comes up on the "worst places to live" threads. We bought a cheap fixer-upper house that still isn't fixed up. But we have a fantastic work-life balance and I don't remember the last time one of us finished work after 5pm.

If everyone I know is absolutely delighted to WFH and have their life back, it's because it was never a choice to be out of the house for 12 hours a day. It has nothing to do with being "career driven", everything to do with just paying the bills.

I do get your point to an extent, but many people also choose careers or jobs that mean they have long commutes and long hours out of the house, and that can only work long-term if both parties are on board in my opinion.

Equally, many people choose to live in expensive areas of the country because it means they're near friends or family - which is of course fine, but that comes with financial consequences that impact all areas of their lives. Others choose to live away from their families to have a better work/life balance and less financial stress.

I have read so many threads on here from people whose partners are out of the house 7-7 and they resent them hugely because they're not around to help with the school run, homework or bedtime. Or threads where both partners work long hours and they argue over free-time, childcare, hobbies.

It is totally okay to say "I didn't sign up to be in a marriage where you're never home". Some couples might be okay with it, but it's fine for others to say they're not.

godmum56 · 20/07/2021 13:12

@warmfluffytowels

fine, but the point was that it's the reality for many couples living together but having long commutes. and it was in response to this could be a really dangerous move, in terms of our relationship?

And my answer was no, either you have a secure relationship or you haven't.

I know what you were saying, I just totally disagree with you lol.

I've done long-distance relationships and relationships where my partner has worked away and I didn't like it. That doesn't mean my relationship isn't secure - it's just not for me.

I wouldn't get into a relationship with someone career-driven who was out of the house 12-14 hours a day either, as that's also not for me and not what I want from a relationship. It's great that it works for some people, but I like being in a marriage where we're both home by 5pm 99% of the time.

So if DH suddenly decided he wanted to work away half the week, it would cause problems as that's not what we agreed we wanted when we got married.

I don't see anywhere where anybody has said that they want to do this....and I would say that if you didn't like it, that says that the relationship wasn't secure, also the fact that I infer that you are no longer in the relationship?
babybopella · 20/07/2021 13:09

My partner is working away at the moment, it's a one off thankfully and I've realised I couldn't cope with it being a regular thing! We do have 6 young kids though all under 12 so bit different for me, but yeah I miss him and it's not easy.

godmum56 · 20/07/2021 13:09

My dad did this and so did my late husband. For my parents there was zero choice and it was immedaitely post WW2 Having a weekend marriage must have been like a walk in the park after knowing your husband was at war.
My late DH and I had periods in our lives when he was either away regularly for one to 5 nights or away for months at a time but then home for long periods. For us it worked fine.
I get the "if you relationship is strong" thing but i would word it differently. I would say if your relationship can encompass it.....for me there are two issues. Some people need continued closeness and that's ok but the relationship is definitely be at risk of breaking down if that can't happen BUT if all that is keeping one or both partners from cheating is that continued closeness, then maybe that's not going to be an especially durable realtionship is it?
maybe the answer for the OP is to consider in detail why they are not happy with the idea instead of looking at others. I know a lot of broken marriages (acquaintances not friends) and none of them had the working away from home thing as a factor.

pleasedonttextmyman · 20/07/2021 13:07

I wouldn't get into a relationship with someone career-driven who was out of the house 12-14 hours a day either, as that's also not for me and not what I want from a relationship. It's great that it works for some people, but I like being in a marriage where we're both home by 5pm 99% of the time.

good if you have the luxury to have a short-hour well paid job
most of us don't.

If everyone I know is absolutely delighted to WFH and have their life back, it's because it was never a choice to be out of the house for 12 hours a day. It has nothing to do with being "career driven", everything to do with just paying the bills.

billy1966 · 20/07/2021 13:00

I think it can work but both parties have to be on board.

If it was an only choice scenario to pay a morgage then it would would have to be borne.

But if it is a choice of an open ended commitment I would be unhappy about that.

OP, has he been looking long?
Handing over the hard week day parenting is a big load to carry.
He comes home to be fun dad whilst all the slog is done.

We did it for 2 years because my first two were loving school and I couldn't bear to pull them out.

But it was tough and I am a very organised person.
We were thrilled when husband told them he was not staying for the projects extension and was returning to his office. End of.

It's a dangerous decision for him to make without you on board.

Very reasonable to say I did not sign up for this, when it is not our only option.

warmfluffytowels · 20/07/2021 12:57

fine, but the point was that it's the reality for many couples living together but having long commutes. and it was in response to this could be a really dangerous move, in terms of our relationship?

And my answer was no, either you have a secure relationship or you haven't.

I know what you were saying, I just totally disagree with you lol.

I've done long-distance relationships and relationships where my partner has worked away and I didn't like it. That doesn't mean my relationship isn't secure - it's just not for me.

I wouldn't get into a relationship with someone career-driven who was out of the house 12-14 hours a day either, as that's also not for me and not what I want from a relationship. It's great that it works for some people, but I like being in a marriage where we're both home by 5pm 99% of the time.

So if DH suddenly decided he wanted to work away half the week, it would cause problems as that's not what we agreed we wanted when we got married.

StrawBeretMoose · 20/07/2021 12:54

DH has worked away on and off for years with periods in between of living together full time.
Sometimes in a different country and sometimes a few hours away.
I sometimes travel for work but short trips rather than e.g. a year-long project which he might do.

We've been living together full time since covid happened.
I'd be very happy if he didn't have to work away again but trips have been starting up.
However if he gets an opportunity and it means living apart again then so be it.

Candleabra · 20/07/2021 12:52

I would have a massive problem with this.

Even without the potential for affairs, it's the sudden inequality in the relationship. You're left at home with the kids and all the demands that comes with it. You resent husband living an exciting life in the city. He, in turn, resents you as you see more of the kids. The partner living away often gets used to a level of service from a hotel - and resents having to clean, cook, tidy etc when at home. It also means you're expected to make every weekend "special" so no chill time for you either.

StripyGiraffes · 20/07/2021 12:48

Either you are secure in your relationship, or you're not.

"I don't see what this has to do with it. Not everyone wants a marriage where they only see their partner at weekends - that doesn't mean those people are insecure in their relationships or that they don't trust their partners."

Exactly. Particularly if you have children and a job and commitments of your own. If this was always the situation and accepted prior to marriage that is different, but to change to this arrangement later can - in some circumstances - put unacceptable pressure on the partner who remains living at home and is often not what was signed up for. Unless both parties are 100% on board with it, it can easily corrode a relationship and cause resentment.

pleasedonttextmyman · 20/07/2021 12:46

I don't see what this has to do with it. Not everyone wants a marriage where they only see their partner at weekends - that doesn't mean those people are insecure in their relationships or that they don't trust their partners.

fine, but the point was that it's the reality for many couples living together but having long commutes.
and it was in response to this could be a really dangerous move, in terms of our relationship?

And my answer was no, either you have a secure relationship or you haven't.

Now not wanting not to spend every evening together is another matter, but again, context needed.
You can't compare someone who is desperate for a job, any job, someone who has been offered the opportunity of a lifetime, or someone who could find half a dozen similar roles at similar salary locally.

StripyGiraffes · 20/07/2021 12:45

It was one of the main factors in my marriage breakdown.

warmfluffytowels · 20/07/2021 12:40

Either you are secure in your relationship, or you're not.

I don't see what this has to do with it. Not everyone wants a marriage where they only see their partner at weekends - that doesn't mean those people are insecure in their relationships or that they don't trust their partners.

It's one of those things that works for some people and doesn't work for others. Your relationship isn't more secure just because you live apart through the week, just like it's not more secure because you share a bed together every night.

babybythesea · 20/07/2021 12:36

Love where we live, sorry.

babybythesea · 20/07/2021 12:36

We do this.
DH works in London but we live very rurally. When he got the job, we had a big debate about whether we wanted to give up our lifestyle and home here and move. We decided that no, we didn’t. We love where we will but the salary was twice as much so it was worth him taking the job (and it was a big step up the career ladder for him, he really, really wanted it.)
In some ways, it’s almost easier now than when he worked locally. He worked long hours and trying to plan kids tea, then dinner later for us, meant I was spending every evening in the kitchen cooking (it felt like that anyway!). And he worked on Sundays. Now, I eat with the kids, I’ve got used to pottering by myself in the evening, and then when he’s home, he’s properly home and not just ‘popping back to work for an hour’ or working every Sunday. In a funny way we get more family time now than we did before.
Kids have got used to it although DD hated it at first. It’s just how it is now. And with the pandemic, work have realised he can do more from home than he was allowed to before so he’s got more flexibility to work from home if suitable.
It’s working for us.

Getabloominmoveon · 20/07/2021 12:33

I currently have a job where I’m away all week, and have done this in the past in another country. In between my husband was also seconded to another country and commuted back on Thursday evenings.

Our kids are older and were then at University, so we had limited commitments at home.

Both of us loved it and still do. Since we’re in busy senior jobs we can put the hours in during the week, and avoid working at weekends. Also going to stay in the different cities was a fab experience.
During the week I often went/go for a drink/dinner with colleagues, male and female, and have managed to resist running off with any of them. (Same for my husband, as far as Im aware, but tbh I don’t need to know what he’s up to all the time).

Been together for about 100 years, with lots of travelling for work when kids were young, and it works really well because we value our individual independence as much as our relationship, and we’ve been able to find the balance for us.

grannycake · 20/07/2021 12:27

My DH works away for 4 nights a week and has done for the last 10 years. Prior to this he was a HGV driver and was either away all week or working nights which still meant I didn't see him. It is tough but it is what it is - we retire next year so I at least have the end in sight

KnobJockey · 20/07/2021 12:24

I wouldn't do it. I agreed to have a child in a partnership, parenting is already too weighted towards me/ mother's. How can it become more equal when one parent does literally all parenting for 75% of the week? I would be resentful very quickly.

pleasedonttextmyman · 20/07/2021 12:23

Either you are secure in your relationship, or you're not.

What's the long term plan? Wait until the kids finish school and you relocate?
He only works a couple of years there until he finds better?

I have many friends and family around me having to work in separate cities or countries, it's hard on the one staying home with little ones if they have no family support, but they tend to have a closer relationship.

DH only worked away for few weeks at a time here and there, it didn't bother us. Much more attractive than coming home late and leaving early, and there's something to say about catching up!

Swipe left for the next trending thread