Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse to take contraception

461 replies

GreatBigArse · 20/07/2021 08:49

Curious to hear what others think following a conversation with my friend.

I'll try to keep it short.

Myself and DH have one child, DS. DH is adamant he wants no more children. I am actually okay with this although I wouldn't mind another if it happened. I feel very much if it doesn't happen that's fine, if he changed his mind that would also be nice but I wouldn't push it.

After a really horrible experience with both the implant and depo injection I have said I am not taking hormonal contraception again. I feel so much happier and myself without it and I will not be putting anything like that in my body ever again. I was considering the copper coil but someone I know recently got an infection due to it and it's really put me off.

I have told DH this, I've told him I'm no longer going to be the one to bother with all of that. I've not given him other options but as a grown up I'm sure he knows what his options are (no sex, condoms, which he hates, or the snip which he also doesn't want). I also mentioned that if anything did happen he should know I wouldn't be considering a termination.

It sounds very matter of fact written down but this is all just in general conversation with my husband.

He has continued to instigate and have sex (occasionally using the "pull out" method or asking me if I think its a "safe" time in my cycle to which I always answer I don't know).

My friend thinks I am being irresponsible allowing this to go on with someone who I know really doesn't want another child and whilst my husband should also be responsible, I am risking bringing an unwanted child into the world which is unfair and therefore I should also take some responsibility as regardless of want DH does, I know he doesn't want another child and I'm continuing to have unprotected sex with him.

AIBU to think I am within my rights to refuse to use contraception (other than condoms if DH instigates them) and so long as I have explained that to my husband, it's fine to carry on as we are? Or do you think I have some responsibility here knowing that he doesn't want another child and I should take contraception I don't want to take?

Ps. I know it sounds a very odd conversation to have with a friend but we often talk about more serious things like this and have various debates about things. She's a bit like my sister and we've been friends for a very long time.

YANBU - it's fine to not use contraception all long as you have told DH and he knows the situation.

YABU - you shouldn't have sex with DH unprotected even if you've told him and should take contraception yourself.

OP posts:
morepizzapls · 20/07/2021 11:44

why dont you just not have sex until you can both have a grown up conversation about it?

frankly, it's really quite pathetic. like I said previously, i probably do feel stronger as the child of an absent dad who didnt want to be in my life even though he admits having unprotected sex with my mum, it actually makes me furious. more so with your husband who willingly acknowledges he doesnt want more kids but continues anyway but YOU know too. it's so so irresponsible.

SlothinSpirit · 20/07/2021 11:43

@Wheretobuy. 100% agree. It appears that women's health and comfort comes last as usual.

Wheretobuy · 20/07/2021 11:42

A lot of posters on this thread have written stuff that shows why misogyny is still alive and kicking in our society.

SlothinSpirit · 20/07/2021 11:40

It would be sensible to have a no condom, no sex rule until you both figure out what the best way forward is.

Wheretobuy · 20/07/2021 11:40

Some of the posts here are downright nasty and terrible!
Do not call for it OP. You have done your bit, including contraception, pregnancy and the risks it puts you through.
His turn now.
I absolutely do not get what he means by being too young for vasectomy? He is too old to have a baby as he has decided. So does he want to keep his options open for some other woman in case your marriage falls through? Hmm

BiBabbles · 20/07/2021 11:40

I'm not going to put something inside myself so that my husband has a better orgasm.

And I would extend that to his dick until the issue is better resolved.

The OP would not be having an unwanted child. She wants a child.

Either parent not wanting a child results in an unwanted child.

In this situation, we have one who is 'adamant' that he doesn't want one, and another who is happy either way and thinks that if the inevitable pregnancy happens that everything will be fine because "can't see him ever resenting his child. He absolutely adores his son. He is quite the gentle type really."

I know it's my bias, and I'm sure there are cases where it works out, but that raises giant red klaxons for me as so often it doesn't. Having been the child in that situation and knowing others who've had the same, I'm well aware it's a risky gamble when the consequences can be so severe on an innocent child - and, as an adult, as much as my mother is fully responsible for what she did in making sure I knew I was unwanted and eventually turning violent, I also hold my father - no matter whether he wanted another child or just didn't care - as being irresponsible and a bit heartless to have not handled his side of the contraception better when he knew the likely result with my mother and what was her very well known attitude towards kids & contraception. The ideal that she would love us because she was sweet didn't really pan out.

I completely agree the husband is being ridiculous to keep pushing for sex that risks pregnancy and asking BS like whether it's 'safe' and if the OP was the only one at risk then there wouldn't be an issue, but with a potential child at risk, then I think if contraceptions aren't a good option, then changing what sex happens becomes the best option because no amount of her ambivalence or even actively wanting a child is going to change the risks of having the other parent not.

But how do you compromise when it comes to contraception? How do you share responsibility for it? Either one party uses something either hormonal or invasive which comes with far more side effects or one uses a condom.

Many couples do both, and there is also the option to compromise on what sexual activities are an option. There are sex options that don't have pregnancy risks.

Brefugee · 20/07/2021 11:40

And you didnt want a baby and told your partner this but he didnt really pay any mind to this because he was flexible either way. He then ended up getting you pregnant because both of you prefer not to take contraception for your own reasons. It would end up horrific for you and you would of felt forced into the situation by him

Nope. Nope. Nope.

OP doesn't mind. OP's DH does. So he gets to have a vasectomy, wear a condom or no sex. In your analogy OP would have the choice of a range of contraceptives, hysterectomy or no sex. The one who doesn't want a baby is at the steering wheel here.

OP YA definitely NBU. Just keep reminding him that without contraception a baby is always a possible outcome. Then lie back and think of England Grin

Bibidy · 20/07/2021 11:38

@vivainsomnia

It's more like OP has been working full-time for years while her DH hasn't worked at all, and now she's saying she'd like him to take his turn earning the money!! I don't think anyone would say she's unreasonable for that Of course it would be unreasonable because it's not an unilateral decision. Couples work together. They don't suddenly demand something of the other that they don't want just because it suits them at that time. That is indeed selfish behaviour.

Ultimately, I am not sure why your turned it around, again, because it's only acceptable when it's the woman making the demand?

But some things are more difficult not to decide unilaterally because they affect one person far more than the other. Ultimately it always comes down to that one person to decide.

This is one of those times, all of the contraceptive methods OP has tried have had negative effects on her. She should not be pushed to continue them purely because her DH says that's his preference, so he doesn't have to change anything himself.

He is not willing to take the one, easy option that works for them both. OP would not refuse to use condoms, but her DH does.

Struggling to see how your'e defending him not taking that option rather than OP having to take hormones or insert something into her body just so he doesn't have to do anything at all.

WeatherForecast · 20/07/2021 11:38

@NeonDreams

Why are people going on about how it's unfair on the child? All a child needs is a parent who wants them and loves them. That's the OP. A child doesn't need a father to be happy, loved and wanted. Plenty of women deliberately go the single route, use sperm donors etc. As long as a child is loved and wanted by a parent, ie namely the mother, that's all anyone can ask for.

NB: I'm not suggesting she should do all she can to get pregnant, just saying that the 'the father has to want and love the child or else it's a massive disaster' is overwrought and nonsense. As plenty of single mums with loving relationships with their child/ren will attest.

There's a big difference between a child being born to a solo parent, and a child being born to two parents where one doesn't want them.

Have you ever spoken to anyone who was abandoned by their father early or later in life? Who realise that they hadn't been wanted? Who was born into a relationship that later ended due to the strains of a child that wasn't wanted by both?

I take my hat off to single parents who do the hard work of raising a child when the other parent has decided not to bother. But please don't negate the real psychological effects it can have into adulthood if you are abandoned by or realise you were never wanted by one of your parents.

With respect, I think I'll take the body of research about the effects of fatherlessness on kids over a mumsnet comment calling it 'overwrought nonsense'. People do the best they can in the situation they're in, but if you can prevent a child being born to a parent that doesn't want them then of course you should!

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Father_absence

PumpkinsOfFire · 20/07/2021 11:37

What do people expect from the OP? Other than leave her husband? Let her current child see it's father every other weekend? What would a grown up do beyond having a conversation to say "I don't want to damage my body anymore?"

Horst · 20/07/2021 11:36

I hate how it always seems to fall to the women.

The op has decided she doesn’t want to use contraception. Her body her choice remember.

If her dh wants sex it’s, condom, snip or the rather risky pull out method.

It’s about time men stepped up and dealt with their sperm, they cause the pregnancy. They just cnba and want care free sex and women put up with the horrible side effects from hormonal contraceptives.

therocinante · 20/07/2021 11:36

YANBU to not want to take any contraception and your husband is a bit BU not to use condoms if he's so adamant he doesn't want another child.

But communication here doesn't sound 100% perfect - I feel like you're both playing on different terms, he's asking 'if it's a safe time' or whatever, assuming that that absolves him of responsibility and you're seemingly setting up a faux-naive 'well, I assumed you knew it was a possibility' in case of a pregnancy. Neither is best practice communication - have a proper chat where you say what you've said here, that you're operating under the assumption he's actually happy there's a chance of another child given his not using condoms. My guess is that he'll say "I'm absolutely not, I asked if it was a safe time" or something - so I think it's worth being absolutely crystal clear with one another about the assumptions you're both acting under rather than assuming he's happy with the risk and him doing the bare minimum to be able to turn round and say "well I pulled out/asked if you were fertile" in case of a pregnancy, in which case you're going to feel annoyed and unsupported and he's going to (claim to) feel as though you've not told him the risks.

Honestly though it sounds like he's not deliberately being an idiot, just being a bit hopefully pretend-stupid about the possibilities because he doesn't want to have any tiny amount of inconvenience... well, welcome to being responsible for contraception pal, it's a compromise somewhere or other! Grin

Cavagirl · 20/07/2021 11:36

@GreatBigArse

Have you had a discussion about what you will do in the event of another pregnancy? Is he expecting you to get an abortion if it fails?

I have told him I would not entertain the idea of an abortion.

That's not really a discussion though is it?

I fully support your body your choice, you are fine with getting pregnant so it shouldn't be down to you to manage contraception and he's fully aware.

But reality is a more complex beast and if you end up pregnant you could find yourself wishing you'd talked through the what-ifs.

"Well you knew what you were doing" and holding the moral high ground isn't going to compensate a (potentially) destroyed marriage and a (potentially) messed up child because the father didn't want it.

You have an obligation to everyone - including DC1 - to have an adult conversation here about the "what if".

whereislittleroo · 20/07/2021 11:36

This makes me so angry. Why do men insist they don't want any more children but then refuse to use condoms or have a vasectomy? Why is the woman so often expected to have something inserted inside her or take medication that messes with her hormones, possibly makes her gain weight and increases risk of blood clots, breast cancer etc? Woman-focused contraceptives are pretty invasive and not without side effects. Condoms might lessen the sensation a bit for men. It is so unbelievably selfish. Covid has prevented my husband from having the snip yet, but I'm so glad he understands that after 3 children and years on hormonal contraceptives, it is now his turn to take responsibility.

Twoforthree · 20/07/2021 11:35

It’s not a casual relationship, they have talked about it. What more do people want her to do. He has a brain.

PumpkinsOfFire · 20/07/2021 11:35

@vivainsomnia

I think he'd be happy to continue with something like tracking if my cycles were able to be tracked but they are a bit of a mess right now Use ovulation tracking sticks. They are cheap and quite accurate.
Or don't piss in cups daily and get him to wear a condom
Twoforthree · 20/07/2021 11:33

You are me.

I was on the pill for years and then decided I didn’t want any more hormones put into my body. I did get a diaphragm but never really used it as it was a faff. We used condoms. It wouldn’t have been the end of the world if I had got pregnant.

Dh knows the risks he’s taking and he knows you’d be ok if you got pregnant. It’s up to him now.

drpet49 · 20/07/2021 11:33

** Your DH is being unreasonable, irresponsible and childish.

You are being unreasonable, irresponsible and childish.

It baffles me that grown adults behave like this. It’s not an argument over who takes the bins out this is a decision (or rather NON decision) about having a child.

Your husband is an idiot but you are deliberately trying to have a baby with him.**

^Great post. OP you need to grow up.

PumpkinsOfFire · 20/07/2021 11:33

@vivainsomnia

It's more like OP has been working full-time for years while her DH hasn't worked at all, and now she's saying she'd like him to take his turn earning the money!! I don't think anyone would say she's unreasonable for that Of course it would be unreasonable because it's not an unilateral decision. Couples work together. They don't suddenly demand something of the other that they don't want just because it suits them at that time. That is indeed selfish behaviour.

Ultimately, I am not sure why your turned it around, again, because it's only acceptable when it's the woman making the demand?

You don't owe anyone your vagina. Stop comparing the ops vagina to a job. It's really misogynistic and gross
ThePants999 · 20/07/2021 11:33

he knows I won't be getting an abortion if it happens and he's still having sex therefore he has agreed to take the risk of another baby surely

It sounds simple enough, but you owe it to this possible future baby to be more explicit than that. Don't just assume he's acting logically. Have the actual conversation - get him to ACTUALLY agree to take the risk of another baby, and promise he'll fully accept his parental responsibilities, or no unprotected sex.

Secondbellini · 20/07/2021 11:32

I never used any kind of contraception except condoms. I have read so many stories on here of women having horrendous experiences with the pill, coil and implants.

VeganCheesePlease · 20/07/2021 11:32

Yanbu at all not to want to take hormonal contraception.
But in your situation would a cycle tracking app not be a good shout? I'm using one for the opposite reason, ttc, but I used it for years before I wanted to get pregnant to pinpoint when we had to be extra careful. I was the same in that I tried the pill and absolutely hated it.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 20/07/2021 11:31

I’d recommend a trip to you family planning unit, have a chat about alternatives that may work for you, diaphragm maybe?... I don't want anything invasive.

Go together. Both of you. A family planning unit will talk through all the family planning options with both of you. Invasive and non-invasive, you and him.

It's not a conversation that is repeatedly happening with DH or causing an atmosphere.

There's going to be one hell of an atmosphere if you get pregnant.

This is a mess. He is making no effort, so maybe that means your DH wont mind if you get pregnant and that he will accept it and will be "mild" about it. Or you could be in for a nasty shock, because maybe in his mind it is still your repsonsibility and it will be all your fault if you get pregnant. Right or wrong that is no atmosphere to bring a baby into, so why take the risk?

He went away and said he was thinking about the snip then said he didn't want to do that. I'm not sure how much clearer I can be.

He has not said what he does want to do. Unless you want an accident and are prepared for him to get nasty about it, put sex off limits until he decides what to do instead.

ClawedButler · 20/07/2021 11:31

@GreatBigArse

For the PP who keeps insisting I was happy to do it when it suited... No. I have NEVER BEEN HAPPY to take contraceptives. They played havoc with my emotions and moods for years. I bled a lot and then on top of that the GP refused to remove my implant for months despite me begging. I have tried things, this is not a refusal to try things at all, I have been on the pill, the mini pill too, I've had the implant, I've had the injection and all of them were horrid. This is a refusal to carry on trying things over and over again because I've been doing that for years and I've had enough.

As I said previously I did this automatically when I was younger as it just seemed like the done thing, you're a woman so you take the contraception. I didn't do it "happily". It's only been since being off them that I've stopped and thought that I don't have to go through that shit anymore and I've got the confidence to say that I won't do it again.

I'm not going to put something inside myself so that my husband has a better orgasm.

HEAR HEAR.

You have explored the choices open to you.

He now has choices open to him. No sex, snip, condom or potential pregnancy.

It's as simple as that. He has to choose one of those things, because all other options have been exhausted. And none of his options is anything like as bad as years and years of hormonal contraception, or having to mess around with fiddly icky intrusive objects inside your body.

vivainsomnia · 20/07/2021 11:31

I think he'd be happy to continue with something like tracking if my cycles were able to be tracked but they are a bit of a mess right now
Use ovulation tracking sticks. They are cheap and quite accurate.