Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse to take contraception

461 replies

GreatBigArse · 20/07/2021 08:49

Curious to hear what others think following a conversation with my friend.

I'll try to keep it short.

Myself and DH have one child, DS. DH is adamant he wants no more children. I am actually okay with this although I wouldn't mind another if it happened. I feel very much if it doesn't happen that's fine, if he changed his mind that would also be nice but I wouldn't push it.

After a really horrible experience with both the implant and depo injection I have said I am not taking hormonal contraception again. I feel so much happier and myself without it and I will not be putting anything like that in my body ever again. I was considering the copper coil but someone I know recently got an infection due to it and it's really put me off.

I have told DH this, I've told him I'm no longer going to be the one to bother with all of that. I've not given him other options but as a grown up I'm sure he knows what his options are (no sex, condoms, which he hates, or the snip which he also doesn't want). I also mentioned that if anything did happen he should know I wouldn't be considering a termination.

It sounds very matter of fact written down but this is all just in general conversation with my husband.

He has continued to instigate and have sex (occasionally using the "pull out" method or asking me if I think its a "safe" time in my cycle to which I always answer I don't know).

My friend thinks I am being irresponsible allowing this to go on with someone who I know really doesn't want another child and whilst my husband should also be responsible, I am risking bringing an unwanted child into the world which is unfair and therefore I should also take some responsibility as regardless of want DH does, I know he doesn't want another child and I'm continuing to have unprotected sex with him.

AIBU to think I am within my rights to refuse to use contraception (other than condoms if DH instigates them) and so long as I have explained that to my husband, it's fine to carry on as we are? Or do you think I have some responsibility here knowing that he doesn't want another child and I should take contraception I don't want to take?

Ps. I know it sounds a very odd conversation to have with a friend but we often talk about more serious things like this and have various debates about things. She's a bit like my sister and we've been friends for a very long time.

YANBU - it's fine to not use contraception all long as you have told DH and he knows the situation.

YABU - you shouldn't have sex with DH unprotected even if you've told him and should take contraception yourself.

OP posts:
GreatBigArse · 20/07/2021 09:18

If your husband doesn't want any more children I can't understand why he is so against the snip

If I were to be completely honest I'd say it's because he wants to be able to change his mind. I personally don't get the impression from him that he's as against it as he says he is but I don't push it.

OP posts:
Cloudninenine · 20/07/2021 09:17

You aren’t being unreasonable to not be using hormonal contraception. And it isn’t your job to manage your husband’s decision about this. But this isn’t just about the two of you - it’s also about this hypothetical third child.

Children should be conceived because they are actively wanted - not as a semi-tolerable consequence of two peoples’ inability to have a frank and decisive conversation about contraception.

A second child who is unwanted by your husband could destroy your marriage. What effect would that have on the new baby, and your existing child?

I you need to start imagining this child as a real person who deserves to be conceived into stable circumstances with two committed and loving parents.

Wanttocry · 20/07/2021 09:17

@Naunet

No, I think the friend is saying that if there is no contraception that both people in the couple can agree on, and the couple also don’t agree on having a baby, they probably shouldn’t be having unprotected sex I agree that OP shouldn’t take contraception she doesn’t want, but since she can’t force her husband to use contraception, no sex is the sensible option

So they shouldn’t have sex because if OP get pregnant it might put strain on their relationship, but OP won’t feel any resentment or disillusioned by not being able to have sex? That’s just as damaging.
He’s happy to have sex anyway, so he can’t be that bothered about her getting pregnant, can he?

I absolutely agree that the husband is by far the most unreasonable person here. I’m just saying, in this situation, I would not be having sex because that’s the only part I can control. I would not be happy about any part of the situation. But I would not want to have a baby with someone who didn’t want one, so since I can’t force the other person use contraception, and I don’t want to use contraception, no sex is the only option left.
ConstantlySeekingHappiness · 20/07/2021 09:17

@ArabellaStrange

This is why Vasectomies were invented, he does not want another child, therefore it is up to him to ensure that there won't be one.
This!

He doesn’t want another child but expects you to take all of the responsibility to ensure he doesn’t have another child.

He needs to make better decisions. Either a condom or a vasectomy.

I would ask him if he’s serious about not having another child since he’s playing silly “pull out method” games. He’s being very irresponsible for someone who’s adamant he doesn’t want another child.

Mrgrinch · 20/07/2021 09:17

Do you secretly want another baby?

Lockheart · 20/07/2021 09:17

I don't think YABU to not want to take hormonal contraception but I think you're being silly to carry on and just assume your partner will be ok with whatever happens.

Sex is something you both do together and you should both be happy with the contraception you're using, or if you're not using contraception then you should both be happy with the risk of falling pregnant. It doesn't sound like this is the case.

You need a frank discussion about what to do going forwards and what you'd do if you were to fall pregnant, and if you're not happy with that risk then how do you mitigate it in a way you're both comfortable with?

What is it about condoms he hates? Has he tried a decent variety of brands and types? I think a lot of men hate condoms because they just grab whatever Durex they can get at the chemist when really they're more like bras and you can't do that - at least, not if you want to be comfortable!

Naunet · 20/07/2021 09:16

I’d recommend a trip to you family planning unit, have a chat about alternatives that may work for you, diaphragm maybe?

Why should she when he won’t even make the effort to wear a condom and he’s the one who doesn’t want another child?! Jesus, why do we pander to men like this?

GreatBigArse · 20/07/2021 09:16

@SchrodingersImmigrant

I don't blame you for not wanting to take contraception, I also don't. But It just sounds like a bit of a toxic relationship for the both of you to be honest.

This...

I mean you could always come to something working together. Pull out and you track your cycle ir something. I am surprised either of you even wants sex with this mood around

There is no mood around honestly. We are completely normal with each other, there is no mood.

This only came up because me and my friend happened to be talking about contraception.

It's not a conversation that is repeatedly happening with DH or causing an atmosphere.

OP posts:
KrisAkabusi · 20/07/2021 09:15

YANBU not to want to use contraception. But you are being a bit unreasonable in continuing to have sex with him. If he really doesn't want a child then he should do something about it. But as others have said, if you get pregnant, it's unlikely to end well, so you need to take some responsibility as well - no sex unless he's protected. And pulling out doesn't count!

Littlepool · 20/07/2021 09:15

Yanbu. Contraception is not solely your responsibility. I made the same decision to come off all Contraception as all the artificial hormones really mess with my body. You have told him this and he is not willing to do anything about it so that's on him not you. My husband completely supported my decision and has now decided to get the snip because he doesn't want me to suffer when there's an easy fix.

If your husband doesn't want any more children I can't understand why he is so against the snip. He seems a bit selfish letting you go through the suffering of hormonal or painful birth control implants etc but won't do anything to fix it himself.

Naunet · 20/07/2021 09:14

No, I think the friend is saying that if there is no contraception that both people in the couple can agree on, and the couple also don’t agree on having a baby, they probably shouldn’t be having unprotected sex
I agree that OP shouldn’t take contraception she doesn’t want, but since she can’t force her husband to use contraception, no sex is the sensible option

So they shouldn’t have sex because if OP get pregnant it might put strain on their relationship, but OP won’t feel any resentment or disillusioned by not being able to have sex? That’s just as damaging.
He’s happy to have sex anyway, so he can’t be that bothered about her getting pregnant, can he?

SchrodingersImmigrant · 20/07/2021 09:13

I don't blame you for not wanting to take contraception, I also don't. But It just sounds like a bit of a toxic relationship for the both of you to be honest.

This...

I mean you could always come to something working together. Pull out and you track your cycle ir something. I am surprised either of you even wants sex with this mood around

GreatBigArse · 20/07/2021 09:13

I’d recommend a trip to you family planning unit, have a chat about alternatives that may work for you, diaphragm maybe?

I don't want anything invasive.

OP posts:
pinkyredrose · 20/07/2021 09:12

But you also know the risks and are letting him

Letting him? Presumably he's got a mind of his own? He knows how babies are made by now and the OP is being honest with him. If he doesn't want another pregnancy he knows how to prevent it.

Ilikeknitting · 20/07/2021 09:12

Your Dh needs to take responsibility for contraception if he doesn’t want another child.

You are very liable to end up pregnant again if you are having unprotected sex, would an unplanned pregnancy be better or worse than wearing a condom? Would your marriage survive a second child? Because if I was aware that a second child could potentially leave me as a single mum to two, sex would be right off.

I’d recommend a trip to you family planning unit, have a chat about alternatives that may work for you, diaphragm maybe?

Naunet · 20/07/2021 09:11

It comes down to him hating condoms vs you not wanting to try the copper just because of one account of a rare event

Well condoms are non invasive and completely safe, so he can stop being selfish and use them, can’t he?

GreatBigArse · 20/07/2021 09:11

@Demelza82

Why won't he have a vasectomy?
He brought it up once as if he was actually going to look into it and then a few days later said he'd decided against it and didn't want to do it. Said he felt too young (early 30s).
OP posts:
Wanttocry · 20/07/2021 09:11

@Naunet

So your friend thinks women should take contraceptives that make them feel shit, despite being ok with getting pregnant, because it’s what her husband wants, purely all so he can ejaculate inside her? Why does him not liking condoms, trump your right not to pump yourself with hormones? Nothing must get in the way of men and their orgasm it seems.

Fuck that. You’ve been very clear with your husband as to where you stand, if he’s 100% sure he doesn’t want another, then he needs to take responsibility for that.

No, I think the friend is saying that if there is no contraception that both people in the couple can agree on, and the couple also don’t agree on having a baby, they probably shouldn’t be having unprotected sex. I agree that OP shouldn’t take contraception she doesn’t want, but since she can’t force her husband to use contraception, no sex is the sensible option.
GreatBigArse · 20/07/2021 09:08

It comes down to him hating condoms vs you not wanting to try the copper just because of one account of a rare event

The person I know got an infection which led to a full hysterectomy and was in hospital for weeks which they believe was caused by her coil. I appreciate it's rare but seeing someone you actually know go through that is quite worrying compared to impacting on how sex feels imo.

OP posts:
Naunet · 20/07/2021 09:05

So your friend thinks women should take contraceptives that make them feel shit, despite being ok with getting pregnant, because it’s what her husband wants, purely all so he can ejaculate inside her? Why does him not liking condoms, trump your right not to pump yourself with hormones? Nothing must get in the way of men and their orgasm it seems.

Fuck that. You’ve been very clear with your husband as to where you stand, if he’s 100% sure he doesn’t want another, then he needs to take responsibility for that.

ArabellaStrange · 20/07/2021 09:04

This is why Vasectomies were invented, he does not want another child, therefore it is up to him to ensure that there won't be one.

GreatBigArse · 20/07/2021 09:04

Yes I do see the point regarding a strain on the marriage if I were to become pregnant and he was very against it.

But, I will admit possibly naively, I just can't see him ever resenting his child. He absolutely adores his son. He is quite the gentle type really.

And to be honest if he resented me for a situation like this, where he'd known all along it was a possibility and the reasons why, I'd think he were a twat anyway and I'd no longer feel like a team who took responsibility for a decision we both had part in and it would probably be the end anyway because of that.

You can of course never say how someone will react in a situation until they have been in it so I don't want to say I think he'd do X or Y. Just that he is typically a good man and our marriage is great so I'd hope it would be something we got through.

But I'm reluctant to put things into my body I don't want to simply to negate a possible bad reaction from him if something did happen. I don't think that really seems fair nor reasonable.

OP posts:
FangsForTheMemory · 20/07/2021 09:04

I wouldn't be using contraception but I'd also be refusing to have sex unless your DH used a condom. Pulling out is a good way to get pregnant: does he really think you won't conceive that way? By asking you if it's a safe time of the month, he's AGAIN making it your responsibility to avoid pregnancy.

LolaSmiles · 20/07/2021 09:01

It's fine to not want to take any form of hormonal contraception, but why does DP have to be the one to 'instigate' condoms? Why can't either of you say "let's get a condom"?

It sounds like you're probably hoping for another baby and he's hoping the pull out method will work /he won't get unlucky.

It comes down down whether you think bringing another baby into this relationship is a good idea, and whether you'd be happy raising your children alone/with a disinterested partner who'll cling to 'but I never wanted another one'.

Wanttocry · 20/07/2021 09:01

Your DH is definitely the most unreasonable person here. But I agree with your friend in that I would not continue to have unprotected sex with him in these circumstances.
You said you gave him the options - no sex, condoms, vasectomy, and I agree he’s unreasonable, but you are now continuing with the fourth option, unprotected sex.
I totally understand your desire to not be on contraception, I’m not on any hormonal contraception, so I just wouldn’t be having sex in this scenario.