Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse to take contraception

461 replies

GreatBigArse · 20/07/2021 08:49

Curious to hear what others think following a conversation with my friend.

I'll try to keep it short.

Myself and DH have one child, DS. DH is adamant he wants no more children. I am actually okay with this although I wouldn't mind another if it happened. I feel very much if it doesn't happen that's fine, if he changed his mind that would also be nice but I wouldn't push it.

After a really horrible experience with both the implant and depo injection I have said I am not taking hormonal contraception again. I feel so much happier and myself without it and I will not be putting anything like that in my body ever again. I was considering the copper coil but someone I know recently got an infection due to it and it's really put me off.

I have told DH this, I've told him I'm no longer going to be the one to bother with all of that. I've not given him other options but as a grown up I'm sure he knows what his options are (no sex, condoms, which he hates, or the snip which he also doesn't want). I also mentioned that if anything did happen he should know I wouldn't be considering a termination.

It sounds very matter of fact written down but this is all just in general conversation with my husband.

He has continued to instigate and have sex (occasionally using the "pull out" method or asking me if I think its a "safe" time in my cycle to which I always answer I don't know).

My friend thinks I am being irresponsible allowing this to go on with someone who I know really doesn't want another child and whilst my husband should also be responsible, I am risking bringing an unwanted child into the world which is unfair and therefore I should also take some responsibility as regardless of want DH does, I know he doesn't want another child and I'm continuing to have unprotected sex with him.

AIBU to think I am within my rights to refuse to use contraception (other than condoms if DH instigates them) and so long as I have explained that to my husband, it's fine to carry on as we are? Or do you think I have some responsibility here knowing that he doesn't want another child and I should take contraception I don't want to take?

Ps. I know it sounds a very odd conversation to have with a friend but we often talk about more serious things like this and have various debates about things. She's a bit like my sister and we've been friends for a very long time.

YANBU - it's fine to not use contraception all long as you have told DH and he knows the situation.

YABU - you shouldn't have sex with DH unprotected even if you've told him and should take contraception yourself.

OP posts:
PinkPlantCase · 20/07/2021 10:33

I can see his point that if he condoms really impact on his enjoyment of sex, you not wanting to even try the copper is being a bit selfish

I can’t believe the attitudes on their thread. You aren’t being selfish at all OP,

The only part I think is questionable is that you don't both instigate condoms, it doesn’t hurt you to remind him that’s you should use one!

YABU to say it's just about hormonal contraception, when in truth you object to all forms that require you to take action. I think you should be honest about your motivation (pregnancy)

I don’t think this is fair. I’m done with hormonal contraceptives and I am completely against the coil for myself. I wouldn’t even consider a diaphragm as an option, it’s less effective than condoms and you need to keep it in for up to 6 hours after sex. Then you have to dig it out afterwards. So much more faf than condoms.

Wanting to use condoms does not mean that someone wants to get pregnant. It generally means the opposite 🤣

Topseyt · 20/07/2021 10:32

A diaphram is NOT invasive. It's a bit of rubber you insert then remove. It's the equivalent of the condom. So if you won't even consider it, you are no better than your DH

Errm, inserting something into your body coated in spermicide which then has to be left there for hours afterwards is the very definition of invasive.

I found the diaphragm invasive and revolting.

Re your other point about coils. They work for some people but not for others. I always hated the mere thought of something like that being put into me but eventually agreed to try a mirena for it's apparently magical abilities to control heavy flooding periods. It was an utter disaster and made things much worse.

LalalalalalaLand123 · 20/07/2021 10:31

Of course I know the consequences. Most adults would I imagine. My husband knows them too.

You can't simply abdicate your responsibility for the consequences by saying 'my husband knows them too'. Obviously you SHARE responsibility when it comes to sex and potential pregnancy. So 50% of it is still yours - and I think personally you need to ideally talk to each other and figure out how to proceed; and in the meantime while there is the risk of an unwanted baby, personally if I were you I would say 'no' to sex unless one of you is using contraception, for example DH using a condom if you refuse to use any form at all.

Best to find some agreement on this with DH, as this issue will continue to exist even if you do have another baby, what then - if you and DH stay together, the issue of contraception v pregnancy will carry on.

LucindaT73 · 20/07/2021 10:31

The other thing is that you came along here asking a question.

You already know the answer in your own mind which is 'I am right'.

Why did you ask?

Only to get confirmation that your opinion is the right one, it seems.

Look into your communication with your DH.

It sounds pretty poor and I fear your marriage is not as good as you think if you can't talk about this and come to an agreement.

DoLallyTapMum · 20/07/2021 10:30

YANBU. Despite what people here are saying the pull out method is a method, it’s just riskier than others but better than nothing (statistically at least). I am in a similar position but made clear from the start of our relationship I wouldn’t take contraceptives and why and that my preference was condoms.

Namenic · 20/07/2021 10:30

Op is ok with abstinence, and ok with pregnancy. It’s her DH that is not, and not ok with condoms and not ok with non penetrative sex.

OP and her DH have different priorities. She has taken a hit in previously having taken contraception. Totally reasonable for him to deal with it at least for a few years given his priorities.

vivainsomnia · 20/07/2021 10:29

Well this is my point. Why is it down to me to want to use any contraception. If my husband doesn't want a baby he can refuse sex or use condoms if he doesn't want the snip
It's not down to you only, nor him only, it's down to you as a couple. Just as it would be if one lost their job and this impacted on the ability to pay all the bills, or one fell ill and the current caring responsibilities needed to change. That's what being a couple means, not you or me, but us.

I agree with the previous post that this more about you wanting another child deep inside. If you didn't want another pregnancy as much as he doesn't, you would take different actions. You just need to discuss this more.

In your shoes, I would agree to try the copper, but made it clear that if that didn't work, he would have to accept condoms.

BiBabbles · 20/07/2021 10:29

It's not unreasonable for you to not want to use those contraceptions. I've only ever used barrier methods - condoms or a cervical cap, until my spouse had the snip (in his late twenties).

It is unreasonable - for both him and you - to continue to have sex that risks pregnancy while this hasn't been fully resolved. Other types of sexual activity are available and his whole putting it on you to know if its "safe" would be laughable if the consequences weren't such an issue. I put more of the unreasonableness on him in that regard.

Being an unwanted child by at least one of my parents (and pretty sure the other was like you - didn't really care either way but didn't prevent it), and knowing others who exist because of this type of irresponsibility, even with the gentlest parents (which many eventually ended up not being in the long run, parenting is hard enough without the added factor of not wanting more of it), it more often than not comes out and is a head fuck for the resulting person. I recognize my own bias in that though, I can entirely get the frustration that it has to be on you when you're both involved.

TheAntelope · 20/07/2021 10:29

However your partner has already told you he doesnt want children. So you cant be holding out on if you get accidentally get pregnant it all works out the same on his behalf. You are risking possible resentment between the two of you, relationship problems and a neglected child. I think its very selfish of you to take this risk and hope that he plays ball with it given he has made it clear to you. You arent respecting or taking hos wants seriously.

How come HE isn't the one risking resentment between the two of them? He's an adult, he knows how babies are made and he is the one who doesn't want another therefore if HE feels he'll resent his wife if she gets pregnant knowing she's not on contraception then HE should take responsibility for that and use something himself.

LolaSmiles · 20/07/2021 10:29

Women need to be more assertive about this stuff.
I agree.
I don't think two adults ignoring the fact they're highly likely to have an unplanned pregnancy whilst being on different pages regarding another baby is a woman being assertive. It's sitting back hoping for another baby whilst saying 'oh well if he is happy with the withdrawal method then so be it'. It's hardly a good dynamic for another baby.

pointythings · 20/07/2021 10:29

It's always a difficult one. I am one of those who had a copper coil and ended up with hideously heavy and painful periods, so I wouldn't recommend one. I also totally get why you don't want to be responsible for the contraception, though personally a diaphragm wouldn't worry me.

But this whole 'the poor men can't use condoms because it doesn't feel nice' thing gives me the rage, because let's face it, hormonal contraception also doesn't 'feel nice' (and a lot worse) to very many women.

There isn't an easy answer, but YANBU.

LucindaT73 · 20/07/2021 10:28

The point is, if he's made it clear that he doesn't want another child and neither of you want to use any form of contraception , then the answer is to be celibate.

You are going to become pregnant by default, (not using contraception) which may result in his leaving the marriage.

Just because he dotes on your child now doesn't mean this would be so with baby No.2

I think you are both being silly.

If this is the level of your behaviour towards each other, your marriage sounds doomed anyway and not the best place to bring another child into it.

I suspect there is more to the problems between you than just not agreeing on this.

ConstantlySeekingHappiness · 20/07/2021 10:28

@TheAntelope

Trying to guilt and pressure women into putting things INSIDE their bodies when they don't want to is fucking disgusting. And no it is in no way comparable to a bloody condom or sex not quite feeling as good.

Just when I think we may have moved forward in the world I hear or read some women like this and realise how far we still have to go. Absolutely gross.

This!!!!

Why the fuck are women on here having a go at OP for making a choice about her body???!!!!!

But apparently it’s absolutely fine for her DH to refuse condom use.

Some women fucking infuriate me with their attitude at times.

The OP can make whatever decision she bloody well likes.

The end.

Puditt · 20/07/2021 10:28

Can I also add op try and imagine if this situation was reverse. And you didnt want a baby and told your partner this but he didnt really pay any mind to this because he was flexible either way. He then ended up getting you pregnant because both of you prefer not to take contraception for your own reasons. It would end up horrific for you and you would of felt forced into the situation by him. If you ended up pregnant when you didnt want to be you would be so angry at him and people would think its appalling for the man to do that. Just another perspective on things to dwell on

But as I said please dont be one of those naive people that assume it will all work out in the end. Take his no to another baby seriously and get something sorted. It's a baby not a puppy

thinkningaboutit · 20/07/2021 10:27

As for second, thirds, fourth babies, the long term solution is as you've stated, abstinence, condoms, the snip. Easy.

CrystalBollocks · 20/07/2021 10:27

OP, in haste: YANBU a thousand million times over.

TheAntelope · 20/07/2021 10:26

[quote LucindaT73]@GreatBigArse You can find negatives about any kind of contraception you want. You're on a mission to do so here.

ie the reports of women with the coil.

I've had a copper coil too.

You sound very unwilling to take responsibility for your body and fertility to the point where any form of contraception is out.

Instead you leave your DH with one option (and I'm excluding the snip as it's permanent in most cases.)[/quote]
Because there is typically ALWAYS side effects with women's forms of contraception.

Tell me one side effect of a condom other than not feeling as good. I'll wait.

That's pretty much the definition of unreasonable - literally not based on reason and logic. It's purely reactionary

Eh? Basing a decision on what other people who have already made that decision have experienced is entirely reasonable and logical. Especially when it's medical and can effect your body. If I wanted to get a boob job and I'd heard from multiple women that they had had complications afterwards, some severe and rare and others more common, it would be entirely reasonable for me to base my decision to proceed or not on that information.

It is literally not up to anyone else to tell someone they are unreasonable to not put something into their own body for whatever bloody reason they want.

thinkningaboutit · 20/07/2021 10:26

I'm shocked anyone thinks you're stubborn or unreasonable for not wanting hormones or items placed inside your body. You've taken the burden of using contraception in the past, had a bad experience and now longer wish to.

You are absolutely right to leave this to your husband now. You do not need to counsel him every time you have sex. He's not a child. As a father I'm sure he understands how it all works.

Frauhubert · 20/07/2021 10:25

What if you do get pregnant, he accepts it, welcomes the baby, and then what? Will you still not be using contraception when you have 2 kids? Will you forever be chancing it? What if you get pregnant with a 3rd? What’s the long term solution?

TheYearOfSmallThings · 20/07/2021 10:25

YANBU. But when he asks if you are in your "safe period" the answer should always be "No. There is no safe period."

EL8888 · 20/07/2021 10:25

@TheAntelope exactly this. Some very depressing comments and attitudes on this thread. Then people wonder why men are so entitled, yeah partly because some people want to pander to them so much! Inserting foreign objects inside you and / or lots of hormones. Because he doesn’t want to wear a condom?!

vivainsomnia · 20/07/2021 10:24

What is the risk to him of using condoms? I am sure they are greater for me having a coil inserted, even if rare (and there was a thread on here not long ago about contraception where lots of women said the copper coil caused them very heavy and painful periods so complications obviously not that rare)
Assuming he doesn't suffer from an allergy and the issue is only with comfort, than no of course, it's not comparable. However, if it means that it genuinely impact on his enjoyment of sex, and ultimately, him wearing condom means no or very reduced enjoyment of sex with you until you do into the menopause is not completely insignificant either and merit not to be totally dismissed.

Noterook · 20/07/2021 10:24

It's not unreasonable to not want invasive contraception, it is unreasonable for him to not want to wear condoms if he doesn't want another child. I think your friend has a point though, it works out okay for you as you'd be happy with another so there's no need to take responsibility yourself as well. I can't think of much worse than having a child the other parent doesn't want, even if it is his responsibility as well.

Bibidy · 20/07/2021 10:23

I am so surprised at some of these comments.

Surely OP is within her rights to not take hormonal contraception/have a coil fitted - as much so as her DH is within his rights not to want a vasectomy or to use condoms.

I don't see why OP should be pushed into taking a pill or whatever when her DH's reason for not using condoms - the easiest method available for him to prevent pregnancy - is that he just doesn't like them?

Not sure why his dislikes trump OP's here when it's him who is most concerned about preventing a pregnancy.

Puditt · 20/07/2021 10:23

The problem is op your inflicting your expectations of the situation onto him. You clearly want another baby even if you arent actively seeking it, therefore if you get pregnant you dont mind.

However your partner has already told you he doesnt want children. So you cant be holding out on if you get accidentally get pregnant it all works out the same on his behalf. You are risking possible resentment between the two of you, relationship problems and a neglected child. I think its very selfish of you to take this risk and hope that he plays ball with it given he has made it clear to you. You arent respecting or taking hos wants seriously.

Have you not read all these threads on mns about the same thing? Were the man said no I dont want another child, continued to do nothing about it and have u protected sex and then when it came down to the woman getting pregnant turned cold or pressured them for an abortion. You can only assume because things are great in your relationship now (when you dont have another baby that he doesnt want) that he would react great. However I think he would feel very cornered and stressed. YES it's unfair because if he doesnt want a baby he should also take responsibility and make sure that isnt the case. BUT many men dont. They just kind of go along for the ride putting their head in the sand and hope it doesnt happen.

I also think its very childish of you op to keep persisting with abstinence as a form of contraception. Unless you have both spoken and mutually agreed you are okay in a sexless marriage you know that isnt feasible for most people, and by the sounds of it you wouldnt want sexless marriage either as you never refuse sex. If you went down that road it leads to the feeling of being unwanted, rejection ect.

You both need to sit down and have a serious grown up discussion. Figure out a way of contraception BEFORE you have sex again and only then have sex. Stop chancing bringing a poor baby into the world this way. You both need to be mature about this!