Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse to take contraception

461 replies

GreatBigArse · 20/07/2021 08:49

Curious to hear what others think following a conversation with my friend.

I'll try to keep it short.

Myself and DH have one child, DS. DH is adamant he wants no more children. I am actually okay with this although I wouldn't mind another if it happened. I feel very much if it doesn't happen that's fine, if he changed his mind that would also be nice but I wouldn't push it.

After a really horrible experience with both the implant and depo injection I have said I am not taking hormonal contraception again. I feel so much happier and myself without it and I will not be putting anything like that in my body ever again. I was considering the copper coil but someone I know recently got an infection due to it and it's really put me off.

I have told DH this, I've told him I'm no longer going to be the one to bother with all of that. I've not given him other options but as a grown up I'm sure he knows what his options are (no sex, condoms, which he hates, or the snip which he also doesn't want). I also mentioned that if anything did happen he should know I wouldn't be considering a termination.

It sounds very matter of fact written down but this is all just in general conversation with my husband.

He has continued to instigate and have sex (occasionally using the "pull out" method or asking me if I think its a "safe" time in my cycle to which I always answer I don't know).

My friend thinks I am being irresponsible allowing this to go on with someone who I know really doesn't want another child and whilst my husband should also be responsible, I am risking bringing an unwanted child into the world which is unfair and therefore I should also take some responsibility as regardless of want DH does, I know he doesn't want another child and I'm continuing to have unprotected sex with him.

AIBU to think I am within my rights to refuse to use contraception (other than condoms if DH instigates them) and so long as I have explained that to my husband, it's fine to carry on as we are? Or do you think I have some responsibility here knowing that he doesn't want another child and I should take contraception I don't want to take?

Ps. I know it sounds a very odd conversation to have with a friend but we often talk about more serious things like this and have various debates about things. She's a bit like my sister and we've been friends for a very long time.

YANBU - it's fine to not use contraception all long as you have told DH and he knows the situation.

YABU - you shouldn't have sex with DH unprotected even if you've told him and should take contraception yourself.

OP posts:
Lazypuppy · 20/07/2021 10:44

God its depressing how many women are trying to force all these different types of contraception on the woman only!! Men can use condoms or have the snip, or risk another child. Why should women always have to hold the responsibility, like i say depressing to read.

OPs husband is a grown up and understands how sex can lead to children and he is deciding to carry on having unprotected sex.

OP YANBU

Farwest · 20/07/2021 10:43

The OP would not be having an unwanted child. She wants a child.

Carrotinthesky · 20/07/2021 10:43

A diaphram is NOT invasive. It's a bit of rubber you insert then remove. It's the equivalent of the condom. So if you won't even consider it, you are no better than your DH

Some women find them very uncomfortable and they have to be left in for hours, unlike a condom which is only there for the duration. That's pretty invasive in my book.

TheAntelope · 20/07/2021 10:42

And talking about the pleasure of sex. If I sat there and watched, convinced or encouraged my partner to put something inside themselves that I knew they didn't want to, the pleasure would be gone anyway.

LalalalalalaLand123 · 20/07/2021 10:42

@TheAntelope
Where on earth did I say the woman should take all the responsibility? I said the exact opposite - that in sex, both man and woman are BOTH responsible for the risk of pregnancy. How they manage that shared responsibility between them, is for them to discuss. Of course the preventative action mostly gets taken on by the woman, for various reasons, but it doesn't need to be, obviously, and a woman can't put all the responsibility on the man, nor can a man put it all on a woman

  • though of course they often try, or expect that, which is the point you're making I think.
Mrgrinch · 20/07/2021 10:41

This sounds really toxic to me.

LoislovesStewie · 20/07/2021 10:40

[quote EL8888]@LoislovesStewie why does the responsibility for contraception have to sit with her though?[/quote]
It doesn't; I didn't like condoms, as that was how I got pregnant. So I used a diaphragm for quite a while. My choice, I agree.

TheAntelope · 20/07/2021 10:39

The only thing that is right is the compromise reached by both together

But how do you compromise when it comes to contraception? How do you share responsibility for it? Either one party uses something either hormonal or invasive which comes with far more side effects or one uses a condom.

Either option is still one party taking the full responsibility. I know which one I'd choose to do if I loved my partner as a man though.

SupremeDreamz · 20/07/2021 10:39

Amazing responses here.

Women mobilise support in shocking case of man facing the possibility of wearing a johnny.

user1471462428 · 20/07/2021 10:38

I’m an unwanted child who wrecked their parents marriage and their siblings happy home. Please don’t do this to another child. My siblings literally remember the before and after and essentially my birth was to blame for their home breaking up (it took a few years but they tell me there was a massive shift in my parents marriage when I was born). Don’t put this on a blameless child.

PinkPlantCase · 20/07/2021 10:37

@JungleBeats

Mini pill and withdrawal?
The mini pill is still hormonal contraceptive and it takes lots of people a long time to find one that agrees with them.

OP doesn’t want hormonal contraception and has made that quite clear.

Farwest · 20/07/2021 10:37

Wanting to use condoms does not mean that someone wants to get pregnant. It generally means the opposite 🤣

I agree! But OP doesn't want to use condoms, not really. She'd prefer nothing at the moment and that's all fine.

I am wondering how this plays out after she has the next baby, if she wants no more. Because then this situation is untenable.

vivainsomnia · 20/07/2021 10:37

Some very depressing comments and attitudes on this thread. Then people wonder why men are so entitled, yeah partly because some people want to pander to them so much! Inserting foreign objects inside you and / or lots of hormones. Because he doesn’t want to wear a condom?!
Or you can see it from the the side and women wanting things their way at all time. Happy to take hormones when it suits them to because they really don't want to be pregnant and want to be in control. Happy to stop when they want to be pregnant, then imposing that they don't go back on hormones because they still want to be pregnant and hope that it will happen somehow, which clearly won't if they do use hormones again.

There is no right or wrong, women or men's rights trump the others. This is about partnership working. I am not surprised so many relationships collapse when people are so tuned in their wishes and desires, and so quick to dismiss those of their partner using whichever justification to convince themselves that they are right.

The only thing that is right is the compromise reached by both together.

TheAntelope · 20/07/2021 10:37

I said the explanation provided in her OP (I know this one person who got an infection) was a pisspoor way to make a decision about medical interventions. It really is.

Except it isn't. If you knew someone who'd had a severe reaction to something medical as in you actually knew the person, AND (as OP has said later on) had read from multiple women that they'd had side effects too being heavy and painful periods, would you really rush out to get one yourself?

Of course it's a valid reason.

Carrotinthesky · 20/07/2021 10:37

As for those pushing diaphragms, I had one once briefly and they are shit. I remember having to coat it with lots of spermicide so it felt revolting. I then had to leave it in for much of the next day, which I hated

Agreed. They are messy, inconvenient and in my case really uncomfortable. I persevered for about 6 months by which time I was glad to see the back of it. I wouldn't have cared if it meant I never had sex again.

StrawberryMargarita · 20/07/2021 10:36

YANBU. At all. I can't believe so many people, are disagreeing with you or trying to talk you out of your decision.

Your DH has different options he can choose from as well. He's free to make his decision as you are to make yours. I completely agree with you.

Darbs76 · 20/07/2021 10:36

Can’t believe anyone would say you’re being unreasonable as you don’t want to use contraception. Your husband has 3 options if he doesn’t want another child. 1. Condoms 2. Vasectomy. 3 Abstain.

JungleBeats · 20/07/2021 10:35

Mini pill and withdrawal?

TheAntelope · 20/07/2021 10:35

Obviously you SHARE responsibility when it comes to sex and potential pregnancy

Except men don't 9 times out of 10 do they? How exactly is the OP having the coil, or the implant, or a diaphragm or the injection or the pill, her husband sharing the responsibility with her? It's not. It's the woman taking it all, as usual.

CoRhona · 20/07/2021 10:34

It's not a conversation that is repeatedly happening with DH or causing an atmosphere.

I think you're both burying your heads. Either you will carry on like this and not get pregnant or most likely you will. And then it will be to late to discuss it.

LucindaT73 · 20/07/2021 10:34

I found the diaphragm invasive and revolting

Well, that's one opinion anyway.

So why did you bother with it in the first place? Surely you knew what happened with it? You have to be fitted and shown how to use it. No one made you.

Farwest · 20/07/2021 10:34

It is literally not up to anyone else to tell someone they are unreasonable to not put something into their own body for whatever bloody reason they want.

I have not said she should use a coil. Or a diaphragm. Or anything at all. Quite the opposite.

I said the explanation provided in her OP (I know this one person who got an infection) was a pisspoor way to make a decision about medical interventions. It really is.

There are lots of good reasons to avoid a coil, the biggest one being that you hope to get pregnant. A coil would be ill advised!

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 20/07/2021 10:34

DH is adamant he wants no more children

Then he has the snip. End of.

You've been very honest with him about not taking any more contraception. The rest is up to him.

Why should contraception be solely down to you?

TheAntelope · 20/07/2021 10:33

If you didn't want another pregnancy as much as he doesn't, you would take different actions

She's been incredibly clear that she isn't as against another pregnancy as her husband is.

Puditt · 20/07/2021 10:33

@Namenic if op was okay with abstinence why is she still having sex with him? That's a form of contraception she is okay with therefore she should be implementing it, but she's not. So I doubt she truly is. Nothing has been stopping her from saying no.