Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse to take contraception

461 replies

GreatBigArse · 20/07/2021 08:49

Curious to hear what others think following a conversation with my friend.

I'll try to keep it short.

Myself and DH have one child, DS. DH is adamant he wants no more children. I am actually okay with this although I wouldn't mind another if it happened. I feel very much if it doesn't happen that's fine, if he changed his mind that would also be nice but I wouldn't push it.

After a really horrible experience with both the implant and depo injection I have said I am not taking hormonal contraception again. I feel so much happier and myself without it and I will not be putting anything like that in my body ever again. I was considering the copper coil but someone I know recently got an infection due to it and it's really put me off.

I have told DH this, I've told him I'm no longer going to be the one to bother with all of that. I've not given him other options but as a grown up I'm sure he knows what his options are (no sex, condoms, which he hates, or the snip which he also doesn't want). I also mentioned that if anything did happen he should know I wouldn't be considering a termination.

It sounds very matter of fact written down but this is all just in general conversation with my husband.

He has continued to instigate and have sex (occasionally using the "pull out" method or asking me if I think its a "safe" time in my cycle to which I always answer I don't know).

My friend thinks I am being irresponsible allowing this to go on with someone who I know really doesn't want another child and whilst my husband should also be responsible, I am risking bringing an unwanted child into the world which is unfair and therefore I should also take some responsibility as regardless of want DH does, I know he doesn't want another child and I'm continuing to have unprotected sex with him.

AIBU to think I am within my rights to refuse to use contraception (other than condoms if DH instigates them) and so long as I have explained that to my husband, it's fine to carry on as we are? Or do you think I have some responsibility here knowing that he doesn't want another child and I should take contraception I don't want to take?

Ps. I know it sounds a very odd conversation to have with a friend but we often talk about more serious things like this and have various debates about things. She's a bit like my sister and we've been friends for a very long time.

YANBU - it's fine to not use contraception all long as you have told DH and he knows the situation.

YABU - you shouldn't have sex with DH unprotected even if you've told him and should take contraception yourself.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Dina0 · 07/08/2021 23:43

YANBU you have been completely honest with your husband about not been on contraception. If he doesnt want another child you have now left him to take responsibility and prevent this from happening. You haven't been dishonest or tried to trap him with a baby like soo many women do. If it was me though i would push the conversation again about not been on contraception and if he doesn't want another baby to do something about it. I think a baby added to the sitaution that he doesn't want will only lead to an unhappy child, parent relationship and resentment in the long run.

callmeadoctor · 07/08/2021 22:05

I would be testing this and saying to DH that my period is late, maybe make him think about all this by giving him a fright and seeing how he reacts........

juice92 · 07/08/2021 21:41

100% your choice not to take contraception, I came off it years it ago and we just avoid my ovulating days (or use the pull out method if we do).

I think it is your Husband who does not another child and so it is his responsibility to find a way of 'not getting pregnant' that works, however I do think you should figure out your cycle (if it is regular of course) and make sure he has the information available to him to make an informed decision.

Od130990 · 07/08/2021 21:23

YANBU
If he's that sure he doesn't want anymore children than he needs to put something on the end of it!
You have already given him a child, tried different contraception that haven't worked... so why should you be subjected to pumping your body full of hormones so he can ( hit it raw )
What does he thinks going to happen if he refuses condoms or the snip? That he'll win a widescreen TV?
I think it's the least he can do, especially when you consider the fact that condoms are free but the morning after pill costs a small fortune.

sunstreaming · 21/07/2021 15:58

My sister (to whom I'm very close) had something like this many years ago, when it was maybe less common for contraception to be discussed in such an everyday way...anyway. She was on the pill for 6 years and came off it to conceive. She'd had to change to a 'lighter' prescription because she had some issues with breast lumps and the GP thought she'd been on the original pill for long enough. She conceived within 6 months. There were some health scares about the baby during the pregnancy, but fortunately everything turned out OK. She wanted to trust exclusive breast feeding for contraception (I know!) and this worked for about a year, when her periods came back. her husband was very reluctant to use condoms and would only use them when she was at her fertile time. He also wouldn't go and buy them or visit the GP for them, so she had to treck to the FP clinic every few weeks, which she said was humiliating and also a waste of her time. She got pregnant again and had her second child and her husband promised that he would have a vasectomy. She was looking forward to being freed from having o take hormonal contraception or visit the FP clinic (now with 2 kids in tow). But he never got round to it. She was worried about having another child for financial reasons, she was also getting older and was concerned about birth defects (re first pregnancy) and also knew that IF she had another child and there was a problem, she'd end up dealing with most of the fall-out and having to 'comfort' him about things not having worked out. She broached the conversation when her periods returned and said that he needed to take some responsibility and that she didn'rt want to have sex with him without contraception ( as a way of pushing him towards the vasectomy which he'd promised) He was angry with her and threatned to 'find someone else' if she wouldn't have sex. I told her she should have said, 'You're welcome to do that but if the other woman also won't use contraception then you'll be paying for another child ..and also all the emotional fall-out.' But she didn't do this. She agreed to have a diaphragm because he said it would only be temporary while he organised a vasectomy. But he didn't organise it and she was really distressed to find she was pregnant again. She said to me that she couldn't see any way out of the situation if she wanted to stay in the relationship other than getting pregnant again and again until she hit the menopause. I persuaded her to see her GP and her husband said is she organised a vasectomy for him, then he'd do it. She did all this but she was upset that the GP thought she was being foolish. She felt manipulated by everyone. In the end he failed to go forhis appointment so she asked the GP for a sterilsation which was done a few months later. It slved some of the problems although my sister felt she'd been treated badly. What really gobsmacked me was hearing him say many years later, that he was just 'so fertile' that she got pregnant easily, as if it was to his credit, but also that they'd sorted it out and she'd been sterilised. It sounded to me as if he thought that her getting pregnant again was due to a failing of hers and she needed the punishment of a stay in hospital. I just wished sh'd been more assertive about the whhole thing, but she was very isolated and the only person she ever talked to about it was me. I liveda long way from her and wasn't really part of her life. It was easier for me to suggest the tougher approach than it was for her to pursue it. I just wish she'd been able to get more support and get him to see he was being irresponsible, but that didn't happen. I haven't explained this very well and maybe there are some inconsistencies, but I'm relating it all second hand.

cravingmilkshake · 21/07/2021 15:30

I think this is such a challenge being women- some of my friends are in the same position as you.

I had a baby in 2019 - she is just approaching two.

My husband wanted two children, so we decided in January to try for another - anyway, I am now pregnant with twins who are due in 10 weeks.

He was adamant he only wanted two, (I would have liked 3) unfortunately it didn't work that way for him, but I have been lucky.

We had a chat recently and I have explained that as I have been on the pill since I was 16, (came off just before our wedding in 2019) I will not be going back on it. Husband is adamant he doesn't want another child, so once the twins have arrived and possibly get to a year old, he will be booking himself in for a vasectomy.

This is for his reasons, as I laid out to him the risks and he made that decision.

I hope you can come to a common place! X

VestaTilley · 21/07/2021 15:19

YANBU, after years of the Pill I’m done with hormonal contraception; I don’t want any of the other methods or a coil either, so we just use condoms.

Your body your choice.

When we’ve completed our family DH will have the snip.

Nanny0gg · 21/07/2021 15:17

@TheAntelope

"Don't assume he's "agreed" to anything

I'm not really sure what other assumption you can make if you've said 'hey DH I'm not taking any contraception and if I get pregnant I'm not having an abortion' and he says okay and continues to have sex with you.

Unless he's a complete idiot that is obviously agreement to take the risk.

And how many men walk away from just that situation?
Topseyt · 21/07/2021 15:09

@PrincessNutella

I do think it is hilarious that his lordship doesn't want another child so the scolds are out telling the OP all the ways she can prevent him from fathering one--except by taking responsibility for his decision.
So do I!

Some are also missing part of the point of the thread and suggesting that OP gets herself sterilised when she has been quite clear that she is amenable to having another child. Would quite like it even.

Are people's comprehension skills so poor that they cannot see why someone who would quite like another baby would not see this as an option?

Bizawit · 21/07/2021 14:48

@PrincessNutella

I do think it is hilarious that his lordship doesn't want another child so the scolds are out telling the OP all the ways she can prevent him from fathering one--except by taking responsibility for his decision.
Exactly this. Unbelievable. Apparently we are in 2021 going on 1950. Honestly you have to laugh otherwise it would be so infuriating and soul destroying.
Ald1Alert2 · 21/07/2021 14:46

You are both not using contraception

He asks you is it safe

No, no, no

He will blame you

NotTodaySatanNotToday · 21/07/2021 14:37

@vivainsomnia

It comes down to him hating condoms vs you not wanting to try the copper just because of one account of a rare event.

I can understand your position that ultimately, you'd be happy with another child, so why should you be the one dealing with contraception. I can see his point that if he condoms really impact on his enjoyment of sex, you not wanting to even try the copper is being a bit selfish.

You really need to talk and come up with a compromise you can both deal with. As things stands, you are likely heading towards trouble and heartache. From that perspective, then yes, you are both being irresponsible.

So him enjoying sex less due to condoms trumps her not wanting a coil? OK then. Do a woman had to have a something she doesn't want so he can enjoy sex more, a bit misogynistic don't you think? So much for body autonomy
PrincessNutella · 21/07/2021 14:34

I do think it is hilarious that his lordship doesn't want another child so the scolds are out telling the OP all the ways she can prevent him from fathering one--except by taking responsibility for his decision.

ConsuelaHammock · 21/07/2021 14:23

If he really doesn’t want another baby then he can have a vasectomy.
If another baby does arrive it won’t be the end of the world? It’s not like you have 4 or 5 already.

Washimal · 21/07/2021 14:14

I didn't vote because the issue isn't as binary as you make out. YANBU to refuse to take hormonal contraception for any reason, of course you're not. Your body, your choice. Your DH is NBU to say he doesn't want another child, that's perfectly valid. However, YABU as a couple to be having unprotected sex when you both know that one of you doesn't want another child.

He is irresponsible to continue having unprotected sex with you and risk bringing a child into the world he does not want. You are being naive and short-sighted to continue having unprotected sex with a man who has categorically said he does not want another child and think it'll all be fine if you do get pregnant. You're right, OP that he should be the one to take responsibility for contraception since he is the one who doesn't want a pregnancy, but he hasn't taken responsibility, so why are you just accepting this? You are both thinking about this from entirely your own perspectives and failing to consider the impact on the potential child. Stop having unprotected sex with him and tell him he needs to sort contraception.

NeonDreams · 21/07/2021 13:52

@Nsky

Just to add, not all women after sterilisation get bad periods, accupunture can help, no issues, good choice for me
@Nsky She would like another child. So why would she want to get sterilised (an invasive procedure for women when having a Vasectomy is quicker, easier and safer with less risks and less side affects)? It's rather counterproductive for her to undergo such an invasive procedure would she would want another child. Please RTFT.
Bizawit · 21/07/2021 13:44

@1Saymynamesaymyname

Why are you having unprotected sex with someone who does not want a child?

Why is he having unprotected sex when he doesn't want a child?

Seriously, I think you both need to grow up.

Sorry.

If he doesn’t want a child that’s HIS responsibility, not OP’s 🙄

He’s obviously not that bothered if he’s happy to have unprotected sex.

Ohhyeahright · 21/07/2021 12:42

You’re not bu in the slightest op. A sea change is needed with regards to attitudes to contraception. Boils my blood.

1Saymynamesaymyname · 20/07/2021 20:26

Why are you having unprotected sex with someone who does not want a child?

Why is he having unprotected sex when he doesn't want a child?

Seriously, I think you both need to grow up.

Sorry.

MumInBrussels · 20/07/2021 20:00

Of course you're not being unreasonable in not wanting to use hormonal contraception.

But you are being a bit unreasonable in assuming he'll magically change his mind if/when you get pregnant, and possibly in assuming he has completely understood that this is a very real possibility - him repeatedly asking you if it's a safe time to have sex suggests that he doesn't want another child, and he thinks this is a good contraceptive alternative to condoms.

I think you need to have a conversation with him where you talk about what would happen if you got pregnant. If your cycle is currently messed up, you have no real way of knowing when your fertile days are exactly, so you're more likely to get pregnant accidentally, even if you didn't want to. I think he might not entirely realise this, and you're resting a lot on the hope that he'll be happy really - he really might not be. In which case, this conversation can be the catalyst for him making sure he uses condoms every time, or has a vasectomy. Or you'll find out that he'd actually be ok with having another child is you got pregnant so you can carry on as you are, and you'll probably have another baby soon.

shrodingersbiscuit · 20/07/2021 19:02

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ.

Cakeorchocolate · 20/07/2021 18:59

YANBU at all.

From your posts you are both fully aware of the situation and have made decisions that neither of you are unhappy with.

I probably wouldn't be bothering to track my cycle either. If DH doesn't want to use contraceptives after you previously using them for years, that's his risk. It's unfair to still expect you to take responsibility for trying to predict if it's low risk enough to have sex, not to mention taking the spontaneity out of it.

As he's against vasectomy, and happy to risk withdrawal method (though personally, I can't understand how it's considered a method by some) it doesn't sound like he's actually against another child. As long as you've both considered the consequence of a pregnancy, which it seems you have, then your friend has played devil's advocate, nothing more. It sounds like you're still happy with the status quo. Don't worry what the mn masses think (including me! Grin).

RandomMess · 20/07/2021 18:45

It's bizarre how some people think birth control is solely the woman's responsibility.

After years of taking the responsibility, being pregnant and giving birth surely it's entirely reasonable that the male partner takes responsibility when he's the one that doesn't want more children!!

LuaDipa · 20/07/2021 18:25

@FangsForTheMemory

I wouldn't be using contraception but I'd also be refusing to have sex unless your DH used a condom. Pulling out is a good way to get pregnant: does he really think you won't conceive that way? By asking you if it's a safe time of the month, he's AGAIN making it your responsibility to avoid pregnancy.
Completely agree with this.

If you fall pregnant you can guarantee it will be your fault. After all, he is taking the time to ask about your cycle, it’s not his fault that you aren’t taking responsibility (firmly tongue in cheek as I think he’s being an absolute twat).

I would also refuse sex without a condom. If he can’t wear one of those for 20 minutes he can’t expect you to bother with anything more intrusive.

morepizzapls · 20/07/2021 17:59

@LemonLymanDotCom

Your body, your choice. Absolutely refuse to take contraception if you're fine with having a baby (& know he can pay for it if you both split up over it). Place the ball very much in his court, why should women always have to take the responsibility?
hate the "he can pay for it" comments about a potential future child that could be conceived. oh yes, that really makes up for having an absent/uninterested parent as a child doesn't it and for the other child to have a potentially broken home.

what a wonderful environment to bring a baby into!

just so we can all rejoice and pat ourselves on the back for holding the moral high ground, whilst smugly saying well I DID tell you I didnt mind if I got pregnant. fuck what it does to the kids though and their mental health.

Swipe left for the next trending thread