Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

1 sibling just given a house

395 replies

canary1 · 20/07/2021 07:40

My parents have two houses, one they live in, one has sat empty for many years. The empty house was inherited. I’ve just been told third hand that one of my siblings is to be given it, is moving into it, and in addition, is being financially assisted by my parents to do the work that needs doing to it. It will be her house.
Some may say I’m merely jealous, but of course I’m jealous that one sibling has been this on a plate, while the rest of us work hard to achieve far less.
I also feel it confirms my parents’ hurtful and now blatantly obvious bias towards her.
AIBU to feel hurt and upset by this news?

OP posts:
GrandDuchessRomanov · 20/07/2021 09:29

Wow! What shitty parents you have OP.

My sympathies.

anon12345678901 · 20/07/2021 09:29

@AhNowTed

It's irrelevant whether the sibling bought or could buy their own home. That was their life choice.

They should all be treated equally regardless. Who knows what the future holds for any of them.

No one sibling should be gifted a house while the rest pay a mortgage for 30 years.

Actually it's not always a life choice; what a silly comment. Circumstances can change for anyone.

This is not OP house nor money, yes express your disappointment, but it never has belonged to the siblings to share the money from it.

Warmduscher · 20/07/2021 09:28

@GrandmasCat

My sister was very angry for years because my parents bought me and my son a house when I divorced.

They didn’t buy me a house, they lent me £5000 for the deposit which I returned in a few months. But nobody told her the details because she never asked.

It is not unusual for parents to help those who they see more in need. They also help in different ways, my parents didn’t lend her money for a deposit as she had enough saved for that but they are still cooking lunches for her, dealing with her laundry, babysitting her dog, and paying for her and her friends every time they go to a restaurant (2-4 times a week) or on a holiday together.

So if your sister and her friends eat out four times in one week, say four friends at minimum £20 a head, your parents would shell out £360 in one week? On top of paying for your sister and her friends to go on holiday, which must run into thousands?

Sorry, but they sound like mugs.

groovergirl · 20/07/2021 09:27

What jumps out is that your DPs have not mentioned this to you. It looks like they mean to keep it a secret (except that you found out). Perhaps they think the tyranny of distance will work in their favour. You are right to be pissed off, especially as they've already helped your sister buy a flat.

A similar thing happened to XH. His uncle died, XFIL inherited uncle's flat and turned it over to his unemployed DS2 to sell and pocket the proceeds. Not a cent for his DS1, my XH, who had slogged his guts out at school and work and had a new baby (DD) and a big mortgage.

It's a toxic situation, and you have my sympathy. I suspect, though, that you'll have to wait until your DPs go to god, then challenge the will.

Pipsquiggle · 20/07/2021 09:25

So sorry about this OP. I would be incensed by this as well. Why do parents do this and think there will be no consequences?!

I have been trying to think of scenarios where you could justify giving 1 child more than his / her siblings in a will or gift - the scenarios are generally where a child or their GC would have a life limiting illness and therefore need more care or kit to lead a more fulfilling life.

I think you are going to have to talk to your parents about this and also your other siblings to see how they feel

ItsVousNotMoi · 20/07/2021 09:25

I would have it out with them. Unbelievably cruel. What have you got to lose?

KnightandDay · 20/07/2021 09:25

I completely understand you being upset OP - I can't imagine treating my children like that.
The fact that your parents haven't mentioned it to you seems to me like they know it's not a fair thing to do. I do think they only thing to do is to ask them why - maybe they have a valid reason that no-one else knows about.

Horehound · 20/07/2021 09:24

I think it is shit but it's up to them what they do with their stuff.

However, are you certain they will have signed over the house to her, in her name?
I would imagine she has been told she can live there rent free and they will do it up but that's not to say it's going to be her asset.

I would deffo find out more.

Also maybe the set up comes with a tie such as "we give you this house, you are our carer in old age". Or some such thing..

AlfonsoTheMango · 20/07/2021 09:24

There's more to the story and the only way to know all the details is to have the parents share their side, which isn't going to happen.

You're just going to have to accept that this is the way it is, OP.

DrSbaitso · 20/07/2021 09:23

It's awful, OP, and I feel for you. I think most people would feel the same.

What do you think your parents' justification would be, assuming this is all true (I do think it's worth checking)? I'm not saying it would be right but it would help to know the thought process. They may think that if she is single she needs the money more than the siblings who have other incomes, and that a house may act as a compensation for not having a family if she wanted one. Not saying that's right, just that it might not be completely straightforward.

SalmonEile · 20/07/2021 09:22

Couple of thoughts ,
Maybe they want to make sure she’s “looked after” when they’re gone ?

Or does the house have any sentimental value ? Is it a family home (did it belong to your grandparents or one of your parents siblings for example)and they want to keep in the family without the stress of renting ?

Cupoftea53 · 20/07/2021 09:19

I would be so angry about this. I am by far the lower earning sibling and would never expect to receive more money from my parents because of it. This is the sort of thing that should be discussed within families. We have found out that PIL secretly give BIL money as we have overheard them on the phone when we have visited (incidentally he never visits them! We are the ones who visit, include them at Xmas, invite them on holidays etc). We found out that they bought him a car and pay the running costs, pay his credit card bill, pay for his TV package etc. They do favour him a lot even though DH is the one who runs around after them. It’s sad for DH, but he is a better person about it than I am!

Lemonmelonsun · 20/07/2021 09:19

Two for three, this isn't an inheritance yet!.

Twoforthree · 20/07/2021 09:19

@5zeds

Presumably when your sister dies the house will be left to you all?
Eh? The siblings might go first.
Lemonmelonsun · 20/07/2021 09:19

Op it sounds like you don't know your sibling well.
What if it transpired she had many issues you don't know about, wouid that make a difference, also why has this house been sat empty for years and no one worried about it being empty!

Twoforthree · 20/07/2021 09:18

It’s not just the money, it’s what it represents about how your parents feel about you. Yanbu on either count.

I’d be so upset.

Lemonmelonsun · 20/07/2021 09:17

I've got a potential similar situation coming in that one of dc seems steady, sensible, will wait for ten cookies rather than eat one right now. Other dd is totally opposite and struggles at school I'm already worried for her future and dh and I are not rich.
How can we support both equally if one is able for instance to buy a house but the other can't?

BustopherPonsonbyJones · 20/07/2021 09:17

I know it’s their house and their choice but I would be very upset and it would make me angry with my parents and my sibling for taking it.

On the other hand, I do think you actually need to speak to them as The information you have been given is third hand. Now you’ve said she’s single, I’m wondering if they’ve done it so she can actually have a home as the cost of a deposit is beyond many on one income - something you might not have experienced as you have a partner. They may intend to take that off the money left to her in the will too so you get more then. I’d talk to them. Then come back and let us know as it would affect my judgement.

Musmerian · 20/07/2021 09:16

@Shelddd

I don't know if I agree with the socialist arguments that money should go to those who haven't figured out life and need more help. Rewarding people for not doing well.
Excellent- the Daily Mail argument. Life is a lot more complex than this and parents are entitled to make their own decisions.
5zeds · 20/07/2021 09:16

Presumably when your sister dies the house will be left to you all?

BigPyjamas · 20/07/2021 09:16

Do you already have a house? Do you need a house? Would you want to live in this house, is it in a good location for your life?

And then same questions about your sibling?

I also would much rather see an empty house lived in and passed through a family than abandoned whilst siblings argued.

If you were both in the same need it seems unfair to give her something and not you. But I strongly believe that fair doesn't mean equal, and that ultimately your parents can do what they want with their money.

I can see why it stings. But as you haven't heard it directly from them, and don't have the details on any arrangement, or future arrangement for you, I'd hold off until you have more information.

Whatinthelord · 20/07/2021 09:14

I think you should just be direct. Tell them you’ve heard about the plan to give your sibling the house and tell them you are hurt by it and feel it’s unfair.

Whatinthelord · 20/07/2021 09:14

How come the house just sat empty for years and not just got sold or used?

Yes I’d feel the same as you. Unless one child needs extra support from a parent (eg if one child have a disability and will need carers etc) the. I don’t see how you can justify such a discrepancy in how you treat your children .

MrKlaw · 20/07/2021 09:13

Maybe she's just being allowed to live in it but it remains the parents' house? Still not ideal obviously but very different from being given such a large amount of equity

WeatherForecast · 20/07/2021 09:12

Going against the grain here to say YABU, on a few levels.

I've been in a similar situation being given £2000 while a sibling received ten times that amount, won't bore you with the details.

I think it's telling that this sibling is the only one who isn't a homeowner, and hasn't formed a steady relationship. I don't know if those two facts are linked in her situation, but it's far, far easier to get a mortgage when there are two of you to contribute a deposit, pay the mortgage, contribute to upkeep, and shoulder problems like redundancy that may befall any of us. If the rest of you have got partners and bought homes then it makes sense why if your parents wanted to give the property to one of you they'd choose her. A way of helping her to get on equal footing with the rest of you despite not having had the fortune to meet a partner like the rest of you have.

Secondly, I do think YABU to feel as though you have any right or claim over someone else's property. It comes across a bit like you feel as though it should have been yours or partly yours and now you're upset because it's been taken away from you. It was never yours, you and your parents are separate people and it's their home to do what they want with. Even if their choices don't make sense to you (or don't benefit you as much as you'd like them to).

'The rest of us work far harder to end up with a lot less' is a really horrible attitude to have. I worked hard to lift myself out of poverty and become a homeowner but that doesn't mean that outcome didn't also materialise due to a lot of privilege too. Meeting a partner is a major thing that not everyone is lucky enough to do. Being a homeowner (including with a mortgage, even if you don't own outright) is absolutely huge and something many people dream of but will never have. Your sister has I assume been paying rent for years while you pay towards buying your property, that doesn't make either of you more or less hard workers (you said yourself she has a career!).

What's fair isn't necessarily giving the precise same thing to every single child, and your parents have made their decision because they want your sister to have the home, not any of the rest of you. And that's down to them. If you allow something like this to ruin your relationship with them then I think you'll really regret it, there's no real way you can approach this with them without it seeming preposterous and entitled (imagine a grown adult crying to their parents because of what they've decided to do with a house they own, while being a homeowner themselves!).

I know you're coming across really bitter and quite nasty but I hope that's the shock talking and that once you've calmed down and processed it a bit you'll realise how unreasonable you're being here. I would hate to see it destroy your family relationships, but you do what you gotta do.

Swipe left for the next trending thread