Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To involve strangers in a meal train?

355 replies

ChockaChick · 20/07/2021 02:21

Just moved house and just had a baby…. We’ve briefly met the neighbours on either side and they seem perfectly pleasant. HV has suggested starting a meal train in the road. Yet I really don’t think I’d feel comfortable asking strangers to cook for us. Surely that’s something you organise amongst friends and family, not new neighbours you’ve not met yet? I’d think it a bit cheeky tbh if I got a demand for food from some unknown newbie. AIBU?

OP posts:
Lockdownbear · 20/07/2021 23:25

Hope you get better soon.
Goodness knows what she was thinking but I think you know its a daft idea. Although I'd be half tempted to ask her more about the "meal train" idea and ask how you get it started 🤔 just for the entertainment 😉

Take your time to get to know the neighbours in a more normal an natural fashion.

GreyhoundG1rl · 20/07/2021 23:07

Hope you recover soon, op. But really, don't do it...

ChockaChick · 20/07/2021 23:00

I love the reply about the HV maybe having been given some sort of ‘community engagement’ target.

I’m wondering now if I perhaps got the wrong end of the stick somehow. She asked if we’d met the neighbours here yet and I said just the two couples nextdoor very briefly and that they seemed nice. She then said, ‘Perhaps you could get a meal train going in the road.’ She maybe meant I could drop heavy hints that one of them could organise it? Although I’m not sure that’s any better, coercing some virtual stranger into taking on that kind of burden? I’m not getting the impression it’s that kind of street anyway where people even know each other behind their immediate neighbours.

Unfortunately I developed an infection postpartum which has slowed my recovery. However I am not short of family support and definitely don’t think this entitles me to free meals from strangers!!

OP posts:
2Rebecca · 20/07/2021 22:40

Never heard of this. Seems unnecessary in an era of microwave meals beans on toast and pasta and pesto. If you have no friends or family at all you could order easy to cook food online. I couldn't be bothered for cooking for people I don't know on a regular basis. I used to want to live in a commune but now it sounds like hell

JudgeJ · 20/07/2021 22:39

I've done something like this as a volunteer cook for a charity that prepared and delivered meals for very ill people

There's a world of difference between doing this for people who are ill and doing it merely because someone has a baby, that's hardly rocket science and I speak as someone who had two babies overseas with no outside 'support'.

UmamiMammy · 20/07/2021 22:33

You can't start one for yourself!

My church do this when someone is ill / has a baby etc. I really appreciated it after I had my children and always contribute.

Lockdownbear · 20/07/2021 20:35

@ChaToilLeam

It’s a lovely thing for friends, family or a community to organise when someone is in real need of support.

A friend of mine set up her own one after her DC was born. I found that a bit cheeky. She has a DH who had plenty of leave and they live in the city centre 2 mins from a supermarket, there are takeaways nearby, etc. No special circumstances, just a bit PFB.

Maybe she had a HV who'd been on the same course!

Seriously I think it's really cheeky.

I can get it in days of old the church rallying round a new mum, when many women were SAHMs and had time on their hands, almost welcoming that new mum into the SAHM community. And that new mum will one day be expected to pass on the favour.

But to try and organise it yourself amongst neighbours you barely know, with no idea of what else they have going on in their life's. Can they even afford to donate dinner to another couple because they asked?
Serious CF territory.

Buy a ready meal, keep your neighbours on side for the day you really need someone to hold your hand, while your toddler has knocked themselves out, or has blood pouring out them or their finger hanging off!

All real incidents when neighbours have been complete God sends.Wink

FightingtheFoo · 20/07/2021 20:12

@LemonRoses

I think its fine and perfectly normal if someone is very elderly and needs support, has a major event such as a partner in intensive care or someone is recovering alone from major surgery.

I can't begin to imagine why someone who has a baby would need it.

Then you must have an extremely defunct imagination.
GreyhoundG1rl · 20/07/2021 20:07

Yes I see the difference but a lot of posts on this thread think its cheeky fuckery to accept meals (from anyone) when all you've done is have a baby.
No. To ask for, not accept. Crucial difference.

Nobody accepting a friend's kindly meant gesture was labelled a cheeky fucker, ever.

Fizbosshoes · 20/07/2021 20:04

@GreyhoundG1rl

Yes I see the difference but a lot of posts on this thread think its cheeky fuckery to accept meals (from anyone) when all you've done is have a baby.
Although I've taken part as a recipient and a participant in meal totals I do think it would be weird to initiate, let alone as your opening conversation starter to new neighbours!
But lots of posters are saying the whole "meals for new parents" is outrageous, because they are apparently not needy enough.

And a lot of MN in general, appear to baulk at the idea of having to speak to, answer the door for, or have anything to do with their neighbours even mostly they aren't about to ask you to supply them with meals

GreyhoundG1rl · 20/07/2021 19:40

Sometimes they take in parcels for me, other times i take parcels for them. If they have visitors they might ask if they can use space on my drive. We feed each others pets while the other is on holiday . And all manner of other outrageously unmumsnetty things!
Nothing outrageous about any of that, it's perfectly normal for people who know each other. Op knows none of them. Most of them she hasn't even met.

Can you really not see the difference?

DeflatedGinDrinker · 20/07/2021 19:35

Might**

BigRedBoat · 20/07/2021 19:35

That would be so cringey to ask strangers to cook you dinner! Stock up on good quality ready meals, I like Cook meals.

DeflatedGinDrinker · 20/07/2021 19:34

If I'd lived next door to single mum Susan for 10 years who had just had twins and I actually really liked her I make take her something. what an odd thing to ask 😂

DeflatedGinDrinker · 20/07/2021 19:31

Oh god no if my neighbour asked me to cook for her because she chose to have a baby I'd hate her forever.

Bluntness100 · 20/07/2021 19:02

I can imagine this advice being given

I’m really struggling I can’t get to the shops or get a delivery. I can’t put her down, I’m exhausted and I’m not eating

Can’t your partner help, no he’s not on th scene or a piece of shit

Any family, friends

No, I’ve no one, please help me, what can I do, I need to eat, I’ve no food, no money, I can’t get out.

Maybe your neighbours could help, start a meal train?

Susannahmoody · 20/07/2021 18:39

Because, depending on the formality, they can be very scheduled, and they're mostly supposed to refer to a period of transition.

^
Grin

Fizbosshoes · 20/07/2021 18:27

FightingtheFoo

I cannot roll my eyes hard enough at all the women coming on here going "well I birthed sextuplets, lost 8 pints of blood and had my arm chopped off and still got straight off the operating table to cook a Cordon Bleu meal for 30 people."

Ever stop to think not everyone feels the same when having just given birth? And not everyone's babies are the same? And that hearing about your performative heroism isn't helpful. Or necessary.

I've heard of meal trains - yes, even in the Uk - and think it's a lovely, community thing especially now we live in a world where most people are not living near their family.

But agree it's better when organised by someone on your behalf.

I think we are in the minority!
People at church did this for me when I had "just" given birth to a baby (no complications, and 1 other toddler at home and a DH who is very good at cooking) and I dont feel a CF about it. It helped me out when I found things difficult. No one would have been forced to cook a meal, people signed up voluntarily, just as I did when other meal rotas (I've never heard the expression meal train before) were set up for all manner of reasons, for other people. Once I just picked up a meal in the supermarket for a friend when she was having a difficult time.

To me I see this sort of thing as a give and take type thing. I received meals, I've also provided meals. In the same way my friends have stepped in and picked up my DC when I was running late for school pick up, and i have done the same or had their DC on a different occassion. I speak to most of my neighbours. Sometimes they take in parcels for me, other times i take parcels for them. If they have visitors they might ask if they can use space on my drive. We feed each others pets while the other is on holiday . And all manner of other outrageously unmumsnetty things!

Singinginshower · 20/07/2021 18:21

I really really really do not believe the HV gave this advice.

Either, as a PP said earlier, she was musing generally that meal trains were great in areas where this was a cultural norm.

Or, the OP has made this up as their first post.

GCrebel · 20/07/2021 16:46

@BlueLobelia

Maybe but the one thing I have found in my 12 years of parenting is that some people are very very good at getting others to do things for them.
Ain't that the truth!
GreyhoundG1rl · 20/07/2021 16:26

From the op, it appears that none of the potential donors are friends or even neighbours in anything but the "live in close proximity" sense.
She's just moved in and these people are complete strangers.
It's a bizarre way to introduce yourself to the neighbourhood.

Pallisers · 20/07/2021 16:21

It's also common In UK and always has been. But those who cook for neighbours in need, bring meals and offer practical help do so independently and completely voluntarily, without being asked or joining a website timetable etc.

yes but it isn't much use if every neighbour or friend drops over dinner on the same day. When my eldest was in daycare another mother had a stroke and was unable to use her right hand. it was a very stressful time for her and her family. so someone asked if they would like help with dinners and they said yes please. a sheet was left at the front desk where you could sign up for a dinner - think it was 2 days a week for 6 weeks of her initial recovery. That made far more sense than everyone dropping off food as they thought of it.

BlueLobelia · 20/07/2021 16:21

Maybe but the one thing I have found in my 12 years of parenting is that some people are very very good at getting others to do things for them.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 20/07/2021 16:21

@ChaToilLeam

It’s a lovely thing for friends, family or a community to organise when someone is in real need of support.

A friend of mine set up her own one after her DC was born. I found that a bit cheeky. She has a DH who had plenty of leave and they live in the city centre 2 mins from a supermarket, there are takeaways nearby, etc. No special circumstances, just a bit PFB.

How to make friwnds run for mountains 101
GreyhoundG1rl · 20/07/2021 16:12

@ChaToilLeam

It’s a lovely thing for friends, family or a community to organise when someone is in real need of support.

A friend of mine set up her own one after her DC was born. I found that a bit cheeky. She has a DH who had plenty of leave and they live in the city centre 2 mins from a supermarket, there are takeaways nearby, etc. No special circumstances, just a bit PFB.

That's really terrible.