Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To involve strangers in a meal train?

355 replies

ChockaChick · 20/07/2021 02:21

Just moved house and just had a baby…. We’ve briefly met the neighbours on either side and they seem perfectly pleasant. HV has suggested starting a meal train in the road. Yet I really don’t think I’d feel comfortable asking strangers to cook for us. Surely that’s something you organise amongst friends and family, not new neighbours you’ve not met yet? I’d think it a bit cheeky tbh if I got a demand for food from some unknown newbie. AIBU?

OP posts:
SchrodingersImmigrant · 20/07/2021 08:04

a good example of when this kind of thing works is when a group of friends and/or neighbours get together and provide meals (on a rota) for a family who have just suffered a bereavement or an individual who is suffering significant illness.

Now that's logical and i think many of us have done it in our life but not in an organised fashion

TheSunShinesBrighter · 20/07/2021 08:03

The people around the person in need start up a ‘meal train’.
Not the person in need themselves.

Your HV is very odd suggesting you set one up yourself. She/he has obviously misunderstood what a MT !

Just moved house and just had a baby
I wouldn’t say you are a person in need tbh!

Ignoring the fact that the phrase ‘meal train’ is annoying, a good example of when this kind of thing works is when a group of friends and/or neighbours get together and provide meals (on a rota) for a family who have just suffered a bereavement or an individual who is suffering significant illness.

godmum56 · 20/07/2021 08:02

@H328

No wonder new parents struggle at times with the attitudes we have in this country. There's nothing wrong with looking after others in our community who might need a helping hand, for whatever reason. Not everyone copes the same after each birth for various reasons. I think the supportive and thoughtful act of making them a meal is a really lovely idea.

I wish we were all a hell of a lot less British at times tbh. Ok maybe the expectant mother is not the one to organise the meal train, but in itself it could be a great thing. Suppose it is that worst of MN crimes though - American.

no its because of the way that its been presented here. As has been said, many communities of people who already know each other do stuff like this. Where this happens, there is oversight and organisation and the service is offered, not arranged by the person who needs it. Personally I would not accept food cooked by folk I didn't know and i certainly wouldn't go door to door in a new neighbourhood asking for it
SchrodingersImmigrant · 20/07/2021 08:00

I wish we were all a hell of a lot less British at times tbh.

This is not just about "British". Many non Brits myself included raise the eyebrows at having to cook for random neighbours you aren't friend with.

gogohm · 20/07/2021 08:00

And surely the vast majority of new mums have a dp, failing that a mum, sister, best friend or just order from Ocado - asking strangers just no.

PandorasMailbox · 20/07/2021 07:59

@EmbarrassingAdmissions

But realistically, how hard is it to whack a pizza or a ready meal in the oven if you're really struggling?

If you mean the OP, some FTMs can be struggling badly. As can others who might have had a rough birth and be unsupported.

And some people can be so unwell that the simple actions you mention can be beyond them. And, for people who are carers for them, it can be a huge kindness at a time of increased stress or when they need to spend even more time caring for someone.

That's not really the issue. This is about the suggestion by the HV that the OP should ask complete strangers to cook food for her.

I've happily done it for friends when they've been ill, but would be a bit WTF if someone I hadn't met before rocked up to my house and requested an evening meal.

bigbluebus · 20/07/2021 07:58

Seriously? This is a 'thing' when someone has a baby? You usually know you're going to have a baby and roughly when. Plan ahead, fill the freezer or buy in easy to cook food supplies. If there's 2 adults then surely one can manage to put some food together for a meal! Totally different to someone suffering a bereavement when friends/neighbours dropping off meals is often the done thing in the UK.

H328 · 20/07/2021 07:57

No wonder new parents struggle at times with the attitudes we have in this country. There's nothing wrong with looking after others in our community who might need a helping hand, for whatever reason. Not everyone copes the same after each birth for various reasons. I think the supportive and thoughtful act of making them a meal is a really lovely idea.

I wish we were all a hell of a lot less British at times tbh. Ok maybe the expectant mother is not the one to organise the meal train, but in itself it could be a great thing. Suppose it is that worst of MN crimes though - American.

C8H10N4O2 · 20/07/2021 07:55

I sort of hope it’s a cultural thing we in the UK might import from the US because it sounds great

It wasn't called a meal train or done via a website but as a child in the UK this was something I remember for births/deaths/big events.

It was done within local communities - church/village/street/working club. More accurately - it was done by the women in the local community. I don't ever remember a man rocking up to someone's door with a casserole!

godmum56 · 20/07/2021 07:54

@RosesAndHellebores

I think you should write to your local CCG and express concern about the HV who undoubtedly needs some training/assessment of her life skills/common sense!
this absolutely...I mean i had heard stories about the incompetence of some HV's but that takes the cake
MrsRockAndRoll · 20/07/2021 07:53

The attached Daily Mail article is making me cringe. The absolute CFery of demanding people cook for you & then not even being willing to open the door to collect it/say thank you ShockAngryConfusedHmm

gogohm · 20/07/2021 07:52

What's that? You have had a baby, doesn't stop you from cooking! I was back cooking within 24 hours, just quick stuff at first obviously but babies, even newborns can be put down.

Hoppinggreen · 20/07/2021 07:51

Can you imagine getting a knock on the door
“hello, I have just had a baby and I was wondering if you would like to make me dinner?”
When one of my neighbours wife was in hospital I cooked extra and sent it round for a few days but this sounds nuts.
I also don’t understand why it’s a “train”

MrsRockAndRoll · 20/07/2021 07:50

@Lynnikins

Sorry if it seems unreasonable to ask, but what does "HV" stand for? I've worked through all possibilities but am still stumped.
@Lynnikins Health Visitor
SchrodingersImmigrant · 20/07/2021 07:50

I assume though in the US it's not just any random neighbours doing this but people who actually know each other well?

KihoBebiluPute · 20/07/2021 07:48

It's a lovely thing to do if it's so embedded into the culture that it is always going to be a reciprocal thing. In the US and other places where it's a thing, by the time someone qualifies for receiving the meals etc they have probably donated towards dozens of other people's needs over the years, and in subsequent years they will donate more, and so over the course of a lifetime most people would have given and received about the same amount, plus or minus a little to account for a particular individual being more or less generous, but the while community is so much richer in terms of the community bonds and mutual support. It's a great thing in principle but it can't be started off by a solo young mum who is struggling in a new area where she doesn't know anyone, unfortunately.

I don't know the figures, so I may be wrong here, but I suspect that the reason it is a lot bigger in the us than in the uk is that the uk has much higher benefits available for new mothers - you'll have SMP or MA if you have been in work, child benefit, and further means-tested benefits for the most in-need, so in effect the government is already facilitating the whole community rallying around to support the new family, via the tax system. It's just much less personal and friendly than receiving the contributions face-to-face.

EncroachingLoaf · 20/07/2021 07:47

I don't know what your HV is thinking. Where is your DH/DP in all of this? Seems weird she thinks it's acceptable to farm out the cooking to random women in the neighbourhood (and let's face it it will most likely be the women), when you presumably have a perfectly functioning partner at home Confused

Does anyone remember a news story about a CF couple doing this a few years back? They were being really entitled and fussy demanding lots of niche stuff. Don't think it ended well.

Babyboomtastic · 20/07/2021 07:47

If he is incapable then order in.

If he's incapable, then

  1. he needs to get over it/learn
  2. if he refuses, then reassess whether you want someone so useless that he can't take care of his basic need for food himself, when having a family.

Fixed it for you.

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 20/07/2021 07:46

No, stick with the begging letters and then order takeaways.
Grin

FuckingFabulous · 20/07/2021 07:45

I can remember reading a post on social media where a bunch of neighbours received a note from their new neighbours asking them to make meals for them because they were having a baby. Full of specific ingredients and dishes, and every person who wasn't American was aghast at the cheeky fuckery of it!

SchrodingersImmigrant · 20/07/2021 07:45

Unless people are single + family-less + immobile before birth, there is just no need because they can prep their own beforehand...
Surprise illness making cooking hard or impossible is a different matter.
Then again. There is trillion food deliveries now so...

Kanaloa · 20/07/2021 07:43

I honestly couldn’t imagine my neighbour saying ‘me and my husband are expecting our first baby, please can you make us some food and drop it off at our house?’ I don’t even know what I’d say.

Get your baby’s dad to make your food if you’re not up to it. If he is incapable then order in.

Manista · 20/07/2021 07:42

I'm surprised that your first response wasn't "What on earth is a meal train?" and your second "Don't be daft!". Grin

Babyboomtastic · 20/07/2021 07:42

Weird.

I can understand a meal train (but not organising your own) for single parents, people with illnesses/accidents/disabilities which impede their ability to cook, bereavement etc, but it's weird otherwise IMO.

Most babies have two parents around at the start at least, and a baby can only be held by one at a time, so I can't see why anyone should go hungry, even if for whatever reason they can't cook their own food or bring something in the oven.

To me, it perpetuates the stereotype that women cook, and that men don't, which is an awful assumption to have for a new family.

Maggiesfarm · 20/07/2021 07:41

Seriously weird. Embarrassing too.

Your Health Visitor suggested it? I know HVs come out with some gems but that takes the biscuit. Hopefully she won't be dropping round to yours very often.

No. I'm sure, like most people, you and your husband are capable of getting meals together, they don't have to be anything elaborate.

Congratulations on your baby, I hope you are both well.

Swipe left for the next trending thread