Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be really scared of Climate Change

189 replies

MagnificentDelurker · 19/07/2021 19:58

Everything seems to have accelerated with heat dome in pacific causing 1 billion creatures dying to the floods in Germany, etc.
We are running out of time and stuck with politicians that will not lead.

www.motherjones.com/environment/2021/07/heres-what-climate-scientists-are-really-saying-about-this-catastrophic-summer/

OP posts:
Noterook · 19/07/2021 23:33

Not on here necessarily but hear a lot of younger people complaining about the older generation, but most grew up with hand me downs, reusable glass bottles for milk as standard, hardly any international travel, plastic not covering everything, toys and other items were made to last. A lot I know carry on with stuff like that, they don't have the same attitude to throwing stuff away and consuming because adverts or peer pressure tells us too. I know that's not always the case at all and I'm talking about a time well past, but we could learn a lot.

Lockheart · 19/07/2021 23:32

@properg

Your logic would have us continually having more and more children in order to prop up older generations, which is unsustainable.

People aren't going to stop having children completely or are you suggesting sterilisation?
And again I'm not saying people should have dozens of children. I have simply pointed out that birth rates have rapidly declined & there are impacts of this which we need to plan for.

No, you said if we wanted to reduce the population then birth rates weren't the only thing we should be looking at.

The implication of which is that we should somehow be trying to prune those who already exist.

MakkaPakkas · 19/07/2021 23:32

This is a good group if you want like minded people who are trying to agitate for structural change: mothersriseup.org.uk/

Lockheart · 19/07/2021 23:30

@properg

We raise tax rates (as I said in my very first post, it won't be pretty or fun).

What taxes would you rise?

From a UK perspective, corporation, VAT, income, IHT, CGT...

You know, all of them.

People won't like it.

Noterook · 19/07/2021 23:30

YANBU, but i try not to think about it as it does my anxiety no favours. We do what we can as a family, and I keep an eye politically when deciding who to vote for, I would support pushing for action is it would help, but yeah I don't let it consume me.

iluvalfredo · 19/07/2021 23:30

What is going to happen if we continue how we are going and when will
It happen? Excuse my ignorance.

bluewanda · 19/07/2021 23:30

Actually I'm not too worried about China they are rapidly cleaning up their environmental act. Any my god when they decide to do something it damn well happens.

@Ooodlesofboodles do you have any reputable links to back up this information? Because it’s the first I’ve heard of it!

bluewanda · 19/07/2021 23:26

Earth is not there for the sole consumption of western countries.

What a horrible phrase. Earth shouldn’t be here for the “consumption” of anybody.

bluewanda · 19/07/2021 23:25

YANBU at all, but all the small things we can do (eat less meat, recycle more) feel like a drop in the ocean when you look at the pollution levels of places like China and consider all the people globally who are regularly flying on private jets and taking long haul flights. It’s disheartening to say the least.

Sidesaladofchips · 19/07/2021 23:25

It's terrifying...and inevitable.
I agree with PP that individual actions are important - eat less meat, use less plastic etc. But I winced today with the irony of buying my plant based sausages all wrapped up in a plastic tray and film... Confused

SilverOak · 19/07/2021 23:21

China and India have a right to bring their people out of poverty. Earth is not there for the sole consumption of western countries.
But the fact is, the planet simply cannot sustain 8bn people living at the same standard of living that Western societies have had in recent years. Or even 3bn people (the population of China and India). The US has approx 330m people and they create a third of the planet’s pollution. Now times that by 9 to see how much pollution China and India will create if they try to reach the same standard of living as the US.

properg · 19/07/2021 23:19

Your logic would have us continually having more and more children in order to prop up older generations, which is unsustainable.

People aren't going to stop having children completely or are you suggesting sterilisation?
And again I'm not saying people should have dozens of children. I have simply pointed out that birth rates have rapidly declined & there are impacts of this which we need to plan for.

womaninatightspot · 19/07/2021 23:18

@MagnificentDelurker

Fairyliz

We definitely deserve it although I do genuinely love humans. We are magnificent animals and not because of our current tech.
I love how we love to play and tell amazing stories. We are worth saving but we have to change. Unfortunately I don’t think it will happen soon enough. Let’s hope enough of us survive and not just billionaires

Do you think that's why all the billionaires are so determined to head into space?
properg · 19/07/2021 23:16

We raise tax rates (as I said in my very first post, it won't be pretty or fun).

What taxes would you rise?

EishetChayil · 19/07/2021 23:16

We are doomed.

Look how people reacted to being asked to wear a mask to stop a pandemic. Now imagine how they'll react when asked to forgo their ASOS hauls and plastic tat to stop climate change.

We're too inured in capitalism to ever turn things around.

properg · 19/07/2021 23:15

So how do you reduce the human population, if not by reducing birth rates?

I've not advocated for ever increasing birth rates, I've just pointed out they are falling & they are falling rapidly. Soon they will be globally below replacement rate so how much lower do you want them to be?

It's really something we need to address because it's going to cause huge issues.

Of course I'm not saying kill old people. However we have to look at a more sustainable approach. So take the UK perhaps care in the home should be funded by the user or prescriptions should not just be free. One of my own parents wants to travel abroad when it's their time after working in a care home & never wanting to end up in one. These are difficult conversations like the climate ones but we need to discuss them.

Lockheart · 19/07/2021 23:14

@properg

We can't get rid of those we have right now. What we can do is make sure we don't have as many in future.

But who looks after the older population? Who are the doctors & nurses caring for them? Who are the tax payers to provide the pensions?

If you have more old people who are economically inactive who funds everything?

The NHS in its current form won't exist when I retire so what happens then?

We raise tax rates (as I said in my very first post, it won't be pretty or fun).

We train more doctors, nurses, and carers (govts can incentivise this by funding medical training and paying properly, and reducing funding to other less needed vocations).

It won't be pretty or fun. Everyone will end up poorer.

Your logic would have us continually having more and more children in order to prop up older generations, which is unsustainable.

Angelica789 · 19/07/2021 23:13

It’s not just children but pets too. They have a large carbon footprint and are completely unnecessary.

torquewench · 19/07/2021 23:10

Oh, and of of our clients has a contract to produce circa 20 million plastic bottles for a supermarket, for just one (cleaning) product. Which makes me feel like Im pissing in the wind doing my bit and recycling everything I can.

DIYandEatCake · 19/07/2021 23:10

YANBU. I look at my children, innocent and full of hope, and worry so much about their futures and what hardships and horrors they might face. I can’t bear to think of them suffering. Sometimes I feel guilty for bringing them into this world.

ChocBeforeCock · 19/07/2021 23:09

@SilverOak

I’ll be dead before it all kicks off so I don’t care anyway. And this is why we have the problem We can’t even persuade people to wear masks to benefit those who are currently alive. So why do you think those same selfish people will change their entire lives to benefit people who haven’t even been born yet?
Well yes but the billions of disposable masks being manufactured and discarded (due to outnumber jellyfish in the ocean) aren’t exactly helping the environmental situation.
properg · 19/07/2021 23:07

We can't get rid of those we have right now. What we can do is make sure we don't have as many in future.

But who looks after the older population? Who are the doctors & nurses caring for them? Who are the tax payers to provide the pensions?

If you have more old people who are economically inactive who funds everything?

The NHS in its current form won't exist when I retire so what happens then?

torquewench · 19/07/2021 23:07

Well my local authority is doing its bit by narrowing the only direct route across the city, closing a few roads, engineering in congestion to be able to introduce a charge. Oh, and declaring a clean air zone, despite granting planning for building of tower blocks for new hotels and offices, all of which will be air conditioned, with the lights on all day, despite being floor to ceiling windows on every floor. Brill. I read somewhere 60% of emissions in cities come from buildings. So maybe fewer of them is the answer?

Lockheart · 19/07/2021 23:05

@properg

As you've said in your post, currently the global fertility rate is above the replacement rate. It will need to continue to fall.

But it is falling every year, 2.1 is the replacement level & of course that's an global average. It's higher in poorer countries as more dc mean more workers to help provide for the family. As those countries prosper, rates will fall faster.

As Ive said reducing the human population just by targeting birth rates is nonsense.

So how do you reduce the human population, if not by reducing birth rates?

Go on, how do you reduce the population without tackling birth rates in any way and without killing off those which are already here (which I hope no-one is suggesting)?

properg · 19/07/2021 23:03

As you've said in your post, currently the global fertility rate is above the replacement rate. It will need to continue to fall.

But it is falling every year, 2.1 is the replacement level & of course that's an global average. It's higher in poorer countries as more dc mean more workers to help provide for the family. As those countries prosper, rates will fall faster.

As Ive said reducing the human population just by targeting birth rates is nonsense.