Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be really scared of Climate Change

189 replies

MagnificentDelurker · 19/07/2021 19:58

Everything seems to have accelerated with heat dome in pacific causing 1 billion creatures dying to the floods in Germany, etc.
We are running out of time and stuck with politicians that will not lead.

www.motherjones.com/environment/2021/07/heres-what-climate-scientists-are-really-saying-about-this-catastrophic-summer/

OP posts:
Manycupsoftea · 20/07/2021 01:07

But if there is the will to put laws in place that severely tax: fossil fuel, second car ownership, meat sales, all forms of plastic... or any behaviour you want to encourage or discourage, what would happen?

MagnificentDelurker · 20/07/2021 00:50

@SilverOak

We can reduce consumption probably by 75% in the rich world and still conduct full satisfying lives You’ve seen how people have behaved in the past year. They simply must have their annual holiday and go out to the pub etc even if it’s risky. There’s been a huge fuss about how unfair it is that life has changed, people are desperate for things to go back to the way they were before, they’re crying about their teens not being able to live the same lifestyles they lived when they were teens themselves. They whinged about altering their lifestyles temporarily for a pandemic so what makes you think they’ll alter them permanently to save the planet and allow a better standard of living for other countries? Can you imagine people accepting that their kids need to have a 75% poorer lifestyle than they had themselves?
What can I say? You are correct Sad
OP posts:
SilverOak · 20/07/2021 00:47

We can reduce consumption probably by 75% in the rich world and still conduct full satisfying lives
You’ve seen how people have behaved in the past year. They simply must have their annual holiday and go out to the pub etc even if it’s risky. There’s been a huge fuss about how unfair it is that life has changed, people are desperate for things to go back to the way they were before, they’re crying about their teens not being able to live the same lifestyles they lived when they were teens themselves. They whinged about altering their lifestyles temporarily for a pandemic so what makes you think they’ll alter them permanently to save the planet and allow a better standard of living for other countries? Can you imagine people accepting that their kids need to have a 75% poorer lifestyle than they had themselves?

Taliskerskye · 20/07/2021 00:46

Who cares! I mean why do you actually care. You’ll be dead in 50-70 years

MareofBeasttown · 20/07/2021 00:45

Just a thought: perhaps the West could reduce its massive carbon footprint rather than expecting China and India to keep millions in poverty so an American can buy his third SUV and continue eating burgers.

MareofBeasttown · 20/07/2021 00:39

@Whoarethewho

Now times that by 9 to see how much pollution China and India will create if they try to reach the same standard of living as the US.

Which is why far from solving world poverty the planet relies on so much of the population being poor and living in harsh conditions. Trying to raise people out of poverty will kill the planet for all.

Wow. The truth will out.
MagnificentDelurker · 20/07/2021 00:30

@Whoarethewho

Now times that by 9 to see how much pollution China and India will create if they try to reach the same standard of living as the US.

Which is why far from solving world poverty the planet relies on so much of the population being poor and living in harsh conditions. Trying to raise people out of poverty will kill the planet for all.

Wow!! I would rather not fall into echo fascism.

Planet doesn’t rely on many people being poor. Greed relies on that.

We can reduce consumption probably by 75% in the rich world and still conduct full satisfying lives. Most people will probably be happier except those that rely on wealth as forms of control and power.

OP posts:
Manycupsoftea · 20/07/2021 00:21

Nothing we say will really reduce waste and emissions meaningfully unless governments across the world implement drastic policy changes.

The consumption issue will continue without governmental intervention. Yes some lifestyle tweaks may help but again not materially changing the system

ARudeTerriblePerson · 20/07/2021 00:18

How come 23% have voted YABU?

wherearemychickens · 20/07/2021 00:12

We need to give up plastic and think about biodiversity as well.

orinocosfavoritecake · 20/07/2021 00:09

The deeply frustrating thing is that we could fix it and it wouldn’t even be that hard. Renewable energy is so cheap now, and storage is so easy that it wouldn’t have to be a dramatic change. It’s not ‘give up your car and go vegan’. We just need to electrify everything.

wherearemychickens · 20/07/2021 00:08

We definitely shouldn't be eating beef from industrial feedlots in Australia, that's for sure

Whoarethewho · 20/07/2021 00:05

Now times that by 9 to see how much pollution China and India will create if they try to reach the same standard of living as the US.

Which is why far from solving world poverty the planet relies on so much of the population being poor and living in harsh conditions. Trying to raise people out of poverty will kill the planet for all.

TalkTalk83 · 20/07/2021 00:05

It's been said a few times on this thread that we should eat less meat to save the environment, but what then should we eat instead in order to save the environment? Avacados transported from thousands of miles away where it is often grown with little regard for the environment and the local people? Surely what we should be doing is eating locally produced food where we know the food's journey to our plate i.e. what use of pesticides, the welfare standards of the meat etc.

colouringindoors · 20/07/2021 00:01

YADNBU.
We literally have a decade for countries to implement major changes, in order to avoid a tipping point where it will be out of control. I'm not optimistic. If the number and severity of weather events (like German floods, US/canada heat explosion) carry on and increase, in 10 years time the public may be more prepared to make some more significant changes but it'll be too late. In the UK we will be more fortunate than other countries, but crop failures and climate migrants will be serious challenges.

RightYesButNo · 20/07/2021 00:00

I’m surprised so many people mentioning that China is cleaning up their act and that China isn’t the “biggest” bad anymore. Erm, yeah. They still are. And most people think not only do their domestic initiatives not work together, but they’re cancelling them out with pollution through the Belt and Road Initiative abroad. However you slice it, “in the past ten years, China has emitted more greenhouse gases, including carbon dioxide, methane, and nitrous oxide, per year than any other country in the world.” This really covers all of it (why them signing the Paris Agreement might not be enough, and so on):
www.cfr.org/backgrounder/china-climate-change-policies-environmental-degradation

The fact is the biggest effect on China’s air pollution was COVID. It dropped some levels to the lowest they’d been since 2014 and let people suddenly see blue sky. (And they returned to pre-COVID levels within a few short months.)
asia.nikkei.com/Spotlight/Coronavirus/Blue-skies-return-to-China-as-coronavirus-cuts-coal-consumption

I’ve attached the satellite image of China right before COVID and during. That’s the output of one greenhouse gas that disappeared during COVID’s peak. In one month, gone.

While China is still one of the worst, yes, every nation has pollution problems, I agree, and most of them showed vast improvement during COVID (lots of articles, photos, maps, etc).

So… my real concern would be that Mother Nature’s answer will be “more” COVIDs with even higher death rates.

AIBU to be really scared of Climate Change
wherearemychickens · 19/07/2021 23:59

I have been feeling like this too. It's not really fear for me, it's fear for what my children's future is going to look like.

I don't think there's ever enough focus on what a positive future could look like. Our lives are going to have to change radically, so we have a choice about whether to do that positively, or get forced into it through disasters - the kind of thing we are now seeing on the news every year.

The stuff that needs doing and makes us more resilient for the future that is coming would improve our lives in lots of ways.

To take one example, rivers that meander and have beavers creating dams to slow them down, and trees in their upper catchments instead of grouse moors and industrial farm units generating nitrate pollution, are rivers that are clean enough to swim in that flood less. I want rivers clean enough to swim in. Why do we accept that they get polluted?

I want to live in a world where public transport is funded so well I only need a car for special journeys, where I don't have to commute as far and I can flexibly work from home, where the natural and cost effective choice is to eat food grown locally, seasonally and organically, where everything that comes wrapped in 'plastic' can be thrown in my compost bin (Riverford have managed it so why can't others?), where houses are built or retrofitted to a standard where they are as comfortable in -10 as they are in 35 degree temperatures with minimal energy uptake, where the focus is on public luxury rather than private luxury and there's less inequality in society, where every child has the opportunity to learn about biodiversity and the natural world at school (forest schools are fab).

In every area it feels like we know what the solutions are but the people articulating them aren't being heard or listened to and there's so much structural inequality built in. Politics these days is so much about fear and division. We need a hopeful message and story - the kind of thing AOC was talking about in America - and one that people can genuinely grasp is for them.

I don't want all of the above to sound like the idealistic pie in the sky dreamworld thinking of a middle class middle aged white woman.

properg · 19/07/2021 23:53

But the fact is, the planet simply cannot sustain 8bn people living at the same standard of living that Western societies have had in recent years. Or even 3bn people (the population of China and India). The US has approx 330m people and they create a third of the planet’s pollution. Now times that by 9 to see how much pollution China and India will create if they try to reach the same standard of living as the US.

My geography teacher told me yrs ago that the emerging (then) developing countries would come to dominate the West impacting on our living standards.

properg · 19/07/2021 23:44

From a UK perspective, corporation, VAT, income, IHT, CGT...

People won't like it.

Tbh I'm not so sure about income tax as the youth of today have such a burden already & have been disproportionately affected by covid.

CGT, corporation etc yes but people won't vote for it or not enough anyway.

PattyPan · 19/07/2021 23:41

Yanbu, this weather is an awful reminder of it. I’ve been donating to Cool Earth for ages but it doesn’t seem to be helping much with the Amazon being destroyed every which way Sad I’m thinking about changing one of my other donations to Climeworks which is carbon capture and storage which will hopefully take off on a bigger scale.

properg · 19/07/2021 23:40

@MagnificentDelurker I read that it's the safest place for surviving an apocalypse.

properg · 19/07/2021 23:38

saying kill old people. It's just a fact that people are living longer.

properg · 19/07/2021 23:38

No, you said if we wanted to reduce the population then birth rates weren't the only thing we should be looking at.

Because it isn't unless you are aiming for zero children? Or to put it another way despite falling birth rates the population is yet to peak.

The implication of which is that we should somehow be trying to prune those who already exist.

Saying that the population is growing because we have more old people doesn't mean I'm

MagnificentDelurker · 19/07/2021 23:33

@womaninatightspot

I thought billionaires had designated New Zealand as the safe spot and were buying land there till they changed the laws. Don’t quote me as I have forgotten where I have read this so it might just be a conspiracy theory.

OP posts:
properg · 19/07/2021 23:33

Go on, how do you reduce the population without tackling birth rates in any way

I think this is where you are confused. Birth rates have already being tackled hence why they are falling. I'm not arguing to increase them, soon they will be below replacement levels anyway so unless your goal is no children I don't see what's left to tackle.